Has Arabic evolved and changed over the years in much the same way that English has over the centuries?

Has imported words from the surrounding languages (Persian, Hebrew, Aramaic, Turkish, and so on) and has certain meanings or spellings changed over time? Are there specific phases of Arabic linguistic history such as Old English, Middle English, and Modern English?

3 Answers 2016-01-23

A historic description of a lunar crater being formed?

A long time ago, I read an interesting book, where they tried to shed more light on natural phenomena we know happened in the past, by studying contemporary texts: Most of there contemporary descriptions didn't know what they were describing, so a lot of it was trying to figure out that 'evil fire from the mouth of the mountain' meant a volcano eruption.

One of the descriptions was thought to maybe be about the formation of a lunar crater. I remember it as being from the middle ages, but maybe it was older. It described how the 'snake in the night sky' got bitten in the tail, which made it twist with pain. Todays historians believed this was a crecent moon that got struck by a meteor, which caused an "earth quake" (moon quake?") on the moon, hence 'twisting in pain'. I remember I looked up what the crater was, and was impressed that it was a clearly visible one, but now I can't remember which it was :( I tried googleing, but I think my memory is too vague to search relevant words.

Does this ring a bell for any historians? I imagine that such a description would be quite significant, so I'm surprised I've not heard more of it.

On a slightly related note, any other historic, cryptic descriptions of major phenomena in the past? I find it really interesting to read what people thought they saw, and then reading the actual explanations.

3 Answers 2016-01-23

Question on Iranian government

I'm currently reading a book on the Iranian Revolution (1978-79), but the book covers most of the 20th century. I'm having trouble understanding exactly how the government operated. There was a prime minister, a Shah, and the Marjles? What power did those three have? I understand there was also the Ulema and other political factions which didn't actually have legal power, but rather incredible influence? It almost sounds like Reza Shah had complete power. What power did the prime minister and Majles have?

Thanks!

1 Answers 2016-01-23

How were women in the Soviet Military treated by men during WW2?

1 Answers 2016-01-23

Having a debate with some friends about Hitler, help needed to settle this.

I've been having an ongoing debate with some friends about whether Hitler would kill a black haired, brown eyed Iranian through 1933-1945. Their reasoning was ''Hitler killed anyone who didn't fit the "visual threshold". I said that it would be unlikely since he didn't fit the visual threshold himself and he just said that as propaganda for the Germans to get on his side. Now it is factual that he was good friends with the Shah of Iran during his ruling and Iran stand for ''Land of the Aryans''. Help us out

1 Answers 2016-01-23

What happened to the remains of the Vichy fleet after the battle of Mers-el-Kébir?

From what I am reading a battleship and a destroyer were left unharmed. Where did they go?

1 Answers 2016-01-23

Saturday Reading and Research | January 23, 2016

Previous

Today:

Saturday Reading and Research will focus on exactly that: the history you have been reading this week and the research you've been working on. It's also the prime thread for requesting books on a particular subject. As with all our weekly features, this thread will be lightly moderated.

So, encountered a recent biography of Stalin that revealed all about his addiction to ragtime piano? Delved into a horrendous piece of presentist and sexist psycho-evolutionary mumbo-jumbo and want to tell us about how bad it was? Need help finding the right book to give the historian in your family? Then this is the thread for you!

11 Answers 2016-01-23

Is it true, that Hitler was a Vegetarian?

I have often heard on the internet, that Hitler was a vegetarian. But yesterday I heard for the first time, that this is a lie and it was in fact only propaganda of Goebbels. So, what is true?

1 Answers 2016-01-23

Was Charlemagne ever fully canonized (considered a saint)?

Hello, I am writing an essay about Charles IV., the Holy Roman Emperor in the 14th century.

It is known how he adored Charlemagne and I got into a very interesting topic - is Charlemagne considered a saint? I have searched the internet and mostly found that no, he was not fully canonized, only Blessed.

I would love to agree with that, but I live in Prague (as you have probably all ready guessed, because we take Charles IV. very seriously here) and we have a church called Church of the Assumption of the Virgin Mary and St. Charles the Great. Yep, the construction began during the reign of Charles IV.

This is where it gets it gets ugly - I don't think that the Catholic church recognizes Charlemagne as a saint, yet they own a building that implies he is one - how is that possible?

Thank you for the answers!

EDIT:Just some quick info about the church, that it really exists: CLICK

1 Answers 2016-01-23

What were dildos like in 1600? (Why do I ask? Because of this song.)

Listen: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sK7s63T1sXY

Other versions: https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=will+you+buy+a+fine+dog

This song is Elizabethan because it was made in ~1600.

I didn't know dildos were even around in 1600. If they were, I wonder what they'd looked like, and how common they were.

1 Answers 2016-01-23

How did medieval Christians believe the world began?

Now, the obvious answer is "God created it in 6 days in about 4000 BC". But I've read that many classical and medieval theologians, such as Origen, St Augustine, Thomas Aquinus, etc, claimed that God created the world instantly, timelessly, or something like that, and that the 6 days were metaphorical in some sense. Though I know Martin Luther believed that it was literal. So, what I wonder is a)how your average peasant believed the world began, and b)what educated Catholics (or Orthodox) believed. Also, were there any significant changes to their understanding of the world's beginning prior to the Reformation, or did Church teaching stay pretty much the same throughout the whole medieval period?

1 Answers 2016-01-23

How did the Canadians treat their "Native Americans" differently than the US?

I know alot about the treatment of US Native Americans, but almost nothing about those in Canada. I assume their nearest neighbor influenced their decision on how to deal with a similar problem. Did they have their own Trail of Tears or similar horrors?

1 Answers 2016-01-23

Why was the opium trade so lucrative in China?

1 Answers 2016-01-23

Does anyone know what would be on the left shoulder of this nose art girl?

Hi historians,

http://imgur.com/IHeUQyZ

Google has failed me in my quest to find more detail about this girl

We are trying to work out what is likely on this girls' left shoulder and what her locket looks like.

Originally we thought it was her hair but the angle is wrong and it seems to be missing any hair flow from the top of her head.

We believe this was RAF 61st squadron if that helps.

Any information you can provide (or point me to where I should be asking) will be appreciated!

2 Answers 2016-01-23

What are some views of historians on the impact of WW1 on the Middle East?

Looking for some sources to talk about - with the inclusion, if possible, of the relevant quotes? Preferably no web sources, but depending on reliability I'm willing to accept those as well.

Many thanks!

2 Answers 2016-01-23

Why was the punishment of "Nine Familial Exterminations" used often as a systemic punishment in China, but not anywhere else?

I'm currently zipping through a Chinese history podcast, and the striking thing is how often palace coups or failed rebellions would lead to the execution of the losers' entire clan. I understand why it was done, what I don't understand is why it seems to be a practice peculiar to Chinese civilization.

I'm sure other civilizations did wipe out entire extended families on occasion, but -correct me if I'm wrong- it doesn't seem to have been a formal punishment, even for crimes perceived to be extremely heinous (I'm thinking for example of the nasty way the assassin of William the Silent was dispatched, which would suggest what he did was viewed as absolutely unforgivable).

2 Answers 2016-01-23

Why did nationalism in Europe seem to develop as ethnic nationalism as opposed to civic nationalism?

1 Answers 2016-01-23

What are some good books on the domestic policy/politics of the Central Powers of WWI?

I've already read A Mad Catastrophe by Geoffrey Wawro, are there other books that can enlighten me on the domestic policy of the central powers? Specifically Austria-Hungary?

1 Answers 2016-01-23

Did French cavalry capture a Dutch fleet in 1795?

I have heard of this story before, but I was looking at Wikipedia and I came across this event again, so did the French cavarly capture a Dutch fleet 221 years a go?

1 Answers 2016-01-23

What would have attracted European Immigrants to Settle in New York over Philadelphia?

My ancestors, Italian, and Irish, settled in Philadelphia between the 1880s and 1930s. Unfortunately, none are alive for me to ask this question to. At a time when New York was growing at such a rapid speed to become America's dominant city, why did so many choose to settle in Philadelphia, a city geographically close to New York, but smaller?

1 Answers 2016-01-23

Ancient Shipbuilding

Did ancient ship construction use nails? I've heard about the clinker and shell first methods of construction, but I'm not sure how the nails survived corrosion or if they had to be repeatedly replaced.

1 Answers 2016-01-23

How much did Mussolini know about the holocaust? How close were Hitler and him?

I'm curious to hear what Mussolini knew about the holocaust and what Italy's involvement was. We don't hear about Italy's side often.

2 Answers 2016-01-23

North African Grain Supply

For the whole history of the Roman Empire, Egypt as a major source of grain for Rome is a given. But it seems the rest of North Africa was as well. Take for example the post-tetarchy chaos when Constantine ruled in Gaul and Maxentius in Italy. The revolt of Domitius Alexander in north Africa causing major political problems for Maxentius due to the shut down of the grain supply from north africa is common knowledge. I had always assumed "North Africa" in this context included Egypt. However based on the following, it seems Domitius did not control Egypt, only what is now modern Libya and surrounds. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domitius_Alexander This does not jive with the modern condition of agriculture in this area. Libya does not grow enough food to handle even 25% of its national need and is relying on major aquifer irrigation projects which clearly did not exist in Roman times ( https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Libya )

Did climactic change or human mismanagement destroy agriculture in this region? What happened?

1 Answers 2016-01-23

Relative (adjusted) cost of paper in 17th century England?

So I was watching this documentary on the history of the Calculus, and this fellow was reading from Liebniz' and Newton's respective notebooks, and I was noticing the impossibly small size of their script relative to my ponderously wasteful use of scratch paper. This got me to wondering what the cost of paper would have been back then, and also what folks would have used to work out their problems as they went. Chalkboards?

Thanks.

1 Answers 2016-01-23

What types of sails did ancient galleys use?

What kind of fabric were they made of? It couldn't have been hemp, because doesn't that only grow in the more northern parts of the world?

1 Answers 2016-01-23

4597 / 7255

Back to start