Why does it seem like early American civilizations' (Maya, Olmec, Aztec) art/architecture is much less developed or much less impressive than that of early Europe and Asia?

I was recently at the Museum of Science Boston's exhibit on the Mayan culture, and while it was a very interesting exhibit full of new knowledge, for me the artifacts just didn't compare to ones I've seen from Ancient Greece or the Roman Republic, or even from ancient China and India. Why is this?

1 Answers 2014-10-19

Changing your name as part of a religious or political movement

Many of the earliest Zionists who first came to Israel - and actually I think this practice is still going on - Hebraicized their name.

I wonder what exactly their reasons were - or where did they get the idea from? And how unusual is this practice in history generally? Obviously, there is also a culture of converts to Islam changing their names - Muhammed Ali had the whole thing with the "slave name" - and various other people have changed their names in history for different reasons, but I'm interested if and when anyone rationalized this practice?

1 Answers 2014-10-19

Smallpox questions dealing with content in "The Demon in the Freezer."

The Demon in the Freezer deals with smallpox eradication and anthrax as a biological question outbreak. There are a few assertions in the book I'd like to double check.

Why after the eradication of smallpox were the vials of smallpox not destroyed?

What evidence of the Soviet Union or Russia in developing a heated smallpox virus. (A biological manipulated virus).

Has there any evidence of Russia, Iraq, or Iran in Developing a biological weapon. What has been other countries attempts at making biological weapons.

Why did WHO remove it's stockpile of smallpox vaccines.

Did Binghamton University really have an accidental smallpox outbreak?

1 Answers 2014-10-19

I've got this Sophia Bible from 1855...

Someone advised me to ask you guys this. I've got this Sophia Bible from 1855, my question to you guys is how much of an historical artifact is this? And what should I do with it?

1 Answers 2014-10-19

Is it just a pure coincidence that the legal drinking age in America is 21 and the amendment to repeal prohibition is the 21st?

1 Answers 2014-10-19

With Japan having made numerous public apologies for their behavior during WWII, why does a strong part of the Asian population still feel they have not properly atoned for their behavior?

1 Answers 2014-10-19

What is the historical background for the phrase, "the fog of war?"

I was just wondering if there was any interesting history to the phrase like where and when it originated from, or any other interesting facts about it.

1 Answers 2014-10-19

Why didn't The United States participate in The Scramble for Africa?

It seems a bit weird they didn't get involved at the time. Why? I'm curious

2 Answers 2014-10-19

In 1838, Joseph Smith came across several stone structures in Jameson, Missouri, that he claimed were altars built by the biblical Adam himself. Do we know anything about what the structures actually were?

(The site was subsequently known as Adam-ondi-Ahman in one of Joseph Smith's gibberish languages)

1 Answers 2014-10-19

Have the Kurdish people have had a country?

There have been alot of news about the kurdish people fighting ISIS and i thought "Have the kurds every had there own country(with a kurdish leader) I google it and didn't really find any thing so now i'm here to ask reddit

2 Answers 2014-10-19

Day of Reflection | October 13, 2014–October 19, 2014

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Day of Reflection. Nobody can read everything that appears here each day, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

4 Answers 2014-10-19

Were any American presidents able to speak other languages than English?

I imagine that some presidents came from immigrant backgrounds. Were there any who spoke another language fluently or natively?

4 Answers 2014-10-19

Political scientist Stephen Van Evera argues that "quirks in historian culture" leave most historical works with significant explanatory and evaluative gaps. Is his characterization/criticism of the field (see inside for his argument and additional questions) accurate?

Stephen Van Evera's Guide to Methods for Students of Political Science (1997):

P. 5:

Chapter 3 also reflects my view that political science should embrace the task of historical explanation among its missions. Historians should not be left alone with the assignment. Many historians are leery of generalizations, hence of the use of general theories; yet theories are essential to historical explanation. Many are averse to explicit explanation, instead preferring to "let the facts speak for themselves." Many are averse to writing evaluative history that judges policies and policymakers. Political science should step in to fill the explanatory and evaluative gaps that are left by these quirks in historian culture."

P. 93:

Moreover, scholarship of types 5 and 6 ("historical explanatory" and "historical evaluative") lacks a friendly home in other disciplines, which leaves this work to political scientists. Some historians are averse to explicit explanation, instead preferring to "let the facts speak for themselves." Others will elaborate a preferred explanation, but they rarely set contending explanations against one another, as one must to fully evaluate an explanation. Historians are also (with some exceptions)9 generally averse to writing evaluative history. However, without explanatory historical work history is never explained; and without evaluative historical work we learn little from the past about present and future problem-solving. Hence some field should accept these tasks. I nominate political science.

  • Is this an accurate characterization of history (leery of general theories, averse to evaluation, preference for "letting the facts speak for themselves")?
  • Why are historians wary about using general theories to explain and evaluative historical events?
  • Why are they wary of evaluation?
  • Why are they wary of clarification?
  • Doesn't that leave significant gaps in history scholarship?
  • Is there a debate in the field on this topic?

2 Answers 2014-10-19

Did so few people read in Austria Hungary, or did they only count German and Hungarian on this map?

It appears that very few people were literate in the new territories (map), was this the case or merely an artifact of the census not counting their language?

1 Answers 2014-10-19

Why has not the US lifted the embargo against Cuba?

1 Answers 2014-10-19

What does an Amtrak look like? WWII

I was watching a show on American Hero's Channel, and an interviewee was talking about an Amtrak that was used to move the dead with 6" of water on the bottom. I couldn't find it through my searches.

1 Answers 2014-10-19

Immediately after the French Revolution, how long did the power vacuum last? Its often hailed as a successful struggle against oppression, but how long was it until that was seen by the people?

1 Answers 2014-10-19

Were legendary swords actually a thing?

In all the many years where swords were used in combat, were legendary swords actually a real thing?

I don't mean simply named swords, but swords that carried a reputation as being exceptionally well made or somehow powerful. I'd imagine given the beliefs of the time, they probably would have been seen to be magical.

If there were, was it well known who had them, and were they feared?

7 Answers 2014-10-19

Are there any historical groups similar to ISIS?

1 Answers 2014-10-19

Why do months not have uniform length?

Why do some have 28 days, 30, or 31? When was this first introduced? By who? Why?

1 Answers 2014-10-19

In the time of Spartans (up to 371BC) did the persians actually have the items in the movie? (grenades etc.)

Im wondering if the persians vsing sparta had the bombs and chemical concoctions that was prevalent in the movie ? and if so could you provide a source? thank you very much ive always wondered this

3 Answers 2014-10-19

Why do old maps consistently show Japan as many times its actual size?

1 Answers 2014-10-19

Did Einstein really say "I do not know with what weapons World War III will be fought, but World War IV will be fought with sticks and stones." If so, when and it what context did he say it?

1 Answers 2014-10-19

What communicable diseases did Native Americans suffer from prior to contact with Europeans? What evidence do we have for this?

1 Answers 2014-10-19

How respected is Stephen Oppenheimer's theory of a non-celtic British and Irish origin among historians?

Here is the article that prompted my curiosity In which Oppenheimer makes a number of significant claims regarding the history and prehistory of the British Isles. What is the current academic consensus regarding his work?

2 Answers 2014-10-19

6193 / 7255

Back to start