Why is holocaust denial/holocaust revisions you illegal in some places?

2 Answers 2015-04-14

What Kind of Main Land Military Force Did Japan Have Prior to Their Surrender and What Would the Invasion Have Been Like?

The U.S. damaged the Japanese forces severely over the course of the war. My question is, at the end of the war, if Japan had decided to stick and invasion out, what kind of main land forces were left for the U.S.? Old men and children with mostly broken weapons like Germany near the end of WW2 or still very formidable? Thx commenteditsharesavehidedeletensfw

1 Answers 2015-04-14

List of historic life expectancies?

I'm just watching a documentary, and the presenter just said that life expectancy in London used to be 35 years in medieval times.

If I understood correctly, almost every time people say that you were supposed to die by age 30 or 40 in ancient times, this is based on the wrongly calculated life expectancy which was severely diminished by the extremely high probability of dieing when really young. I.e.: if you'd make it to e.g. 15 years old, you actually had a good shot of growing older than the number given by the stated life expectancy.

So, is there good data on the age an average citizen might expect to live in different time, given that this citizen has managed to turn 20 (or so) years?

2 Answers 2015-04-14

If Hitler was not so antisemetic would he have been known as one of the greatest rulers ever?

1 Answers 2015-04-14

Why are there so many Palestinians in Chile?

1 Answers 2015-04-14

Zofia Kossak-Szczucka and anti-semitism

Why did Zofia Kossak-Szczucka found a group to help Jews during the Nazi occupation of Poland when she herself was an antisemite? I'm not convinced that it was just to oppose the regime, as there were many other ways to do that.

1 Answers 2015-04-14

Were the Vietnam era protests effective?

Specifically what I am referring to is a comment I saw on askreddit some time ago. I would link it if I could find it but it was a highly upvoted comment saying something along the lines of (paraphrasing): "the protests by college students and 'hippies' actually hindered efforts to end the war. Politicians and regular citizens already wanted the war to end and all the hippies did was make the issues worse. The fact that such a niche counterculture supported a common sentiment only served to discredit it."

Is there any truth to this? Did they (hippies) have any measured impact one way or the other? Or were they just protesting something that was inevitably going to happen anyway?

2 Answers 2015-04-14

In portraits and statues, when did the horse's stance come to symbolize the rider's fate?

When looking at statues and artwork of famous military leaders, the horse is often given one of three stances: all legs down if the rider survived, a raised leg if the rider was injured but victorious, and both front legs raised if the soldier fell in battle, or was defeated.

When did this artistic custom regarding the horse appear and become somewhat codified?

EDIT: I am basing my question largely from US 18th-19th century monuments, in particular the Revolutionary and Civil War.

1 Answers 2015-04-14

My Mom, Marines, went to Panama sometime in the mid 90's. What happened there?

1 Answers 2015-04-14

Why did the Karling kingdoms of East Francia and Italy fail to stay united, like West Francia and instead devolve into the various German and Italian states of the HRE?

1 Answers 2015-04-14

Looking for a photograph from the Vietnam Conflict

I hope I'm posting in the right sub. My father told me a story about when he was young (about 8 or so), and had just learned about atomic bombs. At dinner one night he asked his mother why the Americans didn't just drop atomic bombs to kill all the Viet-Cong to end the war. His mother got up, went to the living room, and came back with an issue of Time Magazine opened to a photograph of an American soldier smiling while holding a severed head in each hand. He said it made him sick to his stomach and forever changed his idea of war. I found a piece of art that uses the photo, but never the photo by itself, despite a lot of searching ( http://www.flickr.com/photos/artoridiocy/152702450/ ) If anyone knows where I can find this original photo, I would greatly appreciate it.

1 Answers 2015-04-14

How was Europe so readily able to populate for WWII after the major death toll in the first?

I was curious. We always hear about how in Europe in WWI a huge percentage of the population died, but then in WWII an even bigger part did. How did Europe manage to repopulate so quickly in 20 years, especially since the birthrate had slowed by this time?

1 Answers 2015-04-14

[Spanish-American War] How did Commodore George Dewey know to attack the Spanish?

Commodore George Dewey was sent to the Philippines prior to the USS Maine explosion or the Declaration of War. How would he know to immediately attack the Spanish if the only communication he had with the U.S. was through other boats which took much time to communicate.

If the information I have is incorrect or lacking in parts please correct me

Edit: Okay, thank you. This makes much more sense than the summery I read.

2 Answers 2015-04-14

What role did the Russo-Japanese war of 1904 play in the fall of the Tsar?

1 Answers 2015-04-14

Why has San Antonio, Texas never developed a lot of the perks of being a large city?

The city has only one major franchise sports team — The Spurs.

It has a large airport that has never been a major hub for any airline.

It also has a nearly nonexistent public transit system except for busses. It is a major Amtrak station but the station is small and old and often requires very long layovers. (say, 8 hours)

Meanwhile the two larger cities in Texas turned into huge population centers and major international airport hubs (two airports apiece) with many professional sports teams and all the rest.

And the Capital City Austin might surpass San Antonio someday or simply merge into it.

I know there are many military bases in the San Antonio area. Have they hindered its growth in the modern era? (since WW2?)

1 Answers 2015-04-14

Where did the French Jews go after being expelled from France in 1394?

Wikipedia states: "On 17 September 1394, Charles VI suddenly published an ordinance in which he declared, in substance, that for a long time he had been taking note of the many complaints provoked by the excesses and misdemeanors which the Jews committed against Christians; and that the prosecutors, having made several investigations, had discovered many violations by the Jews of the agreement they had made with him. Therefore he decreed as an irrevocable law and statute that thenceforth no Jew should dwell in his domains ("Ordonnances", vii. 675). According to the Religieux de St. Denis, the king signed this decree at the instance of the queen ("Chron. de Charles VI." ii. 119).[29] The decree was not immediately enforced, a respite being granted to the Jews in order that they might sell their property and pay their debts. Those indebted to them were enjoined to redeem their obligations within a set time; otherwise their pledges held in pawn were to be sold by the Jews. The provost was to escort the Jews to the frontier of the kingdom. Subsequently the king released the Christians from their debts."

Where did the French Jews go after being expelled from the Kingdom of France?

In this time period, would Jews have been allowed to live in Christian cities or were they forced to live in their own villages?

Would jewish peasants in Europe generally dressed the same as Christian peasants?

1 Answers 2015-04-14

Was non-Roman script forbidden when signing your name on immigration forms at Ellis Island?

I was looking up the etymology of a racist slur which said

immigrants who were also illiterate (or could not use Latin alphabet letters). When asked to sign the entry-forms with the customary "X," the Jewish immigrants would refuse, because they associated an X with the cross of Christianity. Instead, they drew a circle as the signature on the entry-forms.

I ended up in a brief argument with someone over whether signing your name in non-Roman script would have been allowed at Ellis Island. Anyone know the answer?

1 Answers 2015-04-14

Who would clean up battlefields after WWII?

Who would cleanup battlefields after everything was said and done? What was the last reported finding of intact battlefields? Were there burnt out vehicles and bodies still being found decades later? I imagine jungles in the Pacific Islands being littered with bodies and vehicles. Do these still exist?

2 Answers 2015-04-14

Was John Wilkes Booth famous at all before the assassination?

1 Answers 2015-04-14

Why when people speak of the holocaust they attribute it only to jews, when more gentiles have died in the holocaust then jews?

1 Answers 2015-04-13

So late roman world wasn`t complety awful even in 375?

1 Answers 2015-04-13

Origin of names Iceland and Greenland?

I have always heard that Iceland and Greenland were named as such to encourage people to head to Greenland and avoid the beauty of the green Iceland. Is there any truth to that? If not, where did the names originate from?

1 Answers 2015-04-13

What was the state of medicine in pre-European Africa, especially West Africa?

1 Answers 2015-04-13

Is it known what the Romans and Anglo-Saxons thought of pre-occupation British sites such as Stonehenge?

4 Answers 2015-04-13

"The only European port in North America to be discovered, not founded."

Hey gang, I've got a question for you that's sat in the back of my mind for the better part of a decade.

In my undergrad I had a Canadian History professor who was very much a Maritimes/East Coast historian. He was on the board of editors for Acadiensis, all that jazz. He was also a grumpy old coot with some pretty radical ideas and theories about both Eastern Canadian and Irish history.

He was also an anti-confederate and hated Sir John A with a fiery passion, but that's neither here nor there. Just a bit of character building.

Anyhow, in a second year course on the settlement of Canada's east coast he made a joking throwaway remark that St John's, Newfoundland was "the only European port in North America to be discovered rather than settled". This was in the context of migrant cod fishermen coming to Newfoundland and Labrador in the 15th century to take advantage of the huge schools of fish. Basques, Portuguese, Irish, Scandinavians, he said, would camp ashore in Newfoundland during summer months before returning home with their catch. According to him, these fishermen built up makeshift towns to pass their time.

He closed his discussion with "when they mapped Newfoundland, they found St John's to be a thriving port home to two taverns and a brothel."

I'm not sure if that whole lecture was just an elaborate setup to an arcane Newfie joke or if there is some kind of historical veracity to it.

I transferred schools not long after when my home history department was near completely gutted and changed my focus to Victorian history away from my local history/linguistics, so I never really followed up my questions about his lectures.

Until now!

So, what kind of veracity is there to my prof's claims? I'm pretty sure there's evidence of pre-Columbian European fishermen coming and going on the regular to Newfoundland, but beyond that I'm a blank slate. I'd love to hear /r/AskHistorians' views.

1 Answers 2015-04-13

5528 / 7255

Back to start