What was the extent of Thomas Jefferson's advocacy for abolition and was the hypocrisy of Jefferson advocating abolition while keeping his own slaves noted/criticized during his political career or later life?

1 Answers 2018-08-12

Was the confederacy recognized as its own country by any other countries during the US’s civil war?

2 Answers 2018-08-12

When did Imperial Japan first decide to conquer the Southern Resource Area? What were the bounds of the SRA? Did they have a similar name for Manchuria?

1 Answers 2018-08-12

Did ancient Egyptian pharaohs ever give public speeches?

I learned recently that Cleopatra was one of the few (if not the only) ancient Egyptian Pharaohs who bothered to learn to speak the ancient Egyptian language. That got me wondering: did the pharaohs ever give public speeches? Like a modern politician would?

2 Answers 2018-08-12

Dinesh D'Souza's recent film, "Death of a Nation", makes the claim that Nazis were left-wing. What is the historian's perspective on the political classification of the Nazi party?

2 Answers 2018-08-12

It’s common knowledge that gay/bisexual men and women were relatively accepted in ancient European civilisations (especially Greece, Rome). At what point in time did this change, and why?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-08-12

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | August 06, 2018–August 12, 2018

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

3 Answers 2018-08-12

We saw a script found on a step in 1000 year old fort in India (Kalinjar fort, Madhya Pradesh). Does anyone know what the script reads and why they used blocks of what appears to be temples parts to build their fort? Have a look at images : https://photos.app.goo.gl/ChU7pRizB9fS5iRK9

1 Answers 2018-08-12

At the time of his trial, did the available evidence support Galileo?

There was a thread about this in CMV, so I would like to know what any historians have to say about it.

1 Answers 2018-08-12

When did subvocalizing as opposed to reading aloud "take off", and is YHWH's ambiguous spelling related?

  1. When monks and statesmen, from Mesopotamia to Rome to Medieval Europe, were reading and writing texts, transcribing and memorizing, we they saying what they were reading aloud, or were they able to read in their heads like most of us today?

  2. Is this something which has ever been mentioned in old texts, e.g. does the bible ever discuss "the voice in our head" as the voice of god, the voice of our conscience, or mention "crazy people" and prophets who heard voices similar to those with Schizoid disorders experience in modern times?

  3. Are there any groups currently which have reading and writing, without internal voice when reading and writing? Do adults whom have recently learnt to read/write find it difficult to not make mouth movements?

  4. [More anthropological] Do we believe that for as long as humans have had language, we have had voices in our heads? Is it believed that mental-voice could have predated language, in the sense that I feel I am able to have "wordless thoughts", such as "that's a cool rock" when my attention is captured?

This question is predicated on a few assumptions, so correct me if these are misleading me:

  1. The modern world is much more abstract and cognitively stimulating than ancient societies[not pre-agrarian!] and thus more conducive to the acquisition of mental skills like reading internally.
  2. Western Humans only really started subvocalising text, "reading in their head", shortly after the invention of the printing press and widespread dissemination of books. However, I'm not sure how this fits in with bibles and torah(s).
  3. Pre-printing-press Humans learnt to read much later in life than we do now, closer to adulthood.
  4. Learning to read, especially with a mental voice, is quite difficult and complex.
  5. The original pronunciation of YHWH, as the "name of God" is believed to be lost. AFAIK vowels are written with small dots, so Hebrew isn't an Abugida where omission of vowels would be customary for most words.
  6. Jews wouldn't say YHWH aloud and with vowels, at least not when reading the scripture(s), as it is similar enough to "saying God's name in vain".
  7. The Jewish or Yiddish word for "Meditation" means "To mutter to oneself". If this is correct, is it in the context of an Indian Mantra, or Descartes' "philosophical meditation" whereby one inquires into an idea and thinks for a long time, rather than the silencing of inner chatter like most Westerners aim for when we're meditating. [I'm not entirely sure but supposedly meditation can grant us mental-silence by reducing activity in the Default Mode Network https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Default_mode_network , which also occurs during the experience of Flow https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flow_(psychology)

My armchair-historian conspiracy is that "YHWH" was never written with the vowels, not since writing god's name was as bad as saying it, but that it couldn't be written without being spoken.

P.S. A psychiatrist has discussed with me there is speculation that some children with ADHD and Asperger's may have delayed development of their "mental narrator". I have friends that claim they can remember the precise moment they "figured out" how to read in their heads as a child. Is it plausible that if we learnt to read as adults, and in a world with far less abstraction[simpler means of production, smaller vocabularies], then this leap wouldn't be accessible to most of us?

1 Answers 2018-08-12

Hadrian visited most of his provinces during his reign, but to what degree would the average Roman citizen know how big the Empire was?

1 Answers 2018-08-12

Was there a ranking system of Spanish Conquistadors?

1 Answers 2018-08-12

How vital was the Allied victory in North Africa during WWII?

What would the loss of the Suez canal have meant for Britain? Was oil production in NA and the Middle East significant compared to other parts of Allied/Axis territory?

1 Answers 2018-08-12

How did the modern concept, or rather the absence of, human races develop?

I have an encyclopedia from 1936, published in Finland. It has entries with pictures of different negro types and their characteristics, adding that a well educated negro can be very intelligent too. Other peoples are described as well as their histories, for example the Chinese are said to be good businessmen but prone to oppressing others.

How did we end up with the present state, where the whole concept of race is largely abandoned? Did the change come from the West or everywhere at the same time? Were there any influential studies done?

Obviously racism is still a problem around the world, but there haven't been any encyclopedias like this in a long time.

1 Answers 2018-08-12

What percentage of soldiers developed tinnitus during both World Wars? Certainly most of thr artillerymen?

1 Answers 2018-08-12

Feudalism, Parliament and England

CONTEXT: I have this observation that the Parliament of England actually can impose their will to the monarch. This was proven by how the monarch needs the approval of the Parliament to go to war and increases taxation. I understand that the relationship exists thusly because there was a precedent that the members of Parliament, the landowners, to successfully make the Monarch comply, ex: King John-Magna Carta, and King Henry III-De Monfort's Parliament. And this state of relationship is kept through generations which, in my analysis, supported the democratization of the United Kingdom such as appointment of commons' representatives, the appointment of the first lord of treasury to rely on the Commons' trust, the universal male suffrage, the universal women suffrage, and practically giving the position of the head of Government to a member of the House of Commons. Yes, the Monarch might refuse and resist, ex: Ferrers' case and James VII/I's parliament suspension, but when the Monarch has stepped too far, the Parliament could successfully make the Monarch cut off, like what happened to Charles I. The point is the change brought by the Parliament is inevitable to be implemented.

Question:

  1. Why does this kind of relationship not exist in other countries? (French Estates General was weak to the French King and Spanish Cortes were weak to the Spanish King. I mean the elements were all there, the lands were managed by the land-owners, why then there was no resistance at all from these land-owners).

Btw, yes, I'm a new subscriber. I have read the rules, and yes I understand that I'm asking a broader-concept topic. Mainly because I like to talk about the underlining concepts in History.

1 Answers 2018-08-12

When Belisarius was sent to reconquer Italy, he had just 7,500 troops. Why so few?

This seems like a laughably small force to retake the entire peninsula, given the number of Austrogothic forces, and especially relative to the 100,000 troops the empire had sent to Africa just a half-century earlier. If regaining Italy was so important to Justinian, why did he send such a puny force to do it? Was that really all the empire could spare? Were there recruitment problems? Were the rest of Byzantine forces tied down defending other parts of the empire? Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2018-08-12

How did the Indians paint their faces? How did they extract the colors from the natural resources around them?

I have googled this a bit and I would like to find a list of like colors that were used by the Indians and also how they obtained these said colors.

1 Answers 2018-08-12

The Underground Railroad is often cited as a major part of how slaves managed to achieve freedom. Were there any number of cases where slaves escaped without relying on the Underground Railroad?

1 Answers 2018-08-12

How did Germany surrender during WW2.

I am specifically asking about how they established communication in the first place. Apparently Donitz, the new president after Hitler died, communicated with Eisenhower trough telegraph. But how? Was it using radio or were the telegraphs connected by cable. How did they know the radio frequency or how did they connect the cables.

What about Germans on other fronts. According to the Wikipedia page some Germans captains were secretly negotiating surrender and as soon as Hitler died they surrendered. How did they establish communications too? I was reading about a delegation being sent by Donitz at Luneburg Heath. They arrived by car, how did they signal they were coming in peace? What prevented random soldiers from shooting their car at first sight?

And finally, for random pockets of left over German soldiers with no real captain, did they surrender as portrayed in the movies, by waving a White flag and raising their hands?

1 Answers 2018-08-12

What do we know about Friedrich Engels' lifetime partner, Mary Burns? How did she die at 41?

And what's the story behind Engel's topless doodle of her?

1 Answers 2018-08-12

In the time of Octavian, how would a murder be investigated in the city of Rome?

If there were no witnesses, how would they ever find out who killed a person?

And if it was difficult to impossible, what did that mean for the general murder rate of the average Roman?

1 Answers 2018-08-12

How were island nations like the Philippines governed before airplanes and mass electricity

I ask mainly because it seems to me like such vast territories would require a flexible governance strategy. You can't for instance expect a senator from the north to travel to the south in Manila (or wherever the capital at the time would've been) to travel for 5-6 days at a time to the capital to govern could you? How autonomous were provinces? How were claims to territory enforced on more remote islands, if at all? How differing were the governments (Spanish, Americans, etc) in their ideas on how to govern the islands?

1 Answers 2018-08-12

Was Hitler's oratorical ability good by modern standards?

I've often heard (and perhaps this is my main misconception) that Hitler was a good orator and was able to sway people through speech. However, without fail, every piece of film I've seen of him looks outright cringey to my modern sensibilities. His body language is, by modern standards, quite simply stunted and rigid. His speech cadence is vastly (to me) less moving than for instance MLK's "I have a dream" speech, or even a good actor like Anthony Hopkins speaking of something completely inane.

So the question is: was he really that good an orator, or is it simply that he was among the first to exist in the era of large crowds and amplifiers? Or was his oratorical ability only second to the actual circumstances of the era (post WWI Weimar Republic, Great Depression etc) and it was more his message that appealed to populism etc. In short, was the form really part of the reason why he rose to power, or was it all about the content?

3 Answers 2018-08-12

Why did Bismark oppose the Frankfurt Constitution plan for unification, but supported German unification just a few decades later?

Or more broadly, why did Prussian interests shift?

1 Answers 2018-08-12

⯇ 2462 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start