How do contemporary academics who say that race and racism date to the Enlightenment explain what seem to be examples of racial categorization, racial stereotyping and racial prejudice in ancient literature and art?

In the ancient world, there seem to be numerous examples of writers and artists acknowledging that groups of humans have shared physical and cultural characteristics and labeling them with specific group names, in some cases stereotyping them negatively. How does this differ from what we now call racism?

1 Answers 2022-04-02

With the theory that the Sahara desert forms around 5000-11000 years ago is it possible that the shift in the rain zone was the reason for “sea people” and the end of the bronze age civilizations?

Especially considering we haven’t been able to study the western saharan archeologically since 1991 despite technological developments and more recently the eastern saharan due to wars.

1 Answers 2022-04-02

Where should I start?

Never really read much about history, except recently I've been watching copious amounts of toldinstone and history matters. I'm really interested in ancient China but I have no idea where to start reading and what resources are accurate. Any suggestions would be very appreciated :)

1 Answers 2022-04-02

Were Marius’ reforms an actual thing? Or is it a simplification? He is credited with multiple reforms to the Roman military.

1 Answers 2022-04-02

How did Cataphractarii manage their charge?

Why didn't their horses fall when charging an enemy? I mean when they stomp into enemy lines I don't get why the horses wouldn't just fall?

And how could Cataphractarii avoid dropping their lances when they hit a heavy enemy?

A relatively unrelated question: why did Rome increasingly rely on cavalry as they stopped expanding, instead focussing on defense?

1 Answers 2022-04-02

Why are there photos taken at concentration camps such as the photos of prisoners arriving in Auschwitz? What purpose did such photos serve to the regime?

1 Answers 2022-04-02

Can anyone recommend books to learn about the social psyche that would have made people be ok with the Holocaust, and how did society change from (presumably) being ok with the Holocaust or pretending it's not happening to the mentality we have today?

I don't know much about ww2. I've read a few books about it but the nitty-gritty of the war doesn't interest me. However, ever since I read my first book on the holocaust I wanted to read more about the transition.

(What follows are my own uneducated words):

  • Why the Jews and why in Germany.
  • I heard a few things about how entire Europe was against Jews even though not as brutal as the nazis.
  • What did normal Germans think? Why didn't they go totally against the holocaust?
  • I've seen a video where ordinary Germans sort of threw their Jewish neighbors with sticks and so on.
  • I think I read that the French police helped the nazis. -I read a book on three kingdoms (families) and they were more or less like "Hitler is a good chap".
  • I think I read the Jews that fled Germany still dealt with anti-semitism
    • leading my ignorant self to think anti-semitism was mainstream, why was it mainstream, and what were the events that changed our society (this is not to say there's no antisemitism but I hope you know what I mean)

Then, most importantly, how can a society like that change (what I consider) so quickly into feeling guilty about what they did.

In historical fiction I remember this Jewish woman after the war saying how no matter how far away from Germany she went, she still felt under threat because all Europeans were somewhat ok with what had happened (totally my words but just the vibe)

1 Answers 2022-04-02

Was Britain's opium trade to China mainly motivated by profit, or did they also intend to sabotage China by introducing a harmful drug to their society en masse?

1 Answers 2022-04-02

Why is it that in ex-British colonial nations, such as Australia and the US, that Catholics outnumber Anglicans/Episcopalians?

1 Answers 2022-04-02

Why was slavery outlawed in England so early on compared to other countries?

According to this video the slave trade (specifically 'the selling of a man outside the country') was prohibited by William the Conqueror just after his 1066 conquest. (Relevant part starts around 11:30 in the linked video)

The video author then makes the claim that 'by 1086 slavery had almost died out' then, 700 years or so later, 'we still [did] not have slaves in England.' Later on, the video (14 mins in) claims that slavery was not permitted under English law at all.

I'm aware that the author of this video would probably identify himself as a patriot, perhaps a nationalist, and stood for election as a member of a far-right, nationalist party. It also quotes heavily from Wikipedia, which as every uni student knows is not a reliable source. Therefore, I'm taking everything said with a pinch of salt.

So:

  1. Are the claims made in the video true?
  2. How was England able to manage without slaves when slavery was endemic to most societies at the time?
  3. Were there ever any attempts to re-legalise slavery?

If anyone has the knowledge to comment on the situation in Scotland or Wales I'd very much appreciate hearing from them too.

1 Answers 2022-04-02

What is the basis for the stereotypical cartoon bomb?

Just about every animated depiction of a bomb that I’ve ever seen is the same - a black sphere with a fuse sticking out of it, like this. Is that based on any actual explosives that were ever used, or if not, how did it become the default representation?

2 Answers 2022-04-02

Why, in WW2, were Jews put into camps and not killed by Nazis immediately?

Today I realized in school history class I learned a lot about what happened, but less so about why it happened.

So I learned about concentration camps and death camps, and that Jews (and a lot of other people) were deported and put into those camps. And that also a lot of them were murdered there.

But it did make me wonder why the Nazis went through all that trouble? Why did they not "just" kill those people immediately to get rid of them, if that was their goal?

I did try searching Google but I am not really getting articles about this particular question as results..

1 Answers 2022-04-02

How can I best learn about local Indigenous Australian history?

I'm Australian, from Brisbane (Queensland) in particular. Lately, I've realised how little I really know about Indigenous Australian history. In particular our local history and culture (Yuggera/Turrbal country) is of interest to me.

I'm a little bit ashamed of this, as I'm a high school history teacher. Most of what I know, however, is on topics like Ancient Egypt, Greece and Rome; which is what I've always found most compelling.

I want to begin learning more about Indigenous Australian history and I was hoping you brilliant souls could potentially point me in a good direction.

I'd also like to be clear that I don't just want to learn about their history since colonisation, and am more interested in pre-colonial history. A lot of my education on the topic, both in high school and at university, revolved around post-colonisation.

I recently did a case study on the discovery of "Mungo Man/Mungo Lady" and found it utterly fascinating.

Any help would be greatly appreciated. Thank you!

2 Answers 2022-04-02

Why did the the Qing enlisted Europeans, particularly Charles "Chinese" Gordon, to lead their armies against the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom?

1 Answers 2022-04-02

What tests could be done on blood and urine in 1918?

I'm reading Pandemic 1918 by Catherine Arnold.

Chapter two is starting to cover the account Dr Loring Miner, based in Haskell County, Kansas as he starts to notice dramatic cases of pneumonia.

As part of his response he analysed blood and urine samples.

In 1918, what could he have been testing for?

Additionally I'm curious about a few other things:

What was the state of germ theory at that point in history? And how well informed were the general public about viruses and epidemics?

Thanks.

1 Answers 2022-04-02

How does a 400- or 500-year-old document simply "turn up" in a library somewhere?

Apparently for a while the 1485 manuscript of Le Morte d'Arthur by Thomas Malory was believed to be the earliest copy, but then somehow in 1934 some college library is cataloguing their library and they find an original earlier version of the work that was thought to be first written in 1470.

This kind of thing happens from time to time, some paper document from literally centuries ago just "turns up" in some unexpected location. Doesn't paper deteriorate after that long?

It was my impression that literally any surviving piece of paper from that long ago, no matter how quotidian (say a bill of sale or some minor court record) would be considered an important historical artifact. Are there actually lots of pieces of paper from the 15th century surviving and so it would be easy for an actually important document to get lost in a library among piles of boring worthless tax records or whatever?

1 Answers 2022-04-02

good history books?

I'm a big fan about human hairy in general. Any good books or series I should read? I want to learn not only what happened but why it happened. I read Sapiens, which I learned that was factually incorrect in many aspects, so any book of the sort that is factually correct? What about Will Durant Books? Are they good?

1 Answers 2022-04-01

Is this a legit starter kit for reading about the Vikings?

Hello, I am wanting to learn and read about the Vikings. I recently came across a man named Steve Donoghue on youtube. He has a starter kit on books he feels is a good place to start reading about Vikings. Is this list legit or just a waste of time? thank you.

Myths & Legends:

  • The Sagas of the Icelanders (Penguin Classics Deluxe edition)
  • The Elder Edda, translated by Paul Taylor & W. H. Auden
  • The Myths of the Norsemen by Roger Lancelyn Green
  • Mytho-History:
  • Echoes of Valhalla by Jon Karl Helgason
  • Tales of Valhalla by Martyn Whittock & Hannah Whittock
  • Beyond the Northlands by Eleanor Rosamund Barraclough

History:

  • The Vikings by Howard La Fay (National Geographic)
  • The Oxford Illustrated History of the Vikings by Peter Sawyer
  • Northmen by John Haywood
  • Laughing Shall I Die by Tom Shippey
  • The Viking Wars by Max Adams
  • The Norsemen in the Viking Age by Eric Christiansen

Popular Culture:

  • The great Viking novels of Giles Kristian
  • Robert Low's terrific "Oathsworn" series
  • The Half-Drowned King by Linnea Hartsuyker

1 Answers 2022-04-01

Why did Nixon do watergate when the election wasn’t close?

Why would Nixon risk the eventual consequences of watergate when by all accounts the election was heavily in his favor?

1 Answers 2022-04-01

Dzien dobry Redditt! I am Jozef Pilsudski, Polish Marshal and Statesman who was instrumental in creating an independent Poland after WW1, and later became her leader for almost the rest of my life. AMA

8 Answers 2022-04-01

How were lesbians viewed in Ancient Rome?

1 Answers 2022-04-01

I am Harry Truman, failed haberdasher, piano player, one of the three most notorious characters from Missouri, and the 33rd President. AMA!

It does my heart good to be here. Best get all your questions in before I strike a blow for liberty this afternoon, though, although I may come back and answer what I can later.

I'm joined by my press secretary, /u/therealcharlieross, who often advises me to say 'no comment' among other wisdom.

Proof!

15 Answers 2022-04-01

Greetings, subjects. I am William of Normandy, king of England and duke of Normandy. Ask me anything.

56 Answers 2022-04-01

Why, unlike catholicism, are there no protestant universities among the top in reputation in the US?

I’m looking for a sociological historical answer to this, not idealogical, if possible — which is why i’m asking in this sub.

Of course there are very good protestant universities and colleges in the US, but there are no top schools reputation wise that are protestant in a significant way. This is unlike catholicism, which has schools like Georgetown, Notre Dame, Boston College, places that are among the most highly regarded research universities or liberal arts schools. And i guess the other significant part of my question is that there are many catholic universities which still have strong secular programs as well, they’re reputable and highly regarded for things other than religious studies. So protest seminaries also don’t pertain to my question.

Maybe the answer would be related to money, but some denominations like presbyterian or episcopalian are most middle/upper class, so I’m not sure why that would be the case.

Also, some schools like Princeton are technically affiliated with a protestant domination, but not in any way that matters anymore.

1 Answers 2022-04-01

Was primary education different before the industrial revolution/universal schooling ?

In modern discourse, we often hear critique of the present education system for not changing fundamentaly since it was developped in the industrial revolution. But was private primary education actually different before the industrial revolution? If so, how was it like?

1 Answers 2022-04-01

300 / 7255

Back to start