Apparently, Mark Twain blamed Sir Walter Scott for the mindset within the American South that led to the Civil War. Is this completely nuts, or is there some truth to be found behind exaggeration?

I get that Twain was a satirist. But this article by Twain, explored by a modern writer here, describes Scott as an overly romantic fantasist, whose writings popularised an idea of "good old days" that inspired the social structure and mindset of the American aristocracy. I figure there is hyperbole in play, but is there something to this idea? And if Scott cannot be solely blamed, can the wider literary tradition of his time?

Did popular literature have something to do with shaping the Southern character?

1 Answers 2021-08-22

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | August 22, 2021

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

2 Answers 2021-08-22

How prevalent was cannabis and opium use in Ancient Rome?

2 Answers 2021-08-22

Were the Anglo Saxons pushovers for the Vikings?

In the show “Vikings” it often shows the saxons as being completely outmatched by the Vikings and the Saxon’s would only win if they had a MASSIVE numbers advantage, Was this really the case or were they far more even?

1 Answers 2021-08-22

History vs Urban Legend

Is there a difference between history and urban legend? Can an urban legend be a history?

1 Answers 2021-08-22

Why didn't flak cannons used against airplanes rain down shrapnel on friendlies?

How come when I see footage or war films from WW2 where flak cannons fill the air above them with shrapnel rounds that explode everywhere, said shrapnel doesn't rain down on the AA positions and harm the soldiers using the guns?

2 Answers 2021-08-22

Nowadays we look back at Victorian capitalists like Vanderbilt or Morgan in a pretty negative light. "Robber Barons", etc. But at the time, did they have "fans" like Elon Musk does today? Were they as visible in the media as people like Musk or Bezos are today?

1 Answers 2021-08-22

Why was Stalin looked on unfavourably in the USSR after his death but Mao continued (and continues) to be revered in China, despite many of the policies of both being reversed?

I'm by no means a history buff, so apologies if the premise of my question is incorrect. From what I understand, the policies of both Stalin and Mao were undone by their successors. However, it seems like Mao's reputation within China remained largely intact whereas Stalin and Stalinism became dirty words within the USSR.

1 Answers 2021-08-22

Did any ancient culture have a "Santa Claus"-like figure—i.e., a mythical figure they depicted but did not literally believe in?

1 Answers 2021-08-22

Nanking

There have been countless movies, books, games, articles and references of the crimes of Nazis but the Japanese committed even worse crimes against humanity yet we barely see any form of criticism of the Japanese army in the form of art. Why is that? Also, is the Japanese people today aware of their country’s horrific history ?

1 Answers 2021-08-22

How was the standard of living of the average Indian during the pre-colonial rule (Particularly during the Mughal and Maratha empires) as compared to that of the average European?

I have heard many Indians say that India before colonialism was insanely rich and comprised of anywhere between a third and a quarter of the globe's GDP. But I have also heard others say that all of this wealth was heavily concentrated in the hands of a few rulers while the average Indian lived in extreme poverty even by the standards of the time. Where does the truth lie?

1 Answers 2021-08-22

What language(s) did ancient Germanic people speak, do linguists have ideas on what it sounded like, and what other languages did it derive from, if any?

I was watching Barbarians when I wondered what language the Germanic people should’ve been speaking rather than modern German, which seemed uncomfortably inaccurate considering that they went through the effort to ensure the Romans spoke Classical Latin in the show.

I did a quick Google search and learned that the Germanic languages were already split from Proto-Germanic by late antiquity.

Would someone knowledgable please give out a quick rundown of the history of Germanic languages, or at least what we know of it currently? And as a bonus question how/when did it start to become/influence German, Dutch, English, Scandinavian languages etc?

1 Answers 2021-08-22

Was the Eastern Roman Emperor (Byzantine) a de jure monarch? how does the title Basileus, which was used by the the eastern Roman emperor as a title, which I believe translates into English as "king", as it was also used by Alexander of Macedon relate to this theoretical question?

Furthermore, was say Alexios Komnenos as an example as Roman as Julius Caesar, Octavius Caesar, or Sulla?

1 Answers 2021-08-22

When would people first have recognized what year they were in the same way that I recognize I am in 2021?

1 Answers 2021-08-22

Did sailors ever buy commissions in the age of sail?

Are there any accounts of common sailors/seamen, press-ganged or otherwise, buying a commission, perhaps with prize money? Is Master the best one could hope for?

1 Answers 2021-08-22

What was Britain's ultimate and ideal goal/endgame in Palestine?

After World War I the British took over Palestine under a League of Nations Mandate, with the ostensible goal of governing it until it could basically become a nation on its own, although it's my understanding that it basically became an imperial colony in all but name. Was this meant to be permanent, or did they plan to create some kind of Palestine nation that was essentially a British client state like Iraq? If it was the latter, were there organized and concerted efforts to actually do so in Palestine before WW2? As another side question, were League of Nations/UN Mandates really meant to be temporary until they were meant to be governed or was it just a more PR friendly way of gaining colonies?

1 Answers 2021-08-22

How "Lorem Ipsum", a text from ancient Rome, turned into a placeholder text?

The original Lorem Ipsum was written by Cicero during the last days of the Roman Republic, so how this writing of a renowned roman became the synonym of generic random text? why it was chosen? How became so popular?

1 Answers 2021-08-22

Source help for Crusades paper

I am searching for somewhere to confirm or get more information on a source I found in the Bedford Anthology of World Lit. There is a chapter about the crusading era and has a text selection from "History of the First Crusade" Which the book dates to the early 12th century. No author, native language, or origin is given, but it was translated (from something) by James B. Ross. The chapter in the book is called "The first Contact of Crusaders and Turks" and the subtitle is "Impressions of the People and the Country in Anatolia"

Beyond this i cannot find this text ANYWHERE to do more research or even back up the fact that this is a real document. If anyone has heard of this text or can point me in the direction of other copies or translations of it i would be very appreciative. Many thanks!!

Edited to mention: the book i found this in has no reference section.

1 Answers 2021-08-22

Why didn’t Prussia and Russia decide to side with Napoleon?

2 Answers 2021-08-22

Why does Herodotus make no mention of Hebrews/Judea

1 Answers 2021-08-21

Royal Twins - Who gets the Crown?

What would happy if a King or Queen of England (Or any similar monarchy), gives birth to twins? I assume with the current system being based on ancient rules, the male of a boy/girl twin birth would become the heir apprent. But what about a boy/boy or girl/girl twin birth?

1 Answers 2021-08-21

In the movie “Nuremberg”, when footage of the Holocaust is shown during the trial, there is pin-drop silence in the courtroom. Then one judge abruptly gets up to leave and vomit, followed by the rest. Is this dramatization or did the Allies have this strong of a gut reaction to the Holocaust?

edit: 15 hours, 2000 upvotes, 0 responses. Thanks guys. Maybe we’ll have better luck next time.

edit2: okay looks like we’re up to 3000 upvotes and absolutely no replies that haven’t been removed! Might be setting a record!

2 Answers 2021-08-21

An opinion in "The Atlantic" described Donald Rumsfeld as "America’s worst secretary of defense," explicit comparison to Robert McNamara notwithstanding; what were the redeeming features of Robert McNamara's tenure?

In pertinent part:

Rumsfeld was the worst secretary of defense in American history. Being newly dead shouldn’t spare him this distinction. He was worse than the closest contender, Robert McNamara, and that is not a competition to judge lightly. McNamara’s folly was that of a whole generation of Cold Warriors who believed that Indochina was a vital front in the struggle against communism. His growing realization that the Vietnam War was an unwinnable waste made him more insightful than some of his peers; his decision to keep this realization from the American public made him an unforgivable coward.

https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2021/06/how-donald-rumsfeld-deserves-be-remembered/619334/

1 Answers 2021-08-21

British Colonies Ww2

What would have happens to the British Colonies if Nazi Germany conquered Uk?

1 Answers 2021-08-21

Why some medieval monarchs are painted having black hair and dark eyes, but they actually had light hair and eyes?

Two examples I can think right now are William 'the Conqueror' and Richard III, which in almost every paintings are described having dark hair and eyes, but then later, it was scientifically proven that they had light hair and eyes. Is it some kind of epoch-specific symbology?

1 Answers 2021-08-21

564 / 7255

Back to start