I'm currently reading Strategy: A History, by Lawrence Freedman and I'd like to get a better idea of how some of these generals being discussed actually acted during a battle.
I recently read a passage about Napoleon in the battle before taking Moscow not spending much time "on the lines", but I feel unable to understand how involved he would have been in other battles.
If anyone could provide context (links or thoughts) about how generals like: Napoleon, Alexander, Khan, Xerxes, Pericles, Caesar, etc... might have acted during the battle I'd appreciate it.
I'm a Marine combat veteran from Afghanistan, so I have an okay understanding of how generalship and battlefield command works in a modern military, but not in these historic periods.
4 Answers 2016-03-21
1 Answers 2016-03-21
Often called their own little Vietnam type of war, what kind of operations was a common soldier expected to partake in? Were they doing the same kind of counter-insurgency ops we did against the Vietcong? Were they really prepared at all to deal with that kind of enemy?
How did most soldiers feel about the war themselves? What was morale like? Those kinds of things. In a nutshell, I guess what I'm asking is if someone could provide a sort of picture for me showing what it'd look like had I been alive and old enough for service at the time, as I do understand conscription was fairly common in the USSR (or was it required completely)?
1 Answers 2016-03-21
I was recently told that copper from North America (especially the current Upper Peninsula of Michigan) was important in the bronze of the early Bronze Age of east Asia. I have been unable to google such a theory. Is there any suggestion that this could have been the case? Is there any history of trade between the two areas at all?
Edit: I have found one source (a guy called Graham Hancock) who claims that this is the case, I am unable to find anything that substantiates this, nor is my chemical specialty near enough to metallurgy to validate anything that I see about the similarity of the metals to support such a conclusion.
1 Answers 2016-03-21
It's in Chinese but you can roughly tell what the different groups are.
I'm mainly interested in how accurately it depicts Europe, but other areas are fine as well.
1 Answers 2016-03-21
1 Answers 2016-03-20
In Shakespeare's time, female roles were played by boy actors. In opera up until the 19th century, female roles were taken by castrati when female singers weren't available or allowed (depending on jurisdiction). In both cases, the actors involved were seen sometimes as novelties, sometimes as necessary given the limitations of the art, and sometimes as talented performers in their own right.
Flash forward to the twentieth century, and female impersonation is the domain of the gay bar, a facility often illegal outright or de facto. I realize that I'm zooming between countries and centuries, but at some point there seems to be a switch flipped. Did the radical idea that women should be allowed in the arts push away liminal figures that were secretly only ever tolerated out of necessity? Did a greater emphasis on what we now call homosexual behavior stigmatize these figures? Am I talking out of my ass?
I know that Japanese theater has its own relationship with crossdressing, and that's all I know about Japanese theater's own relationship with crossdressing, so I'm limiting the question's purview to the West.
1 Answers 2016-03-20
I'm thinking of King Charles V for example. Or was incest not a big deal back then?
1 Answers 2016-03-20
I am not a big redditor however this was suggested to me as a good place to potentially find the answer to this (so please bare with me). I'm a big history nerd, and currently living in France. One of my favourite periods of history is the interwar period, and more specifically the Paris peace treaties. So far I have been to the signing places of three (by accident), and thought it would be cool to visit all five. I have been to the chateaus of Versailles and Trianon, as well as St. Germain en Laye. It was very easy to find where the Treaty of Sevres was signed and I intend to visit there soon. However I have spent FAR too long researching the Treaty of Neuilly, and cannot find WHERE in Neuilly sur Seine it was signed. Does anyone know?
1 Answers 2016-03-20
Specifically, in England.
1 Answers 2016-03-20
Also, is there any evidence that the Derg spent the Live Aid proceeds on weapons, or was the BBC lying about that report?
Speaking of the BBC, a Newsnight piece a few years ago said that the EPRDF under Meles was also committing a kind of holodomor, in the same way (by withholding western food aid from areas of Ethiopia that supported the opposition parties). Is there any evidence of that?
Once again, please refrain from lay speculation, I don't want the comments to be nuked by mods for being unsourced. This is an answer I've been wanting to know for almost 5 years.
1 Answers 2016-03-20
Naturally many of us know that the Prussians were a valuable ally to Wellington's armies at Waterloo, and that only one hundred years later after a great deal of change, relations were the opposite, seeing as it was now the French and British against the Germans.
Queen Victoria's ancestry was vastly German nobles from the various German states, and her husband (and first cousin...) Prince Albert too was a noble German. However neither to my knowledge, were Prussians - and the rise of Prussia into the German Empire is indeed a very fascinating process and subject of history. This makes me wonder what relations were like between the British and their German neighbours (both Prussia and the small states too) between the 100 years from Napoleon to World War One. Naturally I know that around 1905, the British and Germans were in an arms race for production and invention superiority, and the German nation size and power was seen as a great threat to some others of Europe - leading to World War One.
Also, Wikipedia cites that Hanover was lost and incorporated into Prussia in 1866, during the Austro-Prussian War. I would be very grateful if someone could please elaborate and explain this event!
1 Answers 2016-03-20
Also, what was the standard equipment of a German Wehrmacht/SS soldier at the beginning of the war and what was added/scrapped as the war developed? Are there any differences between Western and Eastern front equipment?
1 Answers 2016-03-20
Today, sitting President Barack Obama is visiting Cuba. The last person to do so was Calvin Coolidge in 1928. What was the purpose of Coolidge's visit, and did it leave any impact on US-Cuba relations?
1 Answers 2016-03-20
Did they think cats, door handles, and clothing was biting them? Demons? Witchcraft? Just one of those things that everyone knew about and didn't make a fuss over?
1 Answers 2016-03-20
What other wars have had global theaters? What other conflicts have been global?
I heard that Churchill once called the Seven Year's War a World War, but are there any others?
1 Answers 2016-03-20
There seems to be a lot of debate over what kind of armor this was. Some say its made of leather other that its a combination of materials including linen.
I am reading a lot of debates and speculation on this armor that was very common in Greece and outside but i cant find many ancient references to it or the word "Linothorax".
2 Answers 2016-03-20
For centuries, the Catholic Church enacted capital punishment on a large scale. But in modern politics, the Catholic Church has been a staunch supporter of life. When did this change?
1 Answers 2016-03-20
Hello, I am Emily McEwan-Fujita, a linguistic anthropologist and author specializing in Scottish Gaelic language and culture. I have a PhD in anthropology from the University of Chicago. My academic publications are available at https://independent.academia.edu/EmilyMcEwanFujita. Currently I live in Nova Scotia and write the Gaelic Revitalization blog (http://gaelic.co). My new book, The Scottish Gaelic Tattoo Handbook: Authentic Words and Phrases from Scotland's Celtic Language, is coming out in May for Gaelic Awareness Month in Nova Scotia (book announcement email list: http://eepurl.com/bT0ZVL).
Ask Me Anything about Scottish Gaelic language and culture! No question is too basic. I especially welcome questions about sociolinguistic aspects of Gaelic language shift and revitalization in Scotland and Nova Scotia.
Cultural and linguistic anthropologists stand on the shoulders of historians a great deal of the time and so it’s a privilege to be asked to contribute here. I take a very broad view of “history” as anything that has already happened (even yesterday) and my dissertation covered the period from about 1980 to 2000 and looked at the influence of neoliberalism on Gaelic revitalization efforts. My sub-field is not always well understood (even by other anthropologists!) so as we go along I’ll try to give you an idea of how I approach problems from a linganth perspective. I’ll do my best to address all questions but of course if there’s something that’s not my speciality I’ll refer you to the work of others.
I’m posting this in advance as suggested. We’re predicted to have a lovely snow/ice pellet/rain storm here in Halifax during the scheduled AMA time (Monday, March 21, 10am-2pm) and I’ll be answering your questions with the laptop battery charged up in case the power goes! Siuthadaibh!
EDIT, Monday 10am EST: OK we're starting now! Some great questions here, thank you so much! I may have to pick and choose, sorry if anyone's question gets passed over. I may be able to mop up over the next day or two, or possibly do blog posts for some of them -- we'll see how it goes. For the next 4 hours at least, I'll be madly typing as the freezing rain glazes everything in Halifax!
UPDATE It's 4pm EST (5pm Atlantic) and I'll need to take a break soon. So many fantastic questions everyone, and thanks for your kinds words about my work. I'm going to try to answer a few more tonight, and then I'll confer with the mods on what to do next (maybe do some tomorrow and then open them up to other replies after that). Some unanswered questions I may answer in future blog posts over the next few months. It's wonderful to see so much interest in Gaelic!
MOSTLY DONE My will to completion got the better of me and I got most of the rest of your questions answered today! I might do a couple more tomorrow if I can manage, or come back later. TAPADH LEIBH UILE, thank you everyone, for a great AMA experience! Once again feel free to subscribe to my blog and send me questions there -- questions can make great blog posts. And sign up on the mailing list (url above) if you want to be notified when my new book about Scottish Gaelic tattoo ideas is published. Thanks again!
28 Answers 2016-03-20
Let me know if I'd be better of going to one of the sister subreddits. Thanks!
1 Answers 2016-03-20
I really have very little knowledge of where the Mexican border was before the war and what happened to Spanish speaking Americans during this time.
1 Answers 2016-03-20