What successful tactics did Eurasian steppe peoples use when faced with an army with large numbers of infantry archers or crossbowmen?

Playing the Total War series, I've found that the one sure counter to horse archers is large numbers of missile infantry protected by spearmen to counter a charge. Did the opponents of the Huns, Mongols and Turks (to name a few) attempt to counter the horse archer's supremacy in the field with infantry archers, and how successful were they in doing so?

1 Answers 2014-10-16

How accurate is this video about the 'facts' of Jesus' death and supposed resurrection?

I'm not religious but I am very interested in the Bible and what parts of it are historical and what parts aren't. I watched a video that made some claims about the facts surrounding the death of Jesus.

The main reason I am suspicious is that his argument is based on the "Historians agree" rhetoric.

Did Jesus Rise From the Dead? | Yale 2014 | Willi…: http://youtu.be/_NAOc6ctw1s

EDIT: for those that don't want to watch the whole thing, here are four things he claims as facts:

  1. After crucifixion Jesus was buried by Joseph of Arimathea in a tomb.
  2. On the Sunday after the crucifixion, Jesus’ tomb was found empty by a group of his women followers
  3. On different occasions different people and groups experienced post mortem appearances of Jesus
  4. Original disciples believe that Jesus had risen from the dead despite their predisposition to the contrary

1 Answers 2014-10-16

How common was comitting suicide in order to die with honor (like seppuku) in ancient greek/rome?

I was reading a book a few years ago (can't remember the name or author) about a roman centurion. Characters in the book would quite frequently either kill themselves, or be ordered to kill themselves (often for VERY petty reasons). How accurate is this?

3 Answers 2014-10-16

Did German soldiers in WW1 try to headbutt enemies with their spiked Pickelhaube helmets?

2 Answers 2014-10-16

Nazi Uniform Question...

My great uncle was an American GI, and fought in Europe during WWII. When he returned to the US he brought this nazi Jacket and hat with him.

Pics here:

direct link to the album:

http://imgur.com/a/PCk3D

or if that doesn't work (sometime it doesn't) you can just go to my imgur page, the nazi uniform pics are my only pics/album, and they are all public, so you can see the same pics by going to:

http://ghee99.imgur.com/

In any event, He gave these two items to my dad, who was a boy at the time. Recently my dad passed away, and I inherited them. As such, I was trying to find out what kind of uniform it was.

There is a name (I think that's what it is?)

...and some numbers on the inside that can be seen the third picture, that might be a clue?

Anyway, i have NO IDEA, so help is appreciated! I looked around the internet, but to no avail.

Does anyone have any idea? it seems like a nice wool uniform, so perhaps an officer's uniform?

Thanks in advance to looking.

p.s. NO i'm not some neo-nazi, or nazi-lover. The jacket and hat was given to our family by am American who was fighting AGAINST the nazis !!!

p.s.s. and yes, i know you are *supposed" to capitalize "nazi" but I just can't bring myself to so that, screw them!

Anyway, just wanted to clear all that sort of thing up, thanks again.

;)

1 Answers 2014-10-16

Why doesn't the U.K. cede, give up, give away, relinquish Northern Ireland back to the Repulic of Ireland?

2 Answers 2014-10-16

Did German U-boats actually make landfall on the Gulf Coast during WWII?

There is an urban legend from Alabama that German subs were able to beach in order for the sailors to visit relatives. There is a population of German-Americans in Baldwin County, which sits on Mobile Bay and the Gulf. Supposedly, this happend during WWII, but I have never seen any actual proof and I google it from time to time when I think about. What say the experts?

FYI- This is a pretty cool sub-reddit. I think I may have to subscribe.

1 Answers 2014-10-16

Why did Arabization happen but not, say, Mongolization?

2 Answers 2014-10-16

When did the Summer Olympics start allowing professional athletes to compete?

For example, for an event like long jump.

1 Answers 2014-10-16

If the Germans were punished for WW1 and suffered hyperinflation how did the Nazis fund their wars?

It is my understanding that the world imposed huge sanctions on Germany after WW1 and they suffered some of the worst economic turmoil and hyperinflation after the Great War. How did the Nazis fund their war effort if their country was doing so poorly?

1 Answers 2014-10-16

How did the Plains Native Americans live before the arrival of horses in North America?

Everything I read about the Native American peoples of the Great Plains is centered around their way of life after Europeans brought horses-- following buffalo herds, living in tipis, and so on. However, this is obviously a very small segment of history. How did they live before horses arrived? What types of shelters did they live in, what did they do for sustenance?

2 Answers 2014-10-16

Did any Native American medicines become popular medicines among non natives in North America?

2 Answers 2014-10-16

I have heard a historian in tv a couple of years ago sharing info on some city when it went under siege, the people in the city had a diet of only a type of groundnut for food that resulted in having the best health for the people.

Hello,

A very interesting tale that suddenly came to mind but I can not recall the city or the food source he talked about nor I was able to find any info about in it in the mighty Internet.

If this tale is true, details on it will be very interesting to read. Thanks.

1 Answers 2014-10-16

Can the United States be considered an empire during the early 1800s?

Most people I've posed this question to tell me the United States started showing signs of becoming an imperialist empire around the turn of the twentieth century, when they began dabbling in smaller wars and tweaking international policy to .

However, I recently read through a couple essays (Richard Drinnon's The Metaphysics of Empire Building: American Imperialism in the Age of Jefferson and Monroe // Patrick Wolfe's Settler Colonialism and the Elimination of the Native) that suggest these ideas of empire actually started forming with the 1790 Naturalization Act, where citizenship was limited to white Americans, and the 1830 Indian Removal Act, where Native American settlements were moved further west to accomodate American farmers and settlers.

Do you think there is an argument for American Empire/Imperialism forming during the early 19th century, or not until after the Civil War?

2 Answers 2014-10-16

[META] Why are there so many removed top comments?

There's been a lot recently. Why?

4 Answers 2014-10-16

Did Egyptologists really have to light matches to check for oxygen?

I was reading about the discovery of King Tut's tomb on Wikipedia and when it describes them first coming across the tomb it says "He cleared the doorway and made his way down a passageway that had been cleared by robbers. It was then that Howard Carter made a hole in the door, struck a match, and after discovering that the air had oxygen inside, went in."

What is going on here?

1 Answers 2014-10-16

In 47bc Julius Caesar stationed the 39th Legion in Egypt after the Alexandrian War. Does the existence of 39th Legion not imply a Republican Army with a core of Legions far larger than what we often consider to be the largest Roman Army like those under Septimus Severus and Trajan?

I understand the 39th was not at full strength when formed but with nothing better to do than protect Roman interests I don't doubt they would've soon been up to full strength, as would the rest of the legions that fought in the civil war. Same for those with mass discharges like the Tenth and others from the Gallic Campaigns.

1 Answers 2014-10-16

What did Goths/Vandals think of the Huns, were they barbarians in their eyes?

1 Answers 2014-10-16

How did citizens of the Western Roman Empire view the Eastern Roman Empire and vice versa?

Specifically post-Theodosius when the split became permanent. Also, what name would one have use to describe the other?

2 Answers 2014-10-16

Mexican history research ideas help.

I am to do a mexican history research paper. This is not my favorite area of history, and just want to some ideas on what you would think would be a good topic. I was thinking history of drug cartels, any suggestions? Thank s in advance.

1 Answers 2014-10-16

If I were a member of the US communist party in 1919, how would that have affected how people treated me? What about the 20s/30s/40s?

1 Answers 2014-10-16

How did submarines navigate during WWII?

I heard from an old German sailor that the primary means to find your location in the ocean (without GPS of course) would be the stars, the maps of the general flow of the tides and maps of the ocean depths. I recall reading a story of a U-Boat Ace sailing up to Scotland and attacking a RN convoy there. A feat his peers thought impossible because of all the sand banks en-route. Was there any other means for them to navigate?

1 Answers 2014-10-16

What exactly caused the relationship between Iraq and the US to sour? How'd we go from supporting them in the 80s with their war against Iran to going to war with them twice since then?

Is it simply because they invaded Kuwait? If so, why did we care about Kuwait? Or is it deeper than that?

Were the countries ever allies? Or was each country getting something out of their relationship in the 80s: Iran not winning the war against Iraq and Iraq not losing against Iran and no actual common goal or shared values?

Thank you!

1 Answers 2014-10-16

What is the best way to study a history topic that you aren't interested in?

Not exactly sure if this is the right board, but I thought it'd be interesting to see the responses from you guys.

So I've recently began my undergraduate and I'm minoring in history. The topic for the majority of year 1 is the Vikings and how their role shaped the world.

While I respect the topic and can see it's relevancy and importance in the role of studying history, I simply just cannot find it interesting, which leads to me lacking in the study department. So, assuming all the historians that are here have more than likely have to have had studied something that bored them to pieces, is the best way to solve this problem?

2 Answers 2014-10-16

How common was diary/journal keeping in history?

1 Answers 2014-10-16

6201 / 7255

Back to start