How can all Europeans be descended from Charlemagne if mobility/migration was so low in history?

I understand the mathematics behind the statement, but don't understand how it's practical for descendants of Charlemagne to be everywhere in Europe and in all classes of society when social mobility and the ability to leave your local area were so proscribed throughout history. If my family has been consistently living in what is now Poland or Spain or Italy for millennia, how could we and all our neighbours have ancestors that breeder with the descendant of a Frankish noble? Did people travel around and change cultures more than I thought in the medieval period?

1 Answers 2015-12-31

Why hasn't the US switched to the metric system?

It's almost 2016, and the US still uses its customary units of weights and measure. Does anyone know why the US has not done full metrication yet? Is there some historical reason for this?

1 Answers 2015-12-31

A while ago, I was speaking to a woman who grew up in West Germany, and she claimed that every time you made a phone call, "You could actually hear the tape recorder click on" at whatever location you were being recorded at. Is this true?

To clarify, she was saying not only that some third party, presumably the West German government, was actively recording phone conversations, but also that you could literally hear the recorder turn on. She also said that "when they ran out of tape, they just disconnected you" because whoever was listening didn't want to miss anything. Neither she nor any relations were dissidents or contentious individuals, as far as I'm aware. I asked this question a month ago but received no reply. Any answers are appreciated!

2 Answers 2015-12-31

How were languages first translated? There are stories of Roman emperors meeting Pharoahs, but Latin and Ancient Egyptian were completely different languages. How did they communicate?

[deleted]

2 Answers 2015-12-31

A Marine’s first general order is, “Take charge of this post and all government property in view.” In 1921 Naval Secretary Denby directed the marines to shoot and never surrender against stage coach bandits attempting to steal the mail. How did the marines get in charge of mail and what changed?

I tried to read the rules and don't think I'm violating anything but this question is based off of this comment: https://www.reddit.com/r/pics/comments/3yxknn/the_united_states_postal_service_doesnt_play_games/cyhnxj3

I googled the quote and its sourced all over ( https://fixbayonetsusmc.wordpress.com/2015/01/30/general-order-no-1/ ) .

I am curious about how the Navy wound up in charge here and why not another federal agency (such as the army) particularly on land based routes. I am also curious if they still have authority here and how/if that has changed.

Thanks

2 Answers 2015-12-31

How exactly did Nazi Germany military tactics make them (more or less) better than others?

Hi! I want to start off and apologize if this question was already answered. I checked the FAQ and couldn't see something that directly answered this.

Recently, I took a class about the history of war since Napoleon. I learned a great deal, but am forgetting some things. I learned about the revolutions in military affairs between wars, with the most focus on pre-WWI, where warfare had changed as a result of the railway systems and machine guns (to a point where it seemed as if WWI was a war fought with weapons that even the most experienced veterans didn't know how to properly utilize). I know that prior to WWII, the German Air Force was greatly supported compared to other nations in Europe. Was the effectiveness of the Nazi army in the West a big result of their air force capabilities, or was it due to other nations not knowing/correctly acting in regards to the Nazi advances? (If you have any input on Nazi military tactics, strategy, or any interesting tidbits about the Nazi military on all fronts I would love to hear them!)

2 Answers 2015-12-31

When did "bargains galore" come about?

The phrase seems to be well used but I can't find an origin story.

1 Answers 2015-12-31

What did the early Christian church do right or have an advantage at that other religions didnt do so well when it came to early expansion in Rome?

I would have asked in Academic biblical, but this seemed more like a historical question.

2 Answers 2015-12-31

Info on family crest (see link)

[deleted]

1 Answers 2015-12-31

During Afghan war, did USSR know the role of Pakistan, and USA in supporting Mujahideen? If yes, why did it not react?

Moreover, if it did not, how could it not?

1 Answers 2015-12-31

I need help with family history.

So my family has a book about our ancestors. That dates all the way back to 1792 for America. I was wondering if anyone could tell me where to find more information on migrants from that time period. I believe my ancestor who's marriage license was issued in 1792 was the son of a Hessian mercenaries from Germany. I was wondering if there are any lists of German Hessian mercenaries names containing the last name England ( this is not my last name but I am directly related to that last name as it is my grandmothers maiden name) or if anyone could help me out with this it would be great. I think that my ancestor was the son of a German Hessian mercenaries who stayed here after the war was over.

1 Answers 2015-12-31

How did General Dwight D. Eisenhower have the prescience to anticipate future holocaust denial? Was outright denial of previous historical events common prior to the holocaust?

1 Answers 2015-12-31

Is it true that Adolf Hitler started wielding his iconic mustache after a close call with gas in WW1?

I remember seeing somewhere that Hitler was caught under a surprise gas attack in WW1, but was unprepared due to not being able to put on his mask on properly becuase of his long mustache. He then shaved it shorter for the mask to fit properly. Is this the real reason why he started shaving his mustache short, or was it just a personal choice?

1 Answers 2015-12-31

When did humans realize that traits of offspring were hereditary?

For example, if I had a kid born with blond hair when both parents have brown hair, I would be suspicious of the mother because neither of us have that trait. Has the concept of inheriting traits from parents been around as long as humans, or is it a (relatively) recent revelation?

1 Answers 2015-12-31

I'm considering the PhD in History, am I dumb?

Dear Historians, I am currently in the process of completing my MA in history at a pretty solid university (a plan I devised to make my applications to Ivys, etc more competitive) and I've been trying to determine if my dream to join the historical profession is worth pursuing in the twenty-first century academy. I've read some articles like:

http://www.historians.org/publications-and-directories/perspectives-on-history/january-2013/the-2012-jobs-report

http://northwesthistory.blogspot.com/2011/11/open-letter-to-my-students-no-you.html

which are most optimistically saying that "there was sort of an increase in entry level hiring in 2012, but there was a higher increase in PhDs conferred and the job market is cloudy"

and most pessimistically saying: "the historical field is essentially dead and this is the last generation of conventional, tenured, professional historians in existence."

My teachers in the program give me answers like "the job market is hard, but not impossible." This is the view of middle-career professionals in tenure-track positions at an Ivy league school. I do not know if it is reflective of the field at large.

Tl:dr: Does the job market for history look like it will be heading to 1990s level-crisis, or worse? Is the professional historian an endangered species? Finally, do PhDs from higher-prestige institutions (U Chicago, Harvard, Yale, Columbia, Princeton, etc.) provide any insulation from the hellish job market, or is everyone in this together?

I love history. I really really want to do this. But I have to accept defeat if that's whats in the cards.

5 Answers 2015-12-31

Was Eastern Europe (Lithuania and beyond) considered Asia at some point?

I've heard it was, but I can't find anything concrete. Perhaps someone could clear it up?

1 Answers 2015-12-31

This is the longest shot ever but it cant hurt to ask.

My wife is trying to track her lineage on her mothers side, They were part of the Connells from Ireland that came over to Canada in and around the great depression.

At one point an author wrote about her family biography around the 1930s, he was given a room in Annie Connell Fergusons residence during this time.

We are trying to track down a copy of this book it was ridiculously large as the Connell family side was very prolific.

does anone have any ideas where I could search for this biography?

1 Answers 2015-12-31

What happened to the French troops evacuated across the Channel at Dunkirk?

What happened to the French troops evacuated across the Channel at Dunkirk? Did they fight for England, go back to Vichy France, or something else?

1 Answers 2015-12-31

I recently saw a photo that was, according to the photographer, cave art written by a German soldier during WW1; it was "Hell" written in candle soot. Would a German have written "Hell" or "Hölle"?

2 Answers 2015-12-31

I have very minor cerebral palsy that only gives me a subtle nuance to how I walk but does not affect anything else. Would I have been persecuted, jailed, or euthanized in Nazi Germany?

2 Answers 2015-12-31

I'm a peasant in 1066 in Warwick. How and when would I find out that some guy name William from Normandy got crowned king of England?

EDIT: Wow, thanks everyone for all the great answer and discussion! This gives a great insight in what I wanted to know!

5 Answers 2015-12-31

In WW1, how was the unit composition decided?

For the US the last huge war was the Civil War where most units seemed to be state based. Was WW1 the same? Or did units have soldiers from all over?

Also, any information of other nations unit compositions would be fascinating.

3 Answers 2015-12-31

Are there any examples of slavery supporters in the American South who changed their mind and rejected slavery (either before or after the Civil War)?

1 Answers 2015-12-31

Can someone explain the history of the French verb 'aller,' (to go) which seems to descend from two different Latin words?

2 Answers 2015-12-31

How did the adoption of Firearms affect the usage of Bows and Crossbows in Western European warfare?

Did armies entirely abandon bows and crossbows all at once? Or did they phase out their use slowly while using some sort of combined-arms approach? What sorts of roles would each weapon serve during this phasing out period?

1 Answers 2015-12-31

4669 / 7255

Back to start