Founding of Rome: What other legends are there besides the Romulus tale.

While reading about stories of the founding of Rome, Romulus brothers tale seems to be the most well known one. However, I did also see that apparently some other minor stories/sources are out there, too. I'm just wondering what they are... or is there any other at all?

1 Answers 2016-05-24

Why did the Romans didn't adopt the linothorax?

In my limited but enthusiast understanding of the classical era I think the linothorax came to be very popular with the later Greeks. From a video I saw on YouTube of a professor with some students testing it, it seemed to pretty sturdy and could withstand arrows at close range while being light and cooler on hot climates like the ones in southern European. So, why did the Romans, that were so good at adopting innovations of their enemies (or by the way any later infantry armies) didn't used it? Or did they?

1 Answers 2016-05-24

Could you recommend sources with information about cultural conceptions of time in post-World War II America?

I've just begun reading Stephen Kern's The Culture of Time and Space, 1880–1918. I am interested in related sources that address more recent history, particularly in the United States.

I am especially curious about the impact the internet has had on our understandings or perceptions of time. Thank you!

1 Answers 2016-05-24

When did shields fall out of favor in medieval armies?

In both video games and in movies, ancient and early medieval soldiers are depicted carrying shields into battle. However, by the time of the renaissance and early modern periods, they are hardly ever seen. When did they lose their popularity and why?

1 Answers 2016-05-24

I've heard that the mobilization of the country and the transition to a war economy at the outbreak of WWII is what ended the Great Depression, how much truth is there to that?

2 Answers 2016-05-24

What motivated soldiers and officers to keep fighting in the First World War ?

Fear and duty, I presume, but surely there must have been more to it.

1 Answers 2016-05-24

What knowledge did Sacagawea posses that would make Lewis & Clark hire a pregnant woman as their guide?

1 Answers 2016-05-24

Any films you can recommend detailing the lives of women of Louis XIV's royal court?

Documentaries, even fiction about women as long as some element is factual (duties, wardrobe, portrayal of peripheral characters who really lived). A very preliminary search ended with my watching Valert recently, but it was pretty unsatisfying...

I'll also accept suggestions for films detailing any member of the court.

2 Answers 2016-05-24

Question about some books about the Early Modern Period

As with my last post, I've been trying to study certain centuries. No one had any real recommendations for me. I thought trying to study historical periods would be the better thing to do, since it fits more academia's terms. This is one book I found in relation this

http://www.amazon.com/dp/0198207603/ref=wl_it_dp_o_pC_S_ttl?_encoding=UTF8&colid=2FQVU2B66T4AU&coliid=I33FUAEONKTT8X

This is the book I'm interested in. It seems to cover the centuries I'm interested. I'm not sure if this is an academic work or what have you. Just'd like some feedback on whether this would be a good book

4 Answers 2016-05-24

Has there ever been a push to ban libraries by the book publishing industry?

It would seem that it would be in the interest of book publishers to push for the illegalization of libraries since it appears to harm book sales. After all, instead of purchasing every book I read, I can just go to the library and borrow the books from there. Has there ever been a push to ban libraries by the book publishing industry?

1 Answers 2016-05-24

Why were there no germanic cities in central europe, before the early middle ages?

And why did it only begin in the middle ages?

1 Answers 2016-05-24

What were some *actual* turning points of WW2?

I'm not talking about general things like the Germans not being able to fully invade Moscow/Russia and then failing during the winter, I'm thinking more about actual, single operations that had a massive impact about the war, which people might not know.

Just as some examples, I'm thinking about the arctic convoy of Great Britain (with the help of the US) for Russia. Or the fact that Göring decided to put the Bf109's to Africa where they were inferior towards the British planes and meanwhile the newer, more agile FW190 were destroying the Russian planes right and left with no problem.

I hope my question is clear enoug; English not being my native language it feels a bit hard for me to properly formulate what I mean.

1 Answers 2016-05-24

Stand up and be counted! It's AskHistorians' fourth census!

Gather round the spring bonfires, for an ancient rite of our people has gone unobserved for too long, and now we need your help to bring it back... We last took a census in October 2014, and that means the group portrait of you, dear readers, is now 18 months and 150,000 subscribers out of date! And the mods love you and want your picture on the break room fridge. So please help us get to know you!

#Please click here to take the census!

Edit 2: turned it off to responses after two days, thanks to everyone who participated and we hope to get the analysis posted in July!

Edit: The location question has all the countries in a pull down and sucks to scroll through on mobile. If you can do the survey on a keyboard please save yourself, otherwise skip that question if you don't want to deal with it, it's optional. And by popular request from last census we'll be leaving this open to responses for 48 hours this time.

Unconvinced? Reasons you should take this survey:

  1. It is timed to take you less than five minutes! There’s pretty much nothing else you can do in this subreddit in that time and not get deleted.
  2. Absolute lowest-effort way you can improve the subreddit.
  3. Only 8 questions are required, but there are also lots of optional text boxes and mods will read all your opinions. We use this information to see what needs to be changed, or what things should focus on. We also use the demographic data to answer questions about the sub from the media.
  4. Analysis and results will be posted in the subreddit!
  5. We can see how much we’ve changed (or not changed) with our growth
  6. It’s anonymous, you can tell the mods how much you love us without feeling embarrassed (meaning there are questions about moderation quality and style and we’d appreciate sincere feedback)
  7. You don’t need to be a regular reader or poster to participate, the opinions of lurkers and casual readers are especially wanted!

After you take the survey and are waiting to see the details you can whet your appetite with the previous census results.

If anything is confusing or broken please let me know in the comments!

19 Answers 2016-05-24

Did Nazi Germany ever have even somewhat serious plans for a jetliner?

As above. The core of the Comet was essentially a wartime design and there were some (admittedly sketchy) ideas floating around for pretty large jet bombers, but has anyone come across what a nazi jetliner might have looked like?

1 Answers 2016-05-24

How did postwar U.S. Presidents feel meeting Emperor Shōwa (Hirohito) during their terms?

I know that Ford in particular had seen combat in the Pacific. How did presidents feel meeting somebody that many of them had been taught to hate? Was there animosity, tension, or was this left in the past in the name of diplomacy and to save face?

2 Answers 2016-05-24

What is the most accurate account of the Spanish Civil War?

I've just finished Noam Chomsky's "On Anarchism" which has a lot of historical information about Catalunya's collectives, anarchism and syndicalism. I've heard Gabriel Jackson's "The Spanish Republic and the Civil War, 1931-39" is a good account but Chomsky and George Orwell in his "Homage to Catalonia" disagree with a lot of the points Jackson makes or the points he brushes over as not that important. Having not read Jackson, I can't compare, but I would like to read the best and accurate account of the Civil War. (In English)

1 Answers 2016-05-24

In the contingency plans prepared for the possible showdown between the Warsaw Pact and NATO during the Cold War, what role was delegated to the Norwegian military? What were they supposed to be doing?

Bonus question: What sort of plans did Sweden have in place for this eventuality? Although they were a neutral power, I can't help but assume that push-come-to-shove, they would have been inclined to throw their lot in with the West, so was there any secret policy discussions on that matter?

[1970s - Scandanavia - Battle]

1 Answers 2016-05-24

Was Sparta really the ultra-militaristic city that we always see it depicted as?

Life in Sparta seems like something out of a fantasy book rather than a real ancient civilization, and I feel as though such a state could never exist (or at least, couldn't exist for as long as Sparta did), even in modern times.

3 Answers 2016-05-24

Book - A peace to end all peace by David Fromkin

Friends,

Hello. Has anyone read this book. Wanted to know if its suitable for a beginner / easy to read. Thanks a lot.

Sid

1 Answers 2016-05-24

Why were cavalry forces (seemingly) always so small in Classical Greek armies? Wouldn't the inflexible hoplite phalanx be incredibly vulnerable to flanking movements from cavalry?

Looking at many battles from the Peloponnesian War and earlier, cavalry forces often seem to be of token size, if even present at all. My thinking is that the wealthy citizens of many Greek cities certainly had enough money to outfit themselves as cavalrymen, so why didn't the Greeks take advantage of what could have been a vital asset on the battlefield?

2 Answers 2016-05-24

Review of 'Napoleon and the Struggle for Germany' by Michael V. Leggiere

Hi all, I was just hoping of a quick review on this book, by those who have a focus on this area and have read it. Thanks

1 Answers 2016-05-24

Tuesday Trivia | Memorials and Remembrances

Previous weeks' Tuesday Trivias and the complete upcoming schedule.

Today's trivia theme comes to us from /u/sunagainstgold!

What does it mean to remember, and how do different cultures go about it? Please share any examples of how history is remembered through history, from the tangible (like Memorial Stadiums) to the intangible (like federal holidays coming up on Monday.)

Next week on Tuesday Trivia: Some people are rather ahead of their time (as we say), but some other people are just right for their time... We'll be contrasting historical idealists and realists!

9 Answers 2016-05-24

What have been the corruption levels in the United States been since its founding?

For example, people in other countries pay bribes daily. Were there ever times in the US where this was a norm also?

Edit: If you only have knowledge on a certain period I would welcome that information as well.

1 Answers 2016-05-24

Did Sophanes, the Athenian soldier who carried an anchir into battle with him, really exist? Or was he just a legend?

Herodetus reports of an Athenian soldier called Sophanes who carried an anchor with him into battle so that when it came time to fight he could drop the anchor and prevent himself from fleeing.

Do we know anymore about this guy, if he was real or just a legend that Herodetus had been told?

Edit: Sorry about typo in title

1 Answers 2016-05-24

What were the consequences of Athens’ decisions, and how did their downfall effect Greece and ultimately leave it open for Phillip II to conquer.

What I am really curious about is, well mainly what allowed Phillip II to come into Greece, and conquer what was almost a unified force, prior to the collapse of the Delian League. (Also apologies if my question is poorly informed, I am recently interested in ancient Greek history and this is what I have kind f pieced together)

1 Answers 2016-05-24

4246 / 7255

Back to start