What are the prospects for a rediscovery of the lost Greek epic poem Titanomachy? Is that something that might conceivably be found in the Villa of the Papyri?

1 Answers 2022-04-01

I am Henry Curtmantle, King of England, Duke of Normandy and Aquitaine, and Count of Anjou. In light of recent controversies in my reign, I have been advised by the brothers of Canterbury Cathedral to participate in this AMA as part of my penance for the slaying of Archbishop Thomas Becket. AMA?

I am Henry, by the grace of God, King of England, Duke of Normandy and Aquitaine, Count of Anjou and Maine. Son of Empress Matilda, and Geoffrey Plantagenet, Count of Anjou.

In light of my connection with the murder of Archbishop Thomas Becket, my former chancellor and friend, and the recent rebellion of my sons, with the aid of the King of the Franks, I have been advised to allow my subjects this once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to ask me anything.

At present, my amanuensis is managing the most important business of the realm, and may only be able to answer inquiries as their other duties allow.

My proof

Edit: My amanuensis is overwhelmed with petitioners at the moment but has seen all of your questions and will be taking my dictation when time allows.

Edit 2: Having just received word of the defeat of William, King of Scots at Alnwick, I must now excuse myself to begin negotiations with the rebels. Clearly Thomas has forgiven me.

21 Answers 2022-04-01

I am Marcus Tullius Cicero, Father of the Roman Republic. Honored as father by Caesar the Younger, and adversary to Mark Antony, some have named me 'Rome's Greatest Statesman.' AMA!

35 Answers 2022-04-01

I'm 30ish, my left knee sucks, my thumbs hurt when gripping some things. Did historical soldiers that had to walk around in dozens of pounds of armor and gear just have aches all the time and wear down their bodies, or were they fitter than us?

1 Answers 2022-04-01

Herodotus: Fiction, fact or somewhere in between?

I have read Herodotus' History and can see he delivers some real whoppers in terms of things and events that are highly unlikely to have existed or happened. This leads many to opine that generally he can't be trusted as a reliable source. I'm not so sure. For instance his claim that Scythians used marijuana by burning its seeds inside felt tents on braziers has been borne out by archaeology. My question is how reliable is he?

1 Answers 2022-04-01

Perennially misunderstood for over 350 years, I, René Descartes, hereby unveil the final lost volume of my magnum opus, The World. AMA - you ask, therefore I am.

20 Answers 2022-04-01

How do we know that our history is correct?

We weren't there when ancient Egyptians built their pyramids; nor were we there when Columbus set foot in America. We have texts, artifacts, and other materials from the time period and that's it. How can we understand ancient people's customs, culture and behaviour with that limited "evidence"? Can you please explain how historians know the things they do about past societies?

2 Answers 2022-04-01

Friday Free-for-All | April 01, 2022

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

13 Answers 2022-04-01

We are the wives of Henry VIII, King of England, France, and Ireland. Ask Us Anything!

Greetings! Here be our proof.

We, the six wives of King Henry VIII, shall jointly share this account to answer your questions about our lives and our tumultuous times. We shall individually introduce ourselves:

I am Katherine, daughter of Isabel of Castile and Fernando of Aragon, and true and loyal wife of my husband Henry from our marriage to my death. I bore several children, but only my daughter Mary survived infancy.

Katherine Regina

Hello! I'm Anne, and I am very happy to speak to you today about the great changes my husband made to reform the true Church of England, and the great sacrifices we made for each other along the way. My daughter, Elizabeth, was my pride and joy even before she became one of the preeminent monarchs of England.

Anne B.

My name is Jane, and I do not know how much I can tell you, for I stay away from weighty matters of politics and religion. I am the wife who gave Henry his son and heir apparent, his most dear Edward.

J. Seymour

I must admit that I am not technically a wife of Henry VIII, as our marriage was never fully binding under canon law. But I welcome the opportunity to share my views on his court during my time there as his Beloved Sister!

Anna von Kleve

Hello, hello! I greet you respectfully as a visitor to our court. My time as consort was brief, but I am pleased to tell you about my life in the Howard family and as the young woman with "no other will but his".

~ Kathryn

Experience tells me that you will have little interest in me as a person, but I am here regardless. I was with Henry in his twilight years, and influenced him in reconciling with his daughters Mary and Elizabeth. Few are aware that I also acted as de facto regent during my husband's final military campaign!

Catherine Parr

58 Answers 2022-04-01

I am Sokrates, son of Sophroniskos, of the deme Alopeke. I am fond of saying that the unexamined life is not worth living; and in that spirit, I invite you, fellow citizens, to Ask Me Anything.

But do not wonder if I ask you questions in return.

63 Answers 2022-04-01

How did greeting people (or saying goodbye) based on time of day get started? Is it practiced by all cultures? (Good morning/afternoon/evening/night)

1 Answers 2022-04-01

Over the course of 70 years, only two Labour MP’s, Tony Blair and Harold Wilson, have won a General Election in England. Between 1975 and 1997, a Tory held the office of Prime Minister in the UK. Why was Labour so bad at winning elections?

1 Answers 2022-04-01

I am the honorable Andrew Oliver Esq., the assigned stamp distributor for the Province of Massachusetts Bay. AMA about the grave injustices committed towards my person by the townspeople of Boston.

Honorable gentlemen,

Some of you might know my name and person, but for those who are unaware, my name is Andrew Oliver Esq., Secretary of the Province of Massachusetts Bay. In the early months of the year of our lord seventeen-sixty-five, I was commissioned as stamp distributor for the Province of Massachusetts Bay, an act which turned out to be a most regrettable decision.

I invite you to ask me about my life, my experiences with the townspeople of Boston, about the Stamp Act, or anything else that might be of some importance to you.

I have been asked to provide proof of identity and this is what I have been able to arrange on such a short notice.

15 Answers 2022-04-01

Is there any surviving lyrics from ancient history?

IIRC not very much is known about music in the antiquity (Rome, Greece, Mesopotamia...) in comparison to later times, mostly learnt from mosaics, paintings, carvings and such but most depicts people playing instruments and or dancing.

So I ask if there is any surviving records or fragments even of any concrete song played by the oldest instrument, the voice. Or at least if there is any mention about how vocal music was back then.

1 Answers 2022-04-01

The original USB plug, first specified in 1996, is considered one of the worst mistakes in the history of industrial design, being externally symmetric but internally asymmetric. How did all the institutions involved fail to stop that absurd design from making it into a “universal” standard?

1 Answers 2022-04-01

AskHistorians Podcast April Fools Special 2022 – Tartaria with /u/EnclavedMicrostate

AskHistorians Podcast Episode NUMBER is live!

The AskHistorians Podcast is a project that highlights the users and answers that have helped make r/AskHistorians one of the largest history discussion forums on the internet. You can subscribe to us via Apple Podcasts, Stitcher, or RSS, and now on YouTube and Google Play. If there is another index you'd like the podcast listed on, let us know!

This Episode

In this special episode of the AskHistorians podcast, /u/hannahstohelit and /u/EnclavedMicrostate talk about one of the more unusual history-related conspiracy theories of recent years: Tartaria. Why are thousands of internet users convinced of the existence of a lost empire in Eurasia? Where does post-Soviet nationalism come into it? And why are they so obsessed with big buildings? All this and more will be revealed in this special. 60 mins.

A transcript of this episode can be found here.

6 Answers 2022-04-01

I am Jeane Dixon, famed medium, psychic and astrologer! I predicted the death of JFK, and other things which definitely ended up happening. AMA about THE FUTURE!!!!!

Proof.

It is I - the one, the only, the incomparable Jeane Dixon, renowned psychic, author and close confidante of the 40th President of the United States, Nancy Reagan. I've written multiple best-selling books, including an autobiography, a cookbook and of course my magnum opus, 'Horoscopes for Dogs'. I also predicted that the apocalypse would start in 2020 - but we can't be right about everything, I suppose*.*

Do you doubt my prowess in parsing the future? Do you require proof of my bona fides? Ah, what sad, closed minds you must have (not like Nancy). Fine then - I predict that you, dear reader, are about to spend a small amount of time reading text on the internet!

This prediction is much more impressive when you consider that I don't even really know what the internet is.

There seem to be many guests on these forums today, but they are all hacks, I assure you. For they purport to tell you only of the dingy, dreary past, like the temporally-challenged buffoons they all are. I, on the other hand, hold the keys to THE FUTURE. Ask me anything about what the future holds in store for you, your family, the world and any given president or pope of your choice!

25 Answers 2022-04-01

In Florence, various palaces and towers remain from the middle ages (such as the Palazzo Medici and the Torre degli Amidei, both originally owned by incredibly wealthy families). Are there any structures remaining that show what an ordinary home might have looked like for a less-wealthy citizen?

1 Answers 2022-04-01

I AM LEONIDAS, KING OF SPARTA! ASK ME ANYTHING!

GREETINGS, REDDIT! I AM LEONIDAS, THIRD SON OF KING ANAXANDRIDAS AND FIRST IN FAME OF THE AGIAD HOUSE! THE EPHORS HAVE DECREED A RARE DAY OF OPENNESS TO THE CURIOSITY OF FOREIGNERS!

PROOF!

284 Answers 2022-04-01

I am an SOE wireless operator, broadcasting from occupied Paris. Ask me anything before my broadcasting window closes!

... --- ...

Greetings! This message is coming to you over the airwaves from a secret location in Nazi-occupied Paris. I can't stay broadcasting for too long before the Gestapo track me down, so get your questions in before I have to go off air and hide.

edit: I will decode these at the end of today but in the meantime you can use this website to try and crack it - if you can guess the key words!

27 Answers 2022-04-01

Why is William Jennings Bryan so heavily featured in education?

So this question is a little bit odd. I know he's quite important and held a number of positions and was the leader of a major party for quite a while. But when I was in High School we spent I think close to an unreasonable amount of time on him. Free Silver and the Cross of Gold speech was covered in depth in my American History and my Government classes. The Scopes Monkey Trial was covered in my American History and American Law classes. All told I spent a solid 5 weeks over three years of school reading (and in some cases listening to- we had a later recorded repeat of the Cross of Gold speech as an assigned listen) all about Bryan. Even the unit on Scopes, where he was a prosecutor, were largely centered on Bryan.

This seems like a level of attention far beyond his actual impact on US History. I'm on the older side of Reddit demographics but nothing approaching it being any sort of current event, my high school time lasted from the late 90s to the early 2000's. Am I missing something? Did my school have a particular weird affinity for Bryan, or is this basically consensus on his importance?

1 Answers 2022-04-01

I am the true sacred sovereign on earth, the second son of God, Hong Xiuquan. Ask me anything!

Proof

Greetings to my brothers and sisters over the Internet. I, the true sacred sovereign, have deigned to speak candidly beyond the walls of my mighty palace to those who would recognise my authority in this world. Should you seek enlightenment on any matter, such enlightenment shall I provide.

45 Answers 2022-04-01

Wang Xihou was sentenced to nine familial executions by the Qianlong Emperor in 1777 for violating the Chinese naming taboo as he wrote the Kangxi Emperor’s name without omitting the final stroke. Was this seemingly extreme reaction normal in Imperial China, and if so, why?

1 Answers 2022-04-01

What is the story behind all the strange bathrooms that were on the Titanic?

I was looking at a deck plan of the Titanic and I noticed that on Deck F there were a number of "flavors" of what appear to be bathrooms that I had no idea what their functions, intended uses, or histories were.

I'm hoping that the smart folks here might help me understand what these rooms are for:

  • Shampooing Room
  • Steam Room
  • Hot Room
  • Temperate Room
  • Cooling Room
  • Elect Bath Room

Cheers!

1 Answers 2022-04-01

Explorer. Governor of New York. Vice President. President. Rough Rider. It's Theodore Roosevelt, hopefully this will go better than the last time I hosted an event in Milwaukee. Ask me anything!

Proof: https://imgur.com/S5nmQBV

40 Answers 2022-04-01

301 / 7255

Back to start