Did French sappers/engineers wear armor circa 1810?

So suggests this illustration by an Alfred Marbot, (the date is not specified, but it was sometime before his death in 1865.) He illustrated a large number of Napoleonic uniforms, which can apparently be found in this book.

But anyways, is this a inaccurate/fictitious reimagining, or did they really wear a cuirass and stahlhelm-like helmets? What purpose could this serve?

1 Answers 2018-03-05

How accurate is William Wallace's dress in comparison to the later highland dress?

Sorry to add yet another question about Braveheart, but I don't think this has been asked before. https://media.discordapp.net/attachments/277385350723403776/420363469980958720/maxresdefault.png?width=1248&height=702

Take this picture. I know it's wrong for the time the film is set, kilts and plaid weren't invented for centuries, but is it an accurate depiction of what later highlanders look like? I'm comparing it to this painting from the 18th century, which I'm assuming is accurate and not seeing many massive differences. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/d5/The_Battle_of_Culloden.jpg

1 Answers 2018-03-05

How historically accurate is “How the West Was Won”?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-03-05

Why was Finland the only country to pay off its entire WW1 debt to the U.S.?

In my U.S. textbook the U.S. debt policy, its financial complications, and its diplomatic effects were briefly discussed, ending with the summary that eventually no country ever fully paid its debts, except for “brave little Finland [in 1976]”. What circumstances led for Finland of all countries to repay its debt over 58 years?

EDIT: I have the quote from my textbook (American Pageant). “President Herbert Hoover declared a one-year debt moratorium in 1931, and before long all the debtors had defaulted — except ‘honest little Finland,’ which struggled along making payments until the last of its debt was discharged in 1976.”. I can dig into my textbooks citations for more info but not tonight as its not on me.

2 Answers 2018-03-05

Whitewashed castles (1400s Bohemia)

Were castles in the (early) 1400s generally whitewashed and painted on the inside walls? More specifically, I want to know about Bohemia/Czech republic.

Thanks in advance.

1 Answers 2018-03-05

1935, Did the British allow Mussolini to use the Suez Canal or Gibraltar to invade Ethiopia?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-03-05

Who were the Carlists and the Futurists, and what role did they play in the fascist movements of their respective countries?

These two groups seem to often be mentioned briefly in connection with Spanish and Italian Fascism. But apart from the Carlists being some kind of royalist faction and the Futurists some kind of artistic movement, their identity and role never seem very clear.

1 Answers 2018-03-05

Shakespeare's Cleopatra was black. How did audiences react to a portrayal of a queen renowned for her beauty and charm in this way at a time when "blackness" was associated with unattractiveness and sin? What are the broader implications of this for her relationship with Antony and Caesar?

For anyone who does not know, Shakespeare does not describe Cleopatra as Hellenistic monarch, instead she is portrayed as a "gypsy" (meaning an Egyptian before it became solely associated with Romani "gypsy" travellers who were mistakenly thought to come from Egypt), of "tawny" (tan) hue, with a breast that "pinches black", and is often considered black in the same sense as Shakespeare's Othello, who is described in similar terms, is "black". Of course, concepts of what made a person "black" were different at the time but I am writing this to ask what contemporaries felt so this is somewhat irrelevant.

Although I have dived into the ramifications of this for changing perceptions of Cleopatra as an Oriental seductress, I never actually gave much thought to how contemporary audiences would have reacted to this.

As /u/cdesmoulins stated here in Was Othello's marriage to Desdemona in Shakespeare's Famous Tragedy a Scandalous or Bold Topic?:

Black people were not exclusively exotics in Elizabethan and Jacobean England; indeed they may have been in the audiences for these plays. But popular stereotypes of blackness were negative and lended themselves to dramatization on the stage anyway -- black characters appeared in Elizabethan and Jacobean drama, and references to black skin pop up with negative connotations to contrast the corresponding idealization of "fair" whiteness. Blackness on the Elizabethan and Jacobean stage is perilously close to devilishness, dirtiness, and difference, not just racially.

But in other respects their [Othello and Desdemona's] respective fates would have played into white audiences' expectations -- that black people are good enough to work alongside but not so good to marry, perhaps, or that black people are unhappily different from white people, for instance, inadvertently reinforcing the prejudice that caused that same unhappiness.

Obviously Antony and Cleopatra's story has to end in tragedy but how did English audiences perceive this (now interracial) relationship and the portrayal of Cleopatra as a whole?

1 Answers 2018-03-05

In Kurosawa's film "Yojimbo", the main character often keeps his arms inside his kimono instead of in the sleeves. Was this a common behavior in 19th century Japan?

1 Answers 2018-03-05

Evidence for/against CIA involvement in drug trafficking?

The theory that the CIA were involved in the distribution of crack to low income black neighbourhoods in the 1980s interests me, but I want to know how much validity there is to this claim, or whether it’s just another crackpot theory

1 Answers 2018-03-05

Nationalism - what road to take?

Hello everyone!

I have been interested in Nationalism for some time now and have recently decided to start delving into professional works about it. So following this I have read 'Imagined Communities' by Benedict Anderson and 'National Identity' by Anthony D. Smith and some other minor articles on the subject. Also I am aware of The Nationalism Project and I have read some of the threads on nationalism under this subreddit. My question for you is which work should I read next? My immediate options for major works are 'Nations and Nationalism since 1780' from Eric Hobsbawm, 'Nations and Nationalism' from Ernest Gellner or 'Nationalism Reframed' by Rogers Brubaker. One other option would be to read 'Nations and Nationalism in a Global Era' by Anthony D. Smith before one of the other major works, as it perhaps would allow me to more closely Smith's arguments since I just finished reading National Identity yesterday.

Lastly, feel free to provide any clarifications/distinctions you may feel are important! Thank you for your help!

3 Answers 2018-03-05

Hitler is pretty clearly seen as the "villain" of WW2. Did WW1 have a "villain" in the eyes of the world at its close?

1 Answers 2018-03-05

how come soldiers can commit these horrible crimes during wartime but not during peace

how come soldiers during the Cambodian genocide can do these awful crimes that go against human nature, but they wouldn't have dreamed of doing it if there was no war? I'm trying to write a paper on this, but i don't know how and where to start

1 Answers 2018-03-05

During the last decade or two of the 18th century, was anyone (apart from Quakers, of course) still using "thee" and "thou" in ordinary speech?

I want to restrict this specifically to ordinary speech, as I am well aware of then-contemporary lingering uses of "thou" and "thee" in fossilized legal and religious language, as well as in certain types of literature.

1 Answers 2018-03-05

Hitler has a change of heart, and surrenders rather than commit suicide in the Furher bunker. What plans did the allies have for him?

Let's say Hitler chose to surrender rather than commit suicide. Did the allies have any plans for him? Would he be executed like other high ranking Nazis? Or would he have been kept as an example of the failing Nazi ideology?

2 Answers 2018-03-05

Readings about clothing in ancient Greece and Rome

Can anyone recommend books that provide comprehensive introductions to the types of clothing in ancient Greece and Rome? I'm especially interested in women's clothing.

1 Answers 2018-03-05

How true is the statement "we have more historical evidence of Jesus existence then that of Julius Caeser."

2 Answers 2018-03-05

Books on the Swedish Empire during the thirty years war and the great Northern war

I am interested in those time periods specifically about Sweden. Basically the 1611-1721 time period, I would like some thing with detail but not hard to read, but please don't exclude any books regardless.

Thank you

1 Answers 2018-03-05

Were "barbarians" (Gauls, Germans, etc) from antiquity typically more brawny, muscular, and more physically intimidating than a typical Roman soldier of the time?

I know that the depiction of these warriors as fearsome and large come from Julius Caesar's commentary on the Gaulic Wars, and there are other instances of ancient writers describing these warriors in a similar manner. One /r/AskHistorians post I read stated that one writer felt the need to illustrate when a Roman soldier defeated a "barbarian" in a one on one fight, indicating that it was an impressive feat, possibly due to the size discrepancy. While Caesar had an ulterior motive to depicting them this way, the ancient writers could be reasonably believed as accurate.

However, a post in /r/HistoricalWhatIf asking about how a modern NFL player would compare physically to ancient soldiers contained a popular comment stating that these barbarian soldiers were, on average, no more physically imposing than a typical Roman. The poster states that this idea comes from Romanticized paintings from the 18th century and is akin to depictions of Vikings wearing winged helms and other historical cliches. They made this claim based off of the assumption that since both cultures we're agrarian, an agrarian diet would lead to similar statures. Below is said post.

https://www.reddit.com/r/HistoricalWhatIf/comments/1abfe9/how_would_modern_american_football_players_fare

Who is right? Were these Gaullic and Germanic peoples really physically larger than a typical Roman? I obviously trust /r/AskHistorians a great deal more given the general expertise of the posters here, but I would love some clarification on this.

1 Answers 2018-03-05

The dawn of the year 2000 was celebrated and feared in many parts of the world. How was the dawn of the year 1000 viewed, in those parts of the world that observed years in this way?

The dawn of the second millenium was met with many theories about the millenium bug and other theories of mass confusion and difficulties. How was the dawn of the first millenium (1000 AD) viewed before it occurred? Was there as much of a reaction by the general public and/or policymakers? Was it celebrated in any special way? I am also wondering about the impact of differing calendars between countries of the world. How/when were monumental years celebrated in countries that used a lunar calendar? Were they celebrated at all?

1 Answers 2018-03-05

What factors lead to the near-disappearance of Buddhism from the medieval Indian subcontinent?

I'd heard previously that Buddhism used to be a very dominant belief system in India, but at some point the Buddhist community in India markedly shrank. This seems unusual to me, as some of Buddhism's holiest sites are in India and it's the place where the religion was born. The only reason I was given was that a series of Hindu thinkers provided a number of arguments that served to convince Buddhists that they were wrong, but this doesn't strike me as a satisfactory explanation, because I don't think communities are, in general, the sort of things that can be "convinced" like individual people, and because the other examples of religious disappearance I can think of are largely due to policy prescriptions, persecution, or the aftereffects of historical events.

1 Answers 2018-03-05

How did the Spanish colonists react to finding the impact location of the meteor in the gulf of Mexico?

1 Answers 2018-03-05

Roman Historians -- Help understanding Claudius' speech/the Lyon tablet

I don't really understand what Claudius means when he says, "I take all the young men whom I see before me; that they are senators should cause no more regret than Persicus feels—a most noble man and my friend—when he reads among the images of his ancestors the name of Allobrogicus..."

Why would he feel regret that the men before him are senators? Because these senators are young men? Because he is saying what he is saying in front of the Senate, and they may not agree with him? Because some of the senators are foreigners/Gauls/what have you? I think I'm missing some context.

Also, when he says, “It is now time, Tiberius Caesar Germanicus, to reveal to the conscript fathers where your speech is leading: for now you have come to the farthest borders of Galiia Narbonensis,” is he speaking figuratively? Is this a quip about his going off topic?

Lastly, based on my interpretation of these two passages, I get the vibe that he is kind of witty and perceptive. Something I wouldn't expect from the stuttering, socially awkward Claudius that so many speak of. Do you agree with me?

This is the very first time I've looked at Claudius' speech, and I'm not very familiar with ancient sources, so these may be silly questions. If anybody can share some insight with me I'd really appreciate it!

Thanks!

1 Answers 2018-03-05

Out of curiosity, what would have happened to my family during the Nazi rule?

My husband is half Jewish, I am not Jewish at all. His father is fully Jewish. His mother isn’t. We have a child also. That’s the biological stuff.

I know household stuff made a difference too, so here ‘s that: We all live together, including my father in law’s mother (so she’s Jewish too). Nothing really religious goes on besides great-grandma not eating pork. We do eat Jewish food like that Matzoh bread and low key participant in Jewish holidays, basically meaning we do it for fun and not really because it’s considered that important. Christmas and Easter is celebrated with the same attitude.

So what would have happened to us as a family? I know nothing good, but I mean specifically.

2 Answers 2018-03-05

what were the reasons for the post-WW2 German borders?

I looked at an ethnic map of Europe in 1933 and things were pretty German back then. The Soviets took a lot of ethnic German land which has been German for centuries, I would understand if they took all of east Prussia and Silesia, but pushing the border to the Neisse and Oder seems weird to me, I understand it was a (pretty just) punishment for Nazi crimes but what were the other Soviet considerations when doing that? did the west protest?

1 Answers 2018-03-05

⯇ 2777 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start