Did Francisco Franco have a nuclear weapons program?

Did Francisco Franco have a nuclear weapons program? If so, did Francoist Spain ever come close to developing a nuclear weapon?

1 Answers 2018-01-19

How many crew historical warships have?

Hello, I wonder how many crews ships in piracy era have? And another question how can we list warships as size and How many people does it take to operate a historical sailing ship? What type of ships does barbary pirates uses. Thank you have good day.

1 Answers 2018-01-19

Why did so many German states voluntarily join Germany following the Franco-Prussian war? What incentives were offered to the various rulers for them to give up power?

1 Answers 2018-01-19

Suppose I'm a young aristocratic Roman heir who ends up squandering all my cash and ending up in debt. How do I get out of this predicament?

For a time frame maybe the Late Republic or Early Empire.

1 Answers 2018-01-19

What happened to the Monophysites after the Arab Invasion?

I've been listening to a listening to a few podcasts and reading a few books about the early church and the Eastern Roman Empire, and I came across the Christian sect of Monophysites. They featured prominently in the historical record and in several councils, but then seemed to have disappeared for the most part after the Arabs arrived. Were they suppressed, absorbed, or did they continue to exist but were no longer the focus?

1 Answers 2018-01-19

Were dogs or other animals ever used to help dig holes or trenches in history?

1 Answers 2018-01-19

Can a U.S. historian comment on U.S. legal issues?

1 Answers 2018-01-19

Is there any information on crime in hunter gatherer groups? Did it occur? What sort of crime would it be? How did hunter gatherer groups deal with this?

1 Answers 2018-01-19

Roman Civil War Friendly Fire

During the Roman civil wars were there any documented cases of roman cohorts on the same side mistaking each other for enemies in the heat of battle and fighting it out? And what would be done in order to prevent this?

1 Answers 2018-01-19

How involved in the actual planning room were the magicians that helped the U.S. army with their strategies in WW2?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-01-19

Why did Havard (and not Yale, Princeton, etc.) end up being regarded as the most prestigious university in the USA and perhaps the whole world?

Yale, Princeton, Stanford, MIT, and others have fabulous reputations in America and abroad, yet Harvard seems to generally always be considered one of the top 2-3 universities in the world by just about every publication.

Internationally, regardless if they are right or wrong, most people seem to view Harvard as the #1 university in the USA (if not world).

How and why did this come into being?

1 Answers 2018-01-19

Question from my 6 year old “Did they have bow and arrows in the 1980s”? I fielded that one. His follow up “1000 years ago did they use bow and arrows, what did they make them from?”

2 Answers 2018-01-19

Were there any illegal drugs in ancient Rome?

1 Answers 2018-01-19

I was surprised when I found out that the Gotha could fly from Germany and bomb London during World War 1. What range did ww1 bombers have? And was the Gotha superior to the other ww1 bombers? And was strategic bombing effective during ww1?

1 Answers 2018-01-19

Why did the people that the Aztecs sacrificed come quietly?

I'm being told that thousands of people were sacrificed every year. I don't think anyone would particularly like to be slaughtered. If that many people were being killed against their will, why didn't they band together and revolt?

1 Answers 2018-01-19

How and why did South Africa, India and Pakistan become Nuclear Nations?

Reading up on Chinese history, I learned that China’s Nuclear Programme came about by Mao pressuring Khrushchev, and as retaliation to Eisenhower’s threats to use atomic bombs like “conventional bullets”.

My question is, who helped the three above nations develop their programmes and why did they feel the need to be Nuclear armed?

2 Answers 2018-01-18

What societal changes did the Soviets implement in Afghanistan? How popular were they?

1 Answers 2018-01-18

I want to know if this video exaggerated or how much of this has been acceptef by Historians or if these have been widely known. Thanks!

https://youtu.be/yxdRTaAp5Fw

1 Answers 2018-01-18

Primary Sources from Late Antique Mesopotamia?

I have a difficult, possibly impossible question to ask: How much do historians and archaeologists know about Late Antique Mesopotamia? That is, during the several hundred year period between about 350 CE and 650 CE, what was going on in the area that was now Iraq, and what sorts of sources survive? Do we actually have an surviving literary sources from Sasanian Mesopotamia. Clearly this area was still very economically productive, since the Eastern Roman Empire and the Sasanian Empire spend so much blood and treasure fighting over Mesopotamia in the later 5th and 6th centuries.

1 Answers 2018-01-18

How similar were Victorian-era taverns to the modern restaurant industry?

In the process of reading up on the Jack the Ripper case, I've learned that some of the last people to see the Ripper's victims alive were bartenders and patrons at the countless taverns scattered throughout Victorian London. I now have a few questions:

  • How did one go about starting a tavern in this period?

  • Do we have any idea how many taverns existed in Victorian London?

  • What do we know about how these taverns operated on a day-to-day basis? (For example, do we know how many people an average tavern would typically employ? What responsibilities would they have? etc.)

  • If I traveled via time machine to a Victorian-era tavern, would I more or less recognize what I saw? Or was the bar-going experience somehow different back in the day?

It's so fascinating to learn about ways that society from ~130 years ago wasn't that different from modern society, so I'd appreciate any insight you have on this topic. Thanks!

1 Answers 2018-01-18

How much sun shone on Moscow in December, 1941?

I was listening to my local NPR on the drive home from work this afternoon when they had a short feature on Moscow. This past December Moscow saw only 6 minutes of sunlight. I'd never knew Moscow had such limited sun exposure in the Winter and the piece on NPR left me wondering, how much sunlight would there have been in December of 1941 as the Nazi's struggled through their doomed invasion of Moscow?

NPR Link

1 Answers 2018-01-18

How accurate is the depiction of Spartan hoplite warfare in the historical fiction novel Gates of Fire by Steven Pressfield?

This is the book. In particular the battle that occurs midway through between the Spartans and another Greek city in the 490s BC. I hope it's not too much but I'll quote some excerpts.

A portion of the plain adjacent the wall was occupied by a maritime junkyard; rotting craft lay littered at all angles, extending halfway across the field, amid tumbledown work shacks and stinking mounds of debris squalled over by wheeling flocks of gulls. In addition the enemy had strewn boulders and driftwood to break up the flat over which Leonidas and his men must advance. Their own side, the foe's, had been cleared smooth as a schoolmaster's desk.

When they knew where a battle would take place, did one side ever scatter obstacles on the enemy's side to disrupt their advance while keeping their own side clean?

the Spartan Skiritai rangers had just finished setting the enemy refuse yards ablaze. ... This did not deter the Skiritai from torching the wharves and warehouses of the harbor. ... these light-armed forces had been cleared early by the Skiritai, whose comrades below would advance as always from their position of honor on the Lakedaemonian left. The rangers took possession of half the face, driving the enemy skirmishers back where their slings and shafts were outranged and could work no harm to the army. ... Now the Spartans and Tegeates advanced to their positions in the line. First the Skiritai, on the left, forty-eight shields across and eight deep ... The Skiritai had routed the enemy right. ...

What were the Skiritai? I've heard that they performed specialist roles in the Spartan army. Here it seems that they act as both skirmishers and heavy infantry who take a position of honor on the Spartan left. Is this plausible?

Squires armed the warriors from the feet up ... The total, excluding armed squires ranging as auxiliaries, exceeded forty-five hundred and extended wing to wing across the plain for nearly six hundred meters. ...

Each Spartan hoplite has a "helot squire" who fights alongside him, usually in a light infantry role. Is this accurate?

starting with the heavy oxhide soles which could tread over fire; ... the soles of their footgear churning up trenches in the plain and slinging yet more dust into the already choking air.

The Spartans are depicted as wearing heavy footgear for battle. I've heard that Greek hoplites are always depicted barefoot in artwork, but I don't see how that could have possibly been the case in reality. It seems like shoes would be of the upmost importance in battle when you can't control what terrain you'll be fighting on or where you'll be stepping. The Romans seem to have known that. Just stubbing his toe before battle could put the strongest warrior out of commission. Is this plausible?

This process of arming for battle, which the citizen-soldiers of other poleis had practiced no more than a dozen times a year in the spring and summer training, the Spartans had rehearsed and rerehearsed, two hundred, four hundred, six hundred times each campaigning season. Men in their fifties had done this ten thousand times. It was as second-nature to them as oiling or dusting their limbs before wrestling or dressing their long hair,

Did the Spartans really rehearse and drill for battle this much in comparison to other Greek city states and did that give them a significant advantage?

Finally the men scribed their names or signs upon skytalides, the improvised twig bracelets they called tickets, which would distinguish their bodies should they, falling, be maimed too hideously to be identified. They used wood because it was valueless as plunder by the enemy.

Were something like dog tags used

Among the enemy's ranks, the bravest (or perhaps the most fear-stricken) began banging the ash of their spear shafts upon the bronze bowls of their shields, creating a tumult of pseudoandreia which reverberated across and around the mountain-enclosed plain. Others reinforced this racket with the warlike thrusting of their spearpoints to heaven and the loosing of cries to the gods and shouts of threat and anger. ... Their commander thrust his spear forward and the mass surged behind him into the advance. ... In the enemy's plan, no doubt, the sinuous defile of the river would disorder the Lakedaemonian ranks and render them vulnerable at the moment of attack. The Spartans, however, had outwaited them. As soon as the bronze-banging began, the enemy commanders knew they could not restrain their ranks longer; they must advance while their men's blood was up, or all fervor would dissipate and terror flood inevitably into the vacuum.

Here the less well-trained trained hoplites become impatient and begin a disordered advance against their commanders' judgement, while the more disciplined Spartans outwait them. Are situations like this recorded as happening in Greek warfare?

Here came the foe, picking up the pace of his advance. A fast walk. A swinging stride. The line was extending and fanning open to the right, winging out as men in fear edged into the shadow of the shield of the comrade on their right; already one could see the enemy ranks stagger and fall from alignment as the bravest surged forward and the hesitant shrank back.

Was this a danger when advancing? I know formations had a tendency to drift to the right as described, so how was this counteracted? Did commanders try to advance more slowly or not advance at all if they didn't think their men were capable of maintaining cohesion?

The left wing of the enemy, eighty across, collapsed even before the shields of their promachoi, the front-rankers, had come within thirty paces of the Spartans. A cry of dread rose from the throats of the foe, so primal it froze the blood, and then was swallowed in the tumult.

The enemy left broke from within.

This wing, whose advancing breadth had stood an instant earlier at forty-eight shields, abruptly became thirty, then twenty, then ten as panic flared like a gale-driven fire from terror-stricken pockets within the massed formation. Those in the first three ranks who turned in flight now collided with their comrades advancing from the rear. Shield rim caught upon shield rim, spear shaft upon spear shaft; a massive tangle of flesh and bronze ensued as men bearing seventy pounds of shield and armor stumbled and fell, becoming obstacles and impediments to their own advancing comrades. You could see the brave men stride on in the advance, crying out in rage to their countrymen as these abandoned them. Those who still clung to courage pushed past those who had forsaken it, calling out in outrage and fury, trampling the forerankers, or else, as valor deserted them too, jerked free and fled to save their own skins.

Is this a plausible way that hoplite formations could collapse before even making contact with the enemy?

That sound which all warriors know but which to Alexandras' and my youthful ears had been heretofore unknown and unheard now ascended from the clash and collision of the othismos.

Once, at home when I was a child, Bruxieus and! had helped our neighbor Pierion relocate three of his stacked wooden beehives. As we jockeyed the stack into place upon its new stand, someone's foot slipped. The stacked hives dropped. From within those stoppered confines yet clutched in our hands arose such an alarum, neither shriek nor cry, growl nor roar, but a thrum from the netherworld, a vibration of rage and murder that ascended not from brain or heart, but from the cells, the atoms of the massed poleis within the hives.

This selfsame sound, multiplied a hundred-thousandfold, now rose from the massed compacted crush of men and armor roiling beneath us on the plain. Now I understood the poet's phrase the mill of Ares and apprehended in my flesh why the Spartans speak of war as work.

The sound of battle is vividly compared to an angry beehive. Are there any ancient descriptions of what battle sounded like?

They were in the smoke now. It became impossible to see. Dust rose in such quantities beneath the churning feet of the men, commingling with the screen of smoke from the tindered hulks, that the entire plain seemed afire, and from the choking cloud arose that sound, that terrible indescribable sound.

Did ancient battles really kick up a lot of dust?

I had never appreciated how far beyond the interleaved bronze of the promachoi's shields the murderous iron of their eight-footers could extend. These punched and struck, overhand, driven by the full force of the right arm and shoulder, across the upper rim of the shield; not just the spears of the front-rankers but those of the second and even the third, extending over their mates' shoulders to form a thrashing engine that advanced like a wall of murder. ...

On the center and right, along the whole line the Spartans and Syrakusans clashed now shield-to-shield, helmet-to-helmet. Amid the maelstrom we could catch only glimpses, and those primarily of the rear-rankers, eight deep on the Lakedaemonian side, twelve and sixteen deep on the Syrakusan, as they thrust the three-foot-wide bowls of their hoplon shields flush against the backs of the men in file before them and heaved and ground and shoved with all their strength, the soles of their footgear churning up trenches in the plain and slinging yet more dust into the already choking air.

No longer was it possible to distinguish individual men, or even units. We could see only the tidal surge and back-surge of the massed formations and hear without ceasing that terrible, bloodstilling sound.

Is this a plausible depiction of when both sides clashed? Did the rear ranks really push their shields into the backs of those in front in certain circumstances and is that where the word the "othismos" comes from?

It was of no use. The Spartan front-rankers, men of the first five age-classes, were the cream of the city in foot speed and strength, none save the officers over twenty-five years old. Many, like Polynikes in the van among the Knights, were sprinters of Olympic and near-Olympic stature with garland after garland won in games before the gods. These now, loosed by Leonidas and driven on by their own lust for glory, pressed home the sentence of steel upon the fleeing Syrakusans.

Is there evidence that young men and sprinters were especially used to press home an attack on a retreating enemy?

Here the earth was rent and torn as if a thousand span of oxen had assaulted it all day with the might of their hooves and the steel of their ploughs' deep-churning blades. The chewed-up dirt, dark with piss and blood, extended in a line three hundred meters across and a hundred deep where the feet of the contending formations had heaved and strained for purchase upon the earth.

This might be hyperbolic, but are there any accounts of the earth of battlefields themselves looking torn up from all the fighting?

They had routed the enemy left; their front ranks now surged into the business of cutting down those luckless bastards who had fallen or been trampled or whose panic-unstrung knees could not find strength to bear them swiftly enough from their own slaughter. ... The Spartans were hauling bodies off the stacks of the dead, seeking friend or brother, wounded and clinging yet to life. As each groaning foeman was flung down, a xiphos blade held him captive at the throat. Hold! Leonidas cried, motioning urgently to the trumpeters to resound the call to break off. Attend them! Attend the enemy too! he shouted, and the officers relayed the order up and down the line.

The Spartans are portrayed as killing wounded during the battle but then taking them prisoner once resistance had ceased. How were enemy wounded usually treated in Greek warfare?

2 Answers 2018-01-18

How did American slavery in the 18th century contrast with slavery in the 19th century? How were they similar?

I cannot find much direct comparison on the two periods of slavery but I was wondering if there were any significant differences in terms of practice, public outlook, policy, and severity. In essence, how did the "peculiar institution" of slavery change over time?

1 Answers 2018-01-18

What are some good books to read about South Indian and Sri Lankan history?

The South Asian part of the AskHistorians book list is essentially limited to subcontinent-wide overviews, or specific events dating to the colonial period and in the north of India.

What are some good books to read if I'm specifically interested in Sri Lanka and South India - in particular the Dravidian-speaking parts of India? I'm interested in anything related to the region, of any temporal or regional scope. I'd be equally happy to read anything from a good regional overview, to a detailed history of Anuradhapura, to an in-depth study of caste in southern Kerala in the early 20th century.

2 Answers 2018-01-18

"Reconquista", historic fact or national myth?

How accurate is the classic tale of the reconquista?

Which version is more historically accurate, the one that claims that current Spain is descended from the Visigothic kingdom or the one that claims that its just the product of the (forced) conversion of the majority of the population after a change in the religion of its rulers (From Islam to Christianity)?

2 Answers 2018-01-18

⯇ 2875 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start