How accurate is Treasure Island in portraying the way pirates of the Atlantic and Caribbean spoke?

I finished the show Black Sails and that led me to listen to Treasure Island on audio book. As I've been listening I've found the pirates' dialog to be over the top and eye roll inducing, but I don't know if it's accurate or not. How accurate is that book in portraying the way those pirates would have spoken? And if it's not accurate, is there a good movie/show to watch to get a more accurate portrayal of how they would of spoken?

1 Answers 2018-04-07

Why is Akhenaten's depiction so different from other pharaohs?

Here's a statue and a carving of Akhenaten, and here's one of Ramses the second. While Ramses's depiction is standard for how the pharoah's generally were depicted, Akhenaten looks almost alien-like with his slanted eyes, elongated head, slender frame and wide hips. What is the reasoning behind this depiction? I know that there was sort of a character-assassination policy led by his son Tutankhamun to tarnish his legacy (which is what I assumed was the reasoning behind this bizarre depiction, as sort of an insulting reminder of the heretic that almost destroyed the Egyptian religion), but most of the statues/carvings depicting him were made when he was alive, with his permission and blessing. Did he have some kind of ailment or disease like his son (who was still shown to be normal looking in his statues and carvings) from successive generations of inbreeding? or was he a foreigner who looked different from the rest of the population?

1 Answers 2018-04-07

What is the current state of the historical reasearch regarding the Cabot expeditions?

Hello, I am currently trying to rebuild a model replica (or rather interpretation) of Cabot's Matthew. For that reason i want to know a bit more about the explorer and the current state of the historical research regarding him.

Have there been any recent archeological or historical research papers about him, his expeditions or some new revelations about his vessel?

1 Answers 2018-04-07

Saturday Showcase | April 07, 2018

Previous

Today:

AskHistorians is filled with questions seeking an answer. Saturday Spotlight is for answers seeking a question! It’s a place to post your original and in-depth investigation of a focused historical topic.

Posts here will be held to the same high standard as regular answers, and should mention sources or recommended reading. If you’d like to share shorter findings or discuss work in progress, Thursday Reading & Research or Friday Free-for-All are great places to do that.

So if you’re tired of waiting for someone to ask about how imperialism led to “Surfin’ Safari;” if you’ve given up hope of getting to share your complete history of the Bichon Frise in art and drama; this is your chance to shine!

1 Answers 2018-04-07

If the Byzantine Empire had lost everything except Constantinople to the Ottomans, why was it such a shock when it fell in 1453?

1 Answers 2018-04-07

Ancient Egyptian/Coptic was spoken by almost all Egyptians for thousands of years, from Khufu and Tutankhamen all the way down to Cleopatra, and even under centuries of Roman rule. Why was the language of the pharaohs so quickly replaced by Arabic within just a few centuries of Islamic rule?

1 Answers 2018-04-07

According to the 'The American Experience' on him, US Grant was the most revered public figure in American life in the 19th century, significantly more popular than Lincoln, and yet he has regularly been evaluated as an awful President in CSPAN's survey of historians. Is this a disconnect? Why?

That is, where does the disconnect come from?

2 Answers 2018-04-07

What methods are used to study mythology?

I am doing an rp on mythology and one of the question i have to answer is how mythology is studied and analysed. I have not been able to fins any good information and wanted to know if y'all had any good information or good website/videos thanks. Samira <3

1 Answers 2018-04-07

The letters of Paul are the oldest part of the New Testament; did he realize they would be disseminated widely? Was he writing for posterity?

1 Answers 2018-04-07

I am a Sanskrit speaker in five-rivers area in northwestern Indian subcontinent around 500 BCE. Which areas of Indian subcontinent and Iran speak a language legible to me?

To give some background, I was taught classical Sanskrit at school and understand the language of Rig Veda passably. I opened Avesta transcribed in my mother tongue ( Gujarati - since the majority surviving Zoroastrian community used to speak that language ) on archive.org out of curiosity and found it quite legible. I am not sure of the composition time or geographical area of its composition. But I was struck by how similar it sounded.

2 Answers 2018-04-07

The University of Texas massacre in 1966 was the deadliest mass public shooting in US when it occurred. Was there contentious debates on gun policy and civilian firearm ownership like today in the aftermath of shooting?

1 Answers 2018-04-07

How to do historical research?

I'm not a historian, but would like to conduct some researches about some topics.

Can anyone suggest how to do it? Any goog proces for it?

Thanks

2 Answers 2018-04-07

In the recently released first chapter of the Aztec Empire comic, it is stated that the total population of the Aztec empire is 20 million people. Is this accurate? How has our understanding of Mesoamerican population sizes changed over time?

http://www.bigredhair.com/books/aztec-empire/episode-one/

Furthermore, in the notes, it states

The population of the entire mpire is widely accepted as being around 20 million. Sheburne Cook and Woodrow Borah, leading researchs of Mexican population history, convincingly argue in Conquest and Population: A demographic Approach to mexican History, that there were 25.2 million people in Mexico when Cortes arrived iin 1519

I've always heard the empire's population as 5 million. 20 million would make it larger then any nation in europe at the time, (unless my numbers for those are off too), much larger then ones of comparable area; and is hard to believe, even as somebody who constantly talks about how cool Mesoamerican accomplishments are. At the same time, I've always heard 25 million is around the range of where the total population of Mexico (though I suspect "Mexico" here means "Mesoamericia" rather then moodern mexican borders, so not including very north mexico, and including some of guatamala, belize, etc) was at the time, the Aztec empire only having 20% of that, despite covering, what, 40% of mexico seems off to me. But if it is 20 million, then that would mean the Purepecha empire, despite being extremely large as well, had a disproportionately little amount of people.

Neither the 5 million or 20 million figure seems to make much sense here.

(Also, small bonus question; The notes also identify the infamous Snake labret with the articulated tounge as being Mixte created: I've always thought it was Aztec, which is it?)

1 Answers 2018-04-07

What did the Founders say about the Second Amendment and its use against potential tyranny?

First of all, I understand that the Founders were against any notion of revolt against a representative government, and believe revolt was justifiable only in the event that elections were not being held.

But did any of the Founders say this was one of the purposes of the Second Amendment?

1 Answers 2018-04-07

Did Ecbert's villa in the TV show 'Vikings' actually exist?

Was it a roman villa in winchester? Was there a roman villa in winchester?

I don't think the show even mentions that the king of wessex has his main residence at winchester, though.

1 Answers 2018-04-07

In WWI, why did Italy join the Entente Powers instead of the Central Powers?

I have heard that Italy had a treaty with Austria-Hungary before the war began. Why did they choose against joining the Central Powers?

1 Answers 2018-04-07

The English seem adept at divising epithets for their rivals; did the long period of English rivalry with Spain result in any derrogatory nickname more aggressive than 'Spaniard'?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-04-07

Any good books about Confederate soldiers and their motives in the American Civil War?

1 Answers 2018-04-07

Hi, I would like some help finding military records.

So I joined this group a little over a year ago to find records on my grandfather who was a WWII vet. Well, I just found out that I had another WWII vet on my moms side of the family who, for some reason, was neglected by the family. I looked into it more and its says he was a WWII, but this is what confuses me. On some reports it says he was only a korean war vet, but on his gravestone it says he was a WW2 vet. I dont know his military id # since I never met him but i have some info. His name was Harold McDermott and was born on April 26, 1929. He was from Scranton, PA and died March 19, 2008. If you can help me out I would appreciate a ton.

1 Answers 2018-04-07

Did Isaac newton ever come close to a theory of general relativity?

2 Answers 2018-04-07

What incentive (other than violence) was there for pagans to convert to Christianity? What social technologies did Christianity have that led to its rapid spread into the pagan world?

Take, maybe, the Germanic pagans for example (Saxony, Scandinavia etc.). Sorry if the term 'social technology' might be a bit vague, I only ask this way because I've heard it phrased before that the pagan world was 'overwhelmed' by social technology that paganism didn't posses.

1 Answers 2018-04-07

Books that describe the experiences of German soldiers on the front in World War I

Hello /r/AskHistorians.

One of my students is currently writing a history essay on how accurate 'All Quiet on the Western Front' was as a film. She wants to focus on the film's depiction of the life of a German soldier. As such, I'm trying to help her by suggesting books that describe what life was really like for the soldiers. There are a number of great books on the war but most seem to focus on the key events. Now we have a lot of basic info about life in the trenches and the strain of warfare, etc, but I was wondering if you could recommend some books on the subject to help round out the essay. So far we have Ring of Steel by Watson and A world undone: The story of the Great War by Meyer.

I would appreciate any reliable sources, books or otherwise, that can help provide information on this topic.

Thank you

3 Answers 2018-04-07

What is the current state of Japanese historical scholarship in Japan itself?

I am kind of curious, because when people ask questions about Japan the topics that often most reliably answered tend to be those for which Europeans were around in some form, leaving records, letters and transcripts there were passed down and interpreted by western historians.

There seems to be less ability to reliably answer questions about popular subjects such about the Sengoku era (Someone recently remarked there essentially were no reliable English scholars for matters concerning Ninja/Shinobi). Is this because Japanese records for these periods are not translated, or simply are not there?

I suppose I am asking because I really have no idea how comprehensive Japan's own historical record is compared to say, China's, and how many primary sources they have available for many periods of their history (Meiji, Sengoku, Heian). What resources do modern Japanese historians have to work with, how rigorous are the history programs at Japanese Universities, and how much access do Western (English-speaking, primarily) historians have to Japanese primary sources?

2 Answers 2018-04-06

Wyoming, Utah, Montana and Washington were the first states in the US to grant women the right to vote. Were these states unusually progressive on women's rights? If so, why were they so progressive and if not, why were they the first to grant women the right to vote?

1 Answers 2018-04-06

What do we know about the origin of myths ?

1 Answers 2018-04-06

⯇ 2711 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start