I've read that in the 1800's, US military officers were drawn from the upper class. If so, was it possible that a lower class citizen could perform well in school, go to college and be commissioned regardless of his prior social status?

2 Answers 2016-11-15

Is it safe to say that the remainings of the Roman Empire today is Italy?

Considering they both have the same capital..

Sry if it seems stupid

1 Answers 2016-11-15

Is it true that Native American civilizations were entirely stone age? If so, why?

It's my understanding that the major civilizations native to the New World, including but not limited to the Mayans, Inca, Aztecs and the North American tribes were almost entirely stone age civilizations. That is, agrarian, but pre-metallurgy with the majority of industry using primarily stone and wood. Most notably, I believe the Aztecs made limited use of the wheel and extensive use of obsidian blades, while the construction of the central and south american civilizations was limited to piled stone. Meanwhile, the tribes of modern Canada and the USA used stone arrowheads, stone knives, et cetera.

Is this accurate? If so, why did bronzeworking (and from there, iron and steel) never develop? Did their stoneworking ever advance from stone blocks to concrete-analogues?

1 Answers 2016-11-15

Today, fashion in the American West is less formal than that in the East Coast. Historically, how did fashion differ between the two regions?

I'm also curious about how fashion differed among the lower, middle, and upper classes.

I'd love book recommendations as well, as to do my own research.

Thanks!

1 Answers 2016-11-15

How Do I Read a History Book?

Hello everyone,

I recently bought two books:

The Ottoman Endgame

A Brief History of The Magna Carta

I find them very difficult to read. The books go into extreme detail, almost becoming a chronicling of minor events, rather than a narrative of their respective topics. What I really want to read about/take away is an understanding of the significance of these subjects, and knowing bureaucratic details doesn't really add to my intuitive understanding of these subjects.

Am I reading the wrong books? These are very different from my previous experience in non-fiction, but I would still like to read them.

Is there a better method to reading history books of this kind, or am I wrong to read these books recreationally?

EDIT: Wow! Thanks for the insightful advice, much appreciated!

3 Answers 2016-11-15

How did British general public view the collapse of the British Empire?

2 Answers 2016-11-15

[META][SEMI-Meta] Anyone know where the "Second Truth" post is that is or was pretty popular around these parts to explain "bad history"

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-11-15

I want to listen to music from the beginnings of music till today.

So where do I start? Wikipedia gives a little info but its pretty sparse, especially after the classical era. I want to listen to everything though. From as far back and as thorough as possible.

2 Answers 2016-11-15

When did History stop becoming problematic to deal with (in terms of sources)?

I know ancient history is a serious pain to work with given the scarcity of sources in some regions and eras, and the abundance but clear bias of sources in others due to their being written by only a few people. When did this cease to be a problem? For example in the modern day we have millions of records about everything and getting a full picture is less of an issue.

1 Answers 2016-11-15

I'm looking for a book that covers the history of the black panthers. Any recommendations?

I'm having a hard time finding any objective, well-researched sources. Any help would be much appreciated!

1 Answers 2016-11-15

Did any of elected presidents ever lose a primary? (For example Hillary lost a primary election to Obama, but ran again and could have won, but did anyone actually win after a primary loss?)

1 Answers 2016-11-15

Why aren't architectural styles like Gothic and Art Deco no longer used today?

First off I recognize my question might be flawed, as there might be recent examples I'm not aware of (and it's also being asked from an American's view), and there might be other subs better suited for this question, but...

I feel like we never see current, new examples of large buildings built in the styles you see in older construction from urban American centers at the turn of the turn of the century like New York City. The ornate details and the beautiful designs, I feel like these styles are more or less extinct today.

Is this purely because of changes in taste? Did modern safety regulations make these building styles too expensive? Did these styles become too expensive because of changes in labor and material costs? Are we just cheap and boring now?

Edit 2: Just realized my phone auto corrected and destroyed my title. Gotta love mobile.

1 Answers 2016-11-15

In Modern Times (1936), a factory owner is seen monitoring his workers via 2 way video surveillance. Would this have seemed like science fiction at time time?

I was watching the Charlie Chaplin film Modern Times (1936) tonight and there are several scenes in a factory where the owner monitors and communicates with the workers via 2 way video communication. You can see examples here and here (same video, 1m35s and 2m20s if the links don't work).

Television systems were in their infancy around this time. Would the average movie goer have been familiar with the concept of video systems or was this seen as science fiction?

1 Answers 2016-11-15

Effects of Treaty of Versailles in other countries besides Germany?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-11-15

Has a knighting ever ended in a surprise or accidental beheading?

The accolade ceremony often involves a sword tapping either sword of the person being knighted. Is there any evidence of one of these ceremonies going horribly wrong?

1 Answers 2016-11-15

Following the devastation and defeat of Germany in WW2, what happened to the "financial identities" -- i.e. the savings, investments, mortgages and other debts -- of individual Germans?

1 Answers 2016-11-15

What would a woman in 12th century Europe do if her husband was physically abusing her? In the 14th century?

And how would it change depending on her class?

(I realize Europe is very broad, I'm interested in hearing about any specific polity)

1 Answers 2016-11-15

What problems did Italy face after WWI and how did this cause the rise of Fascism?

And what were the geo-political consequences of the war from an Italian perspective?

1 Answers 2016-11-15

How did the European powers react to the loss of Constantinople?

1 Answers 2016-11-14

During the 1850s, illegal logging in the Great Lakes region was so bad that the US Navy was called in to help stop it. How did these "timber pirates" operate, and why were they so successful even after the US Navy was involved?

2 Answers 2016-11-14

Why were there no amphibious landings/battles before the modern era? It seems like someone in the ancient world or maybe someone in the Japanese invasion of Korea MUST have attempted a contested landing, but I understand such operations didn't exist until the age of exploration.

1 Answers 2016-11-14

What happened in the 90's in eastern Europe?

So I recently read the Wikipedia articles of what happened in the FRY and Bosnia. Now without understanding to much it seemed to me that what happened was a bombing of two countries just because they were communists.

I wanna know:

  1. What were the official reasons given for the bombings?

  2. What were the realistic reasons for why the bombings happened?

Thanks in advance.

1 Answers 2016-11-14

Is are the Italian Guelfs and Ghibellines the linguistic basis for the names "elf" and "goblin?"

I recently attended a lecture in which an Italian medievalist claimed that the english nouns "elf" and "goblin" as present in Tolkien come from the medieval guelfs and ghibellines. He said that this was based upon the development of a concept of guelfs as good, pure, and for justice, while ghibellines were the opposite. This claim seems somewhat far-fetched, since these creatures existed in the folklore of non-Italian cultures. Is this a case of English appropriating sounds and concepts from Italy to describe another culture, or just convenient coincidence?

2 Answers 2016-11-14

How was Hitler's relation with the former kaiser Wilhelm?

1 Answers 2016-11-14

In the Age of Sail, how did a ship's draft affect its speed?

i.e. Would a fast warship be low in the water or high in the water?

1 Answers 2016-11-14

⯇ 3822 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start