Atlantic history: emerging field or unnecessary?

I want to go to grad school. My current college (also in my hometown) offers a transatlantic history masters and PhD, otherwise I’d have to go out of state for another program (which I really don’t want)

I really like Latin American history, but I’m also interested in how African cultures interacted with European/Native American populations. Honestly, Atlantic history seems to merge a lot of interesting fields without having to specialize on one region or period. That’s very appealing to me.

That being said, a lot of historians have criticized the emerging research field of “transatlantic” or “atlantic” history.

I have a background in economics and will be learning to speak French soon (already fluent and a very strong writer in both Spanish and English)

Thoughts on whether this is a worthy endeavor?

1 Answers 2018-04-11

What raw materials were most important to a WW2 nation's war industry?

Of course steel, and aluminum, what other minerals and elements were necessary for the war effort at this time, and what were they used for?

For example I've heard Germany experienced shortages of chromium, tungsten, bauxite, zinc and lead, and I assume many of these are steel additives, but what about stuff like bauxite and tungsten?

What are the most important raw resources for industry at this time period?

Any good texts/docs you can link?

1 Answers 2018-04-11

What did Winston Churchill mean by "perverted science" in his "Finest Hour" speech?

I was under the impression that not all the despicable experiments done by Nazis were known at the time. This history stackexchange post is inconclusive whether Churchill referred to military prowess or Dr. Mengele's experiments.

1 Answers 2018-04-11

Is "Adam Ruins Everything's" Reanimated History really as accurate as it makes itself out to be?

1 Answers 2018-04-11

At what point did the majority of the German military realize they lost WWII?

How many of them "drank the Kool aide" so to speak and believed up until the very end they were gong to win? Did any hope that Hitler would've seen the futility of continuing the war and surrender or seek negotiated peace?

2 Answers 2018-04-11

Can someone tell me more about GLADIO?

1 Answers 2018-04-11

Why is Shakespeare considered to be one of the best writers of all time? Has he always been taught about? If not, when and why did he become a staple of high school curriculum?

2 Answers 2018-04-11

Why all the hate for Guns Germs and Steel?

A lot of people all over the internet seem to have very strong opinions regarding this book; they either love it or hate it, although i tend to see more of the latter. But why? From what I read, the book summed up in one sentence is "Geography determines destiny" and this makes a lot of sense to me. If you live in a place with the necessary resources to start an civilization, then your good, and those resources change over time, so different civilizations dominated the world at different times. So do historians not agree with this argument? Are they just being stubborn? Am I missing something from the book? I've read a lot of views on the book and I was hoping for just an overall summary of why so many scholars (or so called scholars) seem to hate this book.

1 Answers 2018-04-11

According to the Bible, the Tower of Babel is where all languages began. What documents or other similar things do we have in a language other than Hebrew that pre dates Babel, theoretically disproving it?

Many many people take Babel literally. If we have documents that pre date it in a language other than Hebrew, it would disprove it as fact. What documents / tablets / artefacts do we have, if any that do that?

1 Answers 2018-04-11

If I said someone had "yellow skin" in the late 19th/early 20th century USA, would people assume that I was talking about an Asian or a light-skinned black/biracial person?

I hear a lot in songs like "The Yellow Rose of Texas" about "yellow" people, especially girls, and I know they are referring to light-skinned black/biracial people. But would Asians have also been thought of as having "yellow" skin, or would there have been a different idea as to what color they were? And were the two ever connected in any way?

1 Answers 2018-04-11

How, in less than three generations, has Germany gone from losing the Second World War to becoming the economical powerhouse of Europe?

1 Answers 2018-04-11

Ibn Battuta and the Land of Darkness

When Ibn Battuta visited the Golden Horde in 1332 (ish) he wanted to travel further North to "the land of darkness" where a strange people with strange customs lived.

They would not trade for goods in person, instead going to an open place in the snow where southern merchants had left goods to trade. They would take these in the night and leave furs and other valuables for the southerners to pick up in the morning.

I have read about trade between Europeans and Native Americans being conducted in a similar way. My question is what kind of assumptions can we make about this behaviour, considering that both native Siberian and American populations were almost eradicated by disease.

Do we know if they had an understanding of disease transmission and that this was done for the same reason in both instances? Are there any other examples of this?

Thanks for your time and apologies for the awful description.

1 Answers 2018-04-11

In Doc Watson's "House of the Rising Sun", he sings "don't believe what a bad woman tells you... ...unless she's standing on some old scaffold high, saying 'fellas they won't let me come down'".

Was putting women up on scaffolds ever an actual practice? Does he mean it metaphorically? Or is it just a nonsense verse?

1 Answers 2018-04-11

Did people make paper airplanes before the invention of the airplane?

1 Answers 2018-04-11

When did tradition of having a first-name and a surname come from? Was there a time when people only had one name?

In Ancient Greece for example you get people like Socrates who's only called Socrates. But in Rome it seemed everyone had 2 names. So when did this happen?

2 Answers 2018-04-11

Where did the idea that Vikings had to die with a sword in their hand come from?

What's the historical/theological context behind this? Why did they, as pagans, prefer pyres to burials? Or are these ideas myths perpetuated by mainstream TV?

1 Answers 2018-04-11

How accurate is the world population estimation of around 10,000 BC?

How confident are historians when they conduct studies like this predicting entire world population eons ago. I can't wrap my head around the fact that most studies estimate that only 2-4 million homo sapiens existed 12,000 years ago. Is there any possibility that these studies are way off?

1 Answers 2018-04-11

How did people in pre-Sunblock times protect themselves from severe sunburn?

1 Answers 2018-04-11

Did warriors have one arm much larger than other due to wielding weapons?

Like tennis where some players have a massive dominant arm. But I've never heard/seen it really being noticeable with ancient warriors or it being mentioned.

1 Answers 2018-04-11

How did archers keep their arrows?

In movies you often see archers running around or on horseback with a quiver with arrows on their backs. I'm wondering if this is an accurate depiction of how archers kept their quivers?

If so, how were the arrows kept in position while running/moving so violently?

3 Answers 2018-04-11

How long on average did people spend in Nazi camps specialized for extermination and not labor?

What I think I kniw

There are prisoners that survived labor camps such as Auschwitz and you hear stories of some occasions where prisoners survived years in these camps, but i'm curious, in camps that where meant solely for extermination, how long could people survive on average, and are there any stories of people surviving extended periods of time?

1 Answers 2018-04-11

How were nobles and other people of importance identified in medieval Europe?

Most modern governments keep records to make sure people are who they say they are, but they can only do this because of modern technology.

So, in the medieval world of Europe, what would stop, say a commoner, from claiming they were a visiting noble of another family and being treated as a guest of another noble?

Did nobles carry around pedigree papers or official insignias of their family's heraldry? If they did, what kept these from being forged?

1 Answers 2018-04-11

During WWII, the Soviets famously moved a great deal of their factories east of the Urals to continue the war effort. Did this create a sustained industrial boom in Western Siberia, or were the factories just relocated back to Ukraine/Belarus after the war?

1 Answers 2018-04-11

Why did Ottoman Jannisaries come only from the Balkans?

Didn’t the Ottoman holdings in the Middle East have Christians too?

1 Answers 2018-04-11

I was told my college campus used to be a morgue.. Can anyone tell me what this is?

1 Answers 2018-04-11

⯇ 2702 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start