Why did Roman Emperor Marcus Aurelius crack down on the Christians so fiercely?

1 Answers 2014-02-05

What is the origin of languages, and to what purpose was it primarily used upon its invention?

I don't know whether this is an appropriate place to submit this question. If this is not the right place, I apologize.

Now the question:

I was reading Rousseau's Discourse on the Origin of Inequality when I came across this passage in the text:

[on the development of language] The first [question] that presents itself is to imagine how languages could be necessary; for since men had no communication among themselves nor any need of it, I fail to see either the necessity of this invention or its possibility, if it were not indispensable. I might well say, as do many others, that languages were born in the domestic intercourse among fathers, mothers and children. But aside from the fact that this would not resolve the difficulties, it would make the mistake of those who, reasoning from the state of nature, intrude into it ideas taken from society.

[interlude on how it was just natural for men and women to live isolated from one another and how nomadic "savage people" were]

It should […] be noted that, since the child had all his needs to explain and consequently more things to say to the mother than the mother to the child, it is the child who much make the greatest effort toward inventing a language […]

Now, I don't know if it is bad history or not. But now I want to know:

  1. Where did the need for language rise up first, if it's possible to determine this?
  2. What was it primarily used for?

2 Answers 2014-02-05

Why did the United States allocate most of their military in Germany towards defending the Fulda Gap instead of the Northern German Plain during the Cold War?

I should clarify that it was not just American soldiers involved, that it was a NATO plan.

1 Answers 2014-02-05

How did drive-in movie theaters get away with showing R and X-rated movies on giant outdoor screens in the 1960s and 70s?

1 Answers 2014-02-05

Was "marrying over the anvil" real? Or just an expression?

So, if you follow the news you may have noticed that Scotland recently passed marriage equality, which means the legendary Gretna Green might be getting some more business in a few months! And this got me thinking about the phrase "married over the anvil" and I found this kitchy video which you might enjoy. I also found a claim that this practice was only an expression and didn't actually happen.

Now, some idioms about marriage ("tying the knot" and "jumping the broom" come to mind) come from real practices, and since iron lore is such a big thing in cultures, this one seems pretty plausible to me. But I can't find anything concrete either way!

So, did people actually hold hands over the anvil and pledge their troth when they ran away to Gretna Green in the 18th century?

1 Answers 2014-02-05

Have there ever been any cases that are examples of successful section 1983 suits?

42 U.S.C. § 1983 waives sovereign immunity for the government and allows you to sue the government and its agents for constitutional violations. These are notoriously hard to prove because of cost, bad law, bias in favor of the police, and police lying. Has there ever been a situation where members of a police unit were sued for, say, a raid gone wrong, and convicted because of this law?

1 Answers 2014-02-05

In the early days of spy satellites, what sort of training was necessary for analysts to be able to make sense of those grainy images?

1 Answers 2014-02-05

What did the government of France look like immediately prior to the French Revolution?

I was reading an excerpt of a De Tocqueville piece that talked about the "ancien regime" and the centralization of the state under high crown authority, but i feel like thats a very shallow understanding of the monarchical system, and there's probably so much more to it besides "the king was super powerful and controlled everything, and the people wanted freedom and an end to poverty. The end."

I really want to know what the govt system was like in France at the time.

1 Answers 2014-02-05

If Malcolm X was so anti-opression, why did he support the Afro-American Islam Movement?

If I remember correctly, Muslims forcibly spread their religion all throughout Africa, while destroying Native African culture in the process. Muslim soldiers pillaged, raped and killed African villagers. Why did Malcolm X so strongly support Islam?

1 Answers 2014-02-05

How were Asians and other non-black minorities treated in Jim Crowe's South?

Were they expected to use the "colored" facilities or sit in the back of the bus? Sorry, just a question that interests me, which I've never heard an answer to.

2 Answers 2014-02-05

What caused the fall of the Roman Republic?

Curious as to how the Roman Republic fell or the events that caused it.

3 Answers 2014-02-05

How widespread was the persecution of the Hellenes by Christians?

I can't seem to get an objective source on this subject, but I've read a bit from seemingly-biased sources (like this one: http://www.ysee.gr/index-eng.php?type=english&f=lovestories) that paint a grim picture of Hellenic life during Constantine's reign.

1 Answers 2014-02-05

How was Genghis Khan able to maintain an army?

As far as I understand Genghis Khan's army was a mobile horde that scourged the earth, but if an army marches on its stomach and the horde didn't have a nation's farmland producing enough food to sustain such a large army, logistically how was Genghis Khan able to maintain an army?

1 Answers 2014-02-05

How accurate is this BBC article about WWI?

This is the article in question.

1 Answers 2014-02-04

There seems to be a narrative that Quisling betrayed Norway by leaving the proverbial door open for the Nazis to slip in and occupy the county. If Quisling was a such a traitor to his people, why do we not hear stories of the Norwegian resistance as we do the Dutch, French or Polish?

1 Answers 2014-02-04

How strong was the 2001 Iraq military?

1 Answers 2014-02-04

Why isn't Greek Mythology practiced anymore?

I would assume that no one does, since it is referred to as a mythology and not a religion.

1 Answers 2014-02-04

Why did Germany lose the battle of Stalingrad?

Title, and if so, are there any books on it with two preferably differing sides? I know some factors include the environment, soviet numbers, and hitler's restrictive leadership, but can someone help detail this for me? Thanks! :)

2 Answers 2014-02-04

What is meant by the term "Paul's Folly of the Cross"

I'm in an undergraduate course on the Reformation and we are currently in the middle of reading Erasmus' The Praise of Folly which I've so far found super interesting and fun to read. However, in the introduction, there were several mentions of the "Pauline Folly of the Cross". What did this term refer to in 15th and 16th century Europe?

1 Answers 2014-02-04

The sinking of the French Fleet

I recently watched a PBS documentary (Secrets of the Dead) about the seizure and shelling of the French fleet in 1940. I was somewhat taken aback by the refusal of the French to sail with the British. It seemed that they would rather sink their own ships than work with GB. Given that France had capitulated at the time, what was the purpose of resisting the British? Also, the French seem very angry about the incident, some even calling it murder. I don't understand what the French were thinking. From my perspective, they were defeated and the only way to regain their country was to fight the Germans. Given this situation, why did the French so strongly resist transferring their fleet to English ports?

2 Answers 2014-02-04

In what ways did Muslim rulers in the medieval period oppress their non-Muslim subjects?

So in browsing reddit/the internet, I typically come across a scenario where one person says that Muslim rulers were relatively tolerant. Then another person exhorts the first not to over-state his case, and that Muslim rulers were indeed still very oppressive. Then somebody usually references jizya.

Is there something besides a differential tax rate that we can point to to show oppression from Muslim rulers? Or can somebody expand on the jizya to show how it was oppressive other than it wasn't exactly equal?

1 Answers 2014-02-04

Why do totalitiarian regimes exist?

From a psychological standpoint.

1 Answers 2014-02-04

Was there an English upper class in every British colonial area? If so, what happened to the English settlers in Ghana, Egypt, Kenya, Yemen, and Burma?

1 Answers 2014-02-04

A family member is dying (lived 1920s until now), can AskHistorians help me find the right questions to ask?

He was born in the early 20's, served in the U.S. Navy during the Korean War. Has been middle class in the Northwest his entire life. What do I ask to get a glimpse at the eras he got to see? What questions could give me an insight into the economic, social and political changes he has witnessed?

I am in my early 20's, my grandpa died when I was young. Didn't get the chance to learn much from his history. I don't want to let this opportunity go, but I am not well-versed in 20th century history.

Essentially, what can I ask that would be personable and historically enlightening? I want to capture how his perspective as a young 20 yearold must have been radically different (yet similar in perhaps some ways) to how I live today.

7 Answers 2014-02-04

After the American 1920-1933 prohibition, what happened to the underground rum runners, brewers, and speakeasy clubs?

There was an entire underground culture and supply chain for alcohol consumption during prohibition. What happened to this supply chain once prohibition ended? Were they simply out of business? How did the underground clubs adapt?

3 Answers 2014-02-04

7131 / 7255

Back to start