In medieval European warfare, sieges seem to be more common that set-piece battles. However, I've heard this emphasis on siegework didn't exist in Sengoku Japan. How true is that? What caused this difference?

1 Answers 2014-08-14

What was the medieval form of a journalist?

I'm thinking of someone who sought information to spread it to people. Did a thing like that exist?

2 Answers 2014-08-14

In the time leading up to Hitler's WWII Germany, were citizens generally displeased with the direction of their country and government's actions?

Drawing similarities between then and now with the propaganda machines of world powers got me wondering how the masses felt about the general state of things.

Would today's American disposition of anger and frustration be akin to Nazi Germany or considerably different?

Obviously Germans embraced Hitler and his rhetoric but what sentiments did they have about their government and nation before his rise to power?

Are we setting up an environment today that may be conducive to bringing about another Hitler?

2 Answers 2014-08-14

Why does Great Britain only hold Northern Ireland?

More specifically, why do they hold only Northern Ireland, and not like, either none of it or all of it?

2 Answers 2014-08-14

Are diaries and journals considered valuable primary sources? As a source for a historian, what are the qualities of a useful journal/diary?

2 Answers 2014-08-14

Have the Amish always been significantly different than other rural Midwestern farmers? At what point did technological and societal changes really set the Amish apart?

Also, has there ever been anti-Amish sentiment? They aren't evangelizing like the Mormons, but I wonder if their business practices provoked some ire.

2 Answers 2014-08-14

Has African countries ever received immigrants from North America or Europe?

What is the general trend for immigration to Africa, especially more turbulent places like the Congo or Ethiopia?

1 Answers 2014-08-14

I wasn't taught any U.S. History beyond 1975 and would love to learn more!

I recently took a U.S. History Class in my high school that was supposed include history up until 2009; however my teacher did not get to most of it. He only taught us up until around 1975(this is when I started to get really interested in history at this point) He just gave us the answers to the parts of history that we didn't cover. So, I have very little knowledge about what has happened from then onward. I know the name of some wars that has happened since 75' but nothing more than that.

If anybody could give me some guidance on this subject this, whether that may be, links, stories, etc. I would be grateful.

1 Answers 2014-08-14

Did closely related ethnic and linguistic groups in Antiquity recognize each other as such?

Did Germanic peoples in Late Antiquity have an understanding of their relation to one another? Did an Anglo-Saxon recognize a Dane as being Germanic? Did Norsemen understand they were related to Germans?

What about Slavic people? Did ancient Poles and Rus people recognize that they belonged to a greater Slavic whole?

Was this knowledge widespread?

I'm inclined to think that most people had no idea. Some were perhaps disturbed by similarities between themselves and others.

The day some guys land on the beach with swords is traumatic enough. If you'd never been made privy to knowledge of the world (outside of England), the fact they're so similar to yourself might frighten you even more.

1 Answers 2014-08-14

Was the BMW 801 engine the greatest of it's time, and what would it be compared to by today's standards?

I recently saw a special that at one point discussed the 801 and it said that after the war the US made BMW sign a treaty, in which contained a clause that forbid them from producing jet engines. That intrigued me, and I was curious to know if the engines were really THAT good, or what other engines or manufacturers of engines could accomplish at that time compared to when the 801 came out. Please be kind, this is my first time asking a question, thank you all for your contributions, this is a wonderful subreddit!

I know it says not to ask what if questions, but if the engine had been produced 5 years sooner, would it have impacted the outcome of the European front?

1 Answers 2014-08-14

Are there any eye-witness reports of fire-breathing dragons, fictitious or exaggerated?

It's very easy to find accounts of flying serpents and dinosaur-sized reptiles, written by historians considered otherwise credible and sometimes even from a first-person perspective.

I have been completely unable, however, to find any supposed eye-witness report of a reptile that breathes fire or smoke, not even a tiny, wingless one.

Is this because there aren't any?

Any report, no matter how fictitious, will do!

2 Answers 2014-08-14

Information on historical (preferably ancient) suicide missions.

1 Answers 2014-08-14

History Degree not sure what to do next

I graduated this past semester with a degree in history (and a music minor too) and am uncertain about what to do next. I know grad school is something that I will probably have to do eventually, but it's not something I'm interested in doing right now.

So i just wanted to ask around and see what other people with history degrees have done as far as employment. Is there an area, field, or particular position I should look into? Really trying to see what other people have done just to get a clearer picture of what's next.

Any advice is greatly welcomed. Thanks!

6 Answers 2014-08-14

Why was the British defence of Greece in WWII so light?

3 Answers 2014-08-14

Did European nobility have slaves during the middle ages?

If no, how were their servants compensated?

1 Answers 2014-08-14

How were "Looney Tunes" and "Merrie Melodies" marketed when they were originally seen in theaters?

What audience were these shorts originally targeting, and what kind of immediate impact, if any, did these cartoons have in the popular culture of the time?

2 Answers 2014-08-14

Are there instances of musicians or music playing an instrumental role in the success of a military battle?

All of the sudden I remembered a story - whether it's from actual history or a book I read a while ago, I don't remember - where one army ambushed another with music from their homeland, greatly inhibiting their will to fight. Or something along those lines. It might have been in Asia and in a mountain pass. Anywho, what do y'all know about this topic?

Also, not sorry about my usage of "instrumental."

2 Answers 2014-08-14

Book recommendation on the conflicts between Ireland and and the mainland?

Hi, could somebody recommend me a good balanced overview of the history of this conflict? I'm really embarrassed not to know enough about it, but find wildly differing opinions everywhere I look.

1 Answers 2014-08-14

Experience of Japanese sailor versus American sailor during Battle of the Pacific?

How would the experience and life aboard a warship of Japanese sailor have compared to that of an American sailor?

1 Answers 2014-08-14

What kind of operations was the Russian submarine corps conducting in the Baltic and North sea during WWII?

I have heard that even among submarine corps their casualty rates were tremendous. What made this area of operation so dangerous?

1 Answers 2014-08-14

Was there ever any movement to have the United States switch to driving on the left side of the road?

I remember reading about why driving on the right came about, but I'm wondering if there was ever any significant push to shift things over. I vaguely recall reading that our natural instinct to avoid a head-on collision is to break to the left rather than the right. Which is a problem in a car when breaking left puts you into the opposing lane. So given that (assuming I remember right I guess), it made me wonder why we didn't switch over, as it seems like it might make more sense.

2 Answers 2014-08-13

Questions regarding the Afrika Korps

How did the Germans make their way to Africa?

Didn't the British control the Mediterranean?

How did the Wehrmacht prepare for desert combat?

How did the desert affect their equipment and vehicles?

In 1941, how did German soldiers consider a posting to the North Africa Campaign versus a posting to the Eastern Front?

Were soldiers granted leave for R&R, and if so, where would they go and what would they do?

1 Answers 2014-08-13

What was life like in a Venetian colony?

Venice and the other merchant republics of the middle ages (Genoa, Amalfi, etc.) were clearly very different from the typical feudal-aristocratic monarchies that dominated most of medieval Europe, but how different was life for the common people who lived under these republics? I'm thinking especially of the overseas colonies of the stato da mar, such as Istria, Dalmatia, Morea, Crete, and Cyprus. How did the Venetians govern these colonies?

2 Answers 2014-08-13

What is the general consensus among historians about Vladimir Lenin? Is he considered a tyrant? A misunderstood revolutionary? Why?

To provide some background... I commonly see it debated on the internet that Lenin is responsible for the deaths of thousands, that he was a corrupt tyrant, etc. Is their any historical legitimacy to these claims? And if not, what would you say to the people who make this claims?

2 Answers 2014-08-13

Did Pagan religions have definite names?

Something that has long bothered me is calling pagan religions/traditions by their culture. Did religions like Nose, Germainc, Hellenic paganism have shortened names, or titles. I've seen Norse Paganism be referred to as Ásatrú. I'm not sure if that is a recent invention, but do historians have names for pagan religions beside calling them Blank Paganism? Or did the adherents to these faiths have titles for them?

3 Answers 2014-08-13

6418 / 7255

Back to start