I'm looking for a book or two to give me an overview of the Roman Republic (having already looked on the booklist!). I'll probably read and then some books on Caesar and Augustus, so trying to cover the things that won't be covered in good Caesar biographies etc.
As context this is part of trying to get something like a very broad/narrative overview of starting with ancient Greece and moving forward into European/Western/World history (I realised my knowledge of history had centuries with complete gaps!). I've most recently been reading about the Hellenistic Period, especially Peter Green's Alexander to Actium and shortly will be following up with Eckstein's Mediterranean Anarchy, Interstate War, and the Rise of Rome, Polybius's histories and Carthage Must be Destroyed (or similar).
For obvious reasons I'm shifting focus to Rome for next little while, and while I'm 'meeting them' in the Hellenistic period I want to double back and understand their roots better. Both in broad 'what happened' narrative terms and some sense of relevant cultural/structural issues especially if they remain helpful to understanding the Empire. My current knowledge of Roman history is more or less limited to the contents of Mike Duncan's History of Rome podcast.
Massively grateful for completely new suggestions and/or comments on the following which is my current shortlist
Scullard A History of the Roman World: 753 to 146 BC (has the nice touch that if I like it I can follow up with 'from the Gracchi to Nero')
Lomas The Rise of Rome: From the Iron Age to the Punic Wars (1000 BC – 264 BC) (ends quite early but Polybius and Carthage must be destroyed should pick up where this leaves off)
Dillon Ancient Rome: From the early Republic to the assassination of Julius Caesar (this is a 'sourcebook' and I'm slightly unclear on if that means it's a terrible choice as the only one!
Crawford The Roman Republic (Fontana History). This is by far the cheapest (second hand) but also shorter (only 250 pages, but I wish Amazon did word counts instead!) and a bit older
Many thanks in advance!
1 Answers 2018-10-07
In the twilight years of the Byzantine (Eastern Roman) Empire was Byzantium (Constantinople) still a major center of commerce drawing people from across the known world?
1 Answers 2018-10-07
So I've been watching the new David Simon fiction series "The Deuce" set in 70's New York and centering on sex work, and fair number of characters in the series are pimps of some variety.
What interests me is that the show sort of tacitly depicts two different sorts of pimps; white massage parlor guys with "connections" and the classic stereotype of outlandishly dressed African American man, complete with fancy hat, patterned suit and a studded cane.
Characters in the show are depicted decrying the death of the pimp lifestyle as pornography producers begin to poach "talent" and obviate the pimp. So I've inferred that by the 70's, this stereotype was already well entrenched.
A couple things, then:
1 Answers 2018-10-07
I find it rather strange that people call two Kingdoms that were a dual crown Spain when Spain didn't technically exist till the 1700s. It is weird, it's like calling Prussia, Germany. It doesn't make any sense, why do people make this mistake still?
1 Answers 2018-10-07
The details of the Washington Naval Treaty seem to require a large amount of very detailed inspection in order to ensure that all of the signatories were abiding by the agreement. Notably loading each ship in a combat load, minus fuel, and then calculating displacement seems like it would be very difficult to track across multiple nations navies.
Was there a responsible third party who was ensuring that the treaty was being followed? Who was actually calculating the tonnage of each respective warship in the signatories navies?
Were any of the parties intentionally under representing the displacement of ships that were in fact larger?
1 Answers 2018-10-07
1 Answers 2018-10-07
2 Answers 2018-10-07
is there something more practical about a straight katana rather than a curved one?
1 Answers 2018-10-07
What are your go to books for the history of Rome?
Bonus points if you suggest reading material I can access for free on the interwebz (preferably in PDF).
2 Answers 2018-10-07
This is a quote traditionally attributed to the prophet Mohammed: "the worst things are those that are novelties, every novelty is an innovation, every innovation is an error and every error leads to the Hell-fire".
This quote was presented alongside the following claim in an academic article:
"This dictum and the doctrine behind it enabled the Muslim religious conservatives of the Ottoman Empire to hinder or delay the introduction of innovations such as Arabic letter printing, observatory and clock-making."
2 Answers 2018-10-07
1 Answers 2018-10-07
As someone who loves history, I am particularly enamored with women's fashion over the years. Lately I have been watching videos on how women dressed (and the process behind it) in the 18th and 19th centuries. It seems that wealthier women wore endless layers of shifts, stays, petticoats, pocket hoops, etc. It would take forever to get dressed and, obviously, undressed as well. It also seems that most women who would wear this fashion would likely have a hired girl to help her get into and out of it.
If a woman wanted to have sex with her husband, what was that process like? Would he undress her (or she undress in front of him) like is commonly done today, or was there a more elaborate process? Did couples even sleep together at this time? Was there ever any sporadic sex or was it all ceremonial and formal? Did women have attire that could be worn around the house in front of her husband that did not involve a laborious process to put on?
I'll take any information you have. I find it fascinating.
1 Answers 2018-10-07
1 Answers 2018-10-07
Today:
Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.
2 Answers 2018-10-07
In 'Conquerors: how Portugal forged the first global empire', Roger Crowley leaves the impression that the Portuguese, despite their small numbers, were quickly able to use force to impose a measure of control over trade on the west coast of India. Had Asian powers not sought to build up naval power before this to control the wealth of trade? Also, is he right to say that taking control of this trade was not the goal of Zheng-He before the Chinese treasure fleets were cancelled?
1 Answers 2018-10-07
[deleted]
1 Answers 2018-10-07
Hello there!
I just recently moved to Düsseldorf and would like to better understand the history of Germany starting around 500CE onwards. I know it's expansive and I'm asking a very broad question, but I have an audible subscription and would like to understand more of my new (hopefully permanent) home. As my new home is Düsseldorf, any novels that even briefly cover the Battle of Worringen would be huge bonuses.
I'm not too particularly eager to learn about WW2 - I think it's a dick move to move here and then study the Nazis. That being said, I would be interested in understanding the liberation of Düsseldorf better, as it looks to have been seized and surrendered by the resistance on the eve of a large bombing run with a lot of twists along the way. Besides that, more Feudal era upto the transition into the industrial era is what I'm looking for.
Please feel free to suggest books that only cover a brief timeline of that if you find it to be particularly engaging, important to the forming of Germany as we know today, or a story stranger than fiction. Maybe something on Otto von Bismarck? Overarching book on the impact of the Reformation across the country? Podcasts also welcome (so long as it's in English).
2 Answers 2018-10-07
Hello there. I am helping a friend look for resources for an undergrad project, and since I am not a historian, thought it would pay to ask here. We have found this project site, https://elwar.uni.lu and we would like to have some suggestions on current literature/teams/scholars working on relevant stuff. There is no geographic or temporal restriction, we would like just some pointers to help him gather reading material. His professor also semi-suggested that he would prefer somewhat recent data, if that exists. Thanks a lot for your help
Edit: The way I understood it he is looking for sources regarding the following:
a.Formulation of political parties after a war. How did the outcome of the war affect older parties or led to creation of new ones.
b.What it says in the elwar project site: How the war plays in postwar narratives and the affect to institutions (ie in education. Denialism maybe, etc)
This is all I can think of. If I was the one who had this assignment, from what he told me, I would look for politics in post war Germany and post war France, the political parties, the financial policies and the education system. But I am a mathematics major so..yeah.. :-). I am sorry if this is vague, but it seems his professor just told him more or less "find my colleagues who deal with postwar politics around the globe, read their stuff and make a list", which seems a bit too much for me too. Maybe somebody wants to write a new book and is too busy to look for resources :-)
1 Answers 2018-10-07
[deleted]
1 Answers 2018-10-07
I've come across the fact that Aragonese rulers had several vassals in the Balkans including Skenderbey of Albania and Duke of Herzegovina. Why? What did they hope to gain there? It seems so far away from their base in Iberia.
1 Answers 2018-10-07
If you were to ask anyone to give a description of Jesus, it would be very easy: long, straight brown hair, a thick beard, and always wearing flowing white robes. He is instantly recognizable. My question is, when, where and why did this set of physical traits become so commonplace? The Bible never describes his appearance at all, so it must be conjecture by an artist’s creative license, but it must have been a very influential artist indeed.
2 Answers 2018-10-07