The Hateful Eight portrays a stagecoach way station in the middle of a blizzard in Colorado that is uninsulated, and fails to keep snow from drifting inside. Would this have been a normal cold-climate building style in the late 1800s?

3 Answers 2018-09-13

Book recommendation: history of Native Americans in pre-Colombian New England

I am looking for books about the history and culture of pre-Colombian Native Americans. Specifically interested in New England area: Narragansett, Massachusett, Pequot, Mohegan, etc., but open to anything Algonquin or related. Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2018-09-13

Why do newspapers use Old English fonts for the masthead?

for example, the san francisco chronicle: https://i.imgur.com/uaHT8Ih.jpg

the new york times: https://i.imgur.com/BoL70sf.jpg

the washington post: https://imgur.com/fuB7ryC

1 Answers 2018-09-13

How true is the statement that the "Chinese used an advanced method for producing bad steel but the West used a traditional method to produce good steel"?

I've been researching Chinese blast furnaces and cast iron. Frankly most of the science is way over my head but I've been able to make out the gist of it so far, if only slightly.

Anyways, I came upon this site which basically refutes the argument that China was any more advanced than the West in metallurgy. I know that it seems kind of politically or ideologically motivated, but the scientific arguments seem sound, at least to someone like me who does not have a background in metallurgical sciences. I would like to see what more knowledgeable people have to say about the following statements:

The early Chinese techniques included a kind of puddling" process, which is similar to processes used in the West much later (let's say after 1500 AD). Does that mean that the Chinese were 1000 years or so ahead of the West? It's a matter if definition. If you prefer a bad steel made by an advanced method to good steel made in an old-fashioned way, the Chinese were ahead.

The Chinese cast-iron industry certainly pre-dates "ours" by 1 500 years or so. The reason, however, is not that the Romans or others in the West couldn't make cast iron! They could, in fact, but they didn't want to! They simply had no use for the brittle stuff. The Chinese, to their everlasting credit, used their cast iron for making peaceful objects, including flower vases and (huge) sculptures. Western cast iron, when it was finally produced, went immediately into cannon making.

So basically, did the Chinese use an advanced method to produce bad steel while the West used an older method to produce better steel? Did the Romans have blast furnaces, but had no use for cast iron, while the Chinese found cast iron more useful than the rest of the world?

1 Answers 2018-09-13

Where does the surname Mc or Mac (like McCartney) come from?

I know where surname ending with son come from and I guess this comes from something similar but don't know?

1 Answers 2018-09-13

Between 1405 and 1433 Zheng He led seven "treasure voyages" from China to various parts of the Indian Ocean and Southeast Asia. How did the regions he visited react to/record the visits?

Here's a map: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/29/Voyages_of_Zheng_He.png

1 Answers 2018-09-13

The use of forts in the time of Napoleon Bonaparte

Marquis de Vauban created lot of forts to protect France against invasion. Did the forts play a role in defending France in the time of Napoleon or were they already obsolete?

1 Answers 2018-09-13

Any truth to the argument that even without the atomic bomb, Japan would have surrendered because of the soviets invading

This has probably been asked before, but I couldn't find it.

I am always seeing arguments that the atomic bomb is not what ended the war, but rather the soviets invading and without the bomb Japan would have surrendered anyway.

I have also seen arguments that the entire reason to use the bomb was to scare the soviets.

Is there any truth to this?

Thank you

1 Answers 2018-09-13

Why did almost all religions with their different directions have the same story, i mean they all got Adam and Eve, God and Lucifer, but with different names... Was it a competetion between people to make the best religion? "Like Iphone and Samsung now... Was it a fashion?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-09-13

What was the perception of Europe and Christianity during the Islamic Golden Age?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-09-13

How did the Romans deal with an injured man during the battle?

We study how much advanced the military warfare of the romans was, but how much good was their care for people injured while a conflict in the battlefield was still going?

1 Answers 2018-09-13

Why didn't the Mongols invade Africa?

2 Answers 2018-09-13

What did the Aztecs use for buoyancy for their floating gardens?

Hello! This is my first post here, hopefully it will go well! My niece is working on a science fair project I am assisting her with, and we came across the historical stories that the Aztecs grew food and even trees on floating islands. Both of us wondered what he builders used to keep the rafts afloat with the burden of soil and crops atop its surface - any help or advice would be sincerely appreciated! Thank you all in advance for your time reading the post.

1 Answers 2018-09-13

My Grandad Came Across an Iron Cross

Hi All,

I've attached some photos of the medal itself and the leather pouch it came in. We don't really have much provenance around it as it was given to my grandad by his late sister's husband.

Some of the family served in WW2 as British infantry. There was also a Nazi detention camp nearby to where they lived (in Enfield, London), and where some friends of family members worked.

I was wondering if from those details and the pictures anyone could provide any more information? Like the class of the cross and under what conditions it was issued, and the significance of the 1813 date on the back?

Hope this meets all the conditions of the sub - let me know if not.

Pictures: https://imgur.com/a/fVSQY0C

1 Answers 2018-09-13

robert e. lee's special order 191 was famously wrapped with three cigars. we know the order went up the federal chain of command, but do we know what happened to the cigars?

1 Answers 2018-09-13

Vladimir Zhirinovsky won 8% of the popular vote in the 1991 Russian Presidential Election. How did Far-Right politics succeed in appealing to over 6 million voters on the eve of the USSR's collapse?

See This LATimes Article, for instance

How did a far-right, rabidly anti-communist candidate get this sort of traction at all in the Late Soviet Union?

1 Answers 2018-09-13

When did English get rid of it’s vowel accents?

I’m reading Beowulf in Old English and it has accents for its vowels, so I’m wondering when and why English got rid of them? I’ve heard of the Great Vowel Shift, does it have anything to do with it?

1 Answers 2018-09-13

In US politics, did progressive, or conservative parties create greater economic prosperity?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-09-13

What do historians think about Henry Kissinger's book "Diplomacy"?

I found it interesting, and he makes some claims that seem bold or that are contrary to (what I understand to be) conventional wisdom.

-The central thesis of his book is that balance-of-power diplomacy keeps the peace far more effectively than the rule/morality/internationalism-based ideas that gained traction after the horrors of WWI.

-That the "balance of power"-type system (defined as one where several states are forced to interact and compete with one another and none is strong enough to impose their will on the others) is historically very rare, having only been seen in Europe and Warring States era China. He instead says that empire-tributary was the principal type of relationship between entities throughout human history.

-That WWI was principally caused by German belligerence after the death of Bismark and secondarily by Britain refusing to send a clear enough signal of opposition to German aggression before it was too late.

-That WWII was almost entirely the work of Hitler's personality and refusal to wait for Germany to naturally grow into the dominant European state.

-That the Western Allies completely bungled the opportunity to counter the Soviets after WWII. Firstly, by not advancing further east and secondly by stubbornly insisting on democracy and self-determination in Eastern Europe, instead of conceding that they were in the Soviet sphere of influence. This supposedly drove the Soviets to take a harder line on controlling Eastern Europe as opposed to settling for a Finlandization. There is also a general theme of Stalin running circles around the democracies when it came to foreign policy throughout his rule.

-That 20th century American statesmen consistently failed to articulate a national interest to work towards in foreign policy and instead pursued the moral or principled course to a fault. As an example, he says that America made a mistake in coming out so strongly against the British and French during the Suez Crisis and against the Europeans in general on colonial issues.

-That the Vietnam Was was was a mistake, caused by American leaders vastly overestimating the amount of leadership the Soviets had over the world Communist movement and by their fear of a united Communist state in Southeast Asia. Kissinger maintains that American leaders were ignorant of or underestimated the degree of the Sino-Soviet split and that China never would have tolerated a united Southeast Asia.

1 Answers 2018-09-13

Stalin deported over 200,000 Crimeans, of which half died from starvation or disease. for alleged "collaboration" with the Nazis. Is this accurate? How were the lives of these Crimeans affected?

1 Answers 2018-09-13

How reliant were early-medieval armies on raiding/gathering local food?

I'm thinking specifically how reliant armies tended to be on local fare as opposed to the provisions they might have with them, and whatever they might have if a supply route was established.

Sources would be great; I've got a lot of reading to do.

1 Answers 2018-09-13

Thursday Reading & Recommendations | September 13, 2018

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • Asking for book recommendations on specific topics or periods of history

  • Newly published books and articles you're dying to read

  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now

  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes

  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

13 Answers 2018-09-13

How did Byzantine soldiers and crusaders counter the horse archers often used by the Turks?

1 Answers 2018-09-13

The Red Flag Fleet under Ching Shih (active 1801-1810) commanded 20,000-40,000 pirates. What was life like in this fleet, how was Shih able to exert control, and is ‘pirates’ really the proper word to describe this organization?

1 Answers 2018-09-13

How were maps made in the medieval times?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-09-13

⯇ 2401 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start