Are there any side by side articles on the whole “premodern parents didn’t get attached to their children” debate?

1 Answers 2018-03-05

Hitler's Circle of Evil: Question about its accuracy.

Hi all, Hitler's Circle of Evil is a show on Netflix in Australia about the rise of the Nazis but in particular focuses on Hitlers close circle of henchmen. Just a question about its accuracy. The show presents the original party, just before the Nuremberg Laws, as being anti Semitic, but certainly not intent on mass murder and destruction. Hilter and the others seem to be keen on stopping communism and the introduction of protectionist policies that do affect Jewish businesses. The deep hatred of Jews and desire to remove Jews from Germany is presented as being introduced by Goebbels. It portrays Goebbels as essentially brain washing Hitler. How accurate is this? Was Hitler really not that concerned with Jews in the beginning?

My other question is regarding two other members of the inner circle. Himmler in the beginning is show as being disgusted by street brutality against Jews such as the Kristallnacht. Also, Hermann Göring is portrayed as being against any anti semitic laws at all as he has no issues with Jews (his grandfather was a Jew). It also shows him as someone who despises Goebbels and is much more interested in establishing a strong airforce. How accurate are these two portrayals? Thanks! It's a great show by the way, and recommend it to anyone interested in the topic.

1 Answers 2018-03-05

Did Medieval English Longbowmen carry or use sidearms?

I have seen uncited references to Welsh or English longbowmen using falchions, axes, poleaxes, and pikes for close range combat. I'm seeking a more comprehensive understanding of the weapons carried by these medieval bowmen.

1 Answers 2018-03-05

Was the public aware that the Inquisition was most likely burning a bunch of innocent people? Was there any public criticism of it? Martin Luther's primary objection to the church was that it was corrupt and not living up to the spirit of the Bible; did he have criticisms of the Inquisition also?

3 Answers 2018-03-05

Did 18th century generals decide beforehand where a battle would take place?

1 Answers 2018-03-05

How did the battle of Kursk impact the rest of the war?

( World war two if it was not obvious )

1 Answers 2018-03-05

On the timeline of all history why was there a new count from year "one" after BC, if there were records of years past why weren't the eldest know recorded times in history reguarded as year one?

Was the coming of Christ that big an event it was decided universally to between historians? If so at what time? I'm quite curious why historical events are read in this way and not based on any other event instead. How it came to be universally reguarded that way as well.

1 Answers 2018-03-05

How did Islam influence military tactics in the Middle East?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-03-05

Post-Revolutionary Iran is known for having aggressive designs on its neighbors and looking to dominate the region. What was pre-revolutionary Iran's relations with its neighbors like?

1 Answers 2018-03-05

What was the extent of foreign influences to Russian nobility and upper class from the 18th to late 19th centuries?

Like they had a general called Barclay de Tolly https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Andreas_Barclay_de_Tolly

Who was a Scottish man raised in Lithuania. What's up with that? And what's with the large amount of German last names one can find for other generals? Like Wittgenstein and von Benningsen?

And why did the Russian court love French so much and when did this die off?

1 Answers 2018-03-04

Who was more powerful for most of the Cold War: The United States or the Soviet Union?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-03-04

How did early explorers learn a completely new language?

Needless to say all the advantages we now have to learn a new language in the 21st Century, my question is mainly focused on how did explorers from the past (whether it be really far away or not-so far away from our current timeline) learn new languages (from foreign/close cultures). Thanks!

2 Answers 2018-03-04

Why didn’t Hitler focus on taking Britain instead of invading Russia in WW2?

2 Answers 2018-03-04

As a black person, how would medieval Britain react to me roaming the streets?

Would there be prejudice, stares, confrontation? My friend said that if he could travel back in time it would be to the middle ages and I was wondering how society would welcome me.

2 Answers 2018-03-04

How and when did the Devil get his pitchfork?

Does the Bible have it? Did it appear in a specific folklore and get popularized?

1 Answers 2018-03-04

In the First Crusade, you are a young noble looking for personal wealth, where do you go to join the crusade and how likely is it that you make it to Jerusalem and find personal wealth?

Would it be rare for younger nobles to search for personal wealth in the First Crusade or would that be reserved for later crusades- and if so, which crusade had the largest amount of individuals seeking personal advancement? How common was death during the First Crusade on the journey to Jerusalem?

2 Answers 2018-03-04

Why are the answers to the question on r/AskHistorians always so damn long?

It seems like the top answers on every post here are extremely long. It would take me 10+ minutes to read the insanely long essays written. Why do people do this if the answer can be achieved in one short paragraph? They talk about things not relating to the question. And even those which could help.... it’s not worth to waste a good portion of my day reading one reply. And it wasn’t worth a good portion of your day to write it.

2 Answers 2018-03-04

Was the triangular trade a myth? If not, why would one say it was?

While reading Forrest McDonald's "Colliding With the Past", McDonald stated that the triangular trade was a myth because "it never happened, if only because the slave trade in the British Empire was a monopoly of the Royal Africa Company created by Charles II", but I don't fully follow this. I've been taught the triangular trade for most of my life, so could some context to this statement be given?

1 Answers 2018-03-04

Did Native Americans find washed up artifacts from the West?

Is there any proof that the native people of the Americas (North or South) found artifacts on their shores from the Western Worlds? I can imagine that over the course of time, some artifacts from ship wrecks or general pollution might’ve shown up on the coasts of America..

3 Answers 2018-03-04

How much did medieval people know about sex, and where did they obtain that knowledge? Did parents educate their children on how to do it?

2 Answers 2018-03-04

How did Italy and Austria-Hungary supply their troops on the alps during winter ?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-03-04

How did the Christian teaching of communion or Eucharist develop from inception to the 20th century?

What did it look like in it's inception?

How has the understanding and practice of it changed throughout the centuries?

What major theological ideas surrounding it have come and gone? What has remained consistent?

What did most Christian theologians think about communion 200, 500, 1000, and 1500 years ago?

1 Answers 2018-03-04

What advances (in either tech, medicine, or training) did a WW2 medic have over a WW1 medic?

1 Answers 2018-03-04

Questions on Islamic History

Did Islam mostly spread by the sword? Were Islamic empires tolerant of other religions? Any common misconceptions about Islamic History?

1 Answers 2018-03-04

What's the difference between structuralist and intentionalist perspectives?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-03-04

⯇ 2779 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start