What are some good books on the minor Axis powers during WW2?

Hello everyone! I am looking to do a project for which I am writing about the minor axis powers of WW2, namely Slovakia, Hungary, Romania, Bulgaria and Croatia, as well as any other smaller powers too. I would like to know if you have any recommendations for in-depth reading on these nations and their history during the Second World War. Many thanks!

1 Answers 2021-02-09

Relevance of slavery being abolished 100 years after the founding of the U.S.

Slavery was abolished pretty much 100 years after the U.S. was founded. Did this 100 year anniversary play any role in causing the civil war?

1 Answers 2021-02-09

Is there anything left of pre-Norman/English Welsh music and songs?

I love Irish and Scottish music, but I never hear anything from Wales that's not heavily English.

1 Answers 2021-02-09

Jesus Christ preached of an imminent apocalyptic judgment within the lifetimes of his followers. When the world did not end, why were his teachings not abandoned and instead his follower base only grew?

2 Answers 2021-02-09

Are there memoirs of Lucius Cornelius Sulla Felix?

I know that he wrote some when he retired from politics but I can't find them anywhere. Did those memoirs even survive?

1 Answers 2021-02-09

What are some good ways/ or literature that pulls the unpleasantness of the British Empire into histories of defence or geostrategy in the 20th Century?

Im studying a lot of naval and grand strategy/policy style history of the 20th century, especially the interwar period.

The British Empire is integral to the history of the Royal Navy, in some ways providing both its requirements and role.

Yet what strikes me is how absent modern history of empire is from the analysis. Moral failures and unpleasantness of Empire rarely effects the naval interpretation of the need to defend it. In my opinion naval history often falls into implicitly accepting the validity of the British Empire. Geostrategic grounds drown out other issues.

So 3 linked questions

What are some good ways of using histories of Empire, which i assume suggest Empire was not a nice thing, to critique organisations such as the navy implicitly linked to its existence?

Are there some good works that already do this? What are some good modern history of the British Empire that are a good place to start in understanding the 20th century British Empire?

1 Answers 2021-02-09

Did Vikings Have Snowball Fights?

This is maybe a little silly, but keeping with the theme, I'm curious if ancient Scandinavians would have snowball fights and build snow forts and that kind of thing like kids do during the winter today.

1 Answers 2021-02-09

British History Books

What are some of the best British History textbooks?

1 Answers 2021-02-09

Reading list on the Migration Period/Völkerwanderung?

Which books would you recommend on the Migration Period/Völkerwanderung (English or German)?

1 Answers 2021-02-09

Why is Sparta glorified in Western art and culture?

According to Merriam-Webster, in the English language, "Spartan" has taken on the following meaning:

Spartan (noun): Definition of Spartan (Entry 1 of 2)

1 : a native or inhabitant of ancient Sparta

2 : a person of great courage and self-discipline

Spartan (adjective): Definition of Spartan (Entry 2 of 2)

1 : of or relating to Sparta in ancient Greece

2a (often not capitalized): marked by strict self-discipline or self-denial "a Spartan athlete"

2b (often not capitalized): marked by simplicity, frugality, or avoidance of luxury and comfort "a Spartan room"

2c : laconic

2d : undaunted by pain or danger

Likewise, when I was in Year 7 (i.e. 1st year of high school in Australia), our history curriculum covered Ancient Greece. It portrayed Sparta as a place which produced the best soldiers by being extraordinarily harsh on its citizens (e.g. grueling training in the agoge, state-mandated infanticide, annual crypteia where they kill slaves). It goes without saying that in Western books and movies, Sparta is portrayed in a similar way.

But after watching these 2 videos, it debunks the notion of the "Spartan super-soldiers":

This raises the question of Why does the West even glorify Sparta in the first place? After all:

  • Of all the contributions of Ancient Greece to science, art and philosophy, Sparta seems to have had a minor or negligible contribution.
  • Modern Western nations draw inspiration for democracy from Ancient Greek democracies, whereas practically no nations draw inspiration from the Spartan model of governance.
  • As shown in the "Misunderstood Moments in History - The Spartan Myth" video, the Spartan citizens were actually a small elite class akin to medieval knights, their military effectiveness was not much greater than other Ancient Greeks, and Spartan Olympic achievements were generally unremarkable.
  • The Spartan military model failed to achieve massive conquests, unlike that of Macedon, the Diadochi states or Epirus.
  • From a Western Christian POV, there seems to be little to approve of about Sparta.
  • If the glorification of Sparta is due to antipathy against Persia, why fixate on Sparta, instead of Macedon, who was the one to destroy the Achaemenid Empire?

2 Answers 2021-02-09

A Founding Father Wanted European Americans and Native Americans To Join Together As A Single Nation?

I remember in high school a history teacher showing my class a documentary on YouTube that said some founding father or early American historical figure thought that the European Americans and Native Americans should mix together and form a single continental nation together, possibly with a mixed culture. I don’t remember the name of the historical figure or even the documentary. Is there any truth to this idea? Where there people in power who at the time thought this was a good idea? I’m only posting this here cause you guys know about history, this very well could be bad history and this sub allows shorter replies

2 Answers 2021-02-09

According to Daniel Marston in his book The Pacific War, he mentions that the Japanese strategy against the U.S. was to escalate the material and moral costs of the war so that the U.S. would capitulate.

He further goes to state that this strategy is predicated on American effeteness, so my question is what historical events caused the Japanese military command to view Americans as effete and not willing to stick it through? What specific historical occurrences gave the Japanese the impression that the Americans and by extension western powers were effete to the extent that they were willing to base their entire military strategy of the effeteness of western power. Was the Japanese Russian dealings in the Russo-Japanese wars that lead to this image of an effete western power or were there other accounts that lead to this perception?

Edit: clarified the question

2 Answers 2021-02-09

What was the average travel duration during all the crusades (by feet or by boat) ?

1 Answers 2021-02-09

"International" language nowadays is English.What languages were considered such in 1920?

1 Answers 2021-02-09

I am in possession of a 120 year old scrapbook of a United States senator, whats the best way to post the full contents online for anyone to see?

My father bought this https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_J._McSwain man's scrapbook accidentally at a garage sale a couple years ago. I want to take high quality-photos of every page and post them online where historians could use it as a primary source or anyone who is curious could read its contents, but I don't know how to take these photos without damaging its pages. I know I could use my phone to take photos and put an album on imgur, but I think the lighting would be poor and the image quality low. I am pretty certain it's authentic, it is mostly newspaper clippings related to court cases in South Carolina. I can post photos I took with my phone camera if there's interest but ultimately I want something better.

Edit: https://imgur.com/a/lvjmMBZ I know this isn't sufficient to verify it's real but here's a dated passage in the book from 1903.

1 Answers 2021-02-09

What evidence do we have of ancient British Tatoos?

Do we have any images of tatoos ancient britons adorned themselves with?

1 Answers 2021-02-09

If not a kangaroo, then who? What is the current state of scholarship on the Devil's Footprints phenomenon of February 1955, in which odd footprints showed up in a 100 mile track overnight? Is there an agreed upon or likely cause? Was it a complete overblowing of a few snow marks in a couple places?

Wikipedia was about as helpful as ever for reading about uncertain historical events.

The link

The Devil's Footprints was a phenomenon that occurred during February 1855 around the Exe Estuary in East and South Devon, England. After a heavy snowfall, trails of hoof-like marks appeared overnight in the snow covering a total distance of some 40 to 100 miles (60 to 160 km). The footprints were so called because some religious leaders suggested that they were the tracks of Satan and made comparisons to a cloven hoof. Many theories have been made to explain the incident, and some aspects of its veracity have also been questioned.

Any help would be great!

Edit: 1855, damn!

1 Answers 2021-02-09

Book recommendations on ancient Southern Asia and Pre-Columbian North America.

I am a layman when it comes to history however I do enjoy reading about history as much as I can. I realized that most of my knowledge is very Euro and American centric and I have a basic understanding of Central and Eastern Asian history. But I want to learn more about cultures that I haven't been exposed to before. As the title says I am particularly interested in the ancient history of Southern Asia and Pre-Columbian North America. I went through the book list in the wiki and found a couple books. I was just wondering if anyone had any books they would recommend.

1 Answers 2021-02-09

Why Did the Roman Senate Continue to Prominently Display a Pagan Alter after the Conversion of Constantine?

I know the really basic history of that period, Julian the Apostate, the Ecumenical Councils, that type of stuff. But, I read one thing that interested me the other day, that the Altar of Victory, an alter to a Pagan goddess, was still present in the senate until 357 (returned by Julian and removed again 382). Of course, it would be unreasonable to expect that the moment Constantine converted to Christianity they would tear down or convert every single vestige of Paganism in the entire empire but it seemed odd that it would take them 50 years to remove such a protonate aspect of the old religious order. Is there a reason why this remained in the senate for so long? Where many (most?) of the senators still Pagan during this period? Did the Christians decide that it was now only symbolic (like say lady justice)?

1 Answers 2021-02-09

Did the Germans know we were coming on D-day?

I am aware of the mistakes they made; and Hitler deciding to sleep in. I am curious about how much of a surprise it really was.

Thanks ahead of time.

1 Answers 2021-02-09

What were the rules on getting into Valhalla?

Did you just have to die in a fight? Did you have to have a weapon in hand the moment you died? Did you have to kill a certain amount of people in order to qualify for entry to Valhalla?

2 Answers 2021-02-09

When did reviewers of culture (film critics etc.) start numerically rating things?

There's a thread on r/Truefilm right now about Siskel & Ebert's thumbs up/thumbs down rating system, in which someone claims that numerical ratings (e.g. out of five stars) stretched back decades before. But how far? Do we know where and why this practice began? Was it with the movies, or some other form of cultural reporting?

1 Answers 2021-02-09

US generals of WW2

Hey guys. So I've been doing a lot of research on the many military leaders of WW2. From the Germans and Soviets to the British and Americans. And whilst they all have their excellent and not so excellent generals, America is no exception. It had me thinking though, Germany had some exceptional leaders, but this is no surprise with their pedigree of the Prussian empire and German empire in the previous decades. Similarly the British, who had a vast empire and been fighting wars for centuries. But then when I thought about the Americans, who also had some very good leaders in the army, navy and Air force, where did they come from? Where was americas military history up until then to enable them to have some clearly excellent generals who really knew their way around a war and battlefield?

1 Answers 2021-02-09

Do we have ancient accounts for PTSD? What’s the first source we know of that definitely describes PTSD?

Edit: By “first”, I meant “oldest”, my bad guys. Reddit really should give us the option to edit the titles

1 Answers 2021-02-09

Just how different is Olive oil of the Ancient Roman world from the Olive Oil we can find in supermarkets today?

Referring to the Olive Oil reserved for direct Human consumption

I was wondering if it would’ve tasted different at all or have been far cloudier ? Maybe even a different color

2 Answers 2021-02-08

859 / 7255

Back to start