Were there any claims to secession or threats of secession before the American Civil War?

1 Answers 2017-08-28

As a german I never fully understood Watergate. What happened and why was it such a scandal?

5 Answers 2017-08-28

I'm a landed noble in France in the Middle Ages and I want to gift money to another landed noble in the Byzantine Empire. What do I send him? Gold?

Basically: what was the "international currency" in the Middle Ages?

1 Answers 2017-08-28

Who was the first President of the United States to speak with an "American" (not recognizably British) accent?

Pardon the phrasing of this question.

While we all know that the average American sounded indistinguishable from his British counterpart at one point, and the two deviated after their countries were separated, Americans "lost" the "British" accent at different rates depending on the region of the country he was in, and the social stratum he occupied.

I'm asking at around what time the Presidents started sounding 'more American' because that might give a more precise date, and because the President is a symbol of the country and its people in some ways, and the answer to this question would be helpful in identifying some overall, national trends.

1 Answers 2017-08-28

WW2 Era British Paratroopers Question

I was wondering why some British paratroopers would wear berets while some would wear helmets into combat? (most notably the red berets/red devils). Shouldn't they have been issued the same thing into combat? Also how were the British Paratroopers when compared to the US and German counterparts (airborne and fallschirmjager) throughout the war?

Thanks!

1 Answers 2017-08-28

I've read that Columbus instituted a tribute system on Tainos and cut off hands as punishment. I couldn'rlt find a source for this- is it true? Has the narrative swung to be overly critical of him? Is Bartolome de las Casas an unbiased source?

I recently read the Oatmeal comic on Christopher Columbus and it, along with History on Fire's podcast on Cortez's conquest of the Aztecs, has sparked an interest in Columbus within me. It seems that not only the question of if Columbus should be celebrated, but also historical facts about Columbus, have become politicized. I feel like de las Casas would have an interest in exaggerating the atrocities that the spanish, and Cortez, committed.

 I'm hoping to learn how well trusted de las Casas is, the truth of the degree of Columbus' atrocities are, and in particular the claim that he cut off hands as punishment when Tainos didn't deliver the gold they were ordered to collect. In a quick search I could only find it sourced to Zinn's A people's history of the United States, and Hans Koning's Columbus, neither of which had sources themselves (at least online). Also, if there is more information about Columbus' view of keeping women as sex slaves, especially young girls, I'd like to hear them.  I was shocked about the Oatmeal's quote of Columbus:

 "A hundred castellanos are as easily obtained for a woman as for a farm, and there are plenty of dealers who go about looking for girls; those from nine to ten are now in demand, and for all ages a good price must be paid."

[Until I learned he was railing against the sins of other settlers] (http://ageofex.marinersmuseum.org/index.php?type=explorersection&id=65)

I have no doubt that Columbus enslaved and killed hundreds of indigenous Americans, but I'd like to really understand what type of person he was. Was he a devout Christian? Was he holding back men from committing atrocities or was he encouraging them?

Finally, I've learned that Colombus' estimate of the distance to east Asia was 1/10th that which it really is- but he was not alone in thinking that it was much closer than it actually is. How controversial was his claim in the day? I've read the Spain and Portugal's councillors atgued against his trip because they thought the distance was longer, but was he an absolute moron in his time for believing what he did- or just working off a lower estimate for the distance?

1 Answers 2017-08-28

What information is known about the Sea Peoples from the late Bronze Age collapse?

1 Answers 2017-08-28

Jews and Business? When did this association start?

Jewish people are often associated with business and trade. I do not get the sense that Jewish people in the old testament were associated with trade and business to an unusual degree, so at what point did this association begin? I know during the high middle ages, Jewish people played prominent roles as entrepreneurs and moneylenders. Would they have played such a role during the late roman period? How about during the era of the Roman Empire?

1 Answers 2017-08-28

Why is the term "Kinh" not very commonly used to refer to ethnic Vietnamese?

1 Answers 2017-08-28

Was being bilingual or multilingual common among pre-European Native Americans?

I'm wondering this in light of the prevailing stereotype that people living in the United States tend to be monolingual and ignorant of other cultures. By contrast, many people living in Africa, Europe, and Asia grow up speaking three or even more languages fluently.

Well, what about the Native Americans? They were frequently in contact with other tribes, sure. These different tribes probably also spoke different languages. But did that mean they were necessarily multilingual?

Since geography affects the audience you're able to communicate with, I'm guessing that neighboring tribes tended to share linguistic roots and were therefore similar (kind of like Spanish and Portuguese). Were there Native Americans who were in contact with tribes that spoke completely unrelated languages, yet this did not pose a language barrier to either party? Or was one language all you really needed to know to get by in life?

1 Answers 2017-08-28

During the Korean war, how was the evacuation of Hungnam achieved with so few American casualties?

There is strangely little popular media of any kind about the Korean war, and what there is tends to be either contemporary and jingoistic, or extremely broad and highly generalized. I was recently surprised to learn that, during the Chinese counterattack that ejected UN forces from North Korea, significant elements of the American forces and tens of thousands of civilian refugees were surrounded in the port of Hungnam by the Chinese army.

Instead of being captured or destroyed, literally all American forces escaped over the course of a 1-2 week naval evacuation, along with a significant amount of civilian refugees, and all their equipment. The numbers approach those of the battle of Dunkirk in terms of manpower and time pressure (and exceed it in materiel), but the casualties differ wildly: at Hungnam, almost no American casualties are recorded in the writing I can find (2 men were killed and roughly twenty wounded in an accidental explosion).

My question is, why were casualties during this action so light? Were Chinese forces focused on containment, or on pushing towards Seoul? Was the American artillery and air support capable of holding off Chinese forces indefinitely? Were Chinese units under orders to consolidate their position, or wait for reinforcements? It seems to me that, considering the Chinese tactic of mass infantry charges in use at the time, a push through the American artillery curtain wouldn't have been out of the question.

1 Answers 2017-08-28

Historians have found no conclusive, archaeological evidence that the Anglo-Saxons used ship masts in their ship design during the 5th Century. How probable is it that so many Anglo-Saxons were able to emigrate across the North Sea using oar powered boats?

From what I've read, historians have found no conclusive, archaeological evidence that the Anglo-Saxons used ship masts in their ship design during the 5th Century. How could so many Anglo-Saxons have made such a long journey using presumably oar power alone?

I imagine that the use of Anglo-Saxon mercenaries by the late or post-Romans could have advanced the population of Anglo-Saxons in Britain, but the emigration has always been described as an invasion from across the sea, at least from what I've heard.

Is it possible that such excavations at Sutton Hoo, near Woodbridge, Suffolk only uncovered a coastal and river raiding vessel? Are there any instances of ship masts being re-used due to their value or worth, which would preclude them from burial?

1 Answers 2017-08-28

AskHistorians Podcast 093 - The Holy Roman Empire in the Age of Martin Luther

Episode 93 is up!

The AskHistorians Podcast is a project that highlights the users and answers that have helped make /r/AskHistorians one of the largest history discussion forums on the internet. You can subscribe to us via iTunes, Stitcher, or RSS, and now on YouTube and Google Play. You can also catch the latest episodes on SoundCloud. If there is another index you'd like the cast listed on, let me know!

This Episode:

In light of the upcoming 500th anniversary of the beginning of the Protestant Reformation, Professor Peter Wilson talks with us about the Holy Roman Empire in the 16th century.

Professor Wilson is known for books such as Heart of Europe: A History of the Holy Roman Empire and The Thirty Years War: Europe's Tragedy.

Questions? Comments?

If you want more specific recommendations for sources or have any follow-up questions, feel free to ask them here! Also feel free to leave any feedback on the format and so on.

If you like the podcast, please rate and review us on iTunes.

Thanks all!

Previous episode and discussion.

Next Episode: u/AnnalsPornographie is back!

Want to support the Podcast? Help keep history interesting through the AskHistorians Patreon.

7 Answers 2017-08-28

English is ubiquitous in India, but Dutch has virtually no presence in modern Indonesia, although it was under Dutch control for over 300 years. What differences in colonial policies led to this difference?

3 Answers 2017-08-28

Why does John Milton's English sound almost modern whereas people who lived 50 years earlier (Shakespeare, Spenser, Bacon) are incoherent at time?

Did Milton attempt to be more accessible? Was that a conscious difference in style?

Or is it just that the English language changed significantly under the affect of the Glorious Revolution?

If so, why did it stop changing (so much) thereafter?

Ockham's razor says that Milton just used to be much more popular and therefore had more influence on what the English language is now. Is that so? If so, why?

1 Answers 2017-08-28

How did gold come to hold such value across virtually all modern societies?

1 Answers 2017-08-28

What kinds of scholarships are available for history minors and majors going into college?

1 Answers 2017-08-28

I am an American in 1800, what am I critizing the government about?

1 Answers 2017-08-28

In antiquity and the middle ages, what happened after a rout? Where did they go?

Were levies and soldiers ever punished for fleeing the battlefield? Once the enemy stopped pursuing, would people group back together, or just try to find their way home in small groups?

1 Answers 2017-08-28

Why did humans for nearly the entire human history bar some exceptions and the last 200 years centered around monarchies or similar governments as the standard form of government?

Except for some exceptions (Greek City States, Roman Republic, Italian Republics, etc) and the last 200 years, most humans lived in a monarchy. In Mesopotamia it began with city states but soon they "evolved" into kingdoms. In Egypt you had a king-like Pharao, too. Rome, while first being a republic, became an empire. Most of the medieval world was a monarchy except for the Italian City States. In Asia it was pretty much just monarchies. In South America there had king-like rulers, too.

I could go on and on but my question is why most of humanity for most of its time "choose" to be ruled by 1 guy, a king or emperor or priest or god knows what?

Did that have some kind of big advantage compared to republics or other, non-monarchy governments?

3 Answers 2017-08-28

How far back in time could an English speaking person go, and still be understood.

I guess what i'm asking would there be a point that old english speakers wouldn't be able to understand modern english?

1 Answers 2017-08-28

How many men were needed to man Age of Exploration era ships, such as the late Caravel/Nao?

I've been finding conflicting sources on manpower needed to sail ships. The common theme seems to be that sources dealing with millitary history always report crews in the upper tens/lower hundreds (70-150 roughly), while accounts on merchant ships report way below that, sometimes even 15 men for a caravel.

What was the criteria upon which the captains decided the amount of crew they hired, if both 150 and 15 men are viable manpower on the same ship?

What else affected the minimum manpower? Did sail type changes, or rigging improvements make bigger reductions? How much impact did the invention of gaff rigging make? Could there have been caravels with front-aft sail plan and outfitted with either a lug or gaff mizzenmast?

1 Answers 2017-08-28

How did we finally realise the world wasn't flat?

1 Answers 2017-08-28

Is the popular conception of the Catholic Church's "anti-science" stance during the Galileo affair accurate?

1 Answers 2017-08-27

Is Nazism right wing or left wing??

I'm confused. I'm a bit of a history buff and have always thought/read that it was a far right ideology but I'm in high school and my history teacher said that the textbook is technically wrong and that Nazism is actually a left wing ideology. He said this candidly as he often goes on long rants that are slightly offtopic. He said he disagrees with the textbook/curriculum because Nazi-style fascism had origins in socialist groups, like the National Socialist German Workers' Party, and that the collectivist and nationalist qualities of fascism move it closer to the domain of socialism or Marxism than liberal democracy (his words).

I did some Googling and while Wikipedia says it's right wing, plenty of other sites say the opposite and reddit is torn on the issue. I thought the internet would solve this but it's just making it worse.

1 Answers 2017-08-27

⯇ 3169 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start