Was Guan Yu actually a capable military general during the Three Kingdoms Period?

Historically speaking, he seems to have suffered more losses than victories and many of his legendary feats were actually fictional. I understand that he is worshipped as a deity more so for his loyalty than his might but I want to know why he was feared on the battlefield.

1 Answers 2016-07-22

A query about Presidents of the United States and their personal sex life.

Back in the day, I remember reading a random article about Presidents and their sexual practices and affairs. It talked about which ones were single, married, had known mistresses, if they paid child support, and if they had illegitimate children. I am pretty sure I read about all of this during the whole Clinton affair ordeal.

I also remember reading something about one or two U.S. Presidents who may have been gay or Bi.

The first major big deal about a President and their sex life that immediately comes to my mind is JFK, but nothing really before that.

  • Was a President's sex life always a big deal for their political career??
  • Was there a major shift in history when people actually started paying attention to Presidents and their sexual practices??
  • Were the ones who had illegitimate children always frowned upon??
  • Have there been any Presidents who had to pay child support before, during, or after their time in office??
  • Any married Presidents known to have open relationships (I kinda think Hilary and Bill Clinton possibly have one)??
  • Any Presidents who were possibly gay, bi, or asexual??
  • Why is a married President more preferable than a President who is single?? (Is there a historical reason??)

Sorry for the long list of questions but a recent debate I had got me thinking about all of this. I also don't expect all the questions answered, just any information provided would be awesome. Thanks!!

1 Answers 2016-07-22

Is it feasible that the split between Daco-Romanian and Aromanian occurred as a result of the territorial losses and subsequent fall of the Second Bulgarian Tsardom?

To me it seems that given the territorial extent of the Second Bulgarian Tsardom from the Adriatic Sea to the Danube and beyond, it should've acted as a bridge between the eastern, (mostly?) north-danubian Vlachs and the south-western, south-danubian Vlachs, thus facilitating contact and communication between the early Eastern Romance speakers rather than inhibiting it.

Would this be a pertinent hypothesis or does the lack of as many slavonisms in modern Aromanian discard it from get-go?

1 Answers 2016-07-22

Social and political upheaval in the period 1895-1925

A guest on Charlie Rose last night suggested that we are currently experiencing a period of social and political upheaval similar to the period between 1895-1925 in US history. I only have the barest of historical knowledge of that period but will be researching it in greater detail and thought I might start here with suggestions on books to read. I guess I should first ask, does anyone agree with this comparison?

1 Answers 2016-07-22

How did Germany become richer than any other European country?

[deleted]

2 Answers 2016-07-22

If the American Northeast is called New England, why isn't the Midwest called New France and the Southwest New Spain?

2 Answers 2016-07-22

What was the prevalence and significance of Nazi sympathizers in Allied countries before, during, and after World War II?

What was the prevalence and significance of Nazi sympathizers in Allied countries before, during, and after World War II?

1 Answers 2016-07-22

Why do people from the 20s and 40s have such different faces?

Photos of 20s movie stars, particularly the actresses, look markedly different from their 40s-on equivalents. Their faces are rounder and the noses are also different. Is this just what was in fashion?

1 Answers 2016-07-22

Besides Judaism and Christianity, were there any cults or religions in ancient Rome that would be considered monotheistic by the modern definition?

2 Answers 2016-07-22

Did any primary source documents survive from ancient greece/rome? How do we know so much about the intricacies of their politics, history, philosophy and mythology, or know what we "know" is actually true?

2 Answers 2016-07-22

How did the Dutch manage to finance a colonial empire?

The Spanish (who the Dutch broke away from) already had a pretty large and prosperous colonial holding in America, how did the Dutch manage to colonize part of America (especially the prosperous sugar islands) while being a relatively new and geographically small nation? I know some small nations also had some colonies in America, like the Prussian/Curonian colonies, but they were under the protection of the Poland-Lithuania. What allowed the Dutch to set up shop in America, Africa and Asia despite being so small?

1 Answers 2016-07-22

What was Napoleon's experience of the Terror? How dangerous was it for him?

1 Answers 2016-07-22

How have US soda companies been able to get the buying public to adopt the metric system based 2 liter bottle as the standard unit of liquid, but most all other products and services cannot?

I initially thought some one might have answered this question in the past, but in looking through my search results and the FAQ, I did not seem to find one.

If you walk in to any grocery, pharmacy, or convenience store today; you will find smaller bottles of soda in 12, 16, and 20 oz. However, once you go above 20 oz you are met with the ubiquitous 2-liter, the rarer 3-liter, and the and upcoming 1 and 1 1/2 liter bottles. These metric-based bottle sizes with the small exception of certain liquor bottle standards (250 ml, 750 ml, 1500 ml) stand in stark contrast to nearly every other beverage type (milk, orange juice) that get measured in ounces, pints, quarts, and gallons and of course all food-based product measurement sizes - a cup, ounces, etc.

So how did we get here?

  • How were US soda companies and botttlers (and to a lesser extent liquor companies) able to convince the buying public to accept these sizes in a metric standard when all other food and beverages sold in the US come in non-metric sizes?
  • How long was it before these became as ubiquitous as they are today?
  • Was there any push back from distributors and the buying public to these metric-based sizes when they first made it to market?

1 Answers 2016-07-22

How were Japanese Empresses picked? Did the Emperors have a select group of women to choose from? Were there attempts to marry into the Imperial line?

Reading about Shoguns always makes me think that there was a vast opportunity missed to try and make a descendant of yours the Emperor, i.e. by marrying your daughter to a young Emperor or his heir, and bam, having an Imperial descendant, possibly in your lifetime.

But as far as I can tell, that didn't seem to happen. Am I misinformed? Were there any Japanese Lannisters/Tudors who tried this sort of plan? If not, why? How did the Japanese pick their Empresses?

1 Answers 2016-07-22

How do historians do research in languages other than their own?

A question was asked recently about the Iranian/Persian famine that happened during World War I. I imagine that the vast majority of the scholarship and primary sources on this period are in Farsi. If a historian is interested in this event, how do they go about researching it, short of learning Farsi and going to Iran to study?

2 Answers 2016-07-22

On D-Day, were soldiers actually gunned-down as soon as the landing craft ramp dropped, or is it an inaccuracy portrayed in movies?

I think everyone knows this scene from Saving Private Ryan where the landing craft ramp drops but German machine guns instantly kill everyone in the craft. However, I've done a bit of reading about D-Day and learned how the beaches were several hundred yards long, meaning that fire would only be so accurate from the prepared defenses.

As well, I watched a video recently claiming that the German MG 42 and 34 were relatively inaccurate weapons, even to the point that a man could be almost entirely safe when laying down at a distance of 100 yards from a given machine gun emplacement. So, I'm wondering if the portrayal of the landing scenes in Saving Private Ryan (among many other movies) is wrong, or if the German machine gun emplacements were accurate enough to kill everyone in the landing craft as the ramp dropped.

2 Answers 2016-07-22

Saxons v Vikings

What is the general difference between the original Germanic Saxons from Denmark prior to the 5th century AD, and the Vikings? I believe the Saxons and the Angles both co-inhabited Denmark before they invaded the Roman-abandoned British lands. I also believe that the Vikings, also a Germanic people, inhabited Denmark as well. It is a fact that not all Saxons left for England. In fact, the majority remained in Denmark. Understanding this, did the Germanic Saxons and the Vikings coexist in the same country? Did one beget the other? If they both supposedly originated from the same place, how did they come to be completely different peoples?

1 Answers 2016-07-22

To produce the amphora used during the Roman Empire, how much wood was required? What scale was the resulting deforestation?

1 Answers 2016-07-22

Are there any European landed families we know of who originated as descendants of a Roman veteran who was given a plot of land for his service?

As far as I know, that's a prime reason that so many barbarians served in the Roman army toward the end of the western empire, was the guarantee of a plot of land to work and own.

2 Answers 2016-07-21

Is there a good, free, online source for 18th Century (American Revolution era) newspapers from throughout the British Empire?

Maybe I'm using Google's news archive incorrectly, but I'm only finding things like the Virginia Gazette, Providence Gazette, and American Journal. That's fine, but I'm looking for another side of the story.

1 Answers 2016-07-21

There have been over 2000 nuclear weapons tests, why were there so many?

I get the testing of new technology, bomb types, designs, etc., but this seems like a unnecessarily high number of tests. Was it a giant dick waving competition or were there legitimate reasons to need to test thousands of bombs?

1 Answers 2016-07-21

After the Battle of France in WWII, did the victorious Germans appropriate the captured tanks, planes and equipment?

1 Answers 2016-07-21

why do we praise the Templar Knights?

Aren't they the equivalent of modern day terrorists? Marching to foreign lands to kill the infidels and non-believers?

1 Answers 2016-07-21

Aztec Nobility - Did it exist, and how did it work?

1 Answers 2016-07-21

Why did the Confederacy fire first on Fort Sumter? Who made the decision and why?

From a number as sources I’ve read it seems as though both sides were waiting for the other to do something for a while beforehand, and also that if they had not fired it might have been possible to negotiate leaving the Union.

1 Answers 2016-07-21

⯇ 4100 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start