The Japanese Instrument of Surrender was signed by, on the Allied side, representatives from the US, China, the UK, the USSR, Australia, Canada, France, the Netherlands, and New Zealand. I've heard about what almost all of these countries did in the Pacific War (Canada at least helped defend Hong Kong and helped liberate the Aleutian Islands), but how did France fight against Japan? What I currently know is that the Vichy government let Japan use Indochinese bases and the Free French let the US use New Hebrides as a base, but did French forces ever fight directly against Japan?
3 Answers 2015-09-03
I was reading Stephen Greenblatt's Will in the World a biography of William Shakespeare which gives some minor background on the debate between Catholics and Anglicans. He mentions Edmund Campion who apparently after years of hiding was captured and tortured. After his torture he was pitted in a debate against Anglicans, he had no preparation at all and faced unfair odds but still utterly destroyed the competition on three separate occasions.
I was wondering what that debate or any between these two factions would have looked like. What were key points of contention between the two parties? What would their justifications have been for their positions been?
2 Answers 2015-09-03
I'm reading Aztec by Gary Jennings and he's talking about how smallpox spread like wildfire among the Mexican population when the Spanish arrived. I know there are similar accounts in Native American history. Why don't I ever hear of Europeans suffering from diseases common to the Americas?
1 Answers 2015-09-03
From what I understand, the Mughals were rulers of Persian origins that ruled most of India and by Akbar's rule, most of India, Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan.
Also, from what I know, Akbar was the first Hindustani born Mughal emperor and lead the Mughal empire to its peak.
So do Indians then and today feel that the Mughals represent the peak of their greatness or look towards other Hindustani emperors such as Ashoka?
2 Answers 2015-09-03
Does anyone know any good books or resources on this topic? I'm particularly curious about German soldiers who were captured and imprisoned on the Eastern Front.
This statistic particularly stands out for me "Out of the nearly 110,000 German prisoners captured in Stalingrad, only about 5,000 ever returned." What happened to all these men?
3 Answers 2015-09-03
I'd like to know if any form of social security or other, tax funded, assistance was provided to immigrants in the United States between say 1865 and 1929.
For the purposes of this question social security can be any sort of free, or subsidised, benefit provided to immigrants at any point from their arrival in America, for example: housing, food, health care, education. unemployment insurance, pensions or other cash payments.
I'm primarily interested in tax funded benefits provided by Federal, State or local government, as opposed to charitable work done by churches, labour unions or other non-governmental organisations. I mainly have in mind immigrants arriving from Europe, in case people arriving from other places were treated differently (Chinese immigrants for example).
Thank you in advance // Plicated
1 Answers 2015-09-03
I've been watching a lot of kung fu movies and the majority of them are set in the beginning of the 20th century. The hairstyle seems very common. Where did it originate from and what caused it to disappear?
2 Answers 2015-09-03
3 Answers 2015-09-03
Italy owned the German speaking province of south Tryol which they achieved after switching sides in WWI gaining the province from the much hated Treaty of Versailles. This makes Italy seem like an unlikely ally for the Nazis.
So why did the Nazis ally them? and what did the German foreign ministry or the German public think of this decision? It just seems unlikely and contradictory considering the German disdain of Versailles.
1 Answers 2015-09-03
This piece in The Independent makes the argument that as Jeremy Corbyn today is considered an "unelectable extremist" who will damage the reputation of the Labour Party indefinitely in the eyes of voters, so was Margaret Thatcher so considered before her landslide win in 1979.
A lot of the comments are calling bullshit on this, and saying that Thatcher enjoyed an enormous amount of support and so the charge that she was considered unelectable when she became leader of the Conservative Party in 1975 is, essentially, a load of hogwash.
Could anyone elaborate on what the truth is regarding either of these viewpoints? Particularly amongst Tory grandees and the press? I've heard it before that Thatcher was considered unelectable by some, but never really any corroboration for that view.
2 Answers 2015-09-03
Who made that decision and why?
2 Answers 2015-09-03
Many people in the south voted Democrat up until the 1960s and many northern states voted Republican also until the 1960s. What caused the change that generally southern and mountain west states vote Republican and northern and western states vote Democrat?
1 Answers 2015-09-03
The votes are in, and August's winners are clear!
Paying me the most Topping the votes, and taking the "User's Choice" award for the month was /u/Imperial_Affectation, for their answer to the question: "The Republic of Turkey sent 15,000 men to fight in the Korean War, making up the third largest United Nation force after the US and UK. Why did Turkey send so many troops to such a distant war?"
Edging out the competition for the "Flair's Choice" award was /u/dubstripsquads, writing in answer to: "How were non-black minorities treated in the Jim Crow South?".
Congratulations to the winners, and a thank you to the people who helped out by voting and linking threads in the Sunday Digest, as well as thanks to everyone who contributed in the past month!
5 Answers 2015-09-03
I realize this is almost an inherently unanswerable question, given that we don't know what what we don't know, and we don't know what we may eventually uncover that could radically change our perception of any given time period - but, as it stands now, are there any periods in, say, Roman history, or Chinese history, or any history, in which there's essentially nothing left to be gleaned from the sources and archaeology we have available to us, and we feel like we've got a firm and accurate grasp on?
3 Answers 2015-09-03
Did prominent figures within the Roman empire try to justify the continuation of the Roman cultural identity, or was it largely accepted at this point that being Roman had very little or nothing to do with Rome?
1 Answers 2015-09-03
The US was the only one to adopt the M1 Garand and have a semi-auto as their standard rifle. Why was it so difficult for other major countries to do the same when semi-automatic and automatic technology existed since WW1 (as in handguns and machine guns)? I know the Germans and Russians had semi-auto rifles, but why weren't they widespread like the US?
1 Answers 2015-09-03
Which do you use? Why? Is it more important to use one over another? Does it give credibillity?
1 Answers 2015-09-03
The wikipedia page on Mati Das (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bhai_Mati_Das) mentions that he was sawed into two on the express orders of Aurangzeb (he was asked to convert to Islam). Is it true ?
1 Answers 2015-09-03
With all the talk of the chinese victory celebrations it occurred to me that I don't really know very much about the chinese side of WW2 in east Asia.
Is it even reasonable to celebrate "defeating" japan in this fashion?
In my, admittedly, not very well-read mind Japan was primarily beaten by naval blockade and aerial bombing of the Japanese mainland finished with the atomic bombs and the Soviet invasion of Manchuria.
What part did China play in japans defeat?
1 Answers 2015-09-03
Hello. I’m Gillian O’Brien, Reader in Modern Irish History at Liverpool John Moores University. Earlier this year the University of Chicago Press published my book "Blood Runs Green. The Murder that Transfixed Gilded Age Chicago" (http://press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book/chicago/B/bo19966410.html). The book is about an murder of an Irish doctor in Chicago in 1889. At the time it generated enormous interest partly because it was an unusual and particularly brutal murder, partly because a number of influential figures in Chicago were implicated in the crime and partly because the murder was the result of a long-running feud within the secret Irish American revolutionary society Clan na Gael.
In addition to my work on Irish America I research, write and teach about the eighteenth and nineteenth century Irish history particularly the 1798 Rebellion, Georgian Dublin and the history of primary education. I am also work on a number of museum and heritage projects where my role is that of the historical consultant. The role varies from job to job and ranges from offering advice as to the content to be included to choosing the artefacts that will be displayed. In some cases I also write the panel text and the accompanying guidebooks. At the moment I’m working on two projects in Ireland – both were former prisons so I’ve been dealing with lots of issues associated with ‘Dark Tourism’.
I’m happy to answer questions about my book, research or museum work (I can’t answer specific questions in relation to the museums as they are both works in progress, but will answer general ones). You can find more information here: gillianmobrien.wordpress.com or on twitter: @gillianmobrien
8 Answers 2015-09-03