Historians, what is that one question you would love to answer, but nobody is asking?

1 Answers 2014-10-12

Are there any figures regarding the populations of various Mesopotamian empires?

I know that Ur at its height had a population between 50,000 and 80,000 (or was it Uruk?), but what would the population of the lands outside the city have been? Were there satellite villages and towns outside of these cities? Throughout history, the majority of the population has been rural. Did this apply to Mesopotamia?

1 Answers 2014-10-12

What's the historical basis for 4 year presidential terms in the US? Also, why do other elected offices use different term lengths?

I was wondering if there's a historical reason for the four year presidential term length in the US. Why not three years or five years? Is it completely arbitrary? Was it based on the term lengths of previous democracies or other institutions? If so, why do they use that particular term length?

1 Answers 2014-10-11

Romani/gypsy branding?

I've been researching historical European gypsy persecution for a short story, and branding keeps popping up. For instance, in Scotland around 1624, gypsy women were whipped and branded on the cheek. I was curious as to what kind of brand was used (as in the shape, size, design, etc.) and if there were any other locations than the cheek? I am not asking specifically about Scotland; any information (in any European country) on the subject would be greatly appreciated, although I am focusing more on France, Switzerland, and the Netherlands 1580 and after.

Thank you for your help!

2 Answers 2014-10-11

I have just been sent to prison in the Soviet Union. What should I expect?

Let's say it's 1975 or so, and I've been sent to prison for getting into a fight after a little too much vodka.

I have no prior offenses and have been considered a good citizen up to this point. Let's say I lived in Moscow and worked at a factory.

What sort of conditions will I face? Are there rehabilitation programs, or am I just stuck in a cell and left to rot?

1 Answers 2014-10-11

Achaelogists recently found 'vampire graves' in Bulgaria with iron stakes driven through their hearts. These are dated to the 13th and 14th centuries. When did the legend of vampires first originate?

1 Answers 2014-10-11

How long have humans been using knots?

And how do we know?

2 Answers 2014-10-11

Was drunk driving a problem before the invention of the automobile?

Could a drunken carriage driver or horseman do some damage? Were there laws or admonition against drunk driving?

2 Answers 2014-10-11

Finding Newspaper Sources

I was wondering if one of you could give advice on the best way to find newspaper sources for events when they don't come up from a google search Thanks

2 Answers 2014-10-11

Teenage suicide in antiquity?

I am wondering about the prevalence of suicide by young people throughout history? It unfortunately seems to be so common now, somewhat assisted by the societal pressures young people in antiquity may not have had to deal with.

1 Answers 2014-10-11

King Ateas was reported to be 90 years old when he was KIA (429 BC–339 BC) in battle with Phillip II of Macedon. How many other people documented nearly lived to be 100 in ancient times? When and where?

1 Answers 2014-10-11

What would be the impact of Quebec (or all of Canada) joining the Thirteen colonies in the Revolutionary War? Would the war have gone differently? How much differently would the U.S. be today?

1 Answers 2014-10-11

The first humans to land on Madagascar came from Indonesia in the 4th century AD - How did people in this time survive the over 7000km journey across the Indian Ocean, in canoes?

2 Answers 2014-10-11

Had he not been killed in a duel, how likely is it that Alexander Hamilton would have become President of the US?

1 Answers 2014-10-11

In your opinion, what one single event altered the course of human history? And Why?

1 Answers 2014-10-11

Could the Mongol/steppe Bow survive in a wet Western European climate?

I've heard several theorists propose that the mongols would face severe difficulties if they had invaded Western Europe at their height because their bows wouldn't survive the European temperament, the glue would become undone, and the wood would rot. How true is this?

1 Answers 2014-10-11

Why is beer/drinking such a central part of German culture, or is this merely a myth?

Is it maybe just a myth perpetuated through how beer seems important from an outsiders point of view? Sorry for crude wording but I hope my point comes across. I know a few German people and they all drink fairly often, so it's not just a stereotype. Right?

Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2014-10-11

What would have happened if the Dutch had repelled the English attack on New Amsterdam in 1664 and subsequently hadn't handed it over to the English?

1 Answers 2014-10-11

Were there alternative ideas of what to call World War Two?

Also, how did we arrive at the WW2 consensus?

1 Answers 2014-10-11

would a modern Chinese person have an easier time understanding a Chinese person from AD614 than someone from the Anglo sphere would understanding a Saxon from AD614?

1 Answers 2014-10-11

What are some examples of wars fought between Native Americans after European contact?

I know that Europeans fought numerous wars against and alongside Native Americans, but I don't know anything about Native American wars/politics that didn't affect Europeans. Presumably pre-contact tribes killed each other over things like religion, territory, pride, etc. and presumably their post-contact descendants did the same thing until non-Native American intrusion became a higher priority. So what are some examples?

1 Answers 2014-10-11

What countries followed the Nazi eugenics policy?

Who did they target? What would they do to those who were catatonic? I'd also appreciate your sources. I'm trying to write something so-

3 Answers 2014-10-11

Is there an accurate prediction as to the number of extant peoples of Mesoamerican and South American indigenous/native heritage?

For instance, On Wikipedia and other sites I'm getting a predicted 2.5 million Aztec people still alive- however, are hue gees people 100% Aztec genetically, or does the number count Europeans who have interbred with natives? Similarly, are there any accurate predictions to the numbers of native North American, Mayan, and Incan populations?

2 Answers 2014-10-11

Questions about conducting historical research

Hey /r/AskHistorians,

I suspect this may be a naive question, or one where the answer is "go get a history degree" but I figure it wouldn't hurt to ask.

I'm a big spaceflight nerd and have decided to try to capture some of my enthusiasm in a podcast about NASA spaceflight history. It isn't anything rigorous and it's just for fun, but I want to do a good job. I've started reading some old NASA books and cruising around their history.nasa.gov website and it's a lot to take in. Do you have any advice for a history newbie on how to effectively intake and digest a large amount of information and come out the other end with a coherent and succinct idea of what happened?

So far my strategy has just been to read a bunch, then try to write down a few sentences that sum it up nicely. I also make a note of the sources I'm reading because while I don't plan on providing anything like a bibliography now, it seemed like a good idea in case I change my mind.

Any advice, cautions, or comments are extremely welcome! Thanks.

4 Answers 2014-10-11

How did the fall of the Western Roman Empire affect the spread of Islam?

Just wondering, did the fall create a vacuum or affect trade routes or something in such a way that it affected the spread of Islam over 100 years later? Or was the relationship just tangential in the same way that WWI still affects us today?

2 Answers 2014-10-11

6220 / 7255

Back to start