Why, after Charlemagne, did France remain large and (generally) unified, whereas Germany split in to many small states?

I feel it has something to do with the difference in how each branch of Charlemage's family grew, but I feel there should have been some sort of consolidation in Germany at some point prior to the 19th century. Was it that the HRE was 'state' enough to not need to federalize? Was it the structures left behind by the Romans or the strength of the Carolingian power bases? Was it geography?

3 Answers 2015-06-18

Why are naval ships in modern times so often scuttled after their service, rather than refitted or scrapped?

Is it not worth the effort to dismantle them and sell for scrap or other useful materials?

2 Answers 2015-06-18

Have we discovered anything new in Latin in the last 100 years?

Seems we discover ancient greek writings all the time(though most are incredibly fragmentary and are rarely translated) in the Egyptian desert. Though for latin that appears to be very rare that new Latin works are discovered in this manner.

1 Answers 2015-06-18

I've heard a "theory" that the discrepancy between the policies of candidates before and after being elected POTUS could be due to their access to top secret information after their election. Is there some historical data to support this based on since-then declassified info?

6 Answers 2015-06-18

Why did Central Eastern Europe transfer away from Communism so easily?

Something I've been pondering, Central Eastern European countries (Poland, Czech Republic, Slovakia, Hungary) seem to have quite smoothly moved from Communist dictatorship to democracy quite smoothly, even the break up of Czechoslovakia was peaceful. How did this happen after some 30+ years of Soviet propaganda? Does propaganda not take when it's too contrary to everyday observation?

2 Answers 2015-06-18

How prevalent was homosexuality among monks in the Middle Ages?

4 Answers 2015-06-18

What is the earliest evidence of the existence of the Old Testament?

I know that traditional Judaism places the writing of the Old Testament ("Torah") ~1300 BCE, while historians generally believe it was written significantly later than that. What is the earliest contemporary evidence of its existence- either in the form of a manuscript (according to Wikipedia the earliest one is late 2nd century BCE) or other sources referencing it?

1 Answers 2015-06-18

Do battlecruisers deserve the bad reputation they received due to the sinkings of HMS Hood and Renown in World War II?

It strikes me that Hood was destroyed by an exceedingly lucky shot, while Renown Repulse performed about as well as a large ship without air cover or effective screens could in the face of massed aerial attack. Is there a more nuanced way of looking at them than "too little armor, sitting ducks?"

3 Answers 2015-06-18

Is it true that all U.S. presidents except M. Van Buren are descended from John Landlack?

So this thing is always recurring in /r/todayilearned, and almost always the only proof is just this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HGrbJ4_jcc8 . And so Im curious whether this could really be the case.

1 Answers 2015-06-18

Happy "Battle of Waterloo" day everyone. Shouldn't that period, 1812 - 1815 have been called World War 1?

It involved pretty much the same actors - most of Europe plus North America and Russia, just allied slightly differently: France playing Germany's role and the USA on the wrong side! What made the 1914-18 war the first official World War instead?

2 Answers 2015-06-18

Did Canada Ever Have Slavery?

I know that there were slaves in Britain and America, but I have no idea if Canada had them or not. We definitely didn't learn anything about that subject when I was in school.

2 Answers 2015-06-18

Just how brutal was the vigilante response to the supporters of the Vichy Regime after France was liberated?

1 Answers 2015-06-18

Looking for a good Napoleon biography.

I'm looking for one that is preferably not just a recount of his military exploits. If it comes as an audio book even better, long drive this weekend.

3 Answers 2015-06-18

Korean War propaganda flyer disposition

I came across a dozen flyers from around 1952, and I am not sure what to do with them. They are a bit wrinkled but very readable, image and on other side a long message in Korean, half-sheet size. Most are UN side, one looks like NK side. Are they historic?
Are they are so unique or historically valuable, and if so, should I donate them to some collection or post to a KW forum?

Korean War flyer circa 1952

1 Answers 2015-06-18

Have Muslim Countries ever experienced military weakness during Ramadan?

It seems as if a time during which food intake is limited would be a severe weakness for soldiers. Are there any examples of this influencing warfare?

1 Answers 2015-06-18

Did classical composers such as Tchaikovsky and Beethoven have other occupations or did they just come from a wealthy background.

I'm assuming that composers in the early and mid 1800 s did not make much money. so how did they make a living and maintain the lifestyle that they led?

2 Answers 2015-06-18

What was Israels position during the Iran-Iraq War?

I remember reading something that claimed that Israel actually supported Iran with spare parts and technical know-how for their American made weapons to win an ally against Iraq. So I was wondering if their is any truth to this.

1 Answers 2015-06-18

Who are the greatest military minds that are widely unknown?

1 Answers 2015-06-18

What was the earliest example of something we'd call an "airport novel" today?

I've also heard airport novels called trash/pulp fiction. They are, naturally, the sort of mass market books sold in places like airports and dollar stores. They are novels written to appeal to a wide audience to ease the boredom of travel. They have simple vocabularies, are often fast-paced and showcase exotic adventures, and are printed very cheaply.

I've always thought that until relatively recently, reading for pleasure was a thing reserved for the upper crust. Is that true? If it isn't, what was an early example of a book that was widely popular and accessible to the common person? Who was the first John Grisham or Tom Clancy?

1 Answers 2015-06-18

Was the main rationale behind the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki the prevention of Soviet expansion in the East? Did the bombings actually hasten the end of the war?

I was reading this tumblr post which argues - somewhat compellingly, from my amateur perspective - that the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki served essentially no role in forcing/expediting Japan's surrender at the end of World War II, but instead served to preempt Soviet expansion in East Asia.

I've also heard the argument that what forced Japan's surrender was less the atomic bombings than the pending involvement of the Soviet Union in war against Japan. Was the Soviet invasion of Manchuria enough to force Japan to surrender on its own? Or was the Japanese leadership willing to (and the Japanese economy/population able to ) continue the war and defend the home islands in the absence of the atomic bombings?

2 Answers 2015-06-18

It's 1797, You are a samurai who has just assaulted & raped a peasant women. What does the Law say should happen to you? What will in practice happen to you?

1 Answers 2015-06-18

Why not even one person out of the 200 million brainwashed citizens of USSR did not go out on street in 1989 and protest in favor of communism ?

1 Answers 2015-06-18

Why didn't China/Japan discover or colonise the New World by travelling East? Or even Australia?

As we all know, the New World was discovered and colonised largely by Europeans travelling West. Notwithstanding the difference in distance requiring travel (the Atlantic being narrower than the Pacific, making it more traversable; having said that - the Bering Sea?), why didn't any of the large Asian civilisations, such as the Chinese, 'discover' the New World or Australia?

Furthermore, even when such lands were discovered by the more modern world, why did they not colonise these new places, whilst, for example, the European settlers were slowly making their way over-land across the Americas towards the Pacific? Why not plonk new cities along the American-Pacific coast themselves?

Basically, why do we have San Francisco and not San Fransokyo?

1 Answers 2015-06-18

Medieval Rape vs. Modern Rape

2 Answers 2015-06-18

Suppose you are a Visigothic in AD 398. What would it be like to live in amongst a wandering group of people who have no fixed territory? Where do you get food and shelter from one day to next?

1 Answers 2015-06-18

5281 / 7255

Back to start