Do we know FDR's personal thoughts on the internment of Japanese-Americans? Is there any sign he recognized it as a betrayal of American values?

Did he show any personal conflict?

1 Answers 2017-02-03

In the age of nationalism did the Jews view themselves as belonging to a nation?

Throughout the 1800s you see the Germans, French, Croats, Hungarians, etc. all wanting their own nation. Many of these groups were ready to resort to violence to get a nation stage. The there are the Jews who are constantly kicked around or forced to live in specific areas. Did the Jews see themselves as belonging to a nation?

1 Answers 2017-02-03

Has there ever been an enduring facist state?

While a country like North Korea, and to a lesser extent, China and Cuba, have kept the USSR-style model of a Communist government alive, it seems to me that there is no current example of a country with a form of government like the facist states of the WWII Axis -- Germany, Italy, and Spain. While there are many authoritarian governments that do not have a ruling leftist ideology, the most prominent being Russia, those countries are better described as oligarchies or "illiberal democracies", as they do not contain many hallmarks of fascism such as ethnocentric ideologies, a social safety net for members of the "nation", cult of a leader, etc.

My question is, are there were any examples in history of governments that could be called "proto-facist", that endured for a longer time period than the 25 years or so that most facist governments existed for during WWII (with the obvious exception of Spain)?

And in a larger sense, do you think there is any specific difference between the ideologies of Facism and Communism, the two ideological poles of the early 20th century, that caused the latter to endure while the former was all but eliminated? Or was it all historical circumstance?

3 Answers 2017-02-03

Did the Romans know the Earth is round?

1 Answers 2017-02-03

Who governed the Democratic Republic of Vietnam and Republic of Vietnam during the Second Indochina War?

I'm in charge of running a historical simulation of the Vietnam War (crisis cabinet) for a Model United Nations conference.

Simply put, I'm having a lot of difficulty finding a list of key personnel in both governments, such as the Politburo in the DRV or even the names of ministers in South Vietnam. Historiography in English largely favors American involvement, and what little I can find points me mostly to only the top figures in the government like Le Duan or Ky and Thieu.

As such, it'd be tremendously appreciated if anyone can point me to resources, or any text, really, that give the names and positions of such ministers in both North and South Vietnam- preferably during the 1960s.

In addition, anything interesting about South Vietnam? It seems like an even more neglected field of study, even as more research seems to explore them as more than a simple client state. I'm reading Andrew Wiest's Vietnam's Forgotten Army, but any books/journal articles would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks so much!

1 Answers 2017-02-03

Were any previous First-Ladies considered to be "trophy" wives?

1 Answers 2017-02-03

Why was the Spanish colonisation of the Americas so brutal and destructive compared to their colonisation of the Philippines?

When you compare the Philippines to Hispanic America it seems the Philipppines retained so much of their indigenous culture. Filipinos all speak their indigenous pre-colonial languages and most of them are not mestizos or white due to mass rape. I read somewhere that something like 1% of Filipinos can even speak the Spanish language, which is obviously a huge contrast to countries like Mexico and Peru.

I get the impression there was just total genocide of the Aztec or Mayan cultures and people when the Spanish arrived in the Americas. Most of the indigenous people died and they lost most of their culture.

Why were the two regions treated so differently? Or why do they look so different today (culturally and linguistically)? Today you could go to the Philippines and not even realise it was a Spanish colony for centuries.

1 Answers 2017-02-03

The Rise of the Mongol Empire, why did it happen?

For my coursework in History, my question is something along the lines of 'Why did the Mongol Empire expand so rapidly between the years 1190 to 1294.' I need two historians with differing opinions on the causes behind this, and could use some help finding them (and ideally a book written by them which expresses their opinion), would anyone be willing to help? Thanks.

1 Answers 2017-02-03

Were there any foreign reactions to the US purchasing Alaska from Russia?

1 Answers 2017-02-03

Why do only 2% of people in the Gambia speak English, despite being under British rule for nearly 200 years?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-02-03

Was Augustus Caesar the richest man of all time?

I've read that Mansa Musa was "the richest man of all time", however google only shows his net worth at around $400 billion as compared to Caesar's $4.6 trillion?

1 Answers 2017-02-03

Are there any citable sources for the wealth of Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart?

Upon quick research, I have found vastly different results. The movie Amadeus apparently displays Mozart as dying without a single penny, unknowing of his impact on the future of music.

Then others speculate he made almost equivalent to what Beethoven was demanding at that time, which was enough for comfortable living.

So is there any consensus at all for this? Or is it purely speculation based on spotty accounts? Thank you.

Edit: This is purely my curiosity, though it is worded a bit like a homework question.

1 Answers 2017-02-03

Announcing the Best of January Award Winners

The votes are in!

Taking the 'Flair's Choice' Award is /u/sunagainstgold for their answer to "Historiography question: feminist history vs history of women?"

The vote getter for the 'User's Choice' Award was /u/yodatsracist, who answered "I for one am deeply dissatisfied with the amount and quality of historical information available about the mullet. Can anyone properly enlighten me about the rise and fall of this magnificent hairwreck?"

Finally, "Dark Horse Award", recognizing the top voted non-flaired answer, goes to /u/rimeroyal for the response to "What do we know about book design in High Middle Ages in England? Would a scribe in charge of writing up, say, Little Domesday book, had any precise instructions (and training) in regards to page arrangement, size of letters and so on? Was there any standard book to look at as an example?"

The winners each receive a month of reddit gold in recognition of their accomplishment!

So as always, a big congratulations to the winners, and a big thanks to everyone who contributed to the subreddit in the past month! Also a reminder, if you want to nominate answers for the monthly awards, the best way to do so is to submit your favorite posts every week to the Sunday Digest!

For a list of past winners, check out this Wiki page!

3 Answers 2017-02-03

Friday Free-for-All | February 03, 2017

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

14 Answers 2017-02-03

When did America start talking about being the greatest country on Earth?

I doubt we started this rhetoric clear back at the start. Was this like the whole under God thing? Were we trying to pump ourselves up during the cold war?

1 Answers 2017-02-03

What was the explanation for a woman giving birth to twins in the Middle Ages?

1 Answers 2017-02-03

My Chinese girlfriend eats leftovers for breakfast. I find that odd growing up in the South(Louisiana), where all we eat for breakfast is "breakfast foods", bacon eggs etc. When did traditionally associated breakfast foods become a thing in America? And how regional are these breakfast foods?

5 Answers 2017-02-03

What about the political atmosphere in Austria-Hungary Before WW1 led them to push for a war in the balkans vs Serbia?

Clearly Austria-Hungary had its rationale for invading Serbia after the Archduke was assassinated but I understand that the Archdule wasn't that popular and his death didn't necessarily need to result in a major war. How did the Political atmosphere in A-H lead them to make such bold demands vs Serbia that would lead to war? Also what were the effects of the Balkan wars?

1 Answers 2017-02-03

[Spartans] the 'hot gates' are kai-ghe in protoindoeuropean or the asiatic inverse form ghe-kai which is phonetically similar to Xerses (ghe-kai). Is there a reason the hot gates might bare Xerses name?

2 Answers 2017-02-03

Anatomy/Dissection in Early Modern Europe.

Hello lovelies!

I am to begin writing my MA dissertation and have decided on the topic of dissection in EME, aiming for a focus outside of Italy to avoid writing on the already oversaturated scholarship on Vesalius. I am considering an essay discussing public perception related to dissection, taboos, and speculative fear regarding the practice. I.E worries relating to the acquisition of cadavers etc.

I have acquired Klestinec's 'Theatres of anatomy', Sawday's 'The body emblazoned', and Siraisi's 'history of medicine'. Is anyone able to suggest any articles / books that may be useful?

Thanks! X

1 Answers 2017-02-03

How did WW2 pilots find their way back to their carrier after naval battles?

Since the carriers were always moving, simply keeping track of courses, speeds and distances wouldn't have been accurate. Did they have radio navigation back then?

2 Answers 2017-02-03

Italy is predominatly Catholic. What was the religious justification for the wars against Ethiopia, the nation of the legendary Christian king Prester John?

1 Answers 2017-02-03

In most screen versions of Great Expectations Pip starts speaking with received pronoceation to pass as a gentleman. Is that at all period accurate for the 1820s?

1 Answers 2017-02-03

Were there any successful violent or nonviolent protests in Nazi Germany?

2 Answers 2017-02-03

What is the history of homosexuality in the Nazi Party?

I've recently read a few posts and comments about the Nazi Party having various gay members, and how it was viewed as a good and masculine thing. I'd like to get a better understanding of this since Gay Nazis seems contradictory.

As a follow up question: What is the history of homosexuality in the broader Fascist movements of the 20th century? I realize this is a more open question so I understand if it can't be answered easily.

1 Answers 2017-02-03

⯇ 3629 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start