Our community was featured this month in the American Historical Association magazine! | "Have a Question about the Past? AskHistorians."

21 Answers 2016-02-12

If National Socialism is far-right, why isn't it called National Conservatism?

How was the term 'National Socialism' developed.

1 Answers 2016-02-12

How much of earlier myths were later incorporated into later Christian myths?

I ask because I recently seen this coat of arms at my school:

http://imgur.com/cfNuhQo

Which is the coat of arms of the city of Cadiz in Spain. Which from a cursory glance at wikipedia it seems its based on a story of Hercules. And then I remembered a flaired user claiming that many native myths were quickly incorporated into Christianity. So would later Christians have believed in a Hercules or a Trojan War?

1 Answers 2016-02-12

During World War II my grandfather was Italian military. At one point he transfered over to the U.S. Military. How common was this and what was the process to do so?

1 Answers 2016-02-12

How did Slovenia escape most of the bloodshed of the Yugoslav Wars?

According to Wikipedia, Slovenia had a brief scuffle that resulted in the loss of under a hundred lives. But the other Yugoslav republics endured years of hellish conflict in the struggle for independence. Why did Slovenia get out relatively unscathed?

Here are some other discussions that came up in the search:

Same as my question, but no answers

Why was Slovenian's war for independence from Yugoslavia over so quickly

Why did Serbia try to stop Slovenian secession?

1 Answers 2016-02-12

The soundtrack from the Fallout games feature several songs from the '50s that incorporate themes of radiation and atomic bombs with an almost surreal degree of levity. What was the context behind that mentality, and how has the perception of nuclear energy evolved since its inception?

A few examples would be:

By the standards of today, it seems to me really strange to think about radiation and atomic bombs with that kind of playfulness.

Barely 10 years after Hiroshima and Nagasaki, did lay people not understand the seriousness of the technology, and the devastation that came from its use? Or, did they likely understand it and used that kind of levity as a coping mechanism?

How did the perception of nuclear energy change over time, and what precipitated the change? And how did the perception differ globally?

5 Answers 2016-02-12

How likely was it for skirmishers to survive battles during ancient warfare between armies with similar technologies? Who are some notable survivors recorded to be great warriors, without too much exaggeration?

1 Answers 2016-02-12

Question about 1920's Brittish Currency.

Ive been watching Downton Abbey and am curious about the terms they use for money, I am familiar with "pounds" and "quids" although I am not positive on their actual value but they do refer to "Packets" quite often as large sums of money. I know today in American Currency we have "slang" terms for amounts of money; 1 Grand = $1,000. Was there similar terms for english currency and if so what were they?

1 Answers 2016-02-12

In 1914, the Ottoman empire declare Jihad on the Allied powers. Where there any domestic attacks inside Allied countries carried out by Muslims because of this?

1 Answers 2016-02-12

I am an East Asian adult male and for some reason I end up being in Rome in 50 BC. What is likely to happen to me ?

For example, will I cause a commotion when I am walking on the street? Or will I get caught very soon and sold to some slave masters ?

1 Answers 2016-02-12

I'm looking for a book specifically on the great heathen army and its conquests of England.

I watched a television show recently that portrays a fictional account of this era and it looks like a fascinating time. Any help? Cheers.

1 Answers 2016-02-12

How elastic has the Catholic Church been over the years in its policies and doctrine?

There's a lot of discussion going on right now about whether the Pope should lift the ban on contraception and abortion in order to help protect women from the Zika outbreak. I'm told by Catholic friends that sex that can't result in procreation and (maybe more obviously) abortion are strictly forbidden by the Church. In the case of contraception, is forbidding this more a matter of policy than doctrine? Like, heresy is still not cool, but at some point the Church said "we're not going to respond to heresy by burning people anymore". It seems a lot harder to believe that abortion could be declared okay considering it seems to be a pretty cemented doctrine that this counts as murdering a human being. Are there any examples of quick reversals in doctrine based on the Church responding to a humanitarian crisis in history? What does history tell us about the likelihood that the Pope could call for such radical changes?

1 Answers 2016-02-12

How did Vikings decide who was to be a Berserker?

Hello, I'm writing an article about Viking Berserkers and I've scoured the net for the answer to my question and I can't seem to find one. Mainly my question is, is there any criteria Vikings had for choosing who was a berserker? Did they get chosen by a Jarl, or inherit it, or just decide one day "Hey I'm going to do that"? Or something else? Thanks so much for your time.

1 Answers 2016-02-12

Has the USPS ever struggled with an outbreak of fraudulent stamps?

I was looking at my last Harvey Milk stamp and wondering how easy it would be to just print up your own batch of stamps. They do not seem to have any security features, compared to printed money. In its noble history stretching back to Ben Franklin, Has the USPS ever struggled with people selling fake stamps?

2 Answers 2016-02-12

Was Emperor Claudius a republican?

I asked this on /r/history yesterday and didn't get any valuable responses:

I am re-reading I, Claudius again for the third time, and I know it is a fictionalization, but that Graves based it on many historical sources.

So my question is, (as far as we know) did Claudius actually hold republican ideals and was he truly limited in enacting them by the threat of civil war or the suppressive power of the Praetorian guard?

NOTE: Republican in this sense meaning someone who favors the republic versus the monarchy of the roman empire.

1 Answers 2016-02-12

Did the Muladies (indigenous Iberian Muslims of Al-Andalus) look more like the Spanish of today, or did they closer resemble the Moors?

1 Answers 2016-02-12

Friday Free-for-All | February 12, 2016

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

19 Answers 2016-02-12

Was there any backlash regarding Theodore Roosevelt's attempt to win the presidential nomination in 1912 after having served as president from 1901-1909?

3 Answers 2016-02-12

Why is Iran called "Iran" instead of the more traditional Persia?

1 Answers 2016-02-12

What started the Crusades?

I keep hearing that the pope started it and that it was a response to Muslim aggression. But which one is true? And is either true?

2 Answers 2016-02-12

It's 1880 in Australia, who has "an accent"?

1 Answers 2016-02-12

In the 1790s, Haiti's economy utterly collapsed amidst warfare--and Cuba saw explosive growth. How did this affect the lives of the slaves whose labor produced the island's wealth? What about the aristocrats who reaped the benefits?

This is right in the era of colonial rebellions, too. Did the sudden economic growth lead Cubans to call for independence, or give them leverage to win concessions from Spain?

1 Answers 2016-02-12

Why is there a discrepancy of opinion between those that believe Henry Kessinger was a great strategist and those that believe he is a war criminal?

Thought spawned from watching the democratic debate. Reddit will tend to skew towards the Sanders camp so an unbiased account of Kessinger's impact on US Politics would be very much appreciated.

1 Answers 2016-02-12

How early in human history did the onset of what's considered "cancer" develop?

To be clear, I'd like to know whether there's either early records of something that could be thought of as "cancer" or maybe archaeological evidence of neoplasms in human remains.

1 Answers 2016-02-12

How important was the conversion of the Roman Empire to the spread of Christianity? Would Christianity have been remotely as widespread if it wasn't for Constantine?

4 Answers 2016-02-12

4533 / 7255

Back to start