Was Soviet totalitarianism a modernized form of Tsarism?

Russian history seems to be the consolidation and ever so often breakdown of power due to, among other things, its geographical/geopolitical position and vastness. What I mean is, Tsardom arose out the threat of invaders from both the west and east and its Mongolian tutelage, as a large domain that demanded centralization. But even after the Revolution "tsarism" in Bolshevik dress seemed to be revived through Stalin's dictatorship, although for more complex reasons. How different were the power dynamics of Stalinism and tsarism? Was Stalin essentially a modernized tsar?

In other words did the Bolshevik Revolution change the fundamental power structure of Russian politics, or did it just make tsarism more dynamic in a modern world?

An extra question: did Stalin's death undo this regression towards tsarism?

1 Answers 2016-02-13

It's 1985, I'm a manufacturing an illegal electronic device (like a pirate satellite descrambler). How do I find customers?

I understand that just about all of underground commerce was (and mostly continues to be) word of mouth, but I've always wondered how it worked with electronic devices where a large amount of resources is required to create a product.

1 Answers 2016-02-13

What was the political situation of Pre-Colonial Sub-Saharan Africa like?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-02-13

What's the difference between a revolutionary war, independence war, and civil war?

I feel like the outcome determines the actual type of war, but I'd like an expert to confirm it if true. Sources would be appreciated. Thank you!

3 Answers 2016-02-13

How did "Sir" go from a title of nobility to just a term used to address someone politely?

3 Answers 2016-02-12

It's the late bronze/early iron age, and I'm traveling from Cornwall to Mycenae on foot. What gear do I need?

So caveat first, this is research for a low fantasy novel, so the actual geography and societies will vary, but I'm trying to keep it pretty grounded.

I have three people, one adult male, two female children, setting out on a long overland journey, and I'm trying to figure out what they would carry. My starting point would be Ötzi the Iceman, but he's a couple of millennia earlier than the period I'm looking at, and he was probably making a relatively short journey, so I'm trying to fill things out.

I'm particularly curious about how my characters would make fire on the journey. Would they be limited to friction methods like bow drills, or would they carry embers with them? When was the flint-and-iron method discovered? Any suggestions would be gratefully received!

1 Answers 2016-02-12

What did oridnary Indians think of the Beatles vist to India andmeeting with the Maharishi Mahesh Yogi in 1968? Was it widely reported in the Indian press of the time?

1 Answers 2016-02-12

Neanderthal DNA

I read somewhere that there is a theory that Neanderthals interbred with Homo Sapiens and they claim some of their DNA markers (not sure of exact term sorry) are present in people of European descent. How credible is this information and theory? Also is there any additional reading on this theory?

1 Answers 2016-02-12

Did the Byzantine iconoclasts have better relations with Muslims than iconodules due to a shared animosity towards religious imagery?

2 Answers 2016-02-12

Why did the Royal Navy scuttle so many U-Boats after WWII?

During Operation Deadlight, over 100 U-Boats were scuttled by the British, but why didn't the Royal Navy either keep them or scrap them for parts?

1 Answers 2016-02-12

I want to visit a relative in Rome during the reign of Augustus Caesar. I come from the nearby countryside but I have never been in the city before. How would I go about locating my relative's house?

Was there a proper system of labeling streets, and house numbers at this time? How easily could I reliably find the house if I had a proper address? If no system existed, was one eventually developed by future emperors?

2 Answers 2016-02-12

Why are the Roman Catholic and Russian Orthodox church separate in the first place?

Why didn't the leaders get together to talk earlier? One thousand years is a long time to wait.

1 Answers 2016-02-12

Why were the colors brown, yellow, and green so popular in the 70's?

Whenever I see references to the 70's, such as in TV shows, pictures, etc. I always see those colors. I just look at these colors together and it just reminds me of that era. Why were they so popular? Has this happened for other decades/eras?

1 Answers 2016-02-12

How did the Northern US's textile industry not collapse during the Civil War if the South controlled the majority of cotton?

.

1 Answers 2016-02-12

How come so much land during the Baltic Crusades was controlled by monastic orders such as the Livonian Sword Brothers or the Teutonic Knights compared to other crusades in Iberia or the Levant?

1 Answers 2016-02-12

Before the invention of the tattoo gun, what would have been the point of tattooing a slave/prisoner when branding them would have been much quicker and easier?

1 Answers 2016-02-12

In the Middle Ages, if someone was drowning and they're pulled out of the water but unresponsive, was there anything people could do to try to save them?

I know that mouth-to-mouth resuscitation wasn't a thing until the 1700's, so I feel as though I'm answering my own question but...maybe someone knows of something people did back then to try to save a drowning victim?

1 Answers 2016-02-12

How old is the earliest extant manuscript of St. Jerome's letter #78?

Hey guys!

I've been doing some independent research on the letters of St. Jerome and I've been curious about finding some of the manuscripts and references to their dating.

In particular I'm curious of the letter number 78 (or LXXVIII) concerning Fabiola's death addressed to Oceanus. It was written in 399 CE but I'm more curious as to when in history the earliest extant manuscript of this letter is?

I did some googling and found some manuscripts dated to 950 CE but I was interested if there would be earlier extant ones and if so to which period is it dated?

I found this table (link) that mentions the manuscripts used for the book Select Letters of Saint Jerome (1933) [PDF here] (https://ia802604.us.archive.org/3/items/selectlettersofs00jerouoft/selectlettersofs00jerouoft.pdf) which includes the aforementioned letter. However the table is very confusing though according to another source it's supposed to correlate manuscripts with letters the manuscript was used for, maybe if someone could clarify what the letters next to the dates represent it would be helpful.

I was hoping you could help.

Thanks in advance!

EDIT: I'm so stupid, I meant, #77.

2 Answers 2016-02-12

At the time, were the Allied firebombings of German and Japanese cities also seen as war crimes?

Sorry, by "also seen as war crimes", I don't mean to sound like a Wehraboo. My observations come from many people on Reddit saying that they were war crimes.

Firebombings of:

  • Tokyo

  • Hamburg

  • Dresden

Or was this a rare opinion because it was total war and because of:

  • Pearl Harbor

  • The Blitz

  • Coventry Blitz

  • Rotterdam Blitz

1 Answers 2016-02-12

Jerusalem, 1920s. There's been a murder, who conducts the investigation?

Is it a local policemen, a British agent, or someone else?

1 Answers 2016-02-12

Visual book recommendation on European Medieval society.

I've been interested in European Medieval history for a while and have recently freed up time to follow this passion. I had started by reading more casual/fictitious books such as "Daily Life in Medieval Times" by Gies and "The Time Traveller's Guide to Medieval England" by Mortimer.

More recently I have been working through various recommendations (e.g. The AskHistorians master book list) which have included books such as "The Civilization of the Middle Ages" by Cantor and Cambridge's "The New Cambridge Medieval History".

While all these books have been fantastic, I have felt a lack of visual learning. Withouth seeming too crude, I have yearned for a more cutout almost pictorial/diagram/thesaurusial that I could use as a reference point when reading. Inclusive of images such as this but with more infomation and spanning a larger array of Medieval society (homes, objects, human geography). The only ones I have been able to find thus far are aimed at children/the very casually interested.

I'm not sure what i'm looking for exists, but any recommendations or a point in the right direction would be much appreciated.

Thanks for reading.

2 Answers 2016-02-12

Best books for history of China and Japan?

Im looking to travel asia and I want to learn more about the history.

1 Answers 2016-02-12

How Did We Get an American Holocaust Museum/Memorial but No Museum/Memorial to Atrocities which Happened on American Soil?

I think it's wonderful we have been able to preserve memories of such an event that had an impact on the world, don't get me wrong. But it seems odd that we have a site on the National Mall dedicated to a tragedy that didn't happen on American soil when there is no such museum to American slavery or the killing of Native Americans.

1 Answers 2016-02-12

What is the actual origin of Valentine's day?

I have heard that it started as the Roman holiday Lupercalia, but is this true? Also, What is the actual story of Saint Valentine?

3 Answers 2016-02-12

How did the language of Latin "die"?

I just think it's incredibly strange that the language of one of the greatest empires in human history just sort of faded out to what it is today.

Even stranger, it was the "language of Christianity" which spread across Europe like wild fire through Rome.

So in a simple way to understand, why is Latin considered a dead language?

2 Answers 2016-02-12

4532 / 7255

Back to start