To what degree did the Allies and the USSR cooperate in WW2?

I've been reading about the effects of the US and other nations supplying European countries and the USSR to defeat the Axis powers. They also shared SOME information on logistics.

Question: did cooperation between the Allies and the soviets make a difference in the outcome of the war? Would it have been worse for them if they didn't cooperate at all?

http://www.historynet.com/did-russia-really-go-it-alone-how-lend-lease-helped-the-soviets-defeat-the-germans.htm

It seems the Allies and the soviets were going to win anyways, but would the war have lasted longer (costing even more lives) if the two fronts didn't even talk to each other?

1 Answers 2017-11-12

Was the "Italian" peninsula always called that, or had it once been called the "Roman" peninsula?

1 Answers 2017-11-12

How many Polish POWs (roughly) were in NKVD custody by September 19th, 1939?

The USSR invaded Poland on September 17th, 1939.

By September 19th, Lavrentiy Beria issued Order No. 0308, to "organize a Prisoner-of-War Administration under the NKVD USSR".

By the time this order was issued, roughly how many Polish soldiers had already surrendered to the USSR?

1 Answers 2017-11-12

What did the first email inbox look like?

Ray Tomlinson created the first email program, for use with the ARPANET in the early 1970s (the first machine-to-machine electronic message apparently said something unpromising like "QWERTYUIOP").

Even with the ability to communicate to multiple users (until then, electronic mail had been limited to users of the same machine), this new 'email' would have been limited to people in the ARPANET directory.

Knowing that there were a limited amount of users to manage, what did Ray's inbox look like?

How did things like message-specific information like address/to/from display itself?

1 Answers 2017-11-12

Meso-American cultures worshiped a Feathered Serpent. Is this being based on a sort of evolutionary "missing link" between Reptiles and Birds? If so, how was the story of the being passed down for what may have been several millenia from the creatures existence to the age of its worship?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-11-12

Is this claim about racial tensions in the UK between US and UK/Commonwealth troops true?

Claim: "Fun fact about Maori, in WW2 when American's came to Britain, they didn't like black colonial troops and Maori in the pubs. So they demanded the British bar them from the place, and the Brits told them to piss off and put "No White American" signs in their bars."

It's a youtube comment, but given such events as The Battle of Manners Street, Battle of Brisbane and Battle of Bamber Bridge I suspect it might be true. Is there any evidence backing that claim?

1 Answers 2017-11-12

Looking for battle mapping software.

I've developed some kind of obsession lately to map out certain battles (WWI, WWII, Afghanistan, etc.) for some reason, but after countless google searches I've come up with nothing. I know there is a software out there somewhere, as I see several maps with identical markers. If I'm still unclear, I'm looking for a software that will allow me to make battle maps like in a textbook.

1 Answers 2017-11-12

Why was there such a long period without the construction of pyramids in ancient Egypt? Khendjers reign was around 1760BC and and the next pyramid wasn't erected until 721BC by Piye?

2 Answers 2017-11-12

This Week's Theme: Oral Traditions

1 Answers 2017-11-12

In the American South of the 1950s-1970s, was it typical for older men (in their 20s or older) to 'court' teenage girls? What were typical marriage ages and age gaps?

2 Answers 2017-11-12

What was religious practice in Gaul like between Caesar's conquest and the enforcement of Christianity as the state religion under Constantine?

I know some Gaulish gods like Epona spread across the Empire, but what was the general practice in Gaul? Were Gaulish gods still worshipped widely? Were they absorbed into Roman ones (as Zeus was into Jupiter, for instance?) Did one group (Gaulish or Roman) of gods hold pre-eminence over the other? And what did the common people actually practice, in terms of places and forms of worship. I think immediately of the fact that Iceland, which has been Christian for 1000 years, still diverts roads to not bother the elves - and I'm curious to know if Gaul had similar hold-overs that distinguished it from the rest of the Roman world.

1 Answers 2017-11-12

At what point did the patrician/plebeian distinction no longer matter? The Gracchi were plebeians yet Scipio Africanus's grandchildren, and Antony, another pleb, was ancestor to several emperors. Had it ceased to matter by that point?

1 Answers 2017-11-12

Why was Vietnam split into North and South but not Laos and Cambodia?

1 Answers 2017-11-12

Why did camels never catch on as transport animals in the American West, as they did in almost every other desert/plains on earth?

1 Answers 2017-11-12

When/why did America loose it's English accent following independence?

If the colonies had stayed under English rule, would they have developed a new accent? Also, would the differences in words like "favorite/favourite and color/colour arise?

1 Answers 2017-11-12

How well equipped were Soviet soldiers during World War 2?

I’ve heard that Soviet soldiers had only one rifle for every five or ten men. And the sheer number of soviet military deaths compared to any other nation leads me to believe that, while the one rifle/ten men story may not be 100% true, it has some basis in reality. So how well equipped were Soviet soldiers during the Second World War?

1 Answers 2017-11-12

Did the Russians use Dinitrophenol as a supplement during WW2?

I was wondering whether there is any truth to the russians using 2,4-dinitrophenol as a supplement during ww2, with the purpose of staying warm. I can't seem to find any sources on it, but my teacher seemed like he thought it was the case, and I have to decide between writing a large assignment on this or something else, so beforehand I'd like to be sure.

Any help's appreciated, thanks :)

1 Answers 2017-11-12

Panel AMA: The World War II of Call of Duty

Welcome everyone to our World War II Panel AMA!

With the recent release of Call of Duty’s current iteration, “WWII”, we’ve assembled together for you a panel to discuss the historicity of the game, the history behind it, and the META-narrative of history as entertainment to boot. We've had questions about its accuracy - as well as that of earlier games - and anticipate more in the coming weeks, so want to provide a centralized place to address the wide variety of questions it is likely to lead to.

With the game focused on the American Campaign and the broader activities of the Western Front from Normandy onwards, we likewise have tailored this panel to be similarly pivoted, but we have a number of participants, able to cover a wide spectrum of topics related to the war, so please don’t feel too constrained if you have a question not necessarily inspired by the game, but which nevertheless seems likely in the wheelhouse of one of our panelists.

The flaired users at general quarters for this AMA include the following, and the following areas of coverage:

  • /u/Bernardito will be covering topics related to the British Armed Forces, with a focus on in Burma, 1942-1945
  • /u/bigglesworth_'s main area of interest is aerial warfare during World War II. He's not aware of any historical instances of an infantryman waiting until two enemies are close together before calling in an AZON strike to get a multikill.
  • /u/calorie_man's main area of interest are the Malayan Campaign and British grand strategy leading up to WWII.
  • Despite the flair, /u/captainpyjamashark's main areas of interest are gender and 20th century France, and can help answer questions about the occupation, resistance, the Maquis, and interactions between American soldiers and the French, especially involving French women.
  • /u/coinsinmyrocket will be covering the activities of the OSS and SOE during WWII as well as any general questions about the American Military's experience during the war. He can neither confirm nor deny the existence of killstreaks being used to make American Airborne units OP in combat.
  • /u/commiespaceinvader's main area of research is the Wehrmacht and Wehrmacht war crimes. For this AMA he will focus on questions concerning the Holocaust, POW camps, and the treatment of American and other captives.
  • Among other things, /u/Georgy_K_Zhukov likes stuff that go "pew pew pew".
  • /u/kugelfang52 studies American Holocaust memory. He is most interested in how Americans perceive and use the Holocaust to understand and shape the world around them.
  • /u/LordHighBrewer will be covering topics related to the Anglo-Canadian forces from D-day to VE day.
  • /u/nate077 studies the Wehrmacht, Holocaust, and Germany during the war.
  • /u/rittermeister was once very interested in soldier life and material culture in the American and German armies. Essentially, small-unit tactics, uniforms and equipment, and various other minutiae of war at the bleeding edge. Can also muddle through German doctrine, recruitment, and training.
  • As the name implies, /u/TankArchives will be covering the use of armoured vehicles while feverishly flipping through Sherman manuals looking for how many hitpoints each variant had.
  • /u/the_howling_cow researches the United States Army in WWII; the campaigns in North Africa, Italy, Europe, and the Pacific and the Army's organization and training, uniforms, and materiel, with specializations in armored warfare and the activities of the U.S. 35th Infantry Division.
  • /u/thefourthmaninaboat is interested in the Royal Navy, and its operations during the war, especially in the European and Mediterranean theatres.

As always, we ask that users not part of the panel please refrain from answering questions, which is a privilege restricted to those participating.

^^Legal ^^mumbo ^^jumbo: ^^We ^^are ^^in ^^no ^^way ^^endorsing, ^^or ^^endorsed ^^by, ^^the ^^game!

30 Answers 2017-11-12

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | November 06, 2017–November 12, 2017

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

4 Answers 2017-11-12

What did Soviet citizens think of the Bolshevik leaders' pseudonyms?

Lenin, Stalin, Trotsky and most (?) of the Bolshevik leadership used assumed names in the years leading up to their takeover. "Lenin" refers to the Lena river in Siberia, "Stalin" means "man of steel" etc. Did they use these pseudonyms to avoid the Tsarist police (they spent a lot of time in exile either way), or were they used primarily for dramatic effect (or to mask their ethnicities)? What did ordinary Russians think of these names - were they even aware that they were pseudonyms?

In the US, it would be as if a President Mississippi and a Vice-President Concrete had suddenly taken over. Stephen Kotkin's bio of Stalin makes no mention of anyone finding the fake names unusual, but he does relate an interesting bit from a pre-WW1 Lenin letter where he is trying to track down "Koba" (one of Stalin's earlier pseudonyms) but can't remember his real name (Jugashvilli).

1 Answers 2017-11-12

Tristam Shandy strikes me as a post-modernist work written in the middle of the 18th century, down to including bits later eras would label as of questionable taste. Was this a product of the work coming before novels had rules? Am I overstating how surreal it was for something that old?

3 Answers 2017-11-12

In today's gospel, Jesus told a parable which struck me as anachronistic. It was about a husband and his ten newly married brides. In the first century CE, did the Jewish community practice polygamy? Would the idea be regarded as socially acceptable?

2 Answers 2017-11-12

Did nobles in medieval Europe have worse teeth than peasants because of all the salt and sugar?

1 Answers 2017-11-12

Where did the inhabitants of Vatican City get their food and other supplies during the "prisoner in the Vatican" period before Italy recognized it? If they got it from Italy, how did it affect the relationship between the two?

1 Answers 2017-11-12

Divorce seems remarkably casual in ancient Rome. Is this because we have a primarily aristocratic view on the subject? Were women as empowered to initiate proceedings as men? Could they expect to emerge financially and socially intact, or did Rome share other societies stigma for experienced women?

3 Answers 2017-11-12

⯇ 3010 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start