Do we have any primary sources that say that Genghis Khan redirected the Oxus River (Amu Darya)?

I've seen on the Wikipedia page for the Amu Darya stating that water was used from the river to flood a city in Khwarezm and that Genghis Khan destroyed a dam on the river. I was just wondering if there were any primary sources associated with this.

1 Answers 2016-10-19

What are the major distinctions between early-war Luftwaffe 'radar guided' night fighting techniques and the later Wilde Sau and Zahme Sau methods?

1 Answers 2016-10-19

If, at the Nuremberg Trials, the vast majority of those put on trial were guilty in the end, then why even have the trials in the first place? Why not automatically execute or perform some other judicial action instead?

2 Answers 2016-10-19

How did Finland manage to avoid becoming a subject to the Soviet Union after the Second World War?

Considering they fought with the Axis, and all other Axis allies in Europe were turned into Soviet puppet states, how did a country which borders the USSR avoid a similar situation?

2 Answers 2016-10-19

Did Native Americans ever discover their own alcoholic drinks?

"Firewater" seems to be one of the biggest blights of historical Native Americans, introduced by European settlers, yet ancient civilizations knew the process of fermenting, how did pre-American cultures not?

2 Answers 2016-10-19

At the siege of Jadotville a force of at least several thousand Katangese troops failed to inflict a single KIA in the defending force of ~150 Irishmen over a five day siege despite their use of their heavy weapons and an airplane. How is that possible?

At Rourke's drift the Zulu's were underarmed compared to the British, so in that case and in other lopsided battles like it, where firepower sits on one side and manpower on the other, the wildly disproportionate casualties make sense. But at Jadotville the Katangese had mortars, and machine guns, and modern rifles, and an airplane. How could they possibly not have overrun the Irish quickly and decisively.

1 Answers 2016-10-19

Why did Manicheanism fail to become a powerful world religion like Christianity or Islam?

1 Answers 2016-10-19

What did an upside down pentagram with the letters "L F A T A" mean when engraved on a gravestone in early 1900's?

http://imgur.com/0UZ0TY0,gDuPrMK,UjIehew

I found this gravestone in Worcester MA, and can't identify the symbol on it. Is it advocated with freemasonry somehow? (I see the Freemason symbol in the other corner of the grave)

4 Answers 2016-10-19

Why did the post-Roman Gothic kings (Visigoths, Ostrogoths, etc) eventually speak Vulgar Latin instead of pushing Germanic onto the population like the Normans did to England?

title pretty much speaks it all.

Why are the Spanish and Italians not speaking descendants of Gothic?

1 Answers 2016-10-19

When did smiling in pictures become the norm?

Just looking at old photos, everyone seems so stiff and almost afraid

1 Answers 2016-10-19

I'm looking for literature on the transition from Japanese occupation to American occupation in the Pacific, post-1945

Hello Historians.

I'm currently a Junior History Major at a great university, and am looking into doing an independent study course in the Spring. The two professors I plan to study under only somewhat fit the criteria of my research, so I was hoping one/some of you might have the knowledge to fill in the gaps!

I am planning to look into the transition from Japanese occupation to American occupation in the Pacific in the 1940's, as well as the process of America returning autonomy to these nations (and attempting to keep US hegemony in the process) over the following decade or so after initial occupation.

I know this is a broad subject and I may need to narrow it down a bit, and I think obtaining texts to read from experts would help narrow that focus down. Anything is welcome from Indonesia, to the Philippines, to Indo-China, to Korea.

I understand the rules state that we can't ask for help with homework, so I hope this doesn't fall under that branch. I am just looking for historical texts, whether primary or secondary sources. You're welcome to add in your thoughts on the subject too, as I love hearing from other minds on the subject, but ultimately my goal here is to obtain the tools to enrich my understanding through my own study.

Thank you so much in advance!

1 Answers 2016-10-19

[META] Can questions that get over 500 upvotes without a sufficient answer be placed in a "popular unanswered questions" section where people can eventually submit answers and approved answers then get posted as an answered question?

15 Answers 2016-10-19

How do the British view British Colonialism?

I grew up in Bangladesh where in school history classes or outside, we've been taught about British India with the an overlying theme that the British colonialism was unambiguously a bad thing and we're all very glad that it's over. I would assume that any country that was once a British colony takes a similar view.

But recently I've been wondering how do the British view their own colonial past? How is this topic taught in British schools? Do you also think that British colonialism was a bad idea, something to be ashamed of? Do think that British rule wasn't that bad and the very negative view of it is a bit unfair? Do you wish that things had gone over a bit better and you still had an overseas empire?

1 Answers 2016-10-19

What Makes a "Good" Historian?

I recently took a tour of Grant's Tomb in NYC. The guide, an NPS ranger, remarked that historians hadn't been kind to Grant's presidency, well into this century -- one indicator being that his tomb focuses almost exclusively on his Civil War service and virtually zero on his two terms as president.

The ranger said Grant deserved better, and hopefully our ideas of him would be improved because the next biography of him was being written by Ron Chernow, author of "Alexander Hamilton." My group nodded their heads and agreed that was "good news" for Grant's memory.

But then I thought...why? I would assume most modern historians would take a sympathetic view of Grant, due to his work against racism, for conservation, etc. Everyone has access to Grant's autobiography and the papers published after his death. Why is Chernow's involvement "good"? Because Chernow is a "good" historian? How so? No one would question the good he did in restoring Hamilton among the Founders...but is that to his credit, or Hamilton's? Or Lin-Manuel Miranda's?

I have nothing against Chernow or Grant (or Hamilton). I just wonder what Chernow's new status means for his works, how we view his works, and our placement of history in context. What if his biography declares Grant was a despicable tyrant? Should we believe him because he was right about Hamilton?

3 Answers 2016-10-19

Celtic music is a popular music genre nowadays. Does the current genre have any relation to the historical music of the Celts or is merely a modern development?

2 Answers 2016-10-19

Is it true that battles were more "humane" in the ancient world? Did the Romans really suffer less/not suffer from PTSD?

I got into an argument with my history teacher earlier this week over whether or not warfare was less horrible in the ancient world. I based my stance on this video while she said that Lloyd's (the man in the video) main point is about PTSD not really being a thing back then isn't valid because of lack of evidence.

Thanks in advance for any responses!

2 Answers 2016-10-19

What was Stalin's opinion on Georgia, his home country? Did he lend favoritism to its' people?

1 Answers 2016-10-19

How different were the lives of people in central Africa (Congo) in 1800 AD from the people of Central Africa in 0 AD

In terms of technology etc.

2 Answers 2016-10-19

Did different cultures independently ascribe value to gold?

Or did the idea of gold having some sort of intrinsic value originate somewhere and spread to other areas of the world?

1 Answers 2016-10-19

Suppose I got either a map and or atlas printed in England in the 1790s, how would the United States be labelled?

1 Answers 2016-10-19

I am writing a research paper on the German invasion and occupation of France during the first world war.

I was wondering if any of you knew of any good primary sources on the subject.

2 Answers 2016-10-19

Besides slavery, what divisive topics was Congress dealing with in the 1850s?

There were a lot of slavery issues then... what states could have slaves, when could slaves be freed, etc. But what else was going on? What were the gay marriage and Obamacare-esque kinds of political stances of the time?

1 Answers 2016-10-19

How come only 13 of the 20 British colonies in America revolt in 1776? What was the situation in the remaining 7 that they decided to stay away from the fight?

1 Answers 2016-10-19

What happened to the various ambassadors and embassies abroad of the various governments that were conquered by the Axis powers?

I am aware that a number of French embassies cooperated with the new Vichy government but what about the countries like Denmark that were occupied but still retained their own governments for a few years? Did they become bases for governments-in-exile, accept the Axis Powers, or just shutdown?

Edit: There has been a great response for the Danes, but anyone else who has information of other embassies for other occupied countries would also be welcome. Thanks!

1 Answers 2016-10-19

Is the theory of Grand Duchy of Lithuania being mainly Belarusian true?

I have heard about the theory of that GDL is actually Belarusian also called "Litvinism" lots of times. I think it is weird,makes as much sense as Finns claiming the Swedish Empire was actually founded by Finns (ofc theres no such theory), nationalistic and i know its not true,but where is the supposed evidence for this theory which says that GDL is actually a Belarusian state....

1 Answers 2016-10-19

⯇ 3882 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start