What are the historical origins of the principle that defendants do not have to testify against themselves in criminal trials?

I'm asking this question in the context of the Jian Ghomeshi sexual assault trial here in Canada. Many critics of yesterday's decision are outraged that he was not forced to testify during the trial, while the complainants were subjected to withering cross-examination. I know that this is a long standing principle in British common law (the Fifth Amendment of the US Constitution stipulates that no person "shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself"), but where does it come from? Does it have its roots in the Magna Carta or does it have a more recent origin? Were there particular trials in which this principle was established?

2 Answers 2016-03-25

Egyptian Religious History

How did Egyptian culture/religion transform from pyramids and polytheism to Islam?

1 Answers 2016-03-25

Question on Public Perception

Why are the Nazi's (and by association Hitler) thought of as a military juggernaut. Why does the general public think Hitler was one misstep away from world domination? I could kinda get the second misconception, about Nazi world domination. That can be attributed to Allied propaganda. However Nazi 'military superiority' is mainly a by product of luck. Why do people glorify Nazi military conquests?

1 Answers 2016-03-25

How were the female-organized Mantua Makers Guild able to survive prosecution in London and Paris?

2 Answers 2016-03-25

When did St Peter's cross become a symbol of Satanism/evil?

1 Answers 2016-03-25

How was the Ancient Egyptian Pharaoh's claim to divinity perceived by other ancient civilizations?

Did regional powers like the Mittani or Hittites address the Pharaoh's divine status? Were city states that paid tribute to Egypt more likely to see the King as a god?

1 Answers 2016-03-25

Disregarding their moral bankruptcy, have policies of targeted marginalization, genocide, denial of education, etc been successful in achieving their ends?

This question came to my mind while reading a recent post in a thread about the WWII IMT that mentions the Soviet liquidation of Polish POWs with the intent of killing off potential political enemies. Have such brutalities been "good policy" from a perspective of politics, power, cultural identity, etc? Obviously not morally good, but successful in a realpolitik sense.

As this subreddit frowns on "throughout history" and "throughout the world" questions, I'll tentatively ask about 20th century eastern and central Europe, but if any of you historians can speak to other times/places I'd love to read your answers too (e.g. Assyrian resettlement, Sparta's helots, ethnic strife over territory in Japan, etc).

And just to at least try to head off inappropriate posting, please remember THE RULES, especially "We will not tolerate racism, sexism, or any other forms of bigotry," the violation of which is a FIRST-OFFENSE BAN in this subreddit, and the "no soapboxing" rule. Do not post unless you are a qualified historian!

1 Answers 2016-03-25

IRA and the Anglo-Irish Treaty

After reading a little I saw that some members of the IRA opposed the Anglo-Irish treaty of 1921. However it didn't mention why they opposed it. So I was just wondering why they would oppose the treaty to make Ireland independent? Isn't that what they were fighting for?

1 Answers 2016-03-25

Could you possibly recommend some good books about Lithuania, Ukraine, and Byelorus?

I'm studying Eastern European History and although I have searched for a long time I have found few (namely Magosci's History of Ukraine, and Bazan's History of Belarus). I am looking again, but I was wondering if there was anyone here who could recommend some good ones? I'm looking specifically from 700-1800. Thank you all. I am especially interested in a history of Lithuania because I can't seem to find one outside of Lithuania Ascending.

2 Answers 2016-03-25

Concerning WWII Propaganda telling people to keep their mouth shut...

I see a lot of that in the WWII Allied propaganda posters. And I understand why ranking officials should obey this, but these posters were distributed to the general public. So my question is why? What exactly did the average person know that would help the Axis powers?

3 Answers 2016-03-25

Did nobles/people living in 8th-10th century England consider themselves simultaneously Angle and Saxon? Was the idea of Anglo-Saxon developed by then?

Part of me wonders why, for example, Alfred, a Saxon king, desired to unite the realms into a kingdom named for the Angles (England).

1 Answers 2016-03-25

Has anyone heard of the pigment Prismatic Lead White, invented circa 1850s?

Hello! I am in the middle a research Project studying Prismatic Lead White, a type of lead white that presumably appeared during the 1850s. In dispersion and observed with Polarised Light Microscopy, it produced characteristic little prisms. It was apparently a pigment used by Turner. Lead white has been used since the Antiquity and we tend to overlook it in painted works, but this particular one appeared later and can help us date paintings as well as detect forgeries. See: http://www.npg.org.uk/research/programmes/making-art-in-tudor-britain/case-studies/matb-case-study-5.php At the moment, I am having difficulty researching on it as I do not know the name under which it was sold at the time. Definitely not Prismatic Lead White! Getting a name for it would help me search for the manufacture process and understand in what aspect(s) it is different from lead white. If you have the slightest idea, I would be happy to hear it. Cheers :)

2 Answers 2016-03-25

How much do we know about ancient workouts? How did ancient athletes and soldiers train?

How accurate are the marble depictions of those chiseled (pun intended) Greek dudes?

1 Answers 2016-03-25

What do historians think about the assasination of John F. Kennedy?

Is the "mainstream" explanation that the murder was done by one man alone accepted as the most true explanation by real historians?

edit: I accidentally a word

1 Answers 2016-03-25

Why didn't Europe come to the aid of Byzantium?

I know Genoa and venice sent aid but not much. I mean i would think the catholic world would have sent huge aid in defense of a once powerful ally. Honestly it seems like they were betrayed by Europe. I sometimes like to imagine how different the region would be if a crusade was sent and the ottomans were pushed back.

2 Answers 2016-03-25

Were there ever slaves who supported slavery?

First time poster (also not a historian, just a curious redditor).

This may be the stupidest question, but I'm curious whether there were any slaves who supported the enslavement of their people. I ask because in the USA's presidential election we have people of all races supporting Donald Trump for president despite making some rather nasty and racist remarks. This lead me to wonder if there have ever been slaves or people of traditionally enslaved races who supported the enslavement of their people, from any point in time. Please let me know if I can clarify my question in any way, and thank you in advance for your answers!

1 Answers 2016-03-25

In 18th century, to the early 19th century warfare, why was ripple fire or the fire at will command sometimes used over volley fire?

Volley fire may not kill as many men as fire at will as the men when given the fire at will command are firing as fast as they can, but volley fire is way more damaging to morale. This is because of the loud sound created from thousands of men firing at the same time, and hundreds of men falling all around you. Also the British were famous for the fire by ranks tactic which allowed multiple lines to be positioned in front of each other and avoid friendly fire while increasing your fire power. So I was wondering why ripple fire, or fire at will would be used over such tactics? I understand the Austrians were not as well drilled or disciplined so they scrapped volley fire and fire by ranks for the most part, but why would someone decide to use fire at will or ripple fire over volley fire assuming the men are well enough drilled to do so?

2 Answers 2016-03-25

Why was "Me ne frego" ("I don't care") chosen by Mussolini as one of his mottoes?

I know that italian Fascism put a strong emphasis on that "machismo" kind of attitude, but being a totalitarian state, wouldn't that phrase go against the idea of the citizen being continuously involved in activities organized by the party (and therefore sort of "caring" about the fascist party)?

1 Answers 2016-03-25

Friday Free-for-All | March 25, 2016

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

13 Answers 2016-03-25

Who is this person ?

http://postimg.org/image/8pdtx7j39/

1 Answers 2016-03-25

How were large exotic animals caught and transferred to rich collectors before tranquilizers?

Like the collectors mentioned in the thread about Lions in Northern Europe.

1 Answers 2016-03-25

Did this ever happen? [Investigating a meme]

Did something like this really happen? Is the claim that Muslims stopped kidnapping Russians as a result accurate?

http://imgur.com/aEi6ZHb

Edit: ty for imgur link /u/cfx99

1 Answers 2016-03-25

[META] /r/Askhistorians needs you! Apply for a flair today!

Join the AH Community! Apply for a Flair today!

AskHistorians needs you! Heed the call of your favorite internet community and apply for a flair today!

You enjoy history? You enjoy quality? You think it is fun to dig up information and give informative, in-depth, and comprehensive, and awesome answers to all the interested inquirers, engrossed examiners, and inquisitive investigators of history? If your answer is "well, paint me green and call me a cucumber, jolly gosh I do!", then join the internet community dedicated to exactly these tasks and apply to be a flaired user in the AskHistorians community!

"But wait", we hear you say, "what exact advantages does having a flair have for me exactly, exactly?" To which we'll reply: "No need to be a skeptical Sally or doubtful Danny, just hear us out!"

Flairs on AskHistorians are given to users, who have:

  • Expertise in an area of history, typically from either degree-level academic experience or an equivalent amount of self-study.

  • The ability to cite sources from specialist literature for any claims you make within your area.

  • The ability to provide high quality answers in the subreddit in accordance with our rules.

Having a flair here is the community acknowledgement that you are an expert in your field. And who doesn't like to be recognized as an expert? It's like receiving a medal for all the hard work you put into reading up on and studying a topic.

Also, being a flaired user holds so many more advantages, it is hard to even write them all down but here are just a few:

I mean just look at that nice flair next to my name. It looks great, doesn't it. You want one too.

  • It'll make you part of the best group of individuals on the whole internet.

Being flaired is not just a nice bit of text to your name. It'll also further involve you in the community. That ranges from organizing AMAs with others, to giving input on our Monday Method topics, to generally being able to exchanges views, news, and research with the greatest group of historians you'll find anywhere, ever.

  • Improving the community

As a flaired user, you'll be also able to become even more active in improving the quality of the sub. Flaired users can for example edit the wiki to add all the awesome stuff they and others write, add their favorite books to the list and so on. Also, you will be called upon to help out the tireless protectors of quality that is we, the mods.

Flairs will give your high quality answers further visibility. And increased visibility gives increased Karma. You know it, we know it. It's why reddit tells us we are here, after all.

"You got me fully convinced", we hear you say, "I want it. Shut up and take my application already!"

To apply for a flair right now, head to our PANEL OF HISTORIANS XI thread

There we need you to post

  • Links to 3-5 comments in /r/AskHistorians that show you meet the above requirements, and of which at least three were posted in the last six months.

  • The text of your flair and which category it belongs in (see the sidebar). Be as specific as possible as we prefer flair to reflect the exact area of your expertise as near as possible, but be aware there is a limit of 64 characters.

If you have all that - and abided by our expected behavior rule for flairs - go ahead and post your application right now!

If your find yourself thinking "Well, I do have expertise and want a flair but I don't have the answers yet and I am unsure how to best approach this..." Don't despair! As always, our wiki holds the answer! Just consult our handy guide for getting a flair!

Also, never ever hesitate to contact your friendly neighborhood moderators (that's us!) for pointers and help on providing great answers and getting a flair.

On this last point, also a special PUBLIC SERVICE ANNOUNCEMENT:

We love our blue, red and dark green guys, gals, and peeps in between.

But we also really, really want to see some new people in the the other colors like

  • our stylish shades of green for Africa and the Middle East;

  • beautiful beige for Asia and India;

  • the awesomeness that is this Pacific blue for Oceania;

  • the various varieties of white that we offer for History of Religion and the wonderfully descriptive Other;

  • fashionable rose for all the awesome Art History people out there;

  • the jazzy yellow for those interested in Middle and South American History;

  • and last but of course not least, those taking the black with Archaeology and sleek grey of History of Science and Technology.

If you are an expert in one of these areas, especially Africa, India, or Oceania and you want us to see us overjoyed like this, send us a message right now! Some areas sometimes lack the questions for experts of certain fields to amass the answers necessary for a flair but it has been known that certain forces somewhere can sometimes make questions appear that provide opportunities for those with underrepresented fields to share their knowledge...

So to all you great historians, academic and self taught, out there: Hear the call of your community! Apply for a flair!

See you in the Flair thread, you group of talented, smart, and handsome individuals!

48 Answers 2016-03-25

In "Treatises on Friendship and Old Age" by Cicero, Laelius says: "For I am not one of these modern philosophers who maintain that our souls perish with our bodies, and that death ends all." Do we know who is this referring to?

2 Answers 2016-03-25

Why were ethnic Hungarians expelled from post-war Czechoslovakia?

Were there historic tensions among the Czechs, Slovaks and Magyar peoples? How were the expellees accepted and integrated into Hungarian society?

2 Answers 2016-03-25

4413 / 7255

Back to start