What's the best response to people who dismiss widespread consensus by referring to so called "bourgeois historians"?

4 Answers 2015-08-10

What have been your favorite /r/Askhistorians AMAs?

Since 2012, /r/Askhistorians has been fortunate enough to host some fine historians for AMAs. The admins have asked us to compile a list of our 10 favorites and offer suggestions for more, and as the person generally in charge of AMAs here, I've been working on that list. Now, I'd like to hear from you! I'm planning to submit that list in about six hours, and I'm interested in hearing what you have to say until then!

11 Answers 2015-08-10

Why were there broadcasts in TV about Nelson Mandela dying in the 1970s, when he only died a few years ago?

I distinctly remember, and believed for years, he died in 1979. I remember seeing a report too. What's up with that?

1 Answers 2015-08-10

Would the Eiffel Tower have been built differently if it was originally intended to be permanent?

I've read that the Eiffel Tower was intended as a temporary attraction for the 1889 World’s Fair and then it was supposed to have been dismantled. I've always wondered, if they had known it was going to become permanent, would they have built it differently? (For example, a stronger foundation, rust resistant materials or finishes, etc.)

I'm also curious about the same thing in regards to the London Eye.

6 Answers 2015-08-10

During the cold war were there ever serious worries that even if the president gave the order, some of the guys manning the silos would just refuse the launch the missiles?

2 Answers 2015-08-10

How did the Soviets differ from the Bolsheviks?

1 Answers 2015-08-10

Who was Taríacuri? How did he establish the Tarascan state? How was he a visionary leader and what was he before that?

I can't find much info online- a google book without previews, Wikipedia and that's about it. According to Wikipedia he was a visionary leader and founder of the Tarascan state, but what is even meant by visionary leader? Was he previously a military commander? How much is known about him?

1 Answers 2015-08-10

What is the oldest reference to the phenomenon of sneezing when exposed to bright lights?

A pretty obscure question, really I'm both interested to know and trying to ask a question that arose in my head to do with artificial light sources. This post taught me all about how modern lighting has changed our sleep cycle, and this quote made me wonder if perhaps modern lighting has something to do with the phenomenon of sneezing when exposed to bright lights.

When modern lighting was invented the enormous physiological impact of it - and it's absence - was widely agreed upon by contemporary scientists. Charles A. Czeisler, chronobiologist, commented "we are inadvertently taking a drug that affects how we sleep".

Another curiosity of mine is simply that I wonder how far back it may have been that people first noticed and documented the phenomenon.

1 Answers 2015-08-10

Did anyone guard and maintain Stonehenge once it was erected?

Was there a religious prohibition against going if you were not a druid? Did the local ruler have sway over access and repair/modification?

1 Answers 2015-08-10

I'm writing a history book- any advice?

I was just reading Monsters in America by Poole- he says something in the intro about how (paraphrasing, forgive) academics have lost touch with the public and the public only reads pop history because it is a damn good yarn and nothing else.

I really want to bridge that gap with the book I am writing. It is about a murder in 1896 and I'm trying to put the story within the context of the time so that the reader will know what was happening in the US in the late nineteenth century (roughly).

Any general advice or suggestions? Am I crazy for not using footnotes? Should it have any "narrative" qualities? Any thoughts would be appreciated.

4 Answers 2015-08-10

Considering the broken spell of war-romanticism in WWI, how did people recruit for WWII?

I'm thinking particularily of Germany, but also other countries that weren't in a life or death situation.

How do you get people to fight (unless its life/death) only 20ish years after the unmitigated horror that was WWI?

WWI is more understandable to me, as war was seen more as a jolly good time then the horrid sufferfest it turned out to be.

How did people who fought in the first sign up for a second modern war?

How did parents who'd survived the first send their children?

I can understand the countries who fought for their lives, but countries who didn't have to. How could you even convince people to get out there?

edit: I'm talking about people who volunteered

1 Answers 2015-08-10

During the American Revolution, did any colonies come close to remaining loyal to the Crown?

I've read that the northern colonies were far more hawkish, which is usually attributed to British taxation being a much bigger economic issue for the New York/New England shipping industry.

The impression I've always gotten is that the South was more on the fence with the whole war thing because the cotton/tobacco trading situation was suiting them fine under England's rule. On the other hand, England seemed like it was moving a lot faster to outlaw slavery, which (I'd imagine) would make secession a lot more attractive to southern colonies.

tl;dr was there a serious movement in South Carolina or Georgia or anywhere else to be like "Hey let's stay with England!" If so, how close was that to being a reality?

1 Answers 2015-08-10

The history of high heeled shoes in society

1 Answers 2015-08-10

If the U.S. First Amendment guarantees religious freedom, how were the witch trials constitutional?

1 Answers 2015-08-10

What is the historical view on who is the leading candidate in a US election? The person best tied into political machinery and wealth, or the person bringing the most attendance to rallies and the like?

1 Answers 2015-08-10

How do the people of Poland view Napoleon, or how is his legacy taught from the Polish perspective?

I've been reading on the French Republic and subsequent French Empire and I found the subject of Poland very interesting. Napoleon destroyed his entire empire trying to create and defend the Duchy of Warsaw. How is this viewed in Poland, is he a celebrated hero, despised as a conqueror, is it bittersweet? I wonder what the perspective is.

2 Answers 2015-08-10

Can anyone shed any light on even what launguage this sword inscription is in?

In 1825, a mysterious double edged sword containing a cryptic code was found in the River Witham near Lincoln in England. The 13th century sword contains an enigmatic 18-letter message running down the center of the blade, and cryptographers and linguists have been unable to crack it. The British Library is now appealing to the public for help in solving this 800 year old mystery.

http://www.ancient-origins.net/news-general/medieval-sword-contains-cryptic-code-british-library-appeals-help-crack-it-003571

1 Answers 2015-08-10

Who was the deadliest swordsman with evidence to support the claim?

1 Answers 2015-08-10

What role did religion play in the Ottoman expansion in central Europe?

I've read various articles (mostly Wikipedia and history blogs) but i cannot grasp the role of religion for the Ottomans: Was spreading Islam the main motivation that fueled their conquest? Was Vienna THE bulwark of Christianity or just a local battle, which happen to be the physical endpoint of the Ottomans reach? And what are those "golden apples"?

1 Answers 2015-08-10

D-Day: Why did the Allies run into the Atlantic Wall instead of invading Southern France and moving north?

The Atlantic Wall was very well defended and stopped the Allies for several years. Prior to D-Day, the Allies had taken North Africa and most of Italy.

This provided plenty of staging area to invade Southern France and move northward to Paris, Northern France, Low Countries, and into Germany. If Western France could be encircled and destroyed, the Allies would have another landing site closer to the UK.

Was this option considered? From my point of view, timing this with Operation Bagration could have worked even better than D-Day.

1 Answers 2015-08-10

What was the attitude of the common Korean people during and before the Korean War? How effective was the 38th parallel in dividing the people of the once-unified Korea?

Edit: Attitude of Southerners towards Northerners and vice versa. Was the partition somewhat like the India-Pakistan split of 1947?

1 Answers 2015-08-10

How was Napoleon influenced by Charlemagne?

I know that Napoleon crowned himself unlike Charlemagne because he didn't want the Pope to have power over him like he did over Charlemagne, but what else? Their conquests look kind of similar but I imagine that's just a coincidence. Was Charlemagne just a propaganda piece or was he more?

1 Answers 2015-08-10

Did ancient Egyptians have the same skin color as modern ones?

2 Answers 2015-08-10

Which is, in your opinion, the biggest financial scandal before 1950?

1 Answers 2015-08-10

Why did the age of consent increase so much throughout history?

1 Answers 2015-08-10

5089 / 7255

Back to start