Air power was important in WW2, as it was often the key factor in battles like Midway and the Bismarck sinking. Could the Luftwaffe have been enough of a threat to the Royal Navy to facilitate any island invasion?

I’ve often heard that Operation Sea Lion was doomed from the start, mainly since the Royal Navy was just gonna blockade the channel. However, could the luftwaffe have been better utilized in fighting the Royal Navy to prevent this?

1 Answers 2018-10-08

Contemporary Bubonic Plague

What do we think of today caused the bubonic plague? Why did it stop/what they could've done better with their med tech knowldge? Is it true that prices went down and wages went up because of the smaller population? How did it affect the culture of the next few generations?

1 Answers 2018-10-08

Native americans = Fall of the Greek and Roman Empires?

Did disease play any role in the Fall of the empires a la the native American tribes when Europeans came along?

1 Answers 2018-10-08

Was reading about what the vikings believed about Ragnarok and am now wondering if they believed in free will or determinism.

Since the events of Ragnarok are spelled out in very clear terms about what will happen and who will kill who and how everything will transpire... does that mean that the vikings believed in some way that fate was determined for them and that you were merely along for the ride? Probably vastly oversimplifying things based on limited knowledge but genuinely curious.

1 Answers 2018-10-08

Following the loss of North Africa and the Levant to the Arabs, could Byzantium be described as a Roman nation state?

Anthony Kaldellis makes the case for this in his book Hellenism in Byzantium, but I'd be interested in knowing if this has become a mainstream view.

1 Answers 2018-10-08

The Christian Desert Fathers of Egypt sound like they practiced Buddhist-style meditation and had some very Buddhist views on things. What happened to them, and why did their meditation practices never spread throughout the rest of of Christendom?

1 Answers 2018-10-08

Why did the United Nations release men from a refugee camp to be massacred?

Hi guys, I've been trying to remember but I can't. There was a time in the 90's I think, somewhere in eastern Europe, either Bosnia or Yugoslavia where the UN had a camp set up for civilians fleeing conflict. However, they were forced to release the men to be killed or else 'they' would have killed the whole camp. I can't remember what genocide this was and was having trouble finding a description about it. Did I just get my information wrong on this?

2 Answers 2018-10-08

Are there any attempts to understand the satanic ritual abuse panic of the 80s as part of a broader phenomenon?

I've been fascinated by reading about the daycare child abuse and satanic ritual abuse moral panics of the 1980s.

But one thing that seems wrong to me is the description of the panic as something that occurred and then was more or less debunked and ended.

To me it seems like the idea that there is constant ongoing ritual child sexual abuse, and shadowy rings that perpetrate it in a coordinated way, was more or less accepted and incorporated into popular culture in the 80s and 90s. In other words, the ideas behind the panic were taken as true even as actual cases were debunked or at least seriously doubted.

Would anyone be able to point me to reading on this topic or summarize some of the current thinking on it?

1 Answers 2018-10-08

Mitch McConnell claims there is "... a tradition in America, which is that if you have... a Senate of a different party than the president you don’t fill a vacancy created in a presidential year. That went all the way back to 1888.” Is this accurate?

2 Answers 2018-10-08

Why is the Native American. . . disposal (?)... extermination (?) by the American Governmental forces NOT termed a war?

1 Answers 2018-10-08

During 321-297 BCE, Chandragupta Maurya seemed to be such a powerhouse of a leader, in that he conquered almost all of India and pushed out Seleucus. Why wasn’t he able to conquer the Tamil Kings?

2 Answers 2018-10-08

If European's back in the 1600s and 1700s were immune to small pox and their genetic "sisters" why are non of us immune to them? And when did they stop becoming immune?

1 Answers 2018-10-08

What is the origin of the idea of "7 wonders of the ancient world?"

Where did the phrase originate and did the civilizations at the time acknowledge some of their architectural achievements as the wonders of the world? Who made the decision to include the wonders we know of today?

1 Answers 2018-10-08

2nd time: The Stonewall Riots are generally considered the beginning of the modern LGBT rights movement, but gay rights groups had existed long before 1969. What made the post-Stonewall revolution so impactful and what changed to make gay rights movements more cohesive and vocal?

1 Answers 2018-10-07

What series of events led to Haiti being so poor and corrupt?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-10-07

Hisotry Major

I'm a history major freshmen looking to become a world history teacher, although another job I was looking to get if I'm not a teacher is an archeologist. I read that I could be an archeologist with a history degree, but how hard would it be to get a job in that field and how many jobs are in colder climates ( I really want to work on the Franklin Expedition sites in the arctic)?

What other jobs are there in the history field are like teaching and archeology? (Sorry for the stupid question)

2 Answers 2018-10-07

How would Qing Dynasty China looked if the Tongzhi Restoration had succeeded?

1 Answers 2018-10-07

Evidence that Hadrian had a sexual relationship with Antinous?

I get that pederasty was common in Ancient Rome, but I’m reading the Wikipedia page about Hadrian’s “lover,” Antinous, and almost every claim abiut that relationship being sexual is sourced to a 1984 book by Lambert.

Did Lambert discover this? Is his book reputable? Does anyone know the evidence he used to establish that the relationship was sexual? I don’t have access to a library that has that book in its holdings. Thanks.

1 Answers 2018-10-07

To what degree, if at all, did combatants not shoot at medics on either side on the Western Front or in North Africa during World War II? To what degree were medics not armed?

I remember seeing in various fictional works, movies, TV shows and video games how both sides supposedly were not supposed toshoot at medics, though this was usually a point of drama when the medic then got shot anyway. To what degree the combatants actually avoid shooting at medics? To what degree were medics actually not arm?

1 Answers 2018-10-07

Were there ever any attempts by the Byzantine Military to adopt Pike and Shot tactics that were on the Rise in Western Europe?

1 Answers 2018-10-07

When Hippocrates said, "Let Food Be Thy Medicine," there wasn't much in the way of processed foods to make unhealthy choices with, so what foods were people making themselves sick with, and what were viewed at the medicinal foods?

1 Answers 2018-10-07

How was post-battle body removal handled from the classic era til now?

How did they clean up bodies after major battles? Was there some agreement among groups not to kill/fight body removers? During the crusades or other far off wars were bodies/remains sent back to families or did they leave them in theater?

1 Answers 2018-10-07

Why did Vicente Rojo Lluch, a Catholic conservative, come to command the Republican forces during the Spanish Civil War instead of siding with Franco?

Was it out of simple loyalty? Did he have desire to preserve democracy?

I understand that a number of Basque and Catalan conservative separatists sided with the Republic, but how common was it for a Castilian conservative to side with the Republic?

1 Answers 2018-10-07

Historical Analysis as a Method

So I am assessing a diplomatic cable from a British envoy to a then independent Bavaria in 1866. I was asked to "how could I use this source in a form of historical analysis?"

What exactly is meant by historical analysis?

Would it just be stating why the source is relevant? Or why it is accurate? I understand that historical analysis itself has some kind of methodology of its own, but every website I try to look at for more information says that I am not privy to those files. Any guidance would be appreciated.

​

1 Answers 2018-10-07

When did the Maxim Gun first come to symbolize British Imperialism?

I never shall forget the way

That Blood upon that awful day

Saved us all from death

He stood upon a tiny mound

Cast his lethargic eyes around

And said beneath his breath:

'Whatever happens, we have got

the Maxim Gun, and they have not!'

So, if I am recalling it correctly, goes a famous verse from Hilaire Belloc's The Modern Traveller, and it is just one of the many evocative bits of light verse in it.

Was Belloc merely drawing on widely-held popular associations between firearm and ideology here, or was he responsible for cementing this image?

(Bonus question: Was the gun's reputation deserved?)

1 Answers 2018-10-07

⯇ 2357 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start