Why did Islam spread so slowly south of the Sahel compared to in and to the North of it?

During some research into Boko Haram, I've come across the claim a few times that if it were not for European colonialism, Islam would have eventually spread all over West Africa. For example the powerful Sokoto Caliphate had been expanding throughout the territory of contemporary north west Nigeria during the early 19th century - eventually to be defeated by the British in 1903.

Prior to this, there had been relatively large and sophisticated Islamic states expanding in the sahel since the 14th century. For example the Sultunate of Kano, the Songhai empire, the Wadai empire, and the Bornu empire. These states were not Islamised by Arab conquest but by conversion of military leaders and parts of the population, who would subsequently convert the rest of the population.

However expansion into the land south of the sahel seems to have been insignificant. There are accounts of Muslims living among the Igbo, for example, but not in any great strength.

Considering that Islam spread throughout the entire southern and eastern mediterranean in about 100 years in the 7th and 8th centuries, and seems to have spread througout the sahel by the 14th century, why did it not spread from the Sahel to the West African southern coast in the 500 years before European colonisation? There's four possible factors I'm thinking of:

  1. Culture - it seems to me that Islam would have had a large cultural advantage over the animist areas to the south, not least because it brought literacy, and also connection to a huge cultural and intellectual world. But this advantage doesn't seem to have translated into territory.
  2. Military ability - Was there something about the territory that made wars of conquest by Islamic states successful in the sahel but not south of it?
  3. The value of the land and people - were Islamic 'missionaries', traders and conquerors simply not interested in the societies and land south of the sahel?
  4. European trade before formal colonisation - perhaps bringing goods and ideas into coastal regions from the 15th century contributed to a lesser influence for Islam?

1 Answers 2015-01-19

Was Gaius Octavius raped by Julius Caesar?

Hi guys, I was reading Neil Gaiman's Sandman and there's a story about Gaius Octavius, I'm not going to tell the whole thing, but basically throughout the story we see Gaius Octavius struggle with his nightmares and the fear he has of his uncle. In the end we find out that he was raped by Julius Caesar. So I'd like to know if that is true or if it was made up for the sake of the story.

1 Answers 2015-01-19

Axes are recognized in pop culture as symbolical for Viking and Nordic warriors. But how unique were they to these civilizations as weapons, really?

2 Answers 2015-01-19

Are there any patterns in today's time that are the same as in ancient/classic history?

1 Answers 2015-01-19

What is the history behind A-F grading?

When was it first used? Why was there no E grade in the American system? Why letters as opposed to numbers?

1 Answers 2015-01-19

If the real world have elf style immortal people/soldier, how would war be decided? Geopolitical situation be changed?

2 Answers 2015-01-19

Strange coin found

Hi!

We found this strange coin wedged between the floorboards in the living room of our flat in Glasgow, UK. The building itself is pretty old (late 1800s).

The inscriptions read (we think): REVALIE MONETA and LIVONIA MAGISTRI

or something... Can anybody help us identify the coin? Here are some pictures!

https://i.imgur.com/nfd7G7S.jpg https://i.imgur.com/iWL78ut.jpg

Thanks!

2 Answers 2015-01-19

Why were Hiroshima and Nagasaki chosen as the targets of the nuclear attack?

3 Answers 2015-01-19

Did ethnic Germans living in Central and Eastern Europe aid and abet the invading German armies during WWII?

1 Answers 2015-01-19

What is the TL;DR of the Geneva Convention?

1 Answers 2015-01-19

How did world leaders travel to conferences during WWII?

Forgive me if this has been asked before. But I saw this photo in another response today and it reminded me that I've always wondered how Stalin, Churchill, Chiang and other world leaders would travel to the various Allied conferences during WWII.

I'm assuming it was probably a combination of boat and plane travel; but how did they address travel through or across war zones? How did they keep them secret? How long was, say, Roosevelt gone for at the conferences he attended? Were there any "close calls" where one of the leaders' lives was in danger?

And similarly; were there any similar conferences of the Axis powers? Did they have the same travel issues?

3 Answers 2015-01-19

My mom inherited a photo album which once belonged to a WW2 German soldier. Can anyone recognize any of these faces? (imgur link)

6 Answers 2015-01-19

When did last names come into use? Were Roman names such as Julius Caesar divided into first and last name as our names are today?

I read somewhere that last names first came into use in 17th Century England, but how would this work with last names such as Caesar used in Roman Society? Was the way Romans used last names different from how we use them today, or was it another technology/social convention that was lost in the Dark Ages to be rediscovered in the Renaissance?

2 Answers 2015-01-19

"Furlough specials" planes during WW II

I'm reading some letters written to FDR circa January 1945. One person complains about "furlough specials." Here's the phrase in context: “My heart (and many other hearts) were filled with resentment at the time of your son Elliott’s recent marriage—‘chartering planes’ etc. when our own sons were riding ‘furlough specials’ thousands of miles in order to visit their families before leaving the United States.” I have not been able to figure out what exactly this correspondent meant by "furlough specials." She seems to be insinuating some inferior type of accommodation. Can someone give me insight into this slang? If you cannot verify your response but have a good sense feel free to pm me, so as to not break the subreddit rules.

1 Answers 2015-01-19

Why did written language first develop in the Near East, and at the time it did?

Humans were capable of speech long before 3000 BCE, so how come people began developing written language only around that time? Why only among the Near East civilizations?

2 Answers 2015-01-19

Who killed Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.?

I've read that the King family worked to acquit the charges against James Earl Ray believing him to be innocent. Is this true? Was the government responsible for his death?

1 Answers 2015-01-19

What are some historical "facts" that historians used to be sure of, that were later proven to be false?

1 Answers 2015-01-19

I am thinking of research paper ideas on the Vikings. What is an interesting topic to do this on?

1 Answers 2015-01-19

Why was there such pressure on British monarchs to produce a male heir, even though there have been many female monarchs, including the current Queen?

1 Answers 2015-01-19

Was the Christie T3E2 Tank and Christie's armored suspension designs share with the USSR prior to WWII and implemented in the creation of the Russian T34?

1 Answers 2015-01-19

Was this penknife Military Issue? [WWII, British]

I have this penknife which was given to me by my father alongside the throwaway claim that it was military issue from WWII. Is this true?

The claim was that my grandfather acquired a crate of knives after the war in storage sell offs as the military pulled out of the Orkney Isles (as they both lived there, plausible). I never saw any crate but my Dad does have about two dozen of these, many well worn - however I am sceptical because of my fathers tendency to exaggerate.

The knife has

VICTORINOX

SWITZERLAND

STAINLESS

ROSTFREI

at the base of the blade, which seems consistent with all Victorinox knives of the time and since.

I have been unable to turn anything up in regards to a back-catalogue of Victorinox or lists of historic military issue knives.

Does anyone here know anything? It would be a nice little tidbit to throw out whilst cracking open bottles if I knew it was true!

Thanks

1 Answers 2015-01-19

Which is more effective; Japanese or European sword fighting?

I recently read a historic novel that went into some detail about the effectiveness of European sword fighting or fencing with rapiers. Previously I had thought of it as something done by effeminate gentlemen, and considered Japanese sword fighting to be the epitome of the art. Now I wonder; are there any recorded instances of the two styles going up against each other, and which was more effective?

6 Answers 2015-01-19

How much did farmers' basic tools differ in agrarian societies across the globe?

Did all plows look more or less the same?

1 Answers 2015-01-19

Throughout (Civilized) history, how has the number of independent nations changed?

1 Answers 2015-01-19

Was Germany's Nazi party an extreme left or right wing party?

I apologize if this has been asked before. Every time I search for an answer on the internet, I find nothing but conflicting information. Once source says they were extreme left, another says they were extreme right. Thank you for you help.

5 Answers 2015-01-19

5879 / 7255

Back to start