Theory Thursday | Academic/Professional History Free-for-All

Previous weeks!

This week, ending in September 08 2016:

Today's thread is for open discussion of:

  • History in the academy

  • Historiographical disputes, debates and rivalries

  • Implications of historical theory both abstractly and in application

  • Philosophy of history

  • And so on

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion only of matters like those above, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

2 Answers 2016-09-08

Looking for information on an alleged massacre during the Dutch colonization of Indonesia

When I was on holiday I had a nice discussion with someone from Belgium who mentioned that the Dutch at some point perpetrated something like the Red Wedding from A Song of Ice and Fire, where they invited the leaders of a bunch of communities for some kind of meeting, at which they proceeded to kill them wholesale, ending resistance to their colonization efforts in the region. He called it the "prinsenmoorden" which translates roughly to "murder of princes."

Now, there is a tendency in The Netherlands not to talk too much about our colonial past, so I'm not too surprised I hadn't heard about this before. But I'm having a hard time finding any information about this. Googling "prinsenmoorden" only turns up two links that have nothing to do with this, for instance. Also, the period of colonization of the Dutch East Indies spans hundreds of years, so I have no idea where to start looking. I'm really curious if anything like this happened at all, and if it did, where I can find more information about it.

1 Answers 2016-09-08

I'm a messenger in service to Genghis Khan sent to talk to the leaders of civilizations we plan on conquering. Is there anything I can do or say to prevent the leaders from killing me or am I just doomed to die if the leader has hostile intentions?

4 Answers 2016-09-08

Why the general theme that Germany is a dangerous country in Polandball comics?

I am not too well versed in world history though whenever I read any Polandball comics, they all fear Germany. Quotes like "Germany had fun once, 60 million people died" What are they referring to?

1 Answers 2016-09-08

Before modern nail polish was invented, what did people use to paint their nails?

1 Answers 2016-09-08

What is the effect of Keynesian economic on Britain in the XX century?

Can someone give me an outline of both the positive and negative effects the practice of Keynesian economic on the British economy in the XX century (more focusing on the period after Bretton Woods)?

1 Answers 2016-09-08

The Umayyad Caliphate of Cordoba is said to have been a nation of harmonious multiculturalism and religious tolerance. To what extent was this true and how was it achieved?

2 Answers 2016-09-08

To what extent had the Pre-Columbian Indigenous population altered the landscape that European's later encountered?

The American continents are kind of overwhelmingly large. Considering this, it seems unlikely there was much population pressure akin to what Europe saw. Obviously there were phenomenal large scale settlements and cities built in the Americas as well, but I guess I'm asking in a more meta- sense. Was the 'the New World' mostly trackless wilds, or were there large regions defined by permaculture or cultivation of some kind?

2 Answers 2016-09-08

Ive noticed in several westerns games and movies, ranchers wearing large leather armbands, that I havn't seen on anyone else wear in that setting. Did they have some use on the ranch?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-09-08

How important was the geographical location of the Great Britain in establishing itself as one of the great powers of the world?

1 Answers 2016-09-08

Is Paris of Troy the eponym of Paris, the capital of France?

Are there any connections between the mythical character and the capital of France?

1 Answers 2016-09-08

When did the Allies know about Ribbentrop pact details.

I've read everything I can find but I can't find out when the Allies found out about the parts of the Ribbentrop pact that gave the Soviet Union the eastern part of Poland and a chance to invade Finland. Was that known before 39 or was it realised after the war?

1 Answers 2016-09-08

In old Westerns, there's the town - made of wood - and nothing but scrub and desert all around. So where'd they get all that wood from?

It wasn't from trees, as far as I can see.

1 Answers 2016-09-08

In the near East did the hygienic conditions in large cities improve, worsen or more or less stay the same after Islam started running things mid way through the first millennium?

Places like Babylon or Alexandria always look impressive in illustrations but I have to imagine they smelled of literal shit most of the time. Would early Baghdad or Cairo have been an improvement?

1 Answers 2016-09-08

Did European powers have plans to rally and attack the French Empire before Napoleon's campaign in Russia?

I want to stick to the facts -- what happened that we know of -- but I guess in the back of my mind is a "what if" fallacy: what if Napoleon just stopped all campaigns in 1810 and started consolidating the peace, reopening trade and commerce, etc. Could the French Empire have lasted?

1 Answers 2016-09-08

I heard that the Aztecs thought Teotihuacan was built by the gods. Why were they so ignorant of history compared to China or Europe, which had detailed non-mythical accounts of the first millennium AD?

3 Answers 2016-09-08

On D-Day, why didn't the landing boats just land on the beaches at angle so that nests couldn't pick off troops before they even got off the boat?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-09-08

How many libraries were destroyed during world war 2? How much information is estimated to have been lost, and are there examples of books/records we know existed but no longer have copies of because of the war?

I came across the anecdote of Yuri Knorozolov, one of the major linguists decyphering Mayan script, finding books on Mayan in the Prussian State Library in Berlin while he served in the Red Army during the war. There's some dispute as to how much of the story is exaggerated, but apparently the Prussian State Library is known to have lost a lot of books to Russia?

Are there other examples of libraries that were looted or destroyed, and an estimate on how much material was lost?

edit: And yes, individual library examples are welcome, doesn't have to be a total war estimate.

2 Answers 2016-09-08

How did the British defend Singapore during World War II in the Battle of Singapore, 1942?

Hi, I'm new to this subreddit, and to give some background info I'm a student studying in Singapore and am really interested to find out more about this topic.

During World War II, Singapore was invaded by the Japanese and the British came up to defend Singapore. But the British was easily defeated, and Singapore swiftly became Syonan. So after some history classes and research, I found that the Japanese simply had better strategies of attack than we did to defend. So I want to know, what did the British do to defend us? What troops did they have, what weapons, and why did we lose so quickly? I understand the basic gist of it, but I want to learn a bit more on the subject, plus it would help for school work.

Thanks in advance for anyone who explains how we were defended, and how we were so easily conquered.

2 Answers 2016-09-08

Are there any good books in English about the period between Toyotomi Hideyoshi and the battle of Sekigahara?

I'm really curious to learn more about this period of civil war and what lead to it, socially and politically, but I've been having a tough time finding English resources. The only book I've been able to get my hands on is Samson's A History of Japan 1334-1615. The only problem is it feels like he requires something of familiarity with the subject, as even his account of Go Daigo crams a lot of information into such little space it's easy to get lost.

Are there any equivalents to Adrian Goldsworthy's books on Roman history or Anthony Everitt's Rise of Rome, that combine social and political history as well as explaining military history in a way a complete military idiot can understand?

Thank you so much for your time!

1 Answers 2016-09-08

During the Cold War, Americans referred to their Soviet counterparts as "Ruskies" or "Commies." What pejorative terms were used for Americans in the Soviet Union?

1 Answers 2016-09-08

How do I find someone that vanished from the history books? Can I even do it?

I need help, I'm writing a book on Jack The Ripper and one of the suspects, one Dr. Francis Tumblety seems to straight up disappear after he leaves England and goes to America to evade arrest, all I can find is that he went to Rochester, then to according to the 1900 census Baltimore, then to St. Louis where he died in 1903. What can I do to find out what happened to him between 1888 and 1903? If five murders can happen in under four months a lot can happen in fifteen years. So how do I find out, if I even can.

2 Answers 2016-09-08

Spanish plans for conquest into SE Asia and China.

so I found out from a historian friend of mine that Spain had a gameplan for chine and SE Asia. what were the broad plan for spain's plans to conquer china and SE Asia after getting to the California coast?

1 Answers 2016-09-08

18th century Prussians firing 6 times per minute. Was that even possible?

From William Muller's The Elements of the Science of War (1811)

§ 774. On the Quickness of the Fire.

  1. Experience has shewn that with common small arms eleven seconds are necessary to load, and with firelocks with cylindrical or equally thick ramrods, and where the powder falls by itself, through the vent from eight to nine seconds.

  2. Consequently a body of men with common firelocks may fire 4,5 times, and with such as are provided with cylindrical ramrods five or six times per minute; but as accidents will often occur to render such expeditious firing impracticable, four or five times per minute is the quickest that can be expected from common guns.

It doesn't seem like he's using an tricks like Sharpe's "tap-loading". Was six shots in a minute actually possible for 18th century infantry? Was it even possible for most infantry to reload in 12 seconds?

1 Answers 2016-09-08

In the near East did the hygienic conditions in large cities improve, worsen or more or less stay the same after Islam started running things mid way through the first millennium?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-09-08

⯇ 3978 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start