Why does Germany Empire (and Germany) have a good stance towards their Middle East policy relative to Britain, France and Russia and other European powers?

King Wilhelm II visit Istanbul and Palestine, they tried to build Baghdad-Berlin railway, they allied with the Ottomans in World War 1

What is exactly in their mind, what is in the mind of Von Bismark?

even Nazi Germany had a good stance, and you find right wing groups accusing Muslim of being Nazi themselves by bringing evidence of Haj Amin, Slavic Muslim serving the SS, Hitler's word of favor towards Muslims, non-Aggression pact with Turkey,

even the Prussian King Frederick II the Great said "If Turks and heathens were to come to populate the land, we shall build mosques and churches"

Fredrick 1 even had soldiers from the Tatar background escaped from Russia as his personal guard. They have Muslim cemetery and hall for their prayer

2 Answers 2015-09-16

British tanks in ww1?

Need to do a lot of research on a British tanks warfare in ww1 but know very little. What tanks were used and any books to recommend on the topic?

1 Answers 2015-09-16

What was the role of Pope St. John XXIII in the Cuban Missile Crisis?

I'm asking this because I'm curious, and when I try to find information I only get two opposite extremes:

  1. Secular sources that completely ignore the Pope, not even mentioning him.

  2. Catholic sources which portray the Pope as intervening at the pivotal moment to avert war and preserve peace. For example this article quotes Kennedy as having said the pope’s letter was “the first step down the path of peace.”

Afaik, the pure facts is that during the crisis the Vatican communicated with both Kennedy and Kruschev. With approval of at least the White House the Pope then made a public plea for 'Peace and Humanity'. This plea was then published on the front cover of the main Soviet State newspaper.

Was this an impactful action as Catholic sources like to portray it, or do secular sources ignore it because it was completely inconsequential?

1 Answers 2015-09-16

How did Hawaiian natives GET to Hawaii in the first place?

Title. It seems pretty far from land to have reached by a canoe... Was it just a long, random voyage?

2 Answers 2015-09-16

Truth Behind Illiad? Oddysey?

Since it seems the Trojan War as depicted by The Illiad was never even close to happening (much to my recent disappointment), what's the purpose of the story? Surely there is an allegory, some moral to the immense story, some sort of purpose for compiling and maintaining the story lines? I'm actually more interested in the Illiad.

3 Answers 2015-09-16

I found this German pin in a box of trinkets my great grandfather owned. Could anyone here identify, translate or tell me any details about it?

Also if this is the incorrect subreddit, apologies and a link to he correct one would be appreciated.

https://i.imgur.com/LFqoShn.png

https://i.imgur.com/uiCBncH.png

https://i.imgur.com/VinDCey.png

1 Answers 2015-09-16

To what extent did the civilizations of central Africa and the African Great Lakes region interact with the outside world before the Scramble for Africa?

The popular grand strategy game Europa Universalis IV depicts this region as a large chunk of impassable wasteland, indicating that it is unfit for colonization. This is presumably intended to represent how European imperialists did not penetrate into the African interior until the Scramble for Africa of the 1880's.

However, an unfortunate side effect of this design decision is that there is no representation of the various states and empires that existed in this region prior to colonization, or even of the fact that there were people living there at all.

There is also a question of internal consistency, since a variety of "primitive" societies indigenous to North America, South America, and Siberia are recognized as "states" in this manner, ostensibly on the basis that they had more significant interactions with the outside world (i.e. European colonizers). The game's conception for what constitutes a "state" is rather Eurocentric, but it seems rather dubious to me that this construct can be applied to Native American societies but not states of the African Great Lakes.

1 Answers 2015-09-16

Did Native Americans have basic advancement in sciences? Did they do basic math, physics or astronomy?

I'm very curious what the understanding of the world was for them, outside of their mythology. The pythagoras theorem was discovered independently by eastern and western civilisations, did they discover it as well? Thanks in advance.

1 Answers 2015-09-16

How accurate if the movie, "Inherit the Wind"?

Inherit the Wind:

http://imdb.com/rg/an_share/title/title/tt0053946/

  • Court proceedings

  • People's attitudes (townspeople, visitors, and people on other states) -- what comes to mind are the newspaper headlines in the beginning of the movie.

Edit: *is

1 Answers 2015-09-16

Why doesn't Korea want to unify into one country? Vietnam was successful in doing it so what's different with the situation in Korea?

Is it nationalism? are there other factors at play here that may not be so clear?

2 Answers 2015-09-16

The story of Pablo Escobar...

After watching the Netflix show "Narcos," I am interested to read an academically endorsed historical perspective on the rise and fall of the Medellin cartel, do any of this historians in this sub have any recommendations?

1 Answers 2015-09-16

When Did Black Canadians Gain the Vote in Canada?

I've done a little bit of digging on the matter, but I'm having difficulty finding anything about voting legislation with regards to Black Canadians.

I'm aware Asians and immigrants were denied entry and/or voting privileges during the early 20th century, but I'm not finding anything else.

1 Answers 2015-09-16

How common were overweight or obese people in the Ancient World (3600 B.C. to 500 A.D.)?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2015-09-16

How were WWI veterans treated in the Soviet Union?

2 Answers 2015-09-16

Is America named after Amerigo Vespucci or Richard Amerike?

From what I've read, the favourable opinion is that it's named after Vespucci. However, on an episode of QI I've just watched they rejected this and claimed it is actually named after Amerike.

1 Answers 2015-09-16

What was the significance of Schenectady during the 17th and 18th centuries?

I noticed that Schenectady is attacked during King William's War, and again in the Seven Years War. Was there any reason in particular or did the city just happen to be raided?

1 Answers 2015-09-16

How credible are the claims that the Soviets were actively planning to attack Nazi Germany, except the Germans struck first?

Hi,

I've heard it argued that the Soviets were actively planning to attack the Germans during WW2 when Barbarossa was launched, and it was just a matter of time until this came to pass. Several military historians have proposed this idea and while i haven't read their work (not sure if available in English) I can name a few historians names I've heard others mention - Mikhail Melyutkhov, Boris Sokolov, Joachim Hoffman.

Anyways, I'm wondering how valid the idea was that the Soviets intended to double cross Hitler but were themselves double crossed first? I've always discounted it myself, reasoning that the Soviet's poor initial performance and Stalin's own behavior in the immediate aftermath reflected genuine surprise and unpreparedness of the Sovet leadership, if they'd been intending to attack Germany in the coming months or even weeks.

What does AskHistorians think? This is kind of a blindspot in my own WW2 knowledge because finding information from Soviet, or Russian sources can be difficult without being able to read Russian.

1 Answers 2015-09-16

Have there been any instances of movements for citizens to have "the right to bear swords", or controversy involving citizens owning weapons (similar to gun ownership today)?

Or any instances of school "stabbings/clubbings" similar to school shootings?

1 Answers 2015-09-16

How accurate was the meat packing plant part of *The Jungle*?

I just heard someone claim that Sinclair's meat processing plant was probably not accurate because if it was, we would have known the name of the person who was ground up and sold as lard. Is there an actual case where someone was ground up and sold as food? Is any of Sinclair's description reliable?

2 Answers 2015-09-16

Nazis and Argentina (bear with me)

So I'm pretty sure this is a question that gets asked a lot because, well, whenever it comes to History, Godwin's law is in full effect.

I was watching some behind the scenes stuff about the New Star Wars film when they got to talking about the new bad guys, the "First Order". They said that they were inspired by the question "What if all those high ranking Nazis that fled to South America tried to get together once again?" Well their end result plot wise was essentially the Empire going the way of "What if Neo-Nazis had actual resources and older Nazis to guide them in establishing a state?"

So this got me wondering, I imagine many high ranking Nazis never actually made much of an effort to meet with their former peers--after all that could lead them to being found quicker--if they even knew that others had escaped to South America with them.

While I doubt they'd be really keen on the whole "National Socialism" thing given their predicament and how well it worked the last time (not to mention they were likely not as fanatically devoted as Hitler and some of his closest peers were if they fled and went into hiding) is there any record of if they had any plans while in hiding, or attempted to influence the politics of their new countries?

It's an interesting concept, and I'd like to know more about just what many of them were doing while in hiding.

1 Answers 2015-09-16

How did folks from Ancient Civilization lock their doors?

I was watching a documentary on Ancient Egypt and they talked about door locking devices that were left in tombs. The devices were not for locking doors in the tomb, but for locking doors in the real world. Some historians hypothesized that these devices may have lead to formalizing privacy. Wondering if anyone had any information on these ancient locks?

3 Answers 2015-09-16

Why did neither Phillip II, Alexander or their successors ever fully conquer the Peloponnese?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2015-09-16

Primary source refers to "United Nations" in 1943?

On page one of a 1943 US government document, it says: "The Axis strategy is to use starvation to beat conquered peoples into submission. The United Nations' food strategy is to build with food new power to throw against the Axis"

What? The UN was founded in 1945! A quick wikipedia search couldn't answer this for me, so I thought I'd throw this out there, perhaps giving any scholars of international diplomacy a chance to talk about the creation of international communities in the course of WW2 or prior . . . Anyone able to help?

http://arcweb.sos.state.or.us/pages/exhibits/ww2/services/pdf/ag1.pdf

1 Answers 2015-09-16

Did some slave owners in America have their slaves do illegal activities like theft, etc? What would happen to those slaves?

2 Answers 2015-09-16

Origins of Prostitution

I was re-reading Emma Goldman's work entitled The Traffic In Women and she cited Havelock Ellis' Sex and Society which said that "it would seem that the origin of prostitution is the be found primarily in a religious custom..."

Is this a generally agreed upon idea? Or is it outdated? If prostitution's origins aren't in religion what are it's origins?

1 Answers 2015-09-16

4968 / 7255

Back to start