Why has the boy scouts been so popular for the military to recruit from?

In fiction and factual stories about prominent soldiers we see many stories that they once were a member of their nation's boy scouts. Why has the boy scouts been so prominent in the past of these people?

1 Answers 2014-12-23

Gavrilo Princep lived untill 1917, did he ever voice his opinion on the war?

2 Answers 2014-12-23

How accurate was Sir John Glubb in his appraisal of the stages and downfalls of empires?

1 Answers 2014-12-23

What are these old medals and what do they mean?

These medals were in my grandfathers medals but seem to be Japanese or maybe Korean he was in both Okinawa and the Korean War. We have been unable to find anything about these two any help would be great. Here they are.

1 Answers 2014-12-23

Why isn't Genghis Khan talked about more in history?

I've looked many places for him in history books about Asia, and he is barely mentioned in anything. For someone who conquered almost all of Asia you'd think they have more about him.

2 Answers 2014-12-23

Rules of a pistol duel?

I imagine something like this... Start back to back.
Take your paces.
On the count of 3, turn and shoot!
Does this sound correct?
I was also wondering, if one person shot right away and missed, did the second person get an 'open' shot?

1 Answers 2014-12-23

Herod killed the "Holy Innocents" when Jesus born. Was killing of children a common occurrence to deter possible revolutions, population control?

1 Answers 2014-12-23

Ship Captains ability to conduct marriages

When, why, and how did the Captains of ships get the legal right to conduct marriages? Is it just because they may be considered the highest leagal authority while at sea?

1 Answers 2014-12-23

What are the earliest lawsuits for which we have good records?

"Good records" is a bit of a vague standard, but I'm curious about what level of evidence survives from different times. For example, if there's an ancient Babylonian lawsuit where we have a survival of the basic verdict (shekels paid, etc), a Han-period Chinese lawsuit where we have some record of the attorneys, motions filed, etc, and a 16th century Venetian lawsuit that is the oldest for which a complete surviving transcript of the trial, then I'd be curious about all of them.

(I realize an "oldest x, biggest y, fastest z," type question are somewhat frowned on here, but I'm not sure I know enough about the history of litigation to ask about this without including some element of "throughout history," and searching for "earliest lawsuit" and such didn't get what I was looking for.

1 Answers 2014-12-23

What is the oldest known human artifact(s) ?

2 Answers 2014-12-23

How did people machine bronze gears and such in history?

For instance, Leibniz built a stepped reckoner in the 17th century. How was he able to manufacture bronze with enough precision to do this?

2 Answers 2014-12-23

When and how did we accept the birth of Christ as mark in time?

1 Answers 2014-12-23

Why has cider (and also mead) been less popular these days than wine or beer?

If cider has been around in Western civilization (e.g. in Europe or the United States) for centuries just as much as wine or beer, why has cider been less popular, especially in the past 75 years or so?

To put it another way: Why did cider not recover after Prohibition as much as wine or beer - differences in alcohol content? Greater popularity of beer and wine among many immigrants to America (from Central/Eastern Europe and Italy respectively)?

Also, has mead not been as popular in contemporary times in the West as wine or beer because mead is much more expensive?

1 Answers 2014-12-23

How were the nation's railways lit before the invention of the light bulb? Was freight only moved during the daylight hours?

1 Answers 2014-12-23

Historically, did pregnant women and children drink alcohol? When were the harmful effects of alcohol discovered?

One of the functions of alcohol was thought to be sterilisation of water to protect from waterborne diseases.

What did pregnant women and children drink? Was it preferred they too have alcohol or did they drink supposedly unsterilised water? What was thought to be better for them in terms of health tradeoffs?

2 Answers 2014-12-23

[Arguing with a friend] Durning the Polish–Muscovite War (1605–18), is it correct to call it "Polish forces" [His argument] or specifically call it Polish-Lithuanian forces [Mine]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polish%E2%80%93Muscovite_War_(1605%E2%80%9318)

He calls it Polish forces, that the Poles defeated the Russians, while I say you cannot call it "Polish", same as you cannot call Austria-Hungary for "Austria". My argument is, that you have to specifically call it for what it is [Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth] and not "Poles/Polish".

What does /r/AskHistorians think?

2 Answers 2014-12-23

How is the Saudi Royal Family so large?

There's multiple thousands of members. How can they all be directly royal?

1 Answers 2014-12-23

How big a deal were the portrayals of Hell and Satan by Dante and Milton?

So as I understand it, Dante's Inferno and Milton's Paradise Lost are the primary sources of the popular image of Hell and Satan, respectively. I had a few questions about this though!

Firstly, how true is this actually? To what extent were either of them drawing on earlier traditions, and how much of it was flat out creations of their own mind?

Depending on the degree there, what was the public reaction like to this? Were these portrayals a huge thing? Were they shocking? Or was reaction kind of muted?

What was the reaction of the religious establishment of the era? How did the Catholic Church view this bit of "fan fiction" that Dante released? What did the Church of England have to say about Paradise Lost? And for that matter, what did the Catholic Church think?

And finally, how did their works come to be so dominant in the popular image?

1 Answers 2014-12-23

Why did Asa Harmon McCoy join the Union Army?

When I read about the Hatfield vs. McCoy dispute, it seemed like everyone in the region supported the Confederacy. Did Asa Harmon McCoy ever explain, or his family speculate why he decided to enlist with the Union Army?

I realize this answer may be unanswerable, so as a follow up: were murders a common reaction to a civil war soldier enlisting with the unpopular Army in their hometown region, or was Asa Harmon McCoy's case an outlier?

1 Answers 2014-12-23

Books on Diocletian's war machine

I'm looking for something that outlines his reforms to the Roman military. I heard on a podcast that he instigated a heavier emphasis on flying columns and cavalry to combat the hit and run tactics on the frontiers, but I can't find more than that. I've got a nice hardback on the Roman military but it's quiet when it gets to Diocletian, and mentions him very little. If his reforms weren't as substantial as I'm giving him credit for, then what did the army look like that he commanded? How did he use it in a pitched battle versus skirmishes and raiding, and did it translate well into sieges (I'm thinking Alexandria though there may have been more)? Sorry for the loaded question, but any literature on the subject would be greatly appreciated.

1 Answers 2014-12-23

A lot of historical and fantasy fiction portrays medieval era warriors callously slaughtering their own allied peasants during peacetime. Is there any evidence this ever really happened?

For example, I know samurai legally had the right to kill peasants who behaved disrespectfully. However, I've read manga which portrays samurai cutting the heads off randomly selected peasants just to test the sharpness of their swords. Knights are often portrayed murdering peasants for similar reasons. To me, these portrayals seem suspiciously like attempts to demonize a supposedly barbaric other time. However, I could be wrong. Is there any evidence that peasants really were slaughtered with impunity during peacetime?

1 Answers 2014-12-23

What was so different about the Byzantines in ~1050 AD from the Ottomans in ~1470? The former was in terminal decline while the latter was able to completely roll over its neighbors even though their territory was essentially the same size.

2 Answers 2014-12-23

Can anyone name an example of a country that fared poorly as a result of having a really open immigration policy?

1 Answers 2014-12-23

I Have Two Chinese Antiques with a Common Theme - Need help with identification and context

Not really mine, but my grandfather's. He has two antiques from China that both have a similar "theme" of an old man with his foot on top of a crane. He has has always wondered if there is a connection, but has never known. I was hoping it was possible someone on AskHistorians could help identify the connection (or confirm if there is none).

Items in question:

Carpet - Guy in the middle sitting on the crane

"Statue" - This guy has his foot on a crane

Same guy? Who is he and is there any connection or story? Are these common themes on items from China?

Unfortunately, I don't know much about the origin of the items. Only that I think the pole/statue is from the Panama Canal zone from the 30s (his dad bought it from some Chinese trader?). The carpet may have been from canal zone as well, or Shanghai in the 40s (can't remember).

Edit: I also cross listed this in /r/ChineseHistory here. There are some similar identifications of immortals, particularly Fu Lu Shou.

This is a great starting place for me, thanks.

1 Answers 2014-12-23

20 year limit just expired on the start of the First Chechen War - How has history judged Russia's casus belli?

1 Answers 2014-12-23

5974 / 7255

Back to start