Why is nobody asking major questions on this subreddit, choosing tiny snippets?

Why are people so interested in these minor occurrences that in the end, don't majorly effect history?

2 Answers 2018-07-10

Is other countries have fake ancient history?

Well I am south korean and studying history at university.

But some korean people believe that there was an ancient Korean Empire 10000years ago call 'Hwhan'.

They think this Hwhan empire had occupied total Asia continient, half of the russia, and even America and Europe.

This is really awkward theory and there is no any evidence to prove it. But they said there is evidence.

For example in korea word mother is 'Um- Mah'. So they said this Um mah word changed to 'Amen'. So the even Jesus was Korean :/ And you know, their evidences are total shit.

Fortunately there are no historian accept this stupid Hwhan Empire. They said it's just a trash made by a man who wants to masturbate with fake history.

But some people still believe it is true. And even some senetor of korean argue it is ture history. And they attack normal historians. Because normal historians are jews and japanese who wants to 'hide' their Hwhan empire.

Is there any country have same problem like this?

3 Answers 2018-07-10

Are Norman Davies books anti-semitic?

I wanted to buy his books, as I'm Pole. Hoverer, I found that many sources claim that he is an anti-Semite. Is this true? Are his books biased?

1 Answers 2018-07-10

Are the titles World War One and World War Two examples of Euro-centric naming, or are the conflicts still called that in regions where different powers than the European ones were the main belligerents (such as East Asia) or in regions where powers remained largely neutral (like Lain America)?

1 Answers 2018-07-10

Who was the first Japanese Emperor generally accepted to have existed?

What's the mainstream consensus on the early Japanese Emperors? Did Jimmu exist? Are the ages just embellished and exaggerated? Or are early figures like Jimmu entirely mythical?

1 Answers 2018-07-10

It's 1943 in Western Europe and I'm a disillusioned German Officer. How would I go about defecting to the Allies? What would happen to me next?

My first thought we be to get in contact with an Allied spy, but that would mean I would have to know who that is and how to find them.

Another thing I'd imagine is possible is to rent a boat and just sail across the English Channel, but that seems unrealistic.

It's seems really difficult for an individual to switch sides in a war in any situation.

Edit: Added paragraphs of some initial thoughts

3 Answers 2018-07-10

What kind of firearms were popular with Alaskan Boom Town miners post 1900?

More specifically, what did they use against bears and other hostile wildlife?

1 Answers 2018-07-10

Why do Koreans call themselves Han / Daehan?

Any connection to the Chinese Han?

1 Answers 2018-07-10

When and how did "Byzantine" become a derogatory term meaning overly complicated, especially since, historically, the East Roman Empire wasn't known as the Byzantine Empire at all?

This came up over my family vacation this past week: I was talking with my sister and she, being frustrated at some local government red tape, referred to it as "Byzantine." I responded that that was a racist term and they preferred to call themselves Rhomaioi, not Byzantines. So when and why did the term pick up such negative connotations instead of just referring to the great, 1000-year empire of the Eastern Romans? I would assume it was after the particular historian decided to start referring to the empire centered on Constantinople/old-Byzantion, as the Byzantine Empire.

Thanks for your time in reading this and maybe responding. I've been a long-time reader of this subreddit but I think this might be my first actual posting of a question.

1 Answers 2018-07-10

Post Roman Britain ruins

After the Romans left Britain (and their relics remained) did the people who lived there centuries later (after 410AD) ever leave any preserved letters/writing questioning who built the previous structures (like Hadrian's Wall)?

1 Answers 2018-07-10

How would someone become a doctor in the 1700-1800s?

Would they have to go to university and take a similar route to nowadays?

I’ve heard horror stories of doctors from these times that sounded incredibly inept at their job.

1 Answers 2018-07-10

Why were the Celts (Gallic, Germanic, and Brythonic) not able to move past tribal society?

The Celtic tribes of Gaul, Brittania and Germania demonstrated exquisite craftsmanship, construction, and warfare and had access to the necessary materials and knowledge to create a more organized, well functioning society, yet progress seemed to have stagnated.

You'd think their ability to create some of the greatest iron weaponry and tools that they'd use them for more efficient farming and construction. So what happened?

1 Answers 2018-07-10

How did the region around the lower Mississippi River come to be so poor?

It seems to me that the region surrounding a large river that already featured a thriving port (New Orleans) would have been a prime target for industrialization. While New Orleans remains a major trade hub, move a little to the north and you'll find a region that is relatively underdeveloped and features some of the poorest parts of the US. How did this state of affairs come to pass?

1 Answers 2018-07-10

How did the economies of Anarchist Catalonia and the Ukrainian free territories actually function?

How did anarchist economies function for several years? Also can anyone recommend a book about anarchist polities in practice?

2 Answers 2018-07-10

Is there any evidence that Rommel committed war crimes and should have been a part of the Nazi War Crimes Trials?

1 Answers 2018-07-10

Help me find good books

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-07-10

Usage of CE/BCE Vs AD/BC

I would have thought that professional historians would use CE/BCE conventions for dating. Is this true, and why has there been no penetration into broader areas of history writing, such as Wikipedia and school textbooks?

2 Answers 2018-07-10

Why are views on the accuracy of muskets so divergent?

In the West it's common knowledge that old firearms(from early matchlocks to 19th century muskets) were inaccurate and also in other aspects inferior to bows.

But when I read about early firearms I often see the opposite claim, especially in Asia. For example in Samurai 1550-1600 by Anthony Bryant and Angus McBride matchlocks are presented as superior to the bow, with an effective killing range of 200 m. (I realize that an Osprey book is not exactly academic literature, but I've also seen similar claims in academic sources and Bryant seems to know his field)

Today I looked at the wikipedia article of the first percussion cap rifle of the US Army, from 1842, and it says that the unrifled version did not have sights because it was only effective to either 46 m or 69 m. Bryant claims 50 m as the optimal range for the arquebus.

These statements seem to contradict each other. Were Japanese guns or gunners so superior? Is either claim a lie or hyperbolic?

I hope you can understand my question, I'm not exactly sure how to phrase this.

2 Answers 2018-07-10

Did regular people in nazi Germany know of oncoming allied armies?

Say I live in a small town in the Reich, would I know about the allied and soviet troops?

2 Answers 2018-07-10

Did Nazi Germany get any tourism? If so, what countries visited? Were people who would be otherwise gassed (Jews, Blacks, homosexuals, etc) allowed there? Were they allowed to leave?

Reading The Stand by Stephen King, the antagonist Randall Flagg often compared to Hitler and he said something about the other society visiting (as a ruse) and it got me to this question.

Side note: Great book if you're into reading.

2 Answers 2018-07-10

What was "Treasurer's Plantation" in Jamestown, Virginia Colony (around the year 1624)?

1 Answers 2018-07-10

When Northern Italy and the Netherlands stopped being considered part of the Holy Roman Empire?

Decline of the Emperor's power was a gradual process, but was there some decisive point when it was generally recognized that Northern Italy was no longer part of the empire? Were there any negotiations or treaties? Or did the Italian states continue to pay lip service to the emperor until the dissolution of the Empire?

And what about the Netherlands? Before the Dutch rebellion, it was mostly part of the empire, but the wasn't the rebellion against the Spanish crown, not the HRE? Or is it considered to be basically the same thing as both Philip II and Ferdinand I were Hapsburgs?

I hope this question is not against the rule that forbids asking about basic facts, as there is more to it than just a date. If it is against the rules, I apologize.

1 Answers 2018-07-09

Why are most, if not all, ancient structures in Rome inscribed with pontifex maximus?

Is it a dedication? I am assuming that all princeps held the office of pontifex maximus but I wouldn't have thought it the dominant title.

1 Answers 2018-07-09

Are there any stories of major and well planned robberies (like in the Ocean's Eleven movies) in Ancient Rome (from Republic to fall of Rome in 476)?

Hello. First I have to say I love this subreddit and follow it closely.

Thank you all for the amazing job you do answering questions.

My question comes from reading about the time Caesar first walked on Rome and threatened a tribune of the plebs to stand aside as Caesar plundered the treasury of Rome that was in a temple.

Since cities at the time kept all their treasury in temples, are there any accounts during the time of Rome (from Republic to the fall of Rome in 476) of a group of thieves planning a major heist to take the whole treasury of a city(doesnt have to be the city of Rome here - any city will do).

I would love to know even if they failed. Also, if there any books that talk about it. Thanks in advance for the help.

1 Answers 2018-07-09

Is there any truth to the belief that only 3% of colonists took up arms against the British?

The right winged militia group “The 3%” say they based the name of their group off their claim that only 3% of colonists formed militia and fought the British during the Revolutionary War.

Is there any truth to this claim? Thank you.

1 Answers 2018-07-09

⯇ 2527 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start