What is the difference between bias and subjectivity in an academic historian setting?

Everything I'm reading about it has a ton of similarities, hard to see the exact difference between the two concepts.

1 Answers 2016-10-25

What is the TRUE story of titanic?

2 Answers 2016-10-25

How Many President's Have Run (Even If Unsuccessfully) For A Third Term?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-10-25

How powerful a position did the bourgeoisie have in 18th century Russia?

The 18th century is generally seen as the point when the bourgeoisie - merchants, craftsmen, middle class - started to assert itself more as a 'bloc' in Europe (and the United States), a 'politically progressive social class' pushing back against more monarchical order, and laying the groundwork for their real explosion onto the scene at the end of the century and into the 19th.

Did Russia undergo a similar progression of the urban bourgeoisie population during that period? The impression of Russia in that period is of a country that was always more oppressive (see: Serfdom), and always a little behind her western neighbors, playing catch-up with the rest of Europe in many ways. So was there the same rising middle class? Did they have similar progressive aspirations? Were they able to influence decisions made in the 'halls of power'?

[18th Century] - [Russia] - [Business]

1 Answers 2016-10-25

Following the abolishment of slavery in the United States in 1865, was there ever any attempt afterwards to reintroduce it?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-10-25

We often hear of "killing the messenger," but how dangerous was it, really, to be a messenger bearing bad news or unwelcome demands in Classical or Medieval Europe/Near East/North Africa?

Was there an unwritten (or written, for that matter) code protecting messengers? Was killing them frowned upon to the point that even absolute rulers or warlords would face some opprobrium? Or was this a job that nobody wanted because it was totally unsafe?

On that last point, a followup: who became messengers, and why? Obviously, there were high-level delegates and envoys, but I'm thinking more of the "little guy," -- some poor schmuck who has to tell Attila that he'd better get out of Roman territory, for example.

3 Answers 2016-10-25

Did the US really topple the democratically elected leader of Iran in 1953?

I'm mostly referencing this article: https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/middle-east/2014-06-16/what-really-happened-iran Are there a lot of flaws to his argument or does he overlook something? Is conventional wisdom really that wrong?

2 Answers 2016-10-25

Why did the city of San Francisco, predominantly known for the counterculture, become home to the tech industry?

1 Answers 2016-10-25

Tuesday Trivia: Graves & Graveyards

From Black Death burial pits to the elegant and macabre transi tombs that thundered home the message of temporality and decay, the way humans treat their dead can often reveal a lot about a culture.

As we approach Halloween, let's talk about the graves and graveyards of the past!

Next week: Making Saints out of Sinners

7 Answers 2016-10-25

Why was the South "weaker" than the North at the start of the Civil War?

My vague uneducated gathering is that at the start of the American Civil War the South was at a considerable disadvantage, was this just due to population? With the south having the slaves they couldn't have been at an economic disadvantage, or was the east coast more prosperous. What exactly was the power difference between the two the day before the Civil War.

1 Answers 2016-10-25

How was the problem of crossing rivers solved in World War 2?

Thinking primarily about the war in the east with all the large rivers like the Volga but also the Rhine.

Were nations capable of building large enough pontoon bridges to sustain offensives and the like?

How important were rivers to the combat in world war 2?

Thank you.

1 Answers 2016-10-25

My late grandfather was a paratrooper in WWII - 101st Airborne Divison ("Screaming Eagles") - Can you tell me more about these items I have from him [link in comments]?

[deleted]

4 Answers 2016-10-25

During the Civil War, the battle for Gettysburg was one of, if not the most difficult battles for both the Union and the Confederacy, but what was the psychological impact to the local community who was left with the aftermath?

Those people were left to clean up everything, I imagine it took generations to overcome the shock. We're talking thousands of dead and dying, not to mention cleaning up the gore. Yikes!

1 Answers 2016-10-25

Do say "a historian" or "an historian"? Why?

1 Answers 2016-10-25

[Military History] I often hear "Most military operations in the high-late medieval period consisted of raids and sieges, not pitched battles" How did raids work?

It's a phrase I often hear, that battles were few. That most conflict consisted of sieges and raids. My question is centered around raids. Since my original perception of medieval warfare comes from games like Total War, I'm biased towards a thinking centered around pitched battles, but I would like to know how raids functioned. How were they different?

  • What kinds of raids were there? Were there regional differences?
  • How did medieval raids function? Was it planned or opportunistic?
  • What was the scale? Was it 30 guys on one small town, or 30 guys spreading out over a large agrarian area?
  • What was the target? Was it always civilians, cattle, etc. or did it focus on directly crippling an enemies military operations?
  • Who participated in these raids? The knightly class only? Serjeants and henchmen? A whole army full of farmers? Mercenaries?
  • Did they use horses? Sword&buckler? Torches? Or weapons which is suited in array, like a spear, pike or halberd?

Frame of the question: An overall ancient or medieval European or Middle-Eastern focus is good. Spain between 1100-1500 is even better.

1 Answers 2016-10-25

What are the best books on the everyday life of individuals in the past?

I'm looking for books that give an insight into what life was like for normal people, over 100 years ago (kind of vague, but I don't mind which time-period/geographic area). Which books/sources can you recommend? I'd like to know what the routine was like, what the social life was like, what they spent their time thinking about, questioning, observing etc.

Thanks!

1 Answers 2016-10-25

When did Russia get all that land, and who had it before?

My understanding of Russian history has a pretty big gap between the early shifting of regional hegemony from Novgorod to Kiev to Muscovy (and even then, quite a pedestrian one at that) to eventual Mongol subjugation, and when they ended up taking over everything they have now. We're they actively sending out explorers and military missions in the 1600's to go subjugate people like the Kazakhs, Siberians, and Mongolians?

1 Answers 2016-10-25

How does the HRE compare to the EU?

1 Answers 2016-10-25

How does one exactly "capture" a city in modern times?

In wars, and in regional conflicts, armies "capture" cities. In the medieval period, or wherever city walls would be common, it's reasonable to quarantine via blocking the main gates. How would this be done in the 20th century, where walls are far less common, how would one go about capturing a city like Mosul (just an example)? One couldn't possibly have the manpower to cover every square inch of space. Are there specific facilities one would have to "secure" in order to obtain possession of a city? I find it hard to conceptualize. I ask here because I presume that the practice has not changed dramatically in the past century. Further, what does "occupying" a city after capture look like, in broad terms?

Is there a checklist for ensuring that the city is now "yours?" Any specific ideas would be very much appreciated.

2 Answers 2016-10-25

When did it become normal in the West to view Islam as a race?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-10-25

I have heard theories from both Americans and Canadians saying either side won the war of 1812. So which country actually won the war of 1812?

1 Answers 2016-10-25

I have read before that the later regime of Ceaușescu made small but gradual efforts to steer Romania from the Soviet bloc, and more under his own personal control. Did Romania have any unique or differing relationship with the USSR, or within the larger Warsaw Pact?

1 Answers 2016-10-25

Was Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart Austrian?

He was born in the Archbishopric of Salzburg, which is nowadays part of Austria and was during his birth part of the HRE and under the influence of Vienna.

Yet you can find many people saying: "technically he wasn't Austrian."

How would historians define his heritage?

Bonus question: If it turns out that Mozart was not Austrian, wouldn't that make Nikola Tesla one?

1 Answers 2016-10-25

Did American subs really commit "war crimes" against Japanese merchant ships in WWII?

This was in an article on the NY Times this morning about AI and the rules of war. http://mobile.nytimes.com/2016/10/26/us/pentagon-artificial-intelligence-terminator.html

Then came the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor on Dec. 7, 1941. That took just six hours for the United States military to disregard decades of legal and ethical norms and order unrestricted submarine warfare against Japan. American submarines went on to devastate Japan’s civilian merchant fleet during World War II, in a campaign that was later acknowledged to be tantamount to a war crime.

I've never heard about this aspect of the Pacific War.

1 Answers 2016-10-25

Why was area around Konigsberg (today's Kaliningrad oblast) taken by USSR and not given to Poland like the rest of Prussia?

1 Answers 2016-10-25

⯇ 3869 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start