Is Leon Trotsky’s Book, “History of the Russian Revolution” a Biased Source?

Im a Socialist, but I wanna make sure I’m reading factual information.

2 Answers 2019-02-22

What happened to the languages of the African slaves brought to the New World?

Given that around 12 million people were brought across to the Americas, why is it that there seems to be very few remnants of their native languages? I realise that there were many different ethnic and cultural groups brought over but surely there would be commonalities between the many millions that would have enabled them to communicate with each other - even in period movies the slaves are given particularly 'non-African' sounding accents. Were they forcibly assimilated?

1 Answers 2019-02-22

Why do so many continental Germanic surnames (German, Yiddish, Swedish, etc) have topographic features like "stein", "wald", and "berg"?

These kinds of names are strongly associated with Germans and Ashkenazi Jews, and these kinds of names dot the German historical landscape: the Goldberg Variations, the Gutenberg Bible, the physics contributions of Albert Einstein and Werner Heisenberg, Nazi genocidaire Alfred Rosenberg and repentant Nazi officer Kurt Gerstein. The topographic names "Stein", "Steiner", "Berger", and "Bergmann" are among the top 100 in Germany. In Sweden, a whopping 29 out of top 100 surnames end in -berg..

"Stone" is an English surname, but a particularly uncommon one, and often the Anglicized version of Stein. So what causes this great break between the Germanic names of continental Europe versus the British Isles?

2 Answers 2019-02-22

What to study in history

I don't know if this is the right sub to post but I'm not sure where to do it . So , I'm almost certain that I want to do studies about history after the end of high school but there's a big question : What to study ? There's so much interesting and fascinating period I don't know which one to choose . So , would one of you guys know which period is the most interesting to study , or a way to choose between all the ones I like , or even if there's some careers possible as a "general" historian that wouldn't be an expert on one subject but would be pretty good on various stuff . Thanks for your help :)

1 Answers 2019-02-22

How did contemporary Europeans view the Mongolian Empire before, after, and during their expansion into eastern and central Europe?

When the Mongolians were conquering Russia, did any other European groups raise the alarm of the potential coming danger? And also, after the Mongolians had smashed armies in Hungary and Poland, were there any preparations by the Europeans for more fights? And finally, how did they view the Mongolians sudden and unexpected withdrawal?

1 Answers 2019-02-22

What are the factors that determined the success / failure of alcohol prohibitions in US 1933?

The US began to prohibits alcohol in 1920, but it failed in 1933, leading to its ultimate repeal. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prohibition_in_the_United_States

The US is not the only country that tried to ban alcohol, and then repeal the law at a future date: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_with_alcohol_prohibition#Past

However, it seems that prohibition on alcohol is not a sure failed policy, as it remains successful in many other countries, and even in smaller regions within the US, known as Dry County.

https://www.quitalcohol.com/information/in-which-countries-is-alcohol-illegal.html

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dry_county

Specifically, what are the factors that are present / absent in in US 1933, but are absent / present in contemporary countries where alcohol is illegal, and contemporary dry state in the US.

1 Answers 2019-02-22

Why didn't the 18th amendment include drinking alcohol?

The 18th amendment says "the manufacture, sale, or transportation of intoxicating liquors within, the importation thereof into, or the exportation thereof from the United States and all territory subject to the jurisdiction thereof for beverage purposes is hereby prohibited."

Why prohibit only the manufacture, sale, or transportation, but not actually make drinking it illegal? Why not include the consumption? Was it because they knew it would be too hard to enforce, and if so why do it in the first place?

1 Answers 2019-02-22

How did French Expansion/Cultural Imperialism in France Differ from Colonialism Outside France (e.g. in Vietnam & Algeria)?

I'm curious about this whole process of creating Frenchmen from peasants, replacing regional languages with French, exploiting the land and toiling masses during industrialization and generally Frenchifying the country (like the Russian empire's less successful Russification in Poland etc., the Hungarian part of Austria-Hungary's Magyarization etc.) and how it differs from plain old colonialism (or if it wasn't the same process).

Algeria is perhaps closer, being an instance of settler colonialism (but I'm curious about how they treated the native populous), while I don't believe that Vietnam received that many immigrants, although the elites still Frenchified, but what of those outside the cities?

1 Answers 2019-02-22

Do we know what naval combat looked like or if it even happen in medieval Europe?

Except for the Norse, it is almost a topic I almost never hear about. I am especially curious about outside of the Mediterranean, as I find it difficult to believe that the British Isles had no serious mariner tradition.

2 Answers 2019-02-22

Why was the 18th amendment (prohibition) an amendment and not a regular law?

I’ve always thought it was strange. Banning a drug seems like something that should be a law and not a constitutional amendment, and I was wondering why banning alcohol was the latter.

1 Answers 2019-02-22

368208 norwegians voted for independence in 1905 while only 184 voted against. Is such an overwhelming result without precedent in voting history? (99.95% / 0.05%)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1905_Norwegian_union_dissolution_referendum

5 Answers 2019-02-22

Visited the East Coast Memorial today- makes me question; What were the specifics involved that allowed the Allies to defend from 1939 - 1945 during WWII? I’m not to well versed in naval warfare, but this seems like an extraordinary length of time to defend the area.

2 Answers 2019-02-22

What was the Soviet Union’s opinion on FDR’s “New Deal”, “Fair Labor Standards Act”, and the “Social Security Act”?

1 Answers 2019-02-21

I was born and raised in the United States and recently realized Americans pronounce a "chu" sound in informal contractions that involve the word "you." For example: "whatcha doing?" Is there a clear historical origin for this informal contraction in American society?

A "chu" pronounciation seems to be used by most demographics in American society. To the point that most American films depict American and non-American characters using those contractions across space and time. From Star Trek's depiction of a fictional future, to Star Wars' possibly alternate universe, to Western films and shows. Is there a clear historical origin for this informal contraction in American society? It seems like its origin is early enough in United States' history that this pronounciation is used by most Americans.

I started pronouncing you-based contractions without a "chu" sound now that I've noticed it. It sounds too informal. I say that without any judgment. I'm a nineties kid and our generation has embraced casual and informal expressions of clothes and language among other things. However it now sticks out like a sore thumb to me. Follow up question: is there a generation or demographic that consciously decides not to use the aforementioned contractions in spoken form? I understand this might be a difficult question to answer so it's okay if it can't be answered.

1 Answers 2019-02-21

Sleeper trains are arguably one of the most romanticised (and convenient?) forms of transport ever created. What factors have contributed to their demise?

The number of sleeper trains in Europe seems to have gotten smaller in recent decades, and still seem to. Why is this? Newer trends in transport? Less patience?

1 Answers 2019-02-21

Why was the word Ninja censored in the U.K in the 80s and 90s? Ninja Gaiden became Shadow Warriors. TMNT became Teenage Mutant Hero Turtles. Was this simply parent group pressure it was there a law passed to that effect?

I'm just trying to get some answers here. Im sorry if this isn't some deep history question about Napoleon's preference for east or west facing toilets. Thank you.

1 Answers 2019-02-21

Was Egypt a desert in the time of the Pharaos?

I read that North Africa wasn't that dry some thousands of years ago. I wonder how did Ancient Egypt really look like. Was it something similar to today's Spain or Turkey?

1 Answers 2019-02-21

Been watching documentaries on the Black Death and there were two different theories on how the plague came to Europe. One is through merchant ships in Italian ports. The other blames Jewish merchants traveling on Mongolian land trade routes. Which is more accurate?

1 Answers 2019-02-21

What are historians' views of Mao Zedong's rule of China?

I have heard conflicting views of him. On reddit I have seen claims that under his rule literacy rates, life expectancy, gdp, etc all went up during his rule. Yet at the same, my family's own experiences with the Cultural Revolution and the Great Leap Forward. How exactly do historians' characterize his rule of China?

1 Answers 2019-02-21

Is there any way to measure ethnicities in the US going from being discriminated against or ostracized to acceptance?

I'm wondering if this is a predictable societal function, and if we know what the influencing factors are.

For example, blacks have been discriminated against at varying levels since Europeans first landing in the Americas till today.

Asians have been discriminated against in some similar, some different ways, for at least a 1.5 century.

Italians and Irish went through periods of discrimination, but it ended.

Native people have been treated badly since Europeans arrived.

I'm wondering if there are any studies on what the different factors are that create or support discrimination, how they applied to different groups, and also how that might apply to the culture(s) of the US vs. other countries/cultures (like Japan, African countries, England, Brazil, etc.)

Also, i would love to see a timeline of immigration to acceptance of ethnicities in the US.

1 Answers 2019-02-21

Have boomerangs ever actually been used as weapons?

The physics seem quite impossible.

1 Answers 2019-02-21

What are some good, lesser known medieval museums in the UK and US?

2 Answers 2019-02-21

Robert A. Pearson, convicted of rape and executed in 1945 in England by the US military, buried on Guadalcanal, then re-interred in Hawaii. His military records were lost. Any speculation or information on why he was moved post mortem from Europe to the Pacific? Is this information even accurate?

1 Answers 2019-02-21

I've read that Michelangelo was paid 400 gold florins for the realization of the David in 1504. I wasn't able to find sources on how much was the gold florin worth. What could I buy with 400 florins during that age?

1 Answers 2019-02-21

Why are Irish often made fun of? And how much of it is related to their relationship with other countries in the British Isles such as Britain?

One of my friend wondered about this but in the spirit of this sub, I figured there may be something deeper or counter-intuitive other than Irish are always drunk and fighting so I brought the question here.

1 Answers 2019-02-21

⯇ 2106 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start