I saw a video that said that ancient Greece went from an oligarchy to a democracy. Is this true and if so, how did that come about?

1 Answers 2017-12-16

What did people think static shocks were before the concept of electrical charge was understood?

1 Answers 2017-12-16

Were there social programs that helped integrate freed slaves into society after the 13th amendment came into effect?

1 Answers 2017-12-16

a service station (truck stop) near my house sells Chicken Tikka Masala with Basmati Rice for £7.29 a serving. suppose I live in Stoke-on-trent in 1717 instead of 2017, how much would all the ingredients to make that cost me? could I even get them all with any amount of money?

3 tablespoons garam masala

1 tablespoon paprika

Vegetable oil, for cooking and drizzling

4 skinless, boneless chicken breasts

8 3/4 ounces basmati rice

1 teaspoon ground turmeric, curry powder or pinch of saffron strands, optional

1 bunch spring onions

One 3/4-inch piece fresh ginger 2 cloves garlic

1 1/2 cups light cream or yogurt (cream tastes much better but yogurt is healthier), optional

7 ounces tomato paste

2 teaspoon English mustard powder

Salt and freshly ground black pepper

Fresh cilantro or parsley leaves, for serving

3 Answers 2017-12-16

What was the motivation behind Soldiers of Slavic Countries fighting for the Axis in WW2? Countries like Estonia, Czechoslovakia and The Ukraine.

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-12-16

Which website(s) would you recommend?

Do you have any favorite websites that you like to follow/read on with articles on history?

My favourite one currently is Ancient History Encyclopedia (https://www.ancient.eu/), and even though they are mostly concentrating on ancient history (as the name itself gives it away), you can easily read on many other topics as well. But I am interested in what other sites like this one are out there and which one(s) would you recommend?

Thanks in advance!

2 Answers 2017-12-16

Anyone willing to decipher these Colonial Henrico records?

p.217, October 1686, Certificate of Edmd Mashall & Hen: Voden for takeing up three Runaway Indians, Vizt. Harry a boy belonging to Mr. Ro: Burton & Kate & Sarah to wenches belonging to Mr. Will: Glover. p.220, 12 October 1686, Certificate granted to Edmd. Marshall & Hen: Voden for Arthur an Indian belonging to Jno. Wilson his takeing up a Runaway Irish boy servt. to Robert Burton.

1 Answers 2017-12-16

Can the modern council of Rome make a genuine claim to have the authority to overturn Augustus' exile of Ovid in 8CE?

Today I read that the council of the city of Rome had approved a motion to overturn the decree by which Augustus banished Ovid to Constanta.

Disregarding this particular case, so as not to fall foul of the 20 year rule, is there any genuine legal continuity between the early Roman imperial period and local government in modern day Italy? Or any other part of what was once the Roman empire, for that matter?

I have no knowledge of the Italian legal system, but here in the UK there are certainly pieces of legislation that have lasted for several centuries without being repealed or superceded. Are there any such examples in Rome? Does the question even make sense in the Roman or Italian context?

1 Answers 2017-12-16

Could the Normans from the Conquest period of 1066 be considered basically "French" ?

Trying to see if we could say that British and French rivalry started from 1066 and is thus a millennium old.

2 Answers 2017-12-16

Why are elementary-aged students in the US knowingly taught a version of US History that middle and high schools have to completely contradict and reexplain?

I’ve always wondered why so many of the lessons about history (especially US history) taught during the early years of my education (late ‘90s and early ‘00s) were based on myths or tall tales that all my later teachers would have to completely negate. Stuff along the lines of “Columbus proved the Earth was round” or “Benjamin Franklin discovered electricity” or portraying the Founding Fathers as saintly heroes with no room for complexity/flaws.

I’m not suggesting that 5-10 year olds should be exposed to the ugliest/most disturbing parts of our history for the sake of total accuracy, or that such young minds should be expected to grasp all the complexities of real history. But why are so many of these demonstrably false stories taught to young students as fact?

EDIT: Some of the early replies have called into question whether I am misremembering that these stories were really TAUGHT as fact rather than merely told as stories. I won’t reject that possibility with regard to some of the specific examples I provided, but I certainly have many memories of history teachers (from around 6th grade on) having to dispel similar generalizations and falsehoods when reintroducing familiar topics. If the dissemination of bad history like this isn’t due to early education, it would still be interesting to know why/how it became so widespread as to require dispelling at all.

5 Answers 2017-12-16

What caused the Peninsular War?

I read the wikipedia article, but didn't quite get it, not being familiar enough with the background.

Spain was allied with France (why?), and they invaded Portugal together? And... maybe Napoleon's brother was king of Spain for some reason? Or it was some guy called Godoy? And the Spanish revolted against their King (why?)? Or maybe in support of a new King? It seemed like Spain was controlled by France, and so the Spanish revolted, but I don't really get why it was controlled by France. Had they previously conquered it?

2 Answers 2017-12-16

Chinese Three Kingdoms&Cao Cao

I remember a story about Cao Cao that he was with his army marching, and said that anyone that stops will be executed, but later on he himself stopped to drink some water. He orders his soldiers to execute him, but they refuse so they just cut his hair. Is that thing true? I have been trying to find it on the Internet, but nothing seems to pop up. I would appreciate the help, thanks!

2 Answers 2017-12-16

What was the motivation of the Russian volunteers who served under the Germans or fought in the Russian Liberation Army? Was Andrey Vlasov and other officers an opportunist or did they genuinely think they could liberate Russia from Stalin?

2 Answers 2017-12-16

What newspapers were abolinisist in the 1850's?

I need a source for a piece of course work on uprisings in america in the 19th century. I already have a source from Harpers weekly about the raid on harpers ferry, but I would like to have one with a contrasting view point to compare it with. Thanks for any help.

1 Answers 2017-12-16

How was Genghis Khan viewed in Socialist Mongolia/Mongolian People's Republic?

2 Answers 2017-12-16

Saturday Reading and Research | December 16, 2017

Previous

Today:

Saturday Reading and Research will focus on exactly that: the history you have been reading this week and the research you've been working on. It's also the prime thread for requesting books on a particular subject. As with all our weekly features, this thread will be lightly moderated.

So, encountered a recent biography of Stalin that revealed all about his addiction to ragtime piano? Delved into a horrendous piece of presentist and sexist psycho-evolutionary mumbo-jumbo and want to tell us about how bad it was? Need help finding the right book to give the historian in your family? Then this is the thread for you!

8 Answers 2017-12-16

Was there segregation and racism before apartheid in South Africa, did it differ between the different colonies before the union of 1910?

2 Answers 2017-12-16

Did slaves suffer any PTSD or Stockholm’s after being freed? If not what was some psychological effects they suffered?

1 Answers 2017-12-16

How did the different states in Italy react to the reunification movement? North/south reaction? Wealthy/poor states?

I am using states here as an all encompassing term to include Venice to Naples. How did the different states react? Why where they swayed to join up in the Italy project? How did resistance to it look like?

1 Answers 2017-12-16

How realistic were the Sharpe books,by Bernard Cornwell, in portraying the reasons the French lost the Peninsula war in Spain to the British?

The books tend to point to these reasons and I wanted to see how accurate they were:

  • policy of the French to steal from the local populace, as opposed to paying for food, which pitted the locals against them and created guerrillas that harassed French supply lines constantly.

  • British fighting formations vs. French. The books describe the French attacking in deep columns to act as battering rams on the enemy lines whereas the British used long thin lines that allowed many more muskets to be used in a firing line. It seems whenever a British army faced a French army using these tactics, the British won.

  • British domination of the seas prevented French reinforcements and supplies coming anyway but overland which were effected by my first point.

Were there other reasons not mentioned? I never knew much about the Napoleonic wars growing up and they are fascinating to me now.

2 Answers 2017-12-16

How did the Education System (primary, secondary, tertiary and vocational) in the USSR compare to the education offered in western countries like Britain and America during a similar period? (1922-1991)

While reading about the cosmonaut and first human to enter outer space, Yuri Gagarin, I noticed that in a section on his early life Wikipedia says he " entered into an apprenticeship at age 16 as a foundryman at the Lyubertsy Steel Plant near Moscow, and also enrolled at a local "young workers" school for seventh grade evening classes." As an American I find this confusing being that 7th grade in this country is typically much younger (I assume the system must just be different rather than him having been held back 3 or 4 grades) and wanted to know more about the education system of the Soviet Union and how it compared to Western education during the same timeframe (1922-1991)

1 Answers 2017-12-16

How Did Native American Tribes Survive in the Desert?

I'm currently writing a fiction novel that involves a tribe of people who live in the Mojave dessert. However, I am not aware of how people survived or can survive in the dessert with relatively primitive technology.

Wanting to not BS my readers, I tried researching online on how real natives lived in the area traditionally; (Paiute, Washoe, Shoshone, etc.) However I have found very little information on what tools they used to survive, how they made shelter, or how they gathered food and water.

(I'm not entirely sure this is the right subreddit for this, but seeing as my high school had no problems discussing native people in history I assume this counts. If I AM in the wrong place, direction to a better subreddit would be appreciated.)

1 Answers 2017-12-16

When population growth in first world countries slowed down, was there any effort to prevent it?

If I understand population growth in the first world in recent centuries correctly, it grew sharply from the 18th to early 20th centuries because of increasing advances in medicine lowering the death rate, causing cities to stop being population sinks. Then during the 20th century, the birth rate dropped as well, leading to the more or less stable populations first world countries have nowadays. What I am curious about is what people thought of these declining birth rates when they first noticed them. Was there any effort to keep the population growing?

1 Answers 2017-12-16

Why are the days of the week named after pagan gods? Was there ever any pushback from the Church on this?

1 Answers 2017-12-16

[Meta?] Are there any reliable places to find reviews of books as academic texts by people in their fields?

I've got the unfortunate case of being really interested in the social and spiritual landscape of early medieval Europe before and during Christianization, while also not being a student at all and only really having amazon reviews, covers, names, and sparse pages to tell if something is well researched and academically minded or nationalist, racist, wildly speculative drivel about The Heart of the West and Our Warrior Spirit or whatever nonsense.

Was wondering if there was anywhere you can get public access to something that would make the distinction easier to make. Even just like a list of a course's books and a little bit on the course, professor, college etc. would be super helpful. Also the dimensions of the sacred, ritual, that sorta thing.

1 Answers 2017-12-16

⯇ 2941 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start