What are some premodern examples of oppressed groups working successfully to end their oppression? Were there been any notable largely-peaceful movements among slaves, ill-treated ethnic minorities in empires, etc. which improved their conditions?

1 Answers 2015-01-19

How similar are today's economic/social situations...to the times of Theodore Roosevelt and the Trusts?

1 Answers 2015-01-19

Who can be credited with having saved the most human lives through their efforts and/or discoveries?

1 Answers 2015-01-19

How did ships communicate before radio but in more detail than flags seem to allow?

I was reading about "striking the colors" vs raising the white flag on Wikipedia ( http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Striking_the_colors ) and the following passage made me wonder how they communicated with such detail while in battle against each other.

"During the same battle, Bonhomme Richard's ensign was shot away. When Pearson saw that the colors were down, he asked Capt.John Paul Jones of Bonhomme Richard if Jones had struck his colors. Jones has been quoted as replying, "I have not yet begun to fight"."

How did he ask Capt. John Paul Jones if he surrendered? How did the captain reply with such a detailed sentence?

2 Answers 2015-01-19

What were the main reasons that Austria did not become a part of modern Germany?

2 Answers 2015-01-19

What was life like for common people in Napoleonic France?

How much do we know about what life was like for common people during Napoleon's reign? Would the French have considered it to be an improvement over the monarchy? Do we have reliable information about how popular Napoleon really was?

1 Answers 2015-01-19

Monday Methods | Organising Research

Welcome, one and all, to the eleventh (yes I'm still counting) installment of Monday Methods, where we discuss methodology relating to the human past. This week's question is a fairly broad one:

How do you organise your research?

This is explicitly aimed at as many people who work with the human past as possible, be you an archaeologist, historical linguist, historian, anthropologist, or part of any other subject that primarily studies the human past. This is also asked with more than one kind of answer in mind- you might want to talk about how you organise your notes, you might want to talk about how you go about reading through information on a subject, you might want to talk about what you consider good vs insufficient levels of research, you might want to talk about using repositories of knowledge like archives and libraries.

Whatever aspect of this question you'd like to talk about, it'll all be interest, and also highly informative for everyone reading.

Here are the upcoming (and previous) questions, and next week's question is this: How has AskHistorians changed or influenced your approach to your field?

5 Answers 2015-01-19

Was Italy really as useless as it was made out to be in World War 2?

Italy isn't represented very well in reports of WW2 past their failed excursions into Africa and Greece, and their changing of sides after Mussolini was deposed.

This has meant that Italy has become a target for some in popular media, similar to France after their government's surrender.

As I know that France had a good reason to formally surrender, and that they continued to support the allies throughout the war, it has lead me to wonder whether I have been misled about Italy also?

I tried researching it, but without much luck.

2 Answers 2015-01-19

Was there anti-Semitism in pre-Christian Europe?

I'm using the term 'pre-Christian' pretty broadly and wondering if I should split this question into several separate questions such as:

  1. Was there anti-Semitism among eastern European pagans who were conquered by the Teutonic Order and associated Christian crusaders?

  2. in Scandinavia before it converted to Christianity? I'm thinking about the 'vikings' who worshiped Odin and the rest of the Norse pantheon. What about Norsemen who sailed and settled outside of Scandinavia like Normans, Rus, Varangians, etc?

  3. among the barbarian tribes who invaded/settled in the Roman Empire during the Migration Period? Although I heard somewhere that some of those tribes were Christian so I'm not sure if this counts...

  4. Did the Romans persecute Jews? For example I know that various Emperors persecuted Christians, so did they ever do the same to Jews? Also, should the suppression of the various Judean insurrections be characterized as political or ethnic violence? If the latter, did the sentiment extend beyond the regions/events of the insurrections?

  5. Briton, Celtic and Germanic 'barbarians' such as those the Romans encountered/fought in the Republic and Principate periods. Had the Jewish Diaspora even reached these regions by that point?

  6. anywhere/when else. These are just the main scenarios that I could think of.

2 Answers 2015-01-19

Why did the Jews during 1939 through -45 rarely, or never fight back against nazi oppression and genocide?

As far as I know, Im only still in high school, Ive never heard of a mass of Jews fight back. Im asking because if i was (jewish), i would. Even in face of death or torture. Or would i i dont know. The human mind is a complex one.

1 Answers 2015-01-19

Is there any kind of estimate on how many people were killed--both military and civilian--during Alexander the Great's wars?

I know civilian numbers are very hard to track, even in present times, but I'm wondering if there's any sort of estimate out there.

1 Answers 2015-01-19

Don't upvote, Can anyone help me find the original source/artist of this image?

1 Answers 2015-01-19

When did the handshake become common?

I have no idea how long shaking hands has been common. It seems so natural now, but here must have been a time where people just stood awkwardly a couple feet away and said hello without touching.

1 Answers 2015-01-19

Help trying to find a book.

Hello friends at AskHistorians! After many different attempts to Google what I am looking for, I have been met with many failures. I am hoping that you will be able to assist me.

I am in search of older literature. Some background to this is back in college for a class about medieval history, we read excerpts from the book that I am currently searching for. I cannot remember the title or the author, but I can remember different parts of it.

From what I remember, the main theme of the book seemed to be the nature of man and the author's attempt to show that man's nature is shaped by his surroundings.

The story is set in what seemed to be medieval times and is about a boy. It starts where his village is attacked by some renegade brigands and he escapes. He eventually finds or is found by an old hermit living in the woods. This hermit follows the Christian bible and thus passes on these beliefs and ways of living to the boy. The boy learns and lives what are the Christian values. After some time, the old hermit dies and the boy is left alone again. Some time later, the boy finds a town and struggles with what the hermit taught him and with what he sees. He begins to be influenced by others and thus is slowly corrupted.

That is about all I can recall. The only "title" that comes to mind is something like "Simply Kissimus", but no matter what I have searched through online, I cannot seem to find this literature.

I may have unintentionally messed up some of the details as this was back in either 2008 or 2009 and for a class that was not my major. Yet, it has since that time burned in me to finish this story and know the ending.

If you could offer any help or assistance in my search for this book, I would be most sincerely thankful!

1 Answers 2015-01-19

Have navigational tools such as sextants been upgraded?

Inventions (specifically tools) are upgraded as time goes on, but many have not. Obviously we have electronic devices etc. But have (1800's) navigational tools such as the ones used by David Thompson, been upgraded? What is the easiest tool to navigate with nowadays, if you were living like David Thompson. Is there something better than a sextant, that David Thompson could use, for example.

3 Answers 2015-01-19

Some interesting facts about World War 2 ?

1 Answers 2015-01-19

How much did a telegram cost in the 1920s or '30s?

Inspired by this post in TIL, the linked article mentions that

Telegrams reached their peak popularity in the 1920s and 1930s when it was cheaper to send a telegram than to place a long-distance telephone call.

So how expensive was sending a telegram at that time in today's money? And how about a long-distance phone call?

1 Answers 2015-01-19

What do we know about less popular, widely disliked, or just plain "bad" music from the baroque, classical or romantic eras?

Nowadays, we only see or hear performances of music that was deemed good enough to survive 400 years. Bach, Beethoven, Mozart. Even less popular music from these eras we see performed today is still considered to be influential and worthy of study. We even know that some music we love today was considered unpopular when written but influential today.

Is there any music that was written that was hated back then and still hated today? Music with "no value" or considered too generic? How about music that was commissioned and outright rejected by whomever commissioned it?

(I know I am using a lot of subjective terms here, and I apologize. I am not sure how to describe what I am looking for in a purely objective way.)

3 Answers 2015-01-19

China refused to send any representatives to Churchill's funeral. Why?

Edit: why was that comment removed? It sounded like a good explanation.

2 Answers 2015-01-19

English is the international language because of the british empire or because of the US?

If the US never existed, would english be relevant?

3 Answers 2015-01-19

To what extent did Britain's relationship with India change between 1845-1947?

More specifically in what ways did the political, social and economic relationship change between the two? Also in what ways did British attitudes towards Indian culture change?

2 Answers 2015-01-19

When did swords and armored knights become obsolete?

Also, did suits of armor become obsolete before swords, or was it the other way around?

5 Answers 2015-01-19

What was a normal day like for an Indonesian under Dutch rule?

What did the Indonesians have as a daily routine? How much was their daily routine affected by Dutch Colonization of Indonesia? What did the general Indonesian think of Dutch rule? Was the general view positive, negative or was it overwhelmingly neutral?

1 Answers 2015-01-19

How were last names formed?

I know this is a vague topic, but names like "Smith" I can see, because they smithed things, supposedly. And "johnson" I can see, son of john. But my last name is Hewlett for example, and I don't see the connection of how it came to be.

1 Answers 2015-01-19

What's the current scholarly consensus of pre-columbian population of the Americas? Is there one?

Also whether or not there's one, what are the evidence used to derive these numbers?

2 Answers 2015-01-19

5880 / 7255

Back to start