Cast Your Votes! - Best of /r/AskHistorians May Balloting!

Hello everyone!

We are introducing a new little initiative in /r/AskHistorians today! Every month, we'll be recognizing two of the best posts from the previous month, with one "People's Choice Award" handed out based on voting from the sub as a whole, and a "Flair's Choice Award" based on voting from just our panel members. The winners get to enjoy a little star next to their name for the next month, and will have their answers enshrined in a special showcase on the wiki.

This thread is seeded with answers plucked from answers highlighted on the Twitter feed, as well as answers posted to the Sunday Digest threads of the past month (so make sure to help us out and keep them well populated!), but if you don't see the answer you think deserves to win here, feel free to submit ones not listed.

To talk about this generally, please keep responses confined to this post. Top level responses which are not nominated answers will be removed.

31 Answers 2015-06-01

What caused the downfall of the Islamic countries from their golden age?

1 Answers 2015-06-01

Was Henry Ford an anti-Semite, a Nazi sympathizer, or neither?

2 Answers 2015-06-01

What is the smallest estimate of the size of Xerxes' invasion force into Greece?

What is the smallest estimate of the size of Xerxes' invasion force into Greece? How many of these would be soldiers?

1 Answers 2015-06-01

Just how urbanised were the Olmecs?

1 Answers 2015-06-01

Why have the US and Canada been dominated by white people while all countries from Mexico south are composed mostly of brown people?

I know a fair bit about the settling of the New World. Currently, I am reading a book called 1491 which has led me to this question.

Disease wiped out huge populations in the first 150 years or so as the New World was being colonized. There were also battles that turned into massacres. I understand that there were historically larger populations in Central and South America and that there has historically been a white ruling class in many Central and South American countries.

None of these factors seem to account for the huge discrepancy in the ethnicity of the bulk of the populations of these regions, however. The aboriginal population in Canada has been 3-4% and growing for the last couple of decades. Most of those people would be considered mestizo.

If we look at a country such as Peru, Europeans constitute about 15% of the population ( I am getting these stats from Wikipedia) with most of the remaining being Amerindian or mestizo.

So, what accounts for the huge discrepancy?

2 Answers 2015-06-01

The population of Berlin was essentially devastated at the end of WW2. So who lived in West Berlin after the war, and what appeal was there to keep living there during the Cold War, and during the era of the Berlin Wall?

1 Answers 2015-06-01

Wikipedia claims that there were concrete structures in Finland in the 16th century, centuries before the invention of modern concrete. There is no source though. Does anybody know more about this?

The Canal du Midi was built using concrete in 1670, and there are concrete structures in Finland that date from the 16th century.^[citation ^needed]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concrete

I can find similar rumors all over the internet, but no reliable sources. Does anybody know more about this?

2 Answers 2015-06-01

How many people were killed during the French Revolution?

Are there any reliable numbers, esp. during Robbespierre's reign of terror?

1 Answers 2015-06-01

Were there any British/German writers who wrote that World War I couldn't happen due to extensive globalization?

This has been driving me insane lately. I remember that Dan Carlin mentioned in his "Logical Insanity" series that some journalist or author wrote about how a World War was impossible in the weeks after Franz Ferdinand's assassination. He wrote something along the lines of "the world is too globalized for such a massive conflict to take place. Nobody is willing to throw away such an intricate and profitable system for one war."

Google has been no help and re-listening to the podcast yielded no results. Can anyone help?

2 Answers 2015-06-01

What were the reactions to the first and second triumvirate in ancient Rome?

How did the senate/military/citizens react to the formation of both triumvirates?

1 Answers 2015-06-01

To what extent was the ideology of Arab Nationalism influenced by Nazism?

1 Answers 2015-06-01

Was the Soviet Union a Communist country?

Hello guys,

The highlight of my weekend was a spirited debate with my girlfriend after she insisted the Soviet Union was a Communist Country. We got onto this discussion after I mentioned I had been reading about the economy of the Soviet Union during my lunch break. Now as far as I was aware the Soviet union wasn't Communist seen as it wasn't "stateless" nor "classless" etc.

My girlfriend is a teacher, private tutor of subjects including history (which also is a hobby/interest of hers), studied history at Uni ya da ya da ya da.

She is, to all intents and purposes, much brighter and academic than me. But I feel I have her beat on this point.

What do you think /rAskHistorians?

I appreciate you taking the time to answer my question.

2 Answers 2015-06-01

"The Umayyad Caliphate actively discouraged Islamic conversions because of the jizya tax" how true is this statement?

1 Answers 2015-06-01

How was Domestic Abuse handled when it happend in the marriage of people from 2 different noble houses? How did the church treat domestic abuse since there is no "divorce"?

Lets give it a time period, Lets say during the Musket and Bayonet age-Napoleon age, around 18th +, That should give us some reliable records.

1 Answers 2015-06-01

Imagine a young German soldier on the Russian front in 1942, imagine a German soldier (of similar age & rank) working as a guard in an interment camp in Germany or one of pacified parts of Europe. How much and in what ways, do the two men’s living conditions likely differ?

1 Answers 2015-06-01

Do we know how many important rulers ( Kings and dukes) were actually killed by the black death?

2 Answers 2015-06-01

Pretenders to the throne of France during the Third Republic.

I'm reading Stephen Kotkin's Stalin biography and when describing Imperial Russia and the royal family he mentions that Alexander III originally wanted the tsesarevich, the future Nicholas II, to marry Princess Hélène d'Orléans, the daughter of Prince Philippe d'Orléans, Comte de Paris, the pretender to the French throne. The purpose of this match would supposedly have been to strengthen the bonds between Russia and the French Republic.

I find this slightly odd. Wouldn't the government of France have been provoked by a marriage between the heir to a foreign power and the daughter of a man who claimed that he was the legitimate ruler of France and, consequently, that the Republic was not legitimate?

I would be most grateful if anyone could shed some light on this, and perhaps also on the role of the French pretenders more generally in European diplomacy at the time.

1 Answers 2015-06-01

Have Christians always buried the dead well-dressed?

Today in the West we bury our dead with suits; in the long middle ages the royalty buried the elites with gems and fancy clothes.

But what about earlier period Christians like in late antiquity and in apostolic ages? What about Christians in other societies, e.g. Syrian, African, Chinese? Do Christian burial practices significantly vary across time and space?

1 Answers 2015-06-01

Whose fault was the Sino-Soviet Split?

I've studied a fair amount of Communist-bloc history and have noticed the following trend:

Sovietologists seem to blame the split on the diplomatic failures of the Soviet government: that Khrushchev's eccentricity, pettiness, and rather poorly disguised racism, as well as some other qualities shared by those in his clique, pushed away the Chinese as an ally

Whilst Sinologists tend to do the same thing for Mao Zedong: that Mao's craziness, irrationality, and obsessiveness pushed away the Soviets as a valuable ally.

So, whose fault was it?

1 Answers 2015-06-01

Has there ever been a war where one side had the intention of completely erasing the other from existence?

1 Answers 2015-06-01

Does anyone know any good books about Armenian history?

2 Answers 2015-06-01

How big of a deal was PTSD in the ancient world?

I'd argue that pre-industrial warfare was even more brutal than today because warriors literally hacked each other to pieces. But I've never read anything about these guys suffering PTSD.

2 Answers 2015-06-01

Did the final push of Allies during the last hours of WW1 like at Meuse Argonne have any significant impact on the war's political endgame or would it have likely been the same if everyone stayed put till the Armistice?

2 Answers 2015-06-01

How come so many contemporary English words about spycraft are French words? (espionage, sabotage, reconnaissance, coup, rogue, etc...)

2 Answers 2015-06-01

5343 / 7255

Back to start