Why did the whites win in Finland but not Russia?

1 Answers 2015-04-18

Why did the French Revolution not copy the American Revolution and let France become a stable democracy?

2 Answers 2015-04-18

How were the corners of musket protected from cavalry charges by pikes in the Spanish Tercio?

The Tercio was a massive formation with as many as 1,000 pike men in a large solid central block with smaller blocks of shot deployed at each corner:

So what prevented enemy cavalry from sweeping away the exposed corners of shot with a cavalry charge that avoided the central pike bloc?

Did the pikemen expand their formation in to a hollow square to protect the shot?

Did he shot retreat into the square or around the square under the deployed pikes?

And were the rear corners of shot positioned to provide all around fire power or are these the reload positions with the firing positions at the front corners?

In general, if musketeers took refuge kneeling under a protective canopy of pikes to avoid being trampled by cavalry, how may rows of shot could be protected by a line of leveled pikes?

1 Answers 2015-04-18

What is the earliest documented instance of humour?

3 Answers 2015-04-18

Were there Jewish Nazis and/or Black KKK members?

1 Answers 2015-04-18

Was Spanish King Sancho VII at 7'4" the tallest ever monarch in recorded history?

The wiki article states that historian and forensic anthropologist, Luis del Campo, who studied King Sancho VII of Navarre's mortal remains, affirms that he was 2.23 metres (7.3 feet) in height.

Wouldn't that make him the tallest monarch in history? Or were there monarchs taller than him?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sancho_VII_of_Navarre

Anyways what surprised me was that he lived to be nearly 80 years old despite his huge height.

4 Answers 2015-04-18

Were the textile mills of America (industrial revolution) an improvement for the lives of those who worked in them?

On one hand the pay was low and the hours were long (and often the textile workers lived in a mill town, effectively meaning their entire lives revolved around their work.

On the other, it would presumably have been a new sense of freedom for the (mainly) women working there due to earning a wage, and maybe was a better life than what they would have lived on the farm?

I'm aware that there were some protests among the Lowell Mill Girls, but was that widespread or were many quite content? Are there any historians who have studied this issue?

1 Answers 2015-04-18

Cambodian genocide - legally incorrect term?

Hi guys, this might be a legal question, but isn't it legally incorrect to classify the entire Khmer Rouge and its killings as genocidal?

Most of the victims were ethnic Khmers, targeted not for their status as Khmers (a national or ethnic group) but for their political status.

Is there therefore a difference between the legal crime of genocide and the mass killings of an ethnic, racial, religious and/or national group that is commonly called genocide?

3 Answers 2015-04-18

How accurate is the book "Las venas abiertas de América Latina" ("Open veins of Latin America"), by the recently deceased Eduardo Galeano?

1 Answers 2015-04-18

How did Alexander the Great's phalangites fare against missiles compared to hoplites of the same period?

In terms of armour, equipment and tactics, how did a phalangite protect themselves from missiles and how does a hoplite compare? As far as I know they had a small shield strapped to them and their sarrissas in the air provided a screen to block arrows.

How does this hold up against say, slingers or javelin armed men? How does a hoplite from say, Athens, compare in being able to block incoming missiles? How different is the protection offered to men in the back ranks compared to those in the front?

2 Answers 2015-04-18

Why did the Axis start a two-front war, instead of conquering the west and south-east Asia first, and focusing down the Soviet Union together after that?

2 Answers 2015-04-18

What is the oldest recorded mass suicide?

1 Answers 2015-04-18

How did the linear pike and shot tactics of the Swedish Army of Gustavus Adolphus actually work?

I keep looking at these neatly drawn formations of the Swedish brigade (their basic infantry tactical unit) and it looks as if the companies of shot in the center have to fire over or through the line of pikes in front of it. And with the wings of shot extending beyond the lines of pike both right and left, how did the form a continuous defensive line? How did they form a square against cavalry charges with only three lines of pike? The formation as shown does not seem to make any sense:

                     PPPP
                      SSSS

SSSS PPPP.........PPPP SSSS

                      SSSS

1 Answers 2015-04-18

I've always read about war horses being "man-killers" and recently read about a 17th century war horse disembowling a groom. Were horses really that dangerous?

I know that a horse can easily trample people to death during battle, and forgive me of my ignorance, but I run across stories of dangerous horses and they seem a little extreme. Could a horse really disembowel a man ?

8 Answers 2015-04-18

The Iranian Revolution: Why did it occur, why was the U.S. involved, and what are its lasting impacts?

The reason for this question is:

My girlfriend's father is Iranian, although his family is from Azerbaijan, from what I understand. He fled Iran during the revolution, finding sanctuary in the Philippines (where he met my GF's mother, who is Japanese. Both of her parents now live in Japan, and she is Japanese. My girlfriend is 1/2 Japanese and 1/2 Azerbaijani/Iranian.

I'm asking for information because I'm going to be meeting her father at our college graduation next month, and I want to be able to understand his background and have meaningful conversations with him about America, Iran, Azerbaijan, the whole nine yards.

I should also probably mention that she has told me that her father does not like Americans (until she met me, at least), and that her Middle-Eastern family sounds very fragmented and different as a result of the revolution. For example, apparently her uncle (father's brother), was abducted by Iranian forces and is now a "propagandist" for the Iranian government.

What do I need to know about this situation to be able to have a real conversation with her father about all of these issues that pre-date our births, let alone relationship?

1 Answers 2015-04-18

Has the Dalai Lama (current or former) ever been an asshole/dick?

1 Answers 2015-04-18

Recommendations for a biography of Napoleon

There are hundreds of them, and I don't much want to read more than one.

What's your favourite?

What's the most accessible?

What's the most authoritative?

What's considered to be the "classic"?

What's the most controversial?

2 Answers 2015-04-18

What happened to the pets of Jews in Germany during the Holocaust?

2 Answers 2015-04-18

[META] What are the qualities of a good source?

I have looked through the past history of meta posts and found excellent answers on how best to write top-level responses here, here and here.

The sources cited in the answers I have read have generally been sound, so my question is more about what disqualifies a source from being relevant. I admit, I don't have much knowledge of answers that have been deleted for this reason (because they have been deleted) so this is based on one recent post.

There was a long top level answer that cited several books and quoted relevant paragraphs from each of them to paint a broad and seemingly accurate picture. However, there were complaints about his sources and soon after the entire thread was deleted. The complaints were:

  • "The [first] book is written by an economist, not a historian. Hence it is not relevant." This despite the fact that the author had received a Nobel Prize for somewhat related work and had first-hand experience of the events being spoken about.

  • "The [second] book is written by a journalist, not a historian. Hence it is not relevant." The person complaining did not cite any other reasons why the book was bad. He even got the name of the author completely wrong. FWIW, BBC's review of the book was extremely positive called it a "scholarly investigation" that relied on primary sources.

  • "The [third] book is written by an author whose other works are political. Hence he is probably biased."

Let me be clear that I have no interest in discussing the topic of the thread itself. I only ask if these valid criticisms of the sources? I think I speak for many when I say that clarity on this would be great.

5 Answers 2015-04-18

In 1941, the British sent a captured Messerschmitt Bf 110 to the U.S. so American engineers could have a look at her. The Vultee Aircraft Company created an exhaustive report on the aircraft. Does anyone know what happened to the aircraft after Vultee was done with it?

My brain tells me they scrapped it, but my heart wants to believe there's a disassembled Bf 110 sequestered away in some forgotten aircraft hangar in California.

1 Answers 2015-04-18

What do you believe are the key points for Lenin and the Bolshevik revolution during Russia in 1917?

I am revising for an upcoming exam and I have to discuss Russia & the Soviet Union from 1917-1945, one of the syllabus points is the Bolshevik Consolidation of power from 1917-1934 and since I use palm cards to help me study, there isn't a lot of room to fit. I don't want anyone to go into a lot of detail, but more help me in the right direction for what you lovely people believe are the main points I should include on the palm card. (I have 16 lines if it helps)

Thank you!

1 Answers 2015-04-18

Do we have anything written by Shakespeare that is not a play or poem? i.e. diaries, essays, newspaper articles

2 Answers 2015-04-18

Was Jesus an apocalyptic Jew?

Just to clarify:

I am asking whether Jesus believed that apocalypse would occur within his lifetime or the lifetime of his followers, or if he believed that the apocalypse would eventually occur at an unknown time.

2 Answers 2015-04-18

Did the events of the Medz Yeghern constitute genocide, yes or no? And if yes, why doesn't Turkey and its allies admit, apologise and move on?

Really, what's going on?

1 Answers 2015-04-18

Did Ancient Rome have any restaurants? Places where people would sit and order food and socialize? If not, then when did restaurants become the norm?

2 Answers 2015-04-18

5511 / 7255

Back to start