The credibility of Yi Sun-sin

I have recently been researching on Korean history (I'm Korean American) and one person that really stuck out to me was Yi Sun-sin. From the amount of sources that back it up, there is no doubt that he was an amazing naval commander. However I have a few questions about the credibility of these numbers.

I saw in one of his major comebacks, he was able to defeat a Japanese Navy fleet of about 200 ships (or more) with just 13 ships. No matter how great of a commander one may be, I feel like this really pushes the limits and just may have been written to make him look bigger. Did this really happen or more likely exaggerated?

3 Answers 2016-03-17

How effective were 18th century means of execution, such as hanging and guillotine?

Was there a possibility of error for these ways of executing people?

1 Answers 2016-03-17

Why are some state-implicated mass-casualty events known by their victims' names (e.g. Holocaust, Holodomor), while others are known by their propaganda name (e.g. Great Leap Forward)?

1 Answers 2016-03-17

A friend of mine insists that the North was going to succeed from the Union some time before Lincoln was elected, is there any truth to this?

2 Answers 2016-03-17

Did the actions of any one person exacerbate ideological party differences among Whigs that ultimately lead to the dissolution of the party in the nineteenth century?

1 Answers 2016-03-17

WWI: I'm a soldier. What if I run like mad instead of walking slowly towards the enemy trench ?

What would happen to me ? (other than getting killed like everyone else...)

1 Answers 2016-03-17

What sort of work could an American/European woman composer do at the turn of the century?

(Turn of the century meaning circa 1900) By "what work could she do" I mean, could she expect to perform, conduct, travel to do those things, publish music, and teach? In what ways would her musical output be different from a man's of the same time, due to limitations in her rights and social permissions? Were some musical forms seen as more appropriate for a woman of this time over others?

1 Answers 2016-03-17

Algeria coup in 1961

I have been looking for what went on and how it is connected to the cold war and how the U.S or USSR were involved

1 Answers 2016-03-17

Does the field of meta-history exist? Like are there historians who specialize in how history was observed through the years?

This question was inspired by Tacitus. The Roman empire having historians means there must have been significant development in the historical method since then?

Is this an easily answerable question? Did historians of the past focus on specific things? Were these societally inspired values?

I'm sorry of this is too broad a question, mods feel free to remove it if it is. For specificity maybe a compare and contrast of ancient history versus post-Enlightenment history?

1 Answers 2016-03-17

What were the motivations behind Anglo-Saxon conversion to Christianity in the 6th and 7th centuries?

Were there unique advantages associated with converting to Christianity as opposed to keeping paganism?

EDIT: Thank you so much everybody for the excellent answers!

1 Answers 2016-03-16

Vietnam through the ages

Historians of the Reddit-sphere, good day, what was the Vietnamese military like? What were their tactics, who were their ancestral enemies, were they often conquered or did they manage to function as an independent state for most of their existence?

1 Answers 2016-03-16

When the 13 Colonials were first being founded, the heavily religious colonies were founded in the North, such as Plymouth, while the merchantile colonies were founded in the South, such as Jamestown, how did those positions get reversed so completely?

1 Answers 2016-03-16

My wife's grandfather has a couple of 'tear bottles' (tear jars?) - small glass bottles that he alleges were used to carry the tears of one's beloved in battle, or maybe to catch a dying soldier's tears. The latter sounds ridiculous. Any truth to the former?

3 Answers 2016-03-16

How reliable/accurate is the account that Alexander the Great kept a copy of Homer's Illiad in a gold box once owned by Darius?

The Guardian is doing a series of articles on cities through history. In their piece on Alexandria, they cite that Alexander the Great, after the battle of Gaugamela/Arbela, obtained a small golden box that was previously the property of Darius III. He used that to keep his copy of the Illiad, which was cited as among Alexander's most treasured possessions.

For some reason this fine detail stuck out in my mind. The Guardian article cites E. Cobham Brewer's 1898 edition of Dictionary of Phrase and Fable as its source, while in this thread, /u/XenophonTheAthenian cites Plutarch when discussing Alexander's love of Homer.

My question is, how reliable is the account of the gold "casket"? Is there enough evidence of the box, that it's taken as fact, or is it something in the realm of "well maybe," like Pheidippides dying after the Battle of Marathon, or Gaius Gracchus's head being filled with lead?

I apologize if my question seems naive or asks too much in terms of "evidence" from that era. I suppose the better question is really, how reliable is the account of the gold casket, relative to the other historical things(for lack of a better term) we know of that era?

Thank you in advance.

1 Answers 2016-03-16

How did people deal with poor eyesight before glasses?

3 Answers 2016-03-16

Was domestic violence common in Europe in the middle ages?

1 Answers 2016-03-16

I've Got A Different Type Of Question. What Is The Origin Of The High Five?

When did it first come around and who started it? Is there even any record on this type of stuff? Is it a recent thing or has it been around for a long time?

1 Answers 2016-03-16

Why does Canada have no federal district like the United States or Australia?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-03-16

In the lead up to the Civil War, did the iron and steel industries of Western Pennsylvania and their demand for coal play a significant role in Virginia breaking apart and Kentucky staying in the Union?

I know that in Virgina, the geographical barriers between east and west prevented the flow of goods and that the western half always had commercial ties to PA, OH, and KY. Is there any specific mention of Pittsburgh and the ramping up of its metals and armaments industries for the war as a reason to secede/stay?

2 Answers 2016-03-16

What is the first recorded instance of the apocalypse being considered a bad thing?

Most ancient apocalyptic prophecies of which I am aware regard the end of the world as essentially positive, if temporarily unpleasant. However, most contemporary imaginings of the apocalypse (which tend to skew more technological than religious) view it as something which must be avoided or overcome rather than as something necessary for the purification or renewal of the world. When and why did this shift occur? Were there ancient prophecies which had a wholly negative view of the apocalypse? Apologies if this treads a bit on the twenty-year rule.

1 Answers 2016-03-16

Can anyone comment on the role and use of cavalry during the transition from medieval weaponry to musketry?

I'm curious how cavalry changed in its usage from a pre firearm era to the use of musket& bayonet infantry. Any good sources would be appreciated.

2 Answers 2016-03-16

Did the Nazis invent the term "politically correct", and what's the story behind it?

In this video, Cenk makes this claim. How accurate was it, and what's the deeper story behind the term?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l8gZLeA_0Q0

1 Answers 2016-03-16

Help Identifying These Civil War Bullets

http://imgur.com/a/JR7KL

I bought these two bullets at a store in Gettysburg a few years ago and somewhere along the line lost the labels that came with them. I was wondering if anybody would be able to help in identifying the type of bullet each of these is. Any help is greatly appreciated!

1 Answers 2016-03-16

When was the first time that Americans fought the Germans in Germany in WW2?

1 Answers 2016-03-16

What did Nazis do with Jews who were veterans in WWI?

1 Answers 2016-03-16

4437 / 7255

Back to start