Was it common to spell "the" as "thi" in 18th century America or is it one of the many idiosyncrasies of the woman I'm researching?

Has anyone else ever seen these used interchangeably?

1 Answers 2018-05-17

Is Greece the Byzantine successor country?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-05-17

/r/AskHistorians Hits 750,000 Subscribers Today! To Celebrate This Milestone, You May Post Your Frivolous, Lighthearted, and/or Witty Comments in This Thread!

76 Answers 2018-05-17

How much autonomy did the autonomous oblasts have within the USSR and how did they fit into the Soviet political hierarchy?

Reading about autonomous oblasts, the name seemed odd for a nation that was known for central planning. What was the relationship like between these oblasts and the republics, and how much autonomy did they really have?

1 Answers 2018-05-17

How did the Weimar republic halt hyperinflation?

1 Answers 2018-05-17

Who was L. Cassius Caecinianus?

The Wikipedia article on abecedaria references this person and a abecedarially marked denarius he supposedly minted. The name is plausible enough for a Roman Imperial dignitary, but a cursory internet search doesn't give anything beyond this denarius tale, which makes me suspicious. Anything known about him, his dates, his cursus and possibly this denarius?

1 Answers 2018-05-17

How many centuries were in the first cohort of an early Imperial legion?

The early Imperial legion had ten cohorts with the first being double sized. Was each century in the first cohort double sized or did they have an extra six centuries?

1 Answers 2018-05-17

Thursday Reading & Research | May 17, 2018

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Research is intended as an academic free-for-all, for the discussion of all issues historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • New developments or discoveries in the field

  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now

  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes

  • Your current research interests or projects

  • The goings on within the academy

  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion only of matters historical discussion, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

3 Answers 2018-05-17

What are some good books/sources on the Byzantine Empire?

Hi r/AskHistorians,

I'm a recently graduated university student, looking to become a Byzantine/Middle East scholar in the future, and have started studying this "lost empire" in detail. I've read John Norwich's and Judith Herrin's works on Byzantium and was looking for more deep, rich sources that I can read up on. Anything pertaining to the empire, both internally (religion, culture, society etc.) and the geopolitical situation at the time (economics, warfare, technology, other powers, etc.) would be fantastic!

I have a rudimentary understanding of the empire, its society and reactions to its neighbours, along with what's going on in the world during the Migration period/Medieval Era. However, I'm looking to learn more and expand the depth of my studies in this time period. Anything that you guys have to share would be a great help!

P.S. I'm not too sure if this is the right subreddit for these kinds of questions, and I apologise in advance if this isn't.

4 Answers 2018-05-17

[Novel Research] Travel and Daily Life from the American West to Prague in the 1880s

I am currently researching 1880s Prague for the sequel to my first published novel. I was wondering if some of you wonderful people could help me out with a few details that I'm unable to work out.

How would someone travel from say, Abilene, TX all the way to the Czech Republic capital of Prague? (Any good historical sources on what that journey would have been like?)

What was daily life like for a person in Prague, specifically, during the winter?

What was the political/social climate like?

What are a few things that might surprise us about Late 19th Century Prague?

How prevalent was Paganism in European Bohemia at this time?

I'll probably have more questions along the way, so I'd love to start building a relationship with anyone who might have a vested, academic interest in answering questions as they crop up in the narrative.

1 Answers 2018-05-17

Why didn't Imperial Japan Declare War on the USSR in support of Nazi Germany?

I'm listening to an episode of Opening Arguments in which the host digresses to mention that Soviet Russia didn't declare war on Imperial Japan when it joined the Allies against the Axis. Stalin was vulnerable in the east and didn't want to deal with Japanese soldiers while fending off Hitler's invasion on the Osfront.

Why, though, didn't Imperial Japan declare war on the USSR in support of their Nazi allies? Hitler declared war on the USA in support of Imperial Japan and both wars were initiated by Axis surprise attacks.

Was there any political fallout when Japan failed to follow through on the alliance commitments Hitler was faithful to? (that's awkward sentence to write)

3 Answers 2018-05-17

During the Holocaust, were gay men outside of Germany targeted?

I've read a lot about the persecution of homosexual men during the Holocaust, but it's unclear to me if the Nazis targeted people outside of Germany specifically for their sexuality. I know that their reasoning for targeting homosexual men was that they were removing themselves from the gene pool, and thus weakening the Aryan race, but does that mean they didn't target non-German homosexuals?

1 Answers 2018-05-17

There are two places (that I know of) in the Bible where a mob of people come to the door of a house demanding the right to gang rape a visitor - Judges 19:22 and Genesis 19:5. Does this sort of thing happen in other, contemporary ancient texts? If this was a semi-regular thing, why?

2 Answers 2018-05-17

Question about Israel/Palestine

Did Palestinians sell their own land to Jews? If so, how much of it was sold? I can't seem to find a definitive answer on this. Cheers.

1 Answers 2018-05-17

Can anyone tell me more information about this WW2 German prisoner dog tag?

I would like to find out more information about this artifact if possible.

Before my great grandfather died, he told me the story of this badge. He was a communication officer aboard a B-17 bomber. His crew and a host of other bombers flew a mission over Holland to bomb a facility. Upon entering the area, they were unchallenged. Perhaps because the Germans had not had time to scramble a response. However, after dropping their payloads and turning back for home they came under heavy fire from aircraft and ground based anti-aircraft guns. His plane was downed somewhere in Holland.

My grandfather and the rest of his crew, minus the bottom turret gunner who was unable to escape due to hydraulic system failure, landed in the field of a Dutch farmer. The farmer took them a change of clothing and made them hide in the hay stacks of his field for a few days. Later, the squad of men decided to try and trek back to allied lines. However, while on the move, they were captured by a gestapo unit. My great grandfather then spent 3 years of the war in a POW/concentration camp until he was liberated and brought back home.

This is the story as I remember it being told to me as a young boy. I would like to know if anyone can make out the inscriptions or decipher their meaning so I can find out more about where he was detained.

Thanks!

2 Answers 2018-05-17

Why didn’t Portugal get overrun and conquered by Spain?

1 Answers 2018-05-17

During the Modern period (c.1500-1800) many of the regents of European powers claimed some sort of divine right as their mandate to rule. How did they respond to other regents making similar claims in other, often rival nations?

Would, for example, Queen Elizabeth have something to say about the divine claims of the rulers of France and Spain?

Specifically there are two factors I would like to understand more:

1) Many of the royal families in Europe, particularly in the later Modern period, are interrelated. What impact would this have with regard to questioning the legitimacy of one's right to rule?

2) What was the impact of the Protestant/Catholic divide in how Kings and Queens regarded the legitimacy of others' right to rule?

1 Answers 2018-05-17

Did german chancellor Helmut Schmidt and the US interfere in portuguese and spanish politics in the 1970s?

So I'm reading Yanis Varoufakis's And the Weak Suffer What They Must?, and he mentions very offhandedly something that caught my eye:

Italian, Spanish and Portuguese politics were also crucial to the monetary union project. Chancellor Schmidt had invested enormous political capital, in collaboration with Washington, to ensure that the Left failed in its bid for power in the Iberian peninsula14 and, of course, in Italy where a resurgent communist party, under the enlightened leadership of Enrico Berlinguer, was working on a “historic compromise” with progressive elements of Italy’s Christian Democrats.

with footnote 14 saying only:

14. Schmidt proved instrumental in organizing the failure, and eventual overthrow, of the radical leftist government that took over in Portugal after the 1975 revolution that ended a long right-wing dictatorship. He also played a key role in preventing the left from making gains during the transition of Spain from Franco’s fascist regime to parliamentary democracy.

There's no citation, and a look at the references section isn't elucidating what the source for this is. My questions are: is it true that Germany and the US interfered in the domestic politics of Portugal and Spain in the 70s to sabotage left wing political forces and if so how was this done? I've never heard of this, and I'd like to know more.

1 Answers 2018-05-17

I’ve been reading a bit about Israel’s declaration and the history of Judaism. One thing that’s really bothered me is the consistent hatred towards the Jewish people. Are their specific events that triggered anti-semitism? If not, how has it stayed so prevalent for over 2000 years?

I’m not asking why people “dislike” Jews, as the Wikipedia entry is quite clear that there has been political, religious, and racist views of Jews for centuries, possibly resulting in some next-level propaganda. Specifically, are there are events or situations that give anti-semitism formal roots? Or was it just that people thought it was weird that random Jewish migrants never integrated?

I should mention I don’t really know much about the Jewish people, and don’t want to incite some sort of race-war type conversation. I’m more interested in events, statements, people, situations, etc that would at least slightly explain why Jewish people are hated throughout history.

1 Answers 2018-05-17

What do we definitely know about the child sacrifices of the Incan empire?

In preparing for my trip to Peru, I've been reading about various aspects of the Peruvian history. The one thing that baffles me is the treatment of child sacrifices. It seems that the literature generally asserts that:

  • the child sacrifices were often linked to nobility or even the emperor; and
  • it was a great honour for the family and the child to be chosen as the sacrifice.

But I am not convinced. The evidence presented to support the above is that:

  1. The mummies of the child sacrifices discovered to date often show traces of cocaine (coca leaves), which were restricted in the Incan empire and only the people of high status could have access to them;
  2. The child mummies show no signs of malnourishment and they seem and well taken care of;
  3. The mummies are often discovered with very ornate textiles and pottery and jewelry, often belonging to nobility;
  4. There are some writings that show that local chiefs who have volunteered their children as tribute were given high governmental posts.

I completely fail to see that how this indicates that the children came from nobility (some articles go as far as claiming that the children were princes or princesses). For example, the Aztecs fed and dressed their sacrifices well for at least a year before the actual ritual, and as these sacrifices were treated as a member of the inner religious circle (or whatever prestige you have in that society), of course they could have had access to coca leaves that way. Along the same line of thought, they could have been well-treated and well-dressed BECAUSE they were already destined for sacrifice from a very young age, not the other way around.

Furthermore, the fact that some people used their children as a political stepping stone (i.e. they were REWARDED for volunteering their children as sacrifices; if it were truly an honour, people would be PAYING to volunteer their children, not the other way around) proves to me that these child sacrifices were reluctant participants, and most likely not nobility. I think that the more likely would be that they were of the under-privileged class, and that someone not them stood to benefit from their sacrifice.

I believe that there are some accounts of the Spaniards who rescued a girl who was walled up alive for three days as a sacrifice, and also another account of a boy who narrowly escaped being a sacrifice. La Doncella, one of the mummies from the Incan human sacrifice, apparently had well-worn teeth and white hair (at the age of 13!) which are often taken as signs of extreme stress.

I strongly believe that a society where death is truly an honour cannot exist -- if this were the case, everyone would just go ahead and kill themselves for a noble cause (ok, to be fair, the Incan empire didn't last long, but they didn't mean for it to crumble so quickly!) and I doubt even more that the children belonged to important people of the Incan empire. Rather, it seems like a well-designed scam where the children could be volunteered by anyone -- there is SOME chance that they would become child sacrifices, but also:

  • Whoever volunteers the children would receive some tangible reward;
  • the children might not become sacrifices and lead a decent life (I believe they could also be the priestesses of the temple of the sun, or concubines or wives of the Cusco nobles or even the emperor),

so that some people would literally tempt the fate, drawn by these two way more attractive possibilities.

So, why is it that the popular opinion today is still that the children were sacrificed willingly, and that they came from a noble line? I don't mean to be argumentative, and I would be glad to be convinced otherwise (because my views are clearly very grim and disturbing), but I wonder if the historians are overly glorifying the human sacrificial practices of the Incas. (Also since I am not an Andean scholar and most of what I reference comes from Google, you might have to correct me, too).

1 Answers 2018-05-17

When was the Papacy created and how did it gain its current power?

It seems like an easy enough question to answer, but it's a surprisingly difficult answer to find. Catholics claim St. Peter was the first Pope, a claim Protestants have always rejected. The Pope was also absent at the Council of Nicea, so where did the institution come from and how did it become what it is now?

1 Answers 2018-05-17

Smoking wasn't banned on airplanes until 1998. How did airlines put up with it, if it was supposed to affect instruments on the plane?

Were instruments more robust back then? Were flights a lot more dangerous and expensive?

1 Answers 2018-05-17

In "The Prince", who was Machiavelli's audience? He references it is to "those who know" but doesn't elaborate.

While Machiavelli claims it is made for Lorenzo de Medici in the forward, in Chp 16 he states it is really written for "those who know". This implies it is for someone else. Could this be an indirect reference for philosophers or the King's advisors?

2 Answers 2018-05-17

My friend has a CZ-38 German sidearm and he’s trying to figure out who it belonged to.

Is there anyway he can use the serial number to find out what squadron or soldier it was issued to?

1 Answers 2018-05-17

Why does New York State have so many cities named after historical European cities?

I was taking some geography quizzes and doing trivia when I noticed that the state of New York has cities that are named after famous historical places, mostly European cities. Some of these are

Rome, Hamburg, Syracuse, Dunkirk, New Berlin, Carthage, Amsterdam, Bath, Potsdam, Copenhagen, Carthage, Greece, Leeds, Rotterdam

I'm sure there are others I am missing. I do know that these kind of names for cities in the United States are not uncommon in many states, but it seems New York has much more than average. Is there any particular reason as to why this is and if it was a pattern or tradition in New York's history? I was just curious!

1 Answers 2018-05-17

⯇ 2626 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start