After Justinian reconquered N.Africa, did he really allow Romans to reclaim land they allegedly held more than 100 years earlier, i.e., before the original Vandal conquest? How were land disputes between Romans claiming title to the same land resolved? How was valid title determined?

1 Answers 2022-01-18

Did Ireland ever have a known snake problem?

Supposedly Sir Patrick banished snakes from Ireland by standing on a hilltop and... telling them to go away? Is there any evidence, written or archaeological, that suggests the snakes were actually there?

I can understand the religious context and the symbolism of the snake, like Patrick drove the devil out of Ireland. I've heard it suggested that the snakes were a metaphor for the land working Pagans who were culturally driven to destruction by Christians. But I'm not sure this is evidenced or not

1 Answers 2022-01-18

According to Wikipedia, lobotomies were used to "cure" homosexuality in mid-20th century America. How widespread was this method of conversion therapy? And was there any significant opposition to the practice at the time?

1 Answers 2022-01-18

What is the history of White Women sexually abusing Black Men during slavery?

I'm wondering because I've seen data which shows that Black Americans have over 25% of their White DNA from a White Female Ancestor, which surprised me as I had previously believed that only White Men at the time engaged in sexual abuse against Black Women.

In this case, what was the history of White Women sexually exploiting Black Men during this era?

2 Answers 2022-01-18

In "Band of Brothers", a general reacts increduously that Maj. Winters did not fire his weapon after Holland, including all throughout the Siege of Bastogne. Why did he react this way?

In "Points" (episode 10 of "Band of Brothers"), Maj. Winters is being interviewed by Maj. Gen. Chapman of the 13th Airborne Div. for a potential transfer to the Pacific. While recalling his experiences, Winters mentions that he never fired his weapon again after being promoted to battalion XO. The conversation goes like this (~ 1:30 in the linked video):

W: "I fired my last shots there [Holland]."

C (amazed): "For the whole damn war?"

W: "Yes, sir."

C: "You got through Bastogne without having to fire your weapon?"

W: "That is correct, sir."

C: "And you were on the line the whole time?"

W: "Yes, sir."

C: "Can't imagine a tougher test for a leader. Having to sit through a siege like that -- under those conditions."

W: "We got through it."

The general's reaction has always intrigued me. Was he amazed because of its sheer improbability? Or, as the dialogue suggests, there was a belief that someone of Winters's rank not firing his weapon indicated a higher degree of discipline or skill?

1 Answers 2022-01-18

Why is military history so popular/prominent amongst amateur historians? How does it impact the way academic historians engage with the public?

Large portions of museums and bookstore shelves seem to be filled with military paraphernalia, and catalogues of historical weaponry seem to be disproportionately popular compared to other pieces of material culture. Some of the first books I ever had as a child were books handed down to me by my cousins about Cold War materiel, and I have many memories of visiting the IWM with older family members. The various ways of stabbing, shooting and blowing each other up that we have devised seem to be an "acceptable" interest, while, say, the history of textiles or of gardens would be niche or eccentric. The more I think about it, though, the more bizarre this focus on historical warfare is for a global society that nowadays prides itself on peace. Why is this the case, and how do academics feel about it and work around it?

1 Answers 2022-01-18

(request) where to learn about the civil war?

like podcasts or something

learned about it in high school and university would like to know more

heard a few askhistorian podcasts about it but not enough

2 Answers 2022-01-17

How much did Indian Tribes and Empires in North America know of South America? Were the Iroquois Confederacy aware of the Aztec Empire's existence, if through distant tales such as China and Rome?

1 Answers 2022-01-17

Barbary pirates prowled the English channel for most of the 17th century, abducting English people into slavery and taking them to Tripoli and Algiers. Hundreds were taken. Why couldn't the English Navy put a stop to this?

Rumors held that as many as sixty Barbary men-of-war were actively prowling the English Channel, waiting for the opportunity to capture more product for the slave markets of Algiers and Tripoli. For most of the seventeenth century, an English or Irish family living near the coast confronted the real possibility that the might be hauled off without warning….[the] numbers suggest that the odds of sudden enslavement by Barbary pirates were far higher for the average Devonshire resident than the odds of experiencing a terrorist attack in a modern-day Western City.

From Steven Johnson’s "Enemy of All Mankind."

2 Answers 2022-01-17

When did people begin to understand the idea of differing time zones?

I don't necessarily mean time zones in the modern sense specifically. Presumably humans have known that the sun rises in the east and sets in the west since pre-history. But how long did it take for people to realize that towns to their east would have an earlier sunrise? How well was this understood before the industrial revolution sped up communication?

1 Answers 2022-01-17

Good books about the Khazars?

Can someone recommend a good book about the Khazars for lay people? I know Khazar history is controversial and prone to anti-Semitic abuses, so I want to select what I read carefully.

1 Answers 2022-01-17

What’s wrong with the MAIN causes of WWI?

I am a high school history teacher and we’re about to get into the causes of WWI. I normally stick to the script of militarism, alliances, imperialism, and nationalism as the tinder and the assassination of Franz Ferdinand and the “blank check” as the spark that sets it all off.

However, I’ve seen here and elsewhere some criticism of MAIN. Usually it’s part of a list of flawed or outdated ideas and there isn’t a specific explanation of what the flaws are. Could someone provide an explanation of why this is a flawed way of looking at things?

Also, would it be better to teach the same stuff then do a little critical thinking exercise looking at the potential flaws, or should I throw it out entirely and use a different framework. Remember this all has to be squeezed into about three 45 minute periods!

1 Answers 2022-01-17

Books & readings on vagrancy laws?

As a young adults, I’ve come to realize the taunting from middle to older age people has inexplicable roots in vagrancy laws, which essentially punish existing and not working. While you aren’t likely to be fined or jailed for engaging in leisure on a weekday, you’re still gonna get berated by Boomers.

Feel free to expand on what you know of punishing existing & not working, ie vagrancy.

1 Answers 2022-01-17

Did 19th century European and American naval gunners often have hearing loss from firing cannon? What measures were taken to protect their hearing, if any?

1 Answers 2022-01-17

Was rich popular in Europe from the fall of Rome to 1500, in western/central Europe? And why?

I reallize this is a bit vague time line wise, but as it does grow in the regions, is easy to mill, and doesn't end up with rocks and dirty in it. (because you wash it before use)

I really want to know why it never cough on, or if it did, cant really find more then a few cookbooks, and peasants are almost never written about.

Edit: I meant to say Rice, sorry for the spelling mistake.

1 Answers 2022-01-17

I am a French sergeant in July 1940. The government has fallen, but my squad and I have evaded capture. We want to keep fighting. What do we do?

  1. Can we get to Britain? How?
  2. What will happen when we get there? Will we be integrated into the British army? Broken up? Will we even be allowed to continue fighting?

1 Answers 2022-01-17

How easy was travel in Early Medieval Europe and was it easier for clergy people?

Bede tells us that the cleric Hadrian, who was to become an Abbot of Canterbury, was "by nation an African", and at the Niridian monastery, not far from Naples, prior to being sent by the Pope to Britain (Eccles. 4.1). When he did travel to Britain, he was accompanied by the monk Theodore, "born at Tarsus in Cilicia" (ibid.).

How was it that a man from North Africa found himself in a monastery in Italy, before travelling to Britain with an Anatolian man for company? How well connected was Early Medieval Europe and North Africa? Were these international connections facilitated by the church, or was such long-distance travel available to non-clergy people?

Any sources would be most appreciated.

Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2022-01-17

At what point did unified Castile & Arargon begin to be referred to as "Spain"?

I realize that the Kingdoms weren't officially integrated until the 18th century; that they were instead, held in a personal union up to that point. But I'm curious to now - was the term "Spain" used to describe them prior to that point? Were Isabella and Ferdinand actually ever referred to as the King and Queen of Spain by their contemporaries?

1 Answers 2022-01-17

What are some updated alternatives to Issac Asimov's "Guide to the Bible" suitable for more causal readers that explore the Bible as a historical text through the lens of archeology and anthropology?

Hello /r/AskHistorians,

When I was much younger, I read Issac Asimov's "Guide to the Bible". Even as a youngster, while an interesting read, it seemed like there was a fair bit of speculation going and opinionated, rather than really being a academic work informed by the latest research. After reading it and looking for input on the book, it seemed the academic consensus was the book clearly had some inaccuracies, and should not be considered "very scholarly" even at the time of writing.

I am curious if the folks here at AskHistorians would have any recommend books for interested, but causal, readers for a archeological, anthropological, and sociological informed walk-through of the bible as a historical text. This is something that has been on my list to revisit for a while, but being honest, not something I am looking to dive into with a dense academic text (at least currently).

I know this isn't so much a direct question on history, but rather a question about recommended references or sources and potentially a bit off-topic for the subreddit, but any suggestions, input, or general thoughts on any of the above would be greatly appreciated!

TLDR: What pop-history book would you recommend as an update to Issac Asimov's "Guide to the Bible"

Cheers, Rabbits

Edit: If this is too far off-topic for this subreddit and there is a better place to ask such questions, please just let me know!

4 Answers 2022-01-17

After the fall of the USSR, why have Armenia and Georgia moved towards becoming more democratic compared to their neighbor Azerbaijan, who is one of the most authoritarian countries in the world?

Referring to metrics such as democracy index, and Freedom House Scores.

Does this have a historical explanation? What were their respective governments like pre-Soviet era?

1 Answers 2022-01-17

Is there any truth to the idea that court jesters were uniquely situated to “speaking truth to power”?

I’ve heard this as a concept but have never seen any actual examples. The idea is that, in a monarchy where anyone that displeases the King/Queen can be executed, the court jester is the only one able to explore ideas that others are too afraid to touch. It makes sense that having humor as a tool, and being considered a “fool” so not having all of their words fully scrutinized, would allow them to speak more openly, but are there any documented examples of this happening?

1 Answers 2022-01-17

How did Arab Christians in the 6th century practice Christianity when there were no Arabic translations of the Bible at that time?

1 Answers 2022-01-17

How long have people mistakenly believed that the Norse landed in what is now New England? Why did they believe this?

In the Boston area there are several monuments and/or memorial plaques dedicated to the Norse explorers who supposedly landed or made settlements in New England, from Norumbega Tower to the Leif Eriksson statue in downtown Boston to a commemorative plaque conveniently located right next to where Gerry's Landing would be a few hundred years later. Who put these monuments up? What were they trying to say politically? How did they convince themselves?

1 Answers 2022-01-17

What is the current consensus on recent articles on Anne Frank and how her family were discovered?

Prompted by this article on who may have betrayed Anne Frank and her family. Is this view supported by recent evidence, or is it more a case of speculation and hypothesising picked up by the media?

2 Answers 2022-01-17

What were the factors that allowed the Yakuza of Japan to be a semi legitimate operation as opposed to other organized crime organizations?

1 Answers 2022-01-17

386 / 7255

Back to start