Why was Taiwan not properly colonized by and European power?

Taiwan at the time was very close to Japan, China and Korea which for the Europeans was a great place for trading. So it probably would have been valuable to the Europeans. I am aware that the Dutch tried to set up colonies but left and it failed. But later on other colonial powers like the Spanish who already had a colony in the Philippians, the British who just liked stuff and also had colonies and even the French who had Indochina. Especially the UK, they had lots of influence on China who were probably to weak to kick out the British out of Taiwan considering that they were in the "century of humiliation". Even Germany could have temporarily obtained it as they seemed to like having colonies in the pacific and no one else had Taiwan (from a European perspective). I don't see many disadvantages for the European powers to colonize Taiwan but they didn't really colonize Taiwan did they? As far as i'm aware the British, French, Germans or Spanish didn't even try to colonize Taiwan. Why?

1 Answers 2021-02-19

Friday Free-for-All | February 19, 2021

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

6 Answers 2021-02-19

Preserved remains/relics of Christians (or other preserved bodies)

I’m searching for papers exploring the tradition of preserving Christian bodies/skeletons in wax or other materials, (eg St Victoria in Rome) and have hit a blank. If you can recommend any please let me know.

My main focus of study is Neolithic plastered skulls but I am trying to interpret it in a wider context, so tbh other forms of preservation (excluding PNG and Oceanic skulls) could also be useful.

I am especially searching for the use of materials that are precious in themselves. Thanks

2 Answers 2021-02-19

When Nazi Germany was starting, how did they know who was Jewish?

I know that one of the things they did was make people who were Jewish stitch a Star of David onto their clothes, but how did they enforce this? How did they know who was Jewish?

1 Answers 2021-02-19

Why did Czechoslovakia send a tankette to the Shah of Iran?

This seems so...odd. In the early 1930s they ordered 4 Carden-Lloyd tankettes. They experimented on these and they would eventually evolve into the Tancik vz. 33. However, one of these prototypes they gave to the Shah of Iran: why?

1 Answers 2021-02-19

Scottish "blackhouses" had no chimneys but burned peat inside, the smoke apparently escaped through cracks in the thatching. This seems...unhealthy. Did the crofters who lived in these houses have extremely high rates of lung disease?

2 Answers 2021-02-19

A lot of attention is often given to Irish and Italian immigration during the 20th century, but Germans make up the overwhelming amount of immigrants in most of the US and very little focus is given to the experiences of German immigrants during the 20th century. Why is this?

Based on this post in r/Europe, which shows German immigrants seemingly vastly outnumbering any other immigrant group, even in more populous states, despite German immigrants receiving very little attention culturally compared to for example Irish or Italian immigrants.

1 Answers 2021-02-19

How did the Welsh language survive English rule, while Scotts Gaelic, Irish, manx, and Cornish didn't?

And is it possible to do a similar thing to Gaelic, Irish, manx and and Cornish today to save these languages?

1 Answers 2021-02-19

Do historians/archeologists think that Cyrus actually worshipped Marduk?

I'm referring to his use of Marduk in his propaganda after his conquest of Babylon, btw. To what extent was there cross-pollination of the various gods of Mesopotamia with the proto-Iranian peoples, such as Cyrus? Would this also apply to the gods of Assyria?

1 Answers 2021-02-19

What were the opinions of other nations (France, Britain, China, etc.) around the world as a young United States expanded across North America in the 19th century?

We consider national expansion and annexations as controversial in modern times. Were there any nations who had a different opinion amongst the people from one amongst their leaders?

1 Answers 2021-02-19

The mediaeval game of hand-in-cap

I’ve been obsessed with the incredible podcast called ‘The History Of English’, by Kevin Stroud. In particular, an episode I listened to recently contained a detailed description of a game of trading between two people that emerged in the 1300’s in England, involving a third person and a kitty of money apparently called ‘new fair’. Eventually it became known as ‘hand-in-cap’, giving us the word ‘handicap’ as regards horses and golf, and applied to people in the 20th century.

As a maths and data geek I am astonished at the brilliantly simple design of the game that incentivises all participants to do their best to establish a fair trade arrangement.

Can anyone tell me more about it? I’m finding it very hard to get any more info from the net - plus I cannot establish anywhere that it was originally called ‘new fair’.

1 Answers 2021-02-19

African immigration to the USA Post Slavery

After slavery ended in the United States, how long was it before native Africans willingly immigrated to the United States? Were there willing African immigrants in the North before slavery ended? Were Northern Africans immigrants differintiated from Sub Sahran African immigrants?

1 Answers 2021-02-19

What caused Liu Shaoqi and Mao Zedong conflict?

It seems that Liu Shaoqi fell out of Mao grace very quickly and was treated worse than other leaders that just criticized Mao. Was there more to it? Was it becouse of power held by him?

1 Answers 2021-02-19

In the third The Lord of the Rings movie, emergency communication between two isolated and distant communities is accomplished by a beacon relay using signal fires. It seems like that would require constant attention and upkeep in remote areas, but has that ever actually been successfully employed?

3 Answers 2021-02-19

What happened to Leopold Lojka, the driver or Archduke Ferdinand?

Besides his identity as the driver and being known for influencing history significantly, there really wasn’t anything else that I could find about him. Not his family, cause of death, or whether he actually felt guilty or not.

1 Answers 2021-02-19

Is Stephen Kotkin Reliable?

Title. But I’ve been interested in the Stalin-era of the USSR for some time, and out of the works I’ve been looking at to start with Kotkin’s work on Stalin really stood out to me as impressive and all-encompassing. I’ve watched nearly all of his lectures and am about to buy his books, but I wanted to make sure this would be a good starting point for my real deep diving into Soviet history. So, is this a good start or have those angry YouTube comments calling him a reactionary historian true?

1 Answers 2021-02-19

How did Europeans, especially Northern, deal with settling and colonizing warm, tropical places? For example, how did a 17th Dutchman cope with the intensely different climate of Indonesia, or did they just sweat constantly?

I’ve always wondered this, whenever I consider the fact that most of the colonizers had probably never left their country, which though they can get warm probably not that warm (especially during the Little Ice Age), and then suddenly they land in moist, jungly, and scorching terrain—how difficult was the adjustment, and what, if any, coping mechanisms were there? As someone, of European descent who lives in a continental climate, who sweats really easy, this is always my first thought. I can’t imagine any European colonizer, whether it be in Mexico, the Caribbean, Brazil, or wherever, as anything but just sweating themselves into a puddle all the time, and just how gross they must have been, especially with all the clothes and armor. Was it something they just ‘toughed’ out, or did they actually have some way of dealing with it?

Sorry if this is a really broad question, but I can’t find a better way to put it. Thank you in advance!

1 Answers 2021-02-19

During Medieval Ages was there any proof of using both two-handed weapons and shield at the same time?

If this question sounds familiar you may have also watched shad's video on it. I'm just curious was there any proof of people wielding shields and two handed at the same time?

1 Answers 2021-02-19

What was Japan up to during World War One? (1914-1918)

2 Answers 2021-02-18

What were European military leaders’ tactical & strategic opinions of the American Civil War? Did anything surprise them? Were any lessons drawn from it? What were the assessments of the armies’ performances?

1 Answers 2021-02-18

I was taught that the US Power Grid is dangerously outdated. What is the history of that?

I studied electrical and computer engineer in college, and my professors would often bemoan the state of our power grid. A brief look-up seems to confirm that it is true, "most electric transmission and distribution lines were constructed in the 1950s and 1960s with a 50-year life expectancy". I also remember they were so desperate for power engineers, that there were substantial scholarships for students even just considering going into power, because apparently the average age of a power engineer is over 60 (I can find no source of this, so I assume it isn't true).

Specially, I had a professor claim it was largely due to privatization of the power grid in the 80s. Is there any truth to this? More generally, what is the history of the US electric grid of the 20th century?

1 Answers 2021-02-18

How advanced was the Roman Empire compared to the medieval ages in terms of society?

Another way to ask the question is how far down did society go when the Roman Empire fell in the west, following way for the dark ages?

1 Answers 2021-02-18

Do we know how the SS came to know of Anne Frank?

1 Answers 2021-02-18

Zapotec cultures have "Muxes", people born male at birth but dress and behave as women which is described as a third gender. Was this rooted in Mesoamerican culture and if it is, what their view on gender an outlier among Mesoamerica?

I realize I am seeing a lot of seemingly conflicting info on the general Mesoamerican view on gender and sexuality beyond sexual excess being bad.

Especially since the god of homosexuality was also the god of pleasure, would that therefore mean the mesoamericans did not condone these identities because they are associated with excess?

2 Answers 2021-02-18

The stereotype of a 19th century gold prospector is oddly specific: an eccentric, hunchbacked old man with a long beard, a tattered hat, and missing teeth. Does this image come from one particular person or fictional character, was it a stereotype of a real phenomenon?

1 Answers 2021-02-18

842 / 7255

Back to start